5 ms·
The study showed that men under men got promoted faster than men under women, but that women rose at the same rate under both genders. This could be explained b
by whatshisface 7y ago
The study showed that men under men got promoted faster than men under women, but that women rose at the same rate under both genders. This could be explained by a male advantage under men, but it could also be explained by male disadvantage under women, or a combination of both. How can these cases be separated? (The study might address this, I only have access to the abstract.)
- dqv 7y agoIt looks to be available by clicking the Read Now button: https://www.hbs.edu/faculty/Publication%20Files/Cullen%20and%20Perez-Truglia%20-%20The%20Old%20Boys%20Club_ca38672c-c641-4222-a383-30f434bbc830.pdf https://www.hbs.edu/faculty/Publication%20Files/Cullen%20and... It's 45 pages so I can't read it until later, but maybe someone else can.
- duxup 7y agoIt's an interesting question. My purely anecdotal experience is that women (in both business and personal lives) are more likely to have protracted conflicts with other women at work than men. I always wonder how that plays out / if it is even true.
- cgriswald 7y agoThe study would suggest that if such conflicts occur at the institution in question and such conflicts have the gender bias of your experience, that they have no bearing on promotion.
- dx87 7y agoMy wife and some female co-workers have said something similar. They said that when they see men get in disagreements, it normally escalates very quickly, but once the conflict is resolved it's like it never happened. They said the opposite happens with female employees, where the "conflict" never gets as intense, but it can go on for years with both sides not wanting to help each other.
- usrusr 7y agoMight be related to how boys' play tends to be (I think) more often explicitly about selecting winners and losers, so most men are quite accustomed to defeat. Feminism, when it laments about how men are brought up into dominance roles, is conveniently ignoring all those men who did learn that lesson.
- dvfjsdhgfv 7y agoThis is basically the most important single point tacitly ignored by the most vocal feminist activists. E.g. if there is psychopath male who is hurting people, he is hurting both males and females alike, although maybe in different ways. And there are are more male psychopaths and aggressive men than women. But this does NOT equal "women are the victims of men".
- marcosdumay 7y agoYou can see it on children schools too. I wonder if any culture has this differently.
- JoeAltmaier 7y agoPerhaps we just hear about it more. I know men that never got along, years of conflict. And the absolute worst, is when a man gets it into his head that he despises a women (usually for speaking up to him). There's no end to the retribution.
- duxup 7y agoYeah it very well could be a visibility issue where it seems more prevalent than it is. Possibly the visibility is somehow seen by some as a negative.
- kortilla 7y ago> And the absolute worst, is when a man gets it into his head that he despises a women (usually for speaking up to him). There's no end to the retribution. s/a woman/an employee/ I’ve seen more male careers hampered by vindictive bosses than female.
- JoeAltmaier 7y agoOf course. Since men outnumber women in pretty much any industry.
- ksdale 7y agoThere are a lot of industries where men outnumber women, but it's very far from "pretty much any." https://www.bls.gov/cps/cpsaat18.htm https://www.bls.gov/cps/cpsaat18.htm Just by eyeballing this chart, I'd say that women outnumber men in at least a quarter of the categories, and I'd bet there are close to another quarter that are pretty close to 50/50, where inferences drawn from the behaviors of the genders wouldn't be wrong solely because of the distribution of men and women. And given that the total percentage of women employed is 46%, many of the male dominated fields have to be offset by female dominated fields or else it wouldn't be close to 50/50. This isn't to say there is anything like perfect equality, but men outnumbering women in pretty much any industry is much too strong of a statement, in my opinion.
- mb99 7y agoit is a recuring observation in gender related articles, that crucial facts are left out when they are evidence of gender bias against men, ore even when they are just a piece of the puzzle that will prevent you from jumping to the "all men bad, women suffer" conclusion. when data or facts are obviously missing it is therefor good advice to assume they are left out for a reason and will probably go against the authors desired interpretation. alternatively one can conclude its just a bad study.
- jlawson 7y agoThis is just part of the larger pattern of anti-male expression in the media. It's remarkably consistent. If there's a study about differences between men and women, it will only be published if it can be spun such that the women are better. In a sitcom, the husband will always be the dunce of the family, and the wife is always the steady, responsible one. If there's a problem affecting genders differently, it'll always be presented as affecting the women more, while the men's suffering is simply ignored. This can reach absurd levels. E.g. Women's share of university degrees recently passed 60%. The media spin? "It's so terrible these women won't be able to find men educated enough to satisfy them." The reason is simple. All these academics and journalists are under watch from cultural police. If any of them ever wrote something that indicated men were better in any way or context, or were victimized by women in any way, they'd be subjects to a brutal and likely cryptic personal destruction campaign by feminist activists.
- allovernow 7y ago>All these academics and journalists are under watch from cultural police. If any of them ever wrote something that indicated men were better in any way or context, or were victimized by women in any way, they'd be subjects to a brutal and likely cryptic personal destruction campaign by feminist activists While this sentiment is true in extreme cases, I think the problem is more subtle. What we are seeing is the momentum of decades of institutional bias in soft science academia. The current status quo is propped up by activist researchers who believe in what they're doing and are either unaware of the bias in their research or believe it is acceptable in consideration of the greater good. So if you attempt to publish a paper against the political grain of your discipline, you may not be attacked by Twitter feminists, but you will likely see support from colleagues in your department wane, and your academic career could suffer as a result. This implicitly keeps people "in line".
- cgriswald 7y agoThe entire study is not very interesting. They studied a single bank in Asia with "thousands of employees." They don't name the bank. They don't even name the country. They make no attempt to address cultural differences. They disclaim that the study is representative of the world, but then offer some mental gymnastics which imply without actually suggesting that it represents the US because of the country's similarity to the US in gender employment numbers and attitudes.
- patel011393 7y agoIt is very common in social science research to anonymize participants by not revealing their location. This is an important ethical rule that is used to protect participants’ data. I believe that is why these authors were unclear about the bank.
- deogeo 7y agoThat doesn't make their claim that their results for an Asian country are representative for the US any less suspect. Asian and Western cultures are very different. These are not anecdotal observations mind you - it's well documented that psychological/sociological experiment results differ by culture: https://www.psychologistworld.com/issues/cultural-differences-psychology https://www.psychologistworld.com/issues/cultural-difference... It's quite bizarre - if they refuse to name the actual country where the study took place, then why compare it to the US? Why not to Russia or Brazil, or some other random country, drawn out of a hat? Why even include "old boys' club", in the title, when that's a term mostly associated with the anglosphere? Wouldn't "Guanxi [1]: Schmoozing and the Gender Gap" be more appropriate, given that the study took place in Asia? [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Guanxi https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Guanxi
- nimblegorilla 7y ago> The entire study is not very interesting. The study still has value even if they didn't perfectly study 100% of the world. It provides a useful datapoint for other researchers to build upon.
- psychometry 7y ago
- jayd16 7y agoWell its all relative but even the abstract starts to add more nuance than you've listed here. >We show that these manager effects are present only if the employee works in close proximity to the manager. If remote male managers are equivalent to local female managers, it seems natural to phrase it as they have done.