12 ms·
America's Missile That Uses Sword Blades Instead of Explosives Has Struck Again
- remotecool 7y agoThis is a good thing. Less casualties than what happens with explosive warheads.
- jcims 7y agoYes and the past few articles I've seen about these have actually been largely (and pleasantly) impartial. Unfortunately this hasn't stopped my from reflexively scrutinizing them for some angle.
- thaumasiotes 7y agoThe most angle I see in this one is "weapons are cool".
- x86_64Ubuntu 7y agoSomeone is dead, and by state actors. It's not wrong to scrutinize deaths ordered by the state.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 7y agoExactly. This is designed as a "low collateral damage" weapon.
- tasuki 7y agoI wonder whether the people who develop them think "I'm doing good for the world, developing highly targeted killing machines that reduce collateral damage". Perhaps they're even somewhat partially correct in thinking that?
- pas 7y agoIt's a question of ethics. Utilitarian ethics make it easy to give a formula for assessing this, whereas deontological ones (meaning rule-based, eg Kant's) state that don't do something you know is wrong, because the act itself has moral value, no matter the consequences. Of course the fusion of consequentalist ethics with rule based ones have been proposed, and there is some data suggesting people do think like this. (Depending on the context we will either have strict rules or we'll become more analytical.) War, weapons, violence, death/life, quality of life, are always nasty problems in terms of moral philosophy. What's worse, creating life and then taking other lives, or not creating any nor taking any? There's path dependence, sure, the arrow of time cannot be really ignored, and intent matters, and so on, yet we know humans always viewed war/fighting/conflict as a two sided thing. The just wars and the unjust ones. So the question becomes what is justice? How to reconcile everyone's personal concept of justice? John Rawls proposed fairness, and a very clever yet simple (even if maybe ultimately unworkable) method to determine what's fair: thought experiments that consider every possible life (a beggar's, a king's, and everything in between), and as people elaborate in what each one should do in various situations people's views should converge. (See reflective equilibrium.) ... and then there's virtue ethics too, which focuses on, kind of a personal best. Be excellent to each other. And this sounds like utilitarianism with an utility function that has already built in targets that clean up a lot of abstract nonsense from it and place a big emphasis on agency (and thus it kind of captures intent too - because it talks about the virtues and vices of agents' overall character too). I hope that both does and doesn't answer your question. :)
- happytoexplain 7y agoI like to think that "a step in the right direction" and "a good thing" have conversationally subtle, but critically important differences.
- jay_kyburz 7y agowarning: very graphic video embedded in post with shredded bodies.
- RickJWagner 7y agoThe accompanying 'explanation' article suggests such a missile would kill anyone within 3.5 feet of landing. I'd need to go measure, but it seems the driver of a car and a passenger seated in the back seat (opposite the driver) would not both be killed. So it should be aimed at maybe one or two people, while others in the car might live. Pretty amazing. Reduced deaths are a good thing, and it diminishes the value of innocent 'human shield' usage.
- jcims 7y agoI think that's 3.5' radius (edit:wrong). Both hits I've seen online have been center-punched in the middle of the roof of the car...amazing precision.
- thaumasiotes 7y agoThe article is ambiguous on this: > the missile, which is roughly three and a half feet wide when its blades are extended That really sounds like a diameter and not a radius. But on the other hand: > Supposedly, three people were killed in the vehicle when the bladed weapon smashed through the roof of the vehicle.
- sq_ 7y agoFrom an earlier article on the same site [0]: > The payload area is roughly a foot and a half long and let's say the swords are roughly the same length, this would provide about a three and a half foot diameter kill zone, which is similar to what we see in the images of the vehicles that have been struck. So it seems like 3.5ft diameter is The Warzone/The Drive's best guess based on the length of a standard Hellfire and the vehicle damage. [0] https://www.thedrive.com/the-war-zone/31310/this-photo-proves-how-the-hellfire-missile-that-uses-blades-instead-of-explosives-works https://www.thedrive.com/the-war-zone/31310/this-photo-prove...
- jcims 7y agoOK I missed that part, makes sense. Realistically you could probably skip the blades and still kill all the occupants in the vehicle with just the seeker/body/motor. That's a lot of kinetic energy getting dumped into an enclosed space.
- lykr0n 7y agoThis is a good thing. Surgical strikes will have lower casualties. The amount of precision required to kill a moving vehicle without harming other vehicles is impressive.
- astine 7y agoHopefully it'll result in fewer innocent deaths. Though I can still see ways for this to go wrong. Become overconfident in our ability to hit a target and then miss. Not to mention, a lot of the innocent casualties of American bombing haven't come from using bombs but from just picking the wrong target to begin with.
- AnimalMuppet 7y agoSure, but if they miss (or pick the wrong target), it's still fewer innocent casualties.
- astine 7y agoOh sure. I'd rather they shoot this at someone than a fricken hellfire missile. But how much did it cost to develop? We still have the possibility that just assassinating people from the sky at all creates more terrorists than it kills. In which case we're expeding a lot of effort to solve the wrong problem.
- AnimalMuppet 7y agoIt's my impression that the collateral damage was creating more terrorists. I'm not sure that just "death from above" of terrorists is the issue.
- xkcd-sucks 7y agoIn the absence of any really really convincing evidence to the contrary, it seems like remote control assassinations by a foreign power actively work against winning the hearts and minds of the local populace. Unless the locals getting assassinated are truly despised by everyone around them. After all, they have to take it as a matter of faith that they themselves can't possibly be "wrongly" targeted, and precedent suggests otherwise
- whyenot 7y agoI'm not a fan of targeted assassinations, but if the US is going to do them, at least with a weapon like this they can largely avoid the injury and death of innocent bystanders.
- TomMckenny 7y agoI know targeted assassination is frowned on but I don't know why. Surely leaders trying to assassinate each other is better than sending teenagers to die by the thousands while the leaders stay home and benefit.
- Infinitesimus 7y agoI think ideally people wouldn't be trying to kill each other so much.
- DubiousPusher 7y agoThat would be wonderful. In the interim, let the pencil pushers and power grubbers kill one another rather than the manipulable youngins.
- londons_explore 7y agoThroughout human history, ~10% of humans have been killed by other humans. You even see the same in many ape populations. I'm not even sure we have the power to change that. Having said that, the percentage has perhaps been the lowest ever in the past century (neither world war was that deadly), so maybe we're making progress towards your goal.
- dx87 7y agoIn theory, requiring full scale war disincentivizes war, so a peaceful solution is more likely. If targeted assassinations became the norm, you'd probably end up in a scenario where the country with the most advanced assassination techniques could exert much more influence since they wouldn't have to try and justify it to their own population. The most powerful country would basically be a vengeful god; completely untouchable and capable of smiting anyone that doesn't fall in line.
- Invictus0 7y agoI don't really understand how it works. Do the blades move? Are the blades deployed just before impact or after? Or is it basically a sword-wielding boring machine that cuts through the target with sheer speed?
- ycombinete 7y agoBefore, in one of the pics you can see where they sliced through the windscreen, and roof in multiple places.
- chrsstrm 7y agoIt's likely something similar to how mechanical broadheads work. The blades are situated so that in flight they are held closed with a small plastic retaining ring but on impact with the target the blades cam open. It's very low-tech but very effective. Here's some slow-mo shots of mechanicals in action: https://youtu.be/6dv1QySWQ6I https://youtu.be/6dv1QySWQ6I https://youtu.be/PZjEhk-CkKc https://youtu.be/PZjEhk-CkKc
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- onetimemanytime 7y agocoming soon: cars with 4 inch steel plates welded on roof.
- seriesf 7y agoAn anti-tank kinetic energy round (non-explosive) can penetrate foot-thick armor when fired horizontally, much more when fired straight down from an aircraft.
- remarkEon 7y agoI think the point remains. Now that this thing is out in the Wild we’ll see all sorts of attempts, however futile, to defend against it.
- mrandish 7y agoThe best defense would be to ensure no one knows which car you're in. I think we can assume that these HVTs have already employed stringent RF security for themselves and their minions via battery removal and securing all devices in Faraday bags. Yet U.S. intelligence is somehow still able to track them. It must be quite unnerving. I suspect some new techniques are being leveraged that are apparently having some success.
- remarkEon 7y agoIf one assumes some level of constant or near-constant surveillance, I think there's likely some facial recognition or perhaps some kind of matching of your "bio signature" that's going on. These guys swap SIM cards all the time, and are pretty wise to RF tracking at this point.
- mrandish 7y agoI agree. With 24/7 wide-area drone surveillance being recorded and a neural net automating 'vehicle of interest' tracks both forward and backward in time, it's not even necessary to tag vehicles with trackers. I've suspected that they're also using hidden surveillance cams that do license plate and make/model capture along with occupant facial recognition. Assuming you have some additional mobile tracking cameras hidden in vehicles so they can be relocated once a day, the neural net could pretty easily infer guesses about where to put them.
- seriesf 7y agoThe article's assertion that a man-guided weapon would somehow be more accurate and consistent than a computer-guided weapon following a target-designating laser strikes me as needing some supporting arguments.
- torstenvl 7y agoIt isn't that a manually guided weapon is inherently more accurate, it's that manual guidance requires real-time video, which allows more eyeballs. When the spotter identifies a building, and someone else tries to correlate that description to a set of coordinates, and then a GBU is dropped to those coordinates... human error can lead to target mismatch, resulting in terrible tragedies like the Kunduz hospital incident.
- tim333 7y agoFor comparison a car being taken out by an old Hellfire missile https://youtu.be/dLv-7zqHdF4?t=12 https://youtu.be/dLv-7zqHdF4?t=12 The old one was really overkill for a couple of guys in a car, more designed to be used against tanks and probably sent shrapnel a considerable distance.
- torstenvl 7y agoIt can be, but I've seen people walk away from a Hellfire vehicle strike. My guess in that particular video is that there was a secondary explosion from the gas tank.
- phaus 7y agoWeird shit happens with explosives. My friend I deployed with has a foot long piece of shrapnel that almost hit him and a couple other people. Could be a gas tank though.
- dogma1138 7y agoMy guess is that it wasn’t a HEAT warhead but a fragmentation or a MAC warhead, the HEAT warhead was designed to defeat armor it isn’t effective against soft targets.
- dogma1138 7y agoThe fact that the hellfire missile was designed to destroy tanks doesn’t make it an effective weapon against soft targets. In fact the anti-tank (HEAT) warhead would not do that much damage to a car and unless you would be directly under it you’ll be able to walk off from it as the tandem charge doesn’t do much damage when it doesn’t hit hardened armor. The warhead in question in the video is likely a MAC (thermobaric charge) or a fragmentation warhead which were designed to hit soft targets and kill personnel. The hellfire also has DIME warheads which use metal powder instead of larger shrapnel to reduce collateral damage as well as kinetic warheads as shown in the article.
- nwallin 7y agoRegarding man in the loop: if you're a bystander, (and not the target) you want a drone attacking the primary target as opposed to a manned platform. With a manned platform, you have a chance of getting hit by a platform with a rear weapons officer, (F-15E, F/A-18) to verify minimal bystanders. But they're probably concentrating on not missing. Or you can get hit by a single occupancy aircraft (F-16, F-35) who will be dropping pre programmed ordinance. With a drone, you have three separate teams of people watching the video steam. Anyone in that loop can say, "hey there are a lot of civilians here" and everything's on pause until the target moves. And now we have an explosiveless munition with limited opportunities for collateral damage and this outlet is falling over themselves talking about gruesome it is. Having worked in the field makes me really sick of ignorant journalists reporting on it. The outrage the antiwar press tends to carry makes their ignorance more annoying than the journalists talking about AGI, quantum computing, or deep learning.
- ghettoimp 7y agoI want to agree with you, insofar as that being outraged over what appears to be a more precise weapon makes very little sense. On the other hand, it still seems horrible to kill people by remote control. Supposing it becomes possible to very, very precisely kill exactly who you want, from far away, with no judicial process, etc., is this good? War should be painful for both sides, because if it is not, what stops us from engaging in it?
- WillPostForFood 7y agoWhy is it different or worse than low tech ranged weapons like a mortar or cannon that are also safe(ish) for the person firing, but also risk killing innocents bystanders?
- behringer 7y agoWe'll see what you think of it when foreign countries start flying strike drones in the US.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- tehjoker 7y agoGlad it's more precise in theory, but a) why are we fighting again? b) So often they kill the wrong person anyway because it's so easy for them to kill, why bother with being extra careful on the confirmation? c) Trump, in 2017, loosened further the already weak safeguards on conducting strikes, so the number of civilian casualties has increased. d) Why are we fighting again? EDIT: 2018 -> 2017, my how time flies. https://web.archive.org/web/20170414143558/https://www.nytimes.com/2017/04/05/us/politics/rules-of-engagement-military-force-mattis.html https://web.archive.org/web/20170414143558/https://www.nytim...
- exhilaration 7y agoAnd e) I thought Turkey was our ally, with Erdogan and Trump being BFFs -- why are we killing the guys he's backing?
- tehjoker 7y agoTurkey is complicated... however, the US backing awful sides while doing realpolitik is famous, we've even backed Al Queda (!!) which undermines entirely the thin public justifications for even being there which seems to be more about securing oil, militarizing a central economically important region, and preventing Iran from gaining influence (why?) and failing given they took control of Iraq following the (baldly illegal) US invasion. Meanwhile we back an absolute monarchy that did 9/11 (probably) and threatened to do it to Canada on Twitter (lol). [0] [0] https://www.businessinsider.com/saudi-arabia-appeared-to-threaten-canada-with-a-911-style-attack-2018-8 https://www.businessinsider.com/saudi-arabia-appeared-to-thr... (candidate for best tweet of the decade)
- x86_64Ubuntu 7y agoThe narrative direction for "drone strike tech" doesn't really allow us to ask "what is this for again". The main direction of the narrative is supposed to be "wow, look at how many more "terrorists" we can kill without killing civilians". Of course, the whole process for who and how someone gets slapped with the plastic term "terrorist" and how it's decided they should die isn't to be brought into the picture.
- cyberferret 7y agoDon't most air to air (or surface to air) missiles operate on a similar principle? The explosive warhead itself is not usually what destroys the enemy aircraft, but rather, the warhead is set to detonate within proximity of the enemy plane, releasing a bunch of metal shrapnel that acts like a spinning buzzsaw and literally shreds nearby aircraft to pieces (look at pictures of the recovered MH17 wreckage for evidence of this pattern).
- hatsunearu 7y agoI think this weapon is a direct hit kill vehicle, which isn't very common. In fact the ATA missiles are more like traditional HE munitions (like artillery shells), spraying fragments to kill the target.
- bart_spoon 7y agoThis isn't shrapnel. Most bombs involve some kind of killing power via shrapnel. This one doesn't even seem to explode. It just extends six, 3 foot long swords from the main body prior to impact, dicing everything in the immediate radius. Precisely because of the lack of shrapnel/explosion, the risk of collateral damage to nearby people is supposedly greatly reduced. As long as you aren't within the killing radius of the blades, you theoretically shouldn't be harmed.