5 ms·
It is not at all clear that the headline is accurate. It states that after long-term exposure to 23% alcohol (non-deadly), recent bacteria have a higher surviv
by crazygringo 7y ago
It is not at all clear that the headline is accurate.
It states that after long-term exposure to 23% alcohol (non-deadly), recent bacteria have a higher survival rate.
But it states that the 70% alcohol level contained in hand sanitizers is "quickly fatal" and "annihilates bacteria".
I was under the impression that it was impossible for bacteria to evolve resistance to hand sanitizer precisely because it would be like humans evolving resistance to 1000°F temperatures -- sheer impossibility physically.
So does it even matter if bacteria are evolving to be slightly more resistant to lower concentrations of alcohol, but are still killed by the level in hand sanitizers?
The headline appears to be factually inaccurate -- they're not evolving to survive hand sanitizers, they're evolving to better defend themselves (by 10x) against much lower concentrations of alcohol that already weren't wiping them out in the first place.
- newnewpdro 7y ago> So does it even matter if bacteria are evolving to be slightly more resistant to lower concentrations of alcohol, but are still killed by the level in hand sanitizers? I imagine yes, it does matter. It's not like hand sanitizer use is absolutely perfect. Let's assume some bacteria always gets past the direct initial 70% alcohol application, but there's residual alcohol that tends to take care of whatever remains. As the bacteria becomes more alcohol resistant, those lucky survivors of the initial direct application become more likely to survive the residual effects.
- amelius 7y agoYes and evolution in one direction probably means they lose different protective traits (?)
- thaumasiotes 7y agoUnder one of two circumstances: 1. The old traits provide protection against a problem that modern bacteria no longer encounter. As such, when changes to the genome interfere with those old protections, no problem occurs and the old protections are lost to genomic bit rot. (If a colony of Tibetans moved into India, over the long term their high-altitude adaptations would deteriorate under a lack of pressure to maintain themselves.) 2. Alcohol resistance is so valuable that +1 alcohol resistance makes up for -3 traditional resistance. This is the sickle-cell anemia model. There is no conservation law holding constant the total amount of "protection" your genome provides you. If bacteria are adapted to defend themselves against certain risks, and you add a risk of alcohol exposure without removing the other risks, what you'll get are bacteria that (1) resist all the old risks (like the old bacteria did), and (2) also resist alcohol exposure.
- titzer 7y agoGenerally this is how natural selection works, incrementally over long time scales. Just a small bias for survival is enough to get the optimization process to work over the long time scale. One other thing to think about, one strategy that bacteria have been observed to employ is that a colony can clump together and develop a kind of film that protects the entire colony from some chemical that would be fatal to any one individual cell. This ability is greatly enhanced by individuals having a greater tolerance to low concentrations and being able to signal to the colony to begin the defensive response. Bacterial colonies have also been recently shown to communicate amongst the individuals. So, the headline could be reasonably construed as accurate, IMO.
- sorokod 7y agoIt's not the scale of the time, it's the number of generations.
- thaumasiotes 7y agoThey are related as long as one generation takes a finite amount of time.
- londons_explore 7y ago> So does it even matter if bacteria are evolving to be slightly more resistant to lower concentrations of alcohol, but are still killed by the level in hand sanitizers? Yes - your skin is a mountain range at bacteria scales. And when the hand sanitizer is applied, some bacteria will be hiding in caves and crevices, and only come into direct contact with a much lower or no contact with the alcohol.