5 ms·
Israeli startup claims to succeed where Theranos failed
- kingkawn 7y agoCurrent hospital lab tech I’ve seen can finish a CBC in seconds
- caycep 7y agoif they can reduce the amount of blood volume for a CBC that would be helpful. Especially for hospitalized patients - they often get a CBC, chemistry and liver panel daily and over time, you can see their blood counts trend downward so that they're mildly anemic when they get discharged
- catalogia 7y ago> "It counts and examines the number of red blood cells, white blood cells and platelets in a patient’s blood sample" It sounds like they have a very restricted scope compared to Theranos. Testing for one or two things in a drop of finger blood isn't anything new, as many diabetics can attest to. As I understand it the "magic" theranos was originally trying to accomplish [before they decided to scam people instead] was a wide variety of blood tests from a single drop of blood.
- klenwell 7y agoExactly. > Unlike Theranos, Sight Diagnostics is starting small and working its way up. Holmes claimed her device could do hundreds of tests across the four main classes of blood tests: hematology, immunoassays, general chemistry and DNA amplification. Sight is only focusing on a subset of hematology for now. So, in truth, they're not anywhere close to trying to do what Theranos promised. The book Bad Blood goes into the technical details that made Theranos's mission fantastical if not farcical. The scope of it is very different. This was one of the most telling passages for me in Bad Blood: Tim [Timothy Hamill, Vice Chair of UCSF's Dept of Laboratory Medicine] confirmed to me that both practices were highly questionable. He also explained the pitfalls of using blood pricked from a finger. Unlike venous blood drawn from the arm, capillary blood was polluted by fluids from tissues and cells that interfered with tests and made measurements less accurate. "I'd be less surprised if they told us they were time travelers who came back from the twenty-seventh century than if they told us they cracked that nut," he said. (p. 230) https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/38799469-bad-blood https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/38799469-bad-blood Consider, too, the source here: From The Grapevine was created to provide a fresh perspective on Israel. From the land’s natural beauty to Tel Aviv's vibrant technology scene; from the global culinary world's focus on Israeli food and recipes to the innovative Israelis who are changing the world – From The Grapevine covers the bounty of what Israel is about today, in detail, with great writing, rich photographs, and its own editorial voice – engaging, non-political, and non-religious. From The Grapevine tells the stories about Israel you may have missed, but not for much longer, as our engaged social media community begins to share our words. If you find a story that speaks to you, please pass it along, and tell others you heard about it From The Grapevine. From The Grapevine.com is published by The reThink Israel Initiative, Inc, an American non-profit 501c3 corporation. https://www.fromthegrapevine.com/about https://www.fromthegrapevine.com/about Looks like a platform for fluff.
- tehjoker 7y agoIirc the problem with Theranos' strategy was that the fingertip blood has highly variable composition compared to mainline blood. For example, getting lipid counts would be off. I would believe you can accurately count the blood cells in your fingertip, but I (a layman) would need a bit more to believe that this is necessarily representative of mainline. It might still be diagnostically useful.
- catalogia 7y ago> I would believe you can accurately count the blood cells in your fingertip, but I (a layman) would need a bit more to believe that this is necessarily representative of mainline. It might still be diagnostically useful. I'm skeptical of that, since my impression is that the many of the capillaries in one's finger are so tiny that only one blood cell can fit through at a time. That seems like something that could fuck up the results, but I'm no doctor or biologist and it sounds like regulators might actually be paying attention this time around.
- blotter_paper 7y agoI'm not sure that they decided to scam people instead, my impression is that they took "fake it till you make it" to its logical conclusion but failed to make it before people realised they were faking it. They were scamming people and trying to build the product they claimed already existed, which doesn't make the scamming any better.
- catalogia 7y ago> "fake it till you make it" Deciding 'we'll scam people, but only for a short while' is still deciding to scam people.
- blotter_paper 7y agoAgree completely, I tried to make it clear that I wasn't defending their actions.
- jliptzin 7y agoEven this I didn’t really understand. Are there really vast quantities of people so afraid of a little pinch when having your blood drawn that they don’t do regular blood testing? It’s not much worse than having your finger pricked for a drop of blood, once the needle is in you usually don’t feel anything.
- WrtCdEvrydy 7y agoOnce the technology improves, it would be great to have a bracelet that can check your wellbeing semi-continuously (a drop of blood every 2-3 days)
- gus_massa 7y agoIf the nurse/technician is good and you are lucky, you get pinched at the first try and the extractions is fast. If they can't find the vein, you may get pinched twice or more times. (It is also difficult when the patients is too young, or too old, or dehydrated.)
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- entee 7y agoMy main question is whether when someone takes a CBC how often that's the only test. If you're looking for other markers (A1C, Potassium, any number of standard panel stuff) you probably need to take a full size blood draw so I'm not 100% clear on the benefit.
- cududa 7y agoProof of concept on using tiny amounts of blood for certain bio-markets. They’re taking the MVP approach.
- onlyrealcuzzo 7y agoI'm curious to know why you need a full-size blood draw for those tests. Do you know? Can you elaborate?
- bsder 7y ago1) Some of these chemicals are found in quite small concentrations. The fact that we can detect them reliably is actually rather remarkable. 2) Generally, the full blood draw serves as an averaging filter. We know that concentrations of chemicals in the body vary significantly with time, position, etc. Pulling more blood over several seconds serves to average some of this out.
- forrestthewoods 7y agoI read that as Thanos and was VERY confused
- TheRealSteel 7y agoI mean, 3.8 billion users is more than even Facebook, that valuation would be insane...
- tyingq 7y agoNot sure what's new here. Small CBC machines have been around a while. This one takes 7 minutes vs the article quoted 10, and also needs just a few drops into a proprietary finger-stick type tube: https://www.devineexpress.com/products/429001-qbc-diagnostics-hematology-analyzer-qbc-star-clia-moderate-complexity https://www.devineexpress.com/products/429001-qbc-diagnostic... Maybe the one in the article is cheaper or something?
- Animats 7y agoHere's technical info on the Drucker machine, which you can buy right now.[1] It needs 65µL of blood, which can be obtained from a finger stick. The real cleverness of that system is in the sampling tube, which contains all the chemistry, has the needle used for taking the sample, and can be centrifuged. The machine is just a centrifuge plus light sources and cameras to look at the tube. The tube is about $6 each.[2] Apparently this isn't new; the concept dates from 1977. Nicely executed here in a compact one-button desktop unit. [1] https://druckerdiagnostics.com/products/dry-hematology-analyzers/ https://druckerdiagnostics.com/products/dry-hematology-analy... [2] https://www.devineexpress.com/products/429625-qbc-diagnostics-qbc-star-analyzer-tube-sodium-heparin-k2-edta-additive-70-ul-cap-closure-plastic-tube https://www.devineexpress.com/products/429625-qbc-diagnostic...
- tyingq 7y agoJust for clarity, the post above is more info on the machine I posted. Which, again, seems to have everything the machine the article is talking about. The PDF manual seems to indicate it's been around since 2016. I don't know if it's even particularly special itself. Maybe it's one among many competitors.
- CalChris 7y agoTheranos didn't even fail. Theranos was a fraud.
- chapium 7y agoSo... not get caught?
- jmcgough 7y agoIf they were successful in developing the tech behind the scenes while they were faking it, no one would be saying that. They'd say how brilliant Holmes is, how driven and business-savvy she was to use a stop-gap solution. I've seen many startups lie about their tech, like AI recruiting companies that have little-to-no AI for their first few years.
- koreth1 7y agoThe fact that other companies lie about their tech doesn't mean it isn't fraud, it just means other companies are also making fraudulent claims. A non-Theranos example might make it clear why I'm not nuts about the "if they'd succeeded, we'd be singing a different tune" argument: If alchemists had been successful in turning lead into gold, nobody would be calling them frauds now.
- andreareina 7y agoA big difference is that IIRC it's simply not possible to get statistically rigorous results on that many tests with that little blood.
- gamesbrainiac 7y agoI think the title is rather misleading. Theranos could supposedly do a full gamut of tests, not just CBC.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- m0zg 7y agoWhy did you add "claims" to the title? TFA says their device is FDA approved now. That's more than just "claims to succeed", that qualifies as "succeeds" IMO, which is what the title of the article says: "Israeli startup succeeds where Theranos failed".
- lonelappde 7y agoThis is much less than what Theranos attempted, which was a full panel of tests.