3 ms·
Sending the password over email still doesn't make any sense. It should still work like every other password reset scheme. You click on a verification link sent
by imtringued 7y ago
Sending the password over email still doesn't make any sense. It should still work like every other password reset scheme. You click on a verification link sent over email and then you can enter a new password on a https secured site (or it will be randomly generated).
Whether the password is generated or user created doesn't matter. All the old password handling rules still apply. Don't store passwords in plain text. Don't send them over insecure channels. Always offer an option to reset passwords instead of showing the stored password to the user.
The explanation against securing the passwords in the database is also completely illogical.
>If a hacker was able to get into the system then that would mean he might have other things to look at then decrypt or recover a string that we generated when you signed up
If I were a hacker and I could covertly just dump your user/password table then I wouldn't even bother writing a single update query. I would just sell the accounts for $10 each. It would be very difficult to notice the data breach. Who is going to reset e.g. 10 million user passwords just because 10000 were compromised without any evidence that it wasn't user error?
- j-pb 7y agoSo you put the accounts up for sale, and then what? Who would buy access to somebody elses infosec homework. Because that's what this site is. They're essentially playing a low stakes game with low effort. And I give them big KUDOS for that, cause the average web dev joe would follow all the "best pratices" store user passwords and billing info, hashed, salted, cursed, put in stakes that were never needed & get hacked.