8 ms·
Elon Musk wins 'pedo guy' defamation case
- zaroth 7y agoObviously just speculating, but I would imagine a mitigating factor was that Elon and Unsworth were already involved in a public spat before the tweet in question. I think if you tell someone to sodomize themselves with a submarine, you may get called names in return. To then run to the courts demanding $190 million in damages is a bit of a stretch. Another factor could be that Musk was persuasive in convincing the jury that he wasn’t asserting a fact that he knew was false in that tweet, but an insulting colloquialism, which would not meet the definition of defamation (as I understand it - and IANAL). Ultimately how you evaluate the result is in the eye of the beholder. It does seem to me that Musk has learned from this, and there’s been a notable lack of controversy in his Twitter feed over the last several months.
- pg_is_a_butt 7y agoHe just stated publicly that he didn't mean he was a real pedo, and suddenly the case goes away.
- notus 7y agoIt was because you have to prove defamation and nothing bad happened to the guy as a result of what Musk said, so hard to prove they were defamed.
- dresstotheleft 7y agoIn most jurisdictions there is something called defamation per se, which automatically presumes damages. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_defamation_law#Defamation_per_se https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_defamation_law#D...
- cookie_monsta 7y agoDefamation is the act of harming somebody's reputation. All that needs to be proven is that there was one more person who thought he was a pedo as a result of Musk's statements.
- danso 7y agoApparently deliberations were less than an hour: https://twitter.com/rmac18/status/1203084858630791169 https://twitter.com/rmac18/status/1203084858630791169
- threeseed 7y ago> And they suggested that Unsworth was looking for a payday in court I think this is the key issue. $190m is clearly exorbitant for a defamation lawsuit. Shame because Musk crossed the line and an example needed to be set that corporate executives should be held to account for their actions.
- WalterBright 7y agoJust because Musk is a corporate executive doesn't mean he loses the right to insult others.
- threatofrain 7y agoThe problem for me was this was right on the borderline because I was anticipating that Elon Musk really did know "something".
- WalterBright 7y agoIf Musk really did know something, his insult would have included that something.
- threatofrain 7y agoI had an uncertain read because I could believe that Elon with his vast resources knew something, and I couldn't understand why Elon would risk complicating his leadership of his companies without some grounding.
- basch 7y agoIf I understand correctly, in the Ninth Circuit, the fame and affluence of the speaker does not matter, but instead the notoriety of the alleged defamed.
- urbanjunkie 7y agofuck off pedo guy.
- purple_ducks 7y agoWow, genuinely surprised by this.
- CydeWeys 7y agoIt's not that surprising when you consider that the British guy opened the conversation by suggesting that Musk stick his submarine up his ass. That kind of set the tone of the conversation, i.e. mean and figurative.
- krustyburger 7y agoThis is... not the result I was expecting. I hope Elon Musk still takes this as a learning experience despite the good outcome (from his perspective and that of his companies).
- gwbas1c 7y ago(From the most-upvoted post) https://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=pedo%20guy&defid=13075369 https://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=pedo%20guy&d...
- mywittyname 7y agoThe learning experience is that Musk can get away with practically anything.
- greenhatman 7y agoThe diver got away with just as much. That is, insulting someone.
- cookie_monsta 7y ago* somebody's submarine
- happytoexplain 7y agoObviously this equivalence is not something people agree on.
- pix64 7y agoThere is a difference between insulting somebody and claiming someone is a pedophile
- akkartik 7y ago> Mr Musk told the court this week the phrase "pedo guy" was common in South Africa, where he grew up. I just went searching in the obvious place, and it's almost like this was planted for people like me: https://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=pedo%20guy&defid=13075369 https://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=pedo%20guy&d...
- gwbas1c 7y agoGosh, I wish I could re-read the whole with in context, now.
- munmaek 7y ago> created by ElonM July 18, 2018 It's satire.
- Madmallard 7y agoLOL all of those terms were created this year in just recent months? Holy scam
- JanSolo 7y agoSo the question is: Did they rule for Elon because of some legal technicality? Or was it because of the exorbitant defamation claim? Or was it because Elon was correct in his claim?
- gbronner 7y agoBecause it "pedo guy" is an insult, which is protected speech.
- purple_ducks 7y agoMMmmm. Would have thought that was not a defense for him seeing as he then went on to call him a child rapist: > “I suggest that you call people you know in Thailand, find out what’s actually going on and stop defending child rapists, you fucking asshole,” Musk wrote in the first message. “He’s an old, single white guy from England who’s been traveling to or living in Thailand for 30 to 40 years, mostly Pattaya Beach, until moving to Chiang Rai for a child bride who was about 12 years old at the time.” https://www.buzzfeednews.com/article/ryanmac/elon-musk-thai-cave-rescuer-accusations-buzzfeed-email https://www.buzzfeednews.com/article/ryanmac/elon-musk-thai-...
- gbronner 7y agoMusk apparently hired an 'investigator' who turned out to be a conman who came up with this tidbit. He had no actual knowledge that the guy wasn't a child rapist, and he did use reasonable care to verify his "facts", so it wasn't willful defamation.
- nahhhh 7y agoIn related news it turns out Elon Musk himself is a pedophile. He rapes children.
- OnlineGladiator 7y agoYikes. Now I know what kind of content is hidden behind flagged comments.
- ratsmack 7y agoComments like this always comes from someone that creates a throwaway account just to make the comment. I'm always amazed at the effort that is put into stuff like this. Rather than dumping their garbage on HN, they should take it to the chans where it is generally expected.
- gbronner 7y agoIt hinged on whether "pedo guy" was an actual attempt to brand someone as a pedophile, or whether it was an insult, which, at least in the US, is protected free speech. Looks like the jury decided the latter.
- davesque 7y agoOdd considering that Musk hired a personal investigator (apparently a fraudster) in a misguided attempt to prove that Unsworth was, in fact, a pedophile. Kinda defeats that argument, doesn't it?
- gbronner 7y agoNot really -- defamation is extremely hard to win the US, and has to be both demonstrably false and reckless. The fact that he hired a pro investigator (or at least one who professionally held himself out as one) kind of makes 'reckless' hard to prove.
- davesque 7y agoMy comment wasn't about that. I was saying that, if the case did in fact hinge on what Musk meant by calling Unsworth "pedo guy", then it should have been a slam dunk in Unworth's favor. So then, by the contrapositive and crap, we should assume in a logical universe that the case didn't hinge on the meaning of the term "pedo guy."
- cookie_monsta 7y agoDidn't he hire the investigator after making the claim? That would make it him trying to cover his ass after making an unfounded assertion, which fits pretty well into the reckless category. What the investigator found (nothing in this case) is immaterial. The law should protect people from being defamed on a hunch that may or may not later turn out to be true.
- egdod 7y agoNot really. If he turned out to be an actual pedo, that would’ve been a pretty good argument to bring up in court. So it was worth looking into.
- ddtaylor 7y ago> “I assume he literally didn’t mean to sodomize me with a submarine. I literally didn’t mean he was a pedophile,” Musk told jurors. Seems to be the crux of the defense that was employed.
- dragontamer 7y agoThe other crux, which I'd say affects my thought process, is that Unsworth seemed unable to prove damages. If no damage was done (or could be proven), then Musk is innocent. The precedent this sets is bad IMO. I wish there was some degree of damages awarded here. But I can see the argument playing out like that legally. Like the saying goes: no harm, no foul. If Unsworth literally wasn't damaged by this event, then Musk has to be innocent.
- egdod 7y agoThey could have awarded nominal damages, $1 or whatever.
- dragontamer 7y agoThe litigator asked for $5 Million in nominal damages. If the litigator asked for $1 in nominal damages, maybe the Jury could have considered that as an option. But the litigator played the game this way. EDIT: I'm not a lawyer, but I see why the litigator went with the "go big or go home" strategy, asking for $190 Million in total damages. But the strategy seems to have backfired. EDIT: /s/defense/litigator
- egdod 7y agoThe jury isn’t limited to awards that the parties suggest.
- dragontamer 7y agoOf course not. But the litigator has to plant an agreeable idea into their brain. That's literally the litigator's job, and they clearly failed at it. Its not the jury's job to come up with legal maneuvers. The jury are just normal people, like me or you, who may not know all the ins and outs of the law. The litigator makes a case, the litigator makes the arguments, and finally: the litigator bring up some options for what the jury can do. That's the job of the lawyer in this situation: to bring up the best options for representing your case. The litigator went all in with a $190 Million accusation, ignoring the possibility of smaller fees or awards. Its a bold strategy, but it failed. EDIT: /s/defense/litigator. I got my legal terms mixed up...
- ggm 7y agoI'm disappointed. Money and influence defeated a just outcome. Hiring the private investigator speaks of bad intent: Musk should not have been allowed to claim " I didn't mean it" if he went looking for evidence that.. he did mean it.
- outside1234 7y agoSeriously? I have a hard time believing he actually thought the person was a child pedo, or that the other person actually thought that, or that any person observing the conversation would actually think that.
- cookie_monsta 7y agoSo why the investigator? Why the "signed dollar" and "stop defending child rapists" comments? I find it hard to believe that he wasn't making the case that the guy is an actual pedo.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- skuthus 7y agoHow did money and influence change the outcome? Genuinely curious
- davesque 7y agoSo I guess what's the countdown now until Musk pulls something like this again after having been emboldened to terrorize people with his money?
- widowlark 7y agoWoosh
- rickncliff 7y agoAvoiding speech restrictions is always a positive in my book. As for the larger picture "defamation" is incompatible with the first amendment and laws around it should be invalidated.
- cookie_monsta 7y agoThankfully we have the judicial branch to interpret what was written hundreds of years ago. Besides, the 1st prevents the government from making laws that abridge the freedom of speech. It doesn't give every tantrum-throwing cowboy the right to spout off without consequence.
- rickncliff 7y agoConsequences should be social, not legal.
- cookie_monsta 7y agoWhat does that mean? Unfollow him on Twitter?
- rickncliff 7y agoThat is one way, don't buy his cars is another, and he can say whatever he wants.
- cookie_monsta 7y agoAre you seriously suggesting we replace the legal system with... consumer boycotts ? Because I don't sell anything. What's to stop me from making a smear campaign about you?
- wigglewoggle 7y agowoosh
- onetimemanytime 7y agoAny idea why UK was not chosen as the place to sue, I have read it's easier to win and the diver was English?
- urbanjunkie 7y agoElon Musk is a child rapist and a pedo guy.
- rinchik 7y agoThere are a lot more comments than upvotes to the story, it's not gonna be a good one, isn't it?.. Sensitive!
- spectrum1234 7y agoHaha. I made an app to track comments to upvote ratio. Its usual a better interesting story indicator than anything else.
- RivieraKid 7y agoThis result and about half of the comments here are depressing. How is it possible that so many presumably smart people don't understand the massive difference between an insult ("he looks like a pedo") and defamation ("he is a pedo, I've actually looked into it")?
- Udik 7y agoHe said he was a pedo, then reiterated, then told others to "stop defending a child rapist", then said "you don't think it's strange he hasn't sued me". He might have been joking all along, but jokes like these have a price. I'm a great fun of Musk, but I can't help thinking that the jury here acquitted him only because he's a sort of American hero. Which is disgusting.