6 ms·
99% of websites we visit do not need canvas or sound. And the few websites that do can explain why you should click "Allow" when they prompt you for access. Wh
by hombre_fatal 7y ago
99% of websites we visit do not need canvas or sound. And the few websites that do can explain why you should click "Allow" when they prompt you for access.
What's a charitable reason that stops even a supposedly privacy-concerned niche browser like Brave from implementing opt-ins for these things?
I suppose one reason is that you would immediately unleash opt-in spam on your users that don't know what these pop-ups mean since so many major websites use these hacks, so the average user is just going to be conditioned to mindlessly click "Allow All" every time they pop up like UAC on Windows Vista, punishing the average person while doing nothing to enhance their security.
Doesn't help that legislators are absolutely clueless here. For example, demonizing cookies when cookies are the most fair and transparent way to implement tracking, and leading to the first wave of pointless opt-in spam that plagues the internet. I'd rather they leave the internet alone and for browser vendors to step up for us.
Of course, the problem also includes native apps like in TFA. I'm just more optimistic about clients that run in web browsers.
- qxnqd 7y agoBrave blocks cross-site canvas by default under their "Device recognition" option. You can also block first-party canvas access.
- dylz 7y ago> What's a charitable reason that stops even a supposedly privacy-concerned niche browser like Brave from implementing opt-ins for these things? In my experience, blocking these everywhere globally as a default will result in being banned from websites, trigger bullshit "fraud" invasive analytics, and all sorts of obnoxious fail-closed problems by invasive trackers. You will also be banned from most Distil-hosted sites for refusing to enable WebGL or return a canvas fingerprint. Ticketmaster, etc.
- munk-a 7y agoSounds great - especially if chrome could roll out default blocking of it. The EU (via GDPR) made a collective decision to disallow invasive privacy, if TickTock's response to that is to ban everyone in the EU and entirely lose the market that sounds good to me - teenagers will complain and people will shrug.
- dylz 7y agoThis is being done in EU anyway. IIRC I've seen several third party vendorssay that this type of tracking is legal under GDPR to justify 'anti fraud activities' like tracking users and sharing access to their data with other paying customers. I personally have EasyPrivacy enabled on uBlock (because these tracking scripts using canvas, webgl, etc spin up my GPU and absolutely shit all over my battery life) but they are getting more and more aggressive with first-party CNAMEs, shipping a list of dozens or hundreds of hostnames to try progressively if any are blocked (and probably honestly risk score you higher for "trying to evade them" even though it's a default uBlock list). I think it's honestly rather stupid, and I am not a fan of hearing my fans spin up for no reason accessing an otherwise plain website while it tries to open media players, try video elements, draw to canvas, download several megabytes of obfuscated garbage to evaluate.
- munk-a 7y agoI've worked in anti-fraud software and it isn't necessary. Fingerprinting is extremely convenient and sales loves it, but I would hope that necessity could be broken down by reasoned arguments in the EU - I'm outside of the EU and not familiar enough with GDPR but there are a number of clear and accessible counters to that point - especially if payment is involved. If payment comes into play then fingerprinting becomes irrelevant as anyone making a payment can be trusted up to the level of that payment and that payment method tied to their actions.
- kbenson 7y agoIf a large enough chunk of people do it, then it becomes unfeasible to block them all. If Safari, Firefox and Internet Explorer all implemented a block, it doesn't really matter that Chrome doesn't. That's ~30% of browsing traffic, and no sane company with a large web presence is going to throw away 30% of their traffic.
- tempguy9999 7y agoAgreed! There's a lot of moaning about how things should be better. Be the change you want to see. Do it. I'm always amazed at how people will complain but then let themselves be pushed around. I wonder how many people reading this article will change their or their browser's behaviour afterwards. Very few I guess.
- shrimp_emoji 7y agoPerhaps more egregiously, using a VPN gets you auto-banned from some Battlefield 4 servers. D:
- thinkloop 7y ago> Doesn't help that legislators are absolutely clueless here. You're a world-leading computerist and you had no clue either (nor I), how in the world are legislators supposed to do this. It's a fundamental problem. And once it's finally legislated the sme's are already on the next thing.
- ehsankia 7y ago> And the few websites that do can explain why you should click "Allow" when they prompt you for access. You missed it, this doesn't require an Allow, because it's not actually accessing the microphone. It's using the audio APIs to generate a waveform, and depending on your computer/DSP, the waveform will be slightly different. It's not using any of your computers sensors https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21436414 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21436414
- kbenson 7y ago> You missed it, this doesn't require an Allow, because it's not actually accessing the microphone. Presumably, without an allow the API doesn't function at all, so it works perfectly well. When denied access, the API should either not exist, or (more appropriately) just return errors.
- shakna 7y ago> Presumably, without an allow the API doesn't function at all An incorrect presumption. The API works perfectly fine without the need for permissions. This is not a new technique. There's a decent write up here [0]. Permissions are only required to play to the actual device, or record from the actual device. Recording from nothing and not playing is allowed. [0] https://iq.opengenus.org/audio-fingerprinting/ https://iq.opengenus.org/audio-fingerprinting/
- kbenson 7y agoWe're talking about a theoretical situation where we gate the canvas and audio api behind a permission prompt. My "presumably" is about how that would be theoretically implemented.
- shakna 7y agoWhy would gating the API behind the Permissions API change what is currently considered permission by the Browser? That'd require rewriting the API itself.
- iudqnolq 7y agoIn Firefox, setting privacy.resistFingerprinting = true in about:config fixes the canvas leak and possibly the audio leak. It's part of a push to bring into Firefox privacy features from the TOR project. https://wiki.mozilla.org/Security/Fingerprinting https://wiki.mozilla.org/Security/Fingerprinting
- stinos 7y agoI really want to do this, but last time I checked it also leads to FF sending UTC time back to sites (or something like that), resulting in showing non-local time for your own and other interactions on pretty much all sites like github/slack/... Fairly annoying. I hope this becomes a separate setting at one point.
- arjunbajaj 7y agoI enabled it and Todoist would show me a dialog on every page reload to set my timezone to UTC. After I realized that resistFingerprinting was causing it, I had to disable it. It would be nice if the settings inside resistFingerprinting were configurable. I understand that the point of it is to make every browser look the same to analytics engine, but having timezones and zoom levels reset is not the best thing.
- jmiserez 7y agoOr file a bug report with Todoist. Showing a dialog on every page is not very user friendly of them.
- animesh 7y agoI don't know about fixing canvas and audioleak, but it reset browser zoom to 100% on every load of any website say HN. This is pretty annoying.
- iudqnolq 7y agoTry this recommended extension: https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/zoom-page-we/ https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/zoom-page-we/
- varenc 7y agoGoogle's ReCAPTCHA uses the same canvas fingerprinting trick.
- stiray 7y agoOk, how to fix fingerprinting: - for web, stop using chrome, install firefox (or firefox mobile) and in about:config set privacy.resistFingerprinting on true then add following addons: https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/android/addon/canvas-fingerprint-defender https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/android/addon/canvas-finger... https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/android/addon/audioctx-fingerprint-defender https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/android/addon/audioctx-fing... https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/android/addon/webgl-fingerprint-defender https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/android/addon/webgl-fingerp... https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/android/addon/font-fingerprint-defender https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/android/addon/font-fingerpr... They will not only prevent fingerprints but also screw with the data (add random noise to audio/webgl sample, return random fonts,...). - the most important rule, don't use applications like tiktok, fb,.. if your phone is not rooted, with xprivacylua (https://github.com/M66B/XPrivacyLua https://github.com/M66B/XPrivacyLua, for added kicks https://github.com/M66B/NetGuard https://github.com/M66B/NetGuard) installed and you have basic understanding what you allow there (disallow everything for new apps and work permissions one by one). The sole purpose of those apps and their bussiness model is to steal your data. This is most sane advice I can give, sorry :( Voila. Solved. Those methods of fingerprinting are few years old and well known.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- bscphil 7y agoThis is a genuinely great idea. Other stuff like recording audio, looking at your location, and even annoyances like sending you notifications all require a permission request that appears in the browser chrome. Why doesn't Firefox put other features that impact privacy behind the same barrier?
- Angeo34 7y agoBrave is just snake oil. They couldn't ever implement true canvas or audio protection or prevent font or window decoration fingerprinting even if they wanted. If you want that stuff you use Firefox and enable resistFingerprinting its the only possible way