4 ms·
The honor system doesn't work at scale. A small percentage of the population are kleptomaniacs or desperate for their next hit and there isn't an easy way to f
by jandrese 7y ago
The honor system doesn't work at scale. A small percentage of the population are kleptomaniacs or desperate for their next hit and there isn't an easy way to filter them out. Even with small groups you are playing the odds.
The only thing keeping the stores in the article in business is that they stock only a relatively small amount of cheap merchandise with no secondary market. Their total liability is so low that it's cheaper than hiring staff.
- ars 7y ago> The only thing keeping the stores in the article in business is that they stock only a relatively small amount of cheap merchandise with no secondary market. Their total liability is so low that it's cheaper than hiring staff. Giant Eagle, which is a huge grocery store recently started the exact same thing: https://www.beaconjournal.com/news/20190222/zap-giant-eagle-offers-way-to-nearly-ditch-checkout-line https://www.beaconjournal.com/news/20190222/zap-giant-eagle-... They've been doing it for a year, and have added stores, so contrary to what you say, clearly it works.
- jandrese 7y agoLooks like they still have staff manning the store. That is just an alternate form of self-checkout. In fact the article states that they will retain the same level of staff.
- briefcomment 7y agoAlso, (I can see it being possible that)* when it is communicated that the only thing stopping you from stealing is your own conscience, a burden is placed on your conscience every time you shop. I think people will be surprised to see how worn down the conscience can get when you keep invoking it for insignificant situations (in other words, when your conscience belies rationality). People may find themselves stealing when they never would've before. *added as an edit
- vorpalhex 7y agoI hope the act of not murdering or not stealing isn't slowly wearing you down.
- dsfyu404ed 7y agoMurdering people has a totally different risk/reward situation than petty theft. Additionally, situations where murdering someone confers a benefit on the murderer are much rarer than situations where petty theft confers some benefit to the thief.
- briefcomment 7y agoIt is not, and I think that is because it is generally rational to not murder or steal. I think irrationally following your conscience wears you down.
- milesvp 7y agoMurder takes physical effort. Stealing something you already have in your posession does not take any extra physical effort. Don’t conflate the two. You may also be completely ignoring some of the work people have done studying self check outs. My understanding is that people who would never think to hide items from an actual checker are much more likely to leave items unscanned. And that many of them justify the behavior in various ways. I think petty theft is far more instinctive than you may realize. I personally have to fight the urge to steal my daughter’s holloween candy, even though I can easily afford my own, and she would give me some if I just asked. I don’t know where the urge comes from but I know it’s there, and I doubt it’s an uncommon type of urge. Social interactions can really help to bolster behaviors we prefer in ourselves. I can see them being useful in keeping honest people honest. In the same way a gym buddy makes it harder to skip a workout.
- okcando 7y agoThere certainly would be more murders if concrete deterrents were relaxed or eliminated. We definitely do not rely on the honor system to keep murder rates in check. In any case, someone raising questions about emergent behavior in the general population shouldn't invite questions about that specific person's imminent ethical lapse.
- munificent 7y agoI completely agree, especially having seen what the lack of policing of minor property crime has done to Seattle in the past few years. (In Seattle today, at least in my neighborhood, theft and vandalism are essentially legal. The police will not show up, will not investigate, and will not prosecute. Criminals knows this and act accordingly.) A social system can rely on the goodwill of its participants for quite some time. But as that system grows and becomes more well known, it inevitably becomes a honeypot for bad actors to exploit. Once those bad actors take advantage of it and experience the lack of consequences, that behavior is reinforced and shared with other bad actors. The system will either need to change to flush them out, or it will cease to function even for good actors.
- boomboomsubban 7y agoArresting each thief costs taxpayers hundreds of dollars at least, and is unlikely to dissuade people from stealing as they don't have a lot of better options.
- larnmar 7y agoRight, which is why punishment for thieves needs to go far beyond just “arresting” them.
- jandrese 7y agoWhat do you suggest? Cutting off hands? The tone of your post doesn't suggest "job training, drug counseling, and attempting to find them a place in society."
- larnmar 7y agoSociety already gives everyone twelve or thirteen years of that stuff. For some people it doesn’t stick. I’m not sure why anyone thinks that “slightly more of the same” is going to help.
- monocasa 7y ago
- gdilla 7y agoIs it supposed to? It's a cost benefit analysis - do they save money by investing in all the tech? Or is it cheaper to use honor system with little to no investment to do so? Given there's always bad actors all the time, there's some minimum of loss from theft that always exists.
- ggm 7y agoThe honor system doesn't work at scale. A small percentage of the population are kleptomaniacs or desperate for their next hit and there isn't an easy way to filter them out. Even with small groups you are playing the odds. Since it hasn't been tried at scale, this is an unfounded proposition. Shops already deal with routine pilfering. My partner's secondhand bookshop had an estimated 5%+ loss rate from petty theft. Large department stores deal with almost continuous shoplifting. Yes, theft is ubiquitous in a small part of the population. No, this does not mean the honour system cannot work "at scale"