14 ms·
I may not be dying, but I am losing my eyesight. This article is about a very one-sided phenomenon, and largely speaks to the desperation of men in the current
by datingthrowaway 7y ago
I may not be dying, but I am losing my eyesight. This article is about a very one-sided phenomenon, and largely speaks to the desperation of men in the current dating market. I literally cannot imagine reciprocal treatment from a woman. I have not been in a relationship since I got this condition, and I don't expect that I ever will be again.
- frostburg 7y agoI'm sorry about your health issues, but it appears to me that they are (understandably) affecting your overall mindset. There are plenty of disabled men in functional relatioships (and not-so-functional ones, there is a subset of people, male or female, that are specifically attracted to ill or dying partners for problematic reasons). Please lose the incel angle.
- datingthrowaway 7y agoShow me some. If you are able to find examples, they will most likely be famous billionaires or actors. However I can point you to an equal number of examples where fame and fortune still didn't cut it. You cannot discount my experiences and observations unless you have gone through this yourself.
- ceejayoz 7y agoThe idea that blind people don't/can't date is readily disprovable. Examples of anything will tend to be notable; that doesn't mean non-notable people don't exist. https://www.vice.com/en_us/article/j5ajj7/how-dating-works-when-youre-living-with-blindness https://www.vice.com/en_us/article/j5ajj7/how-dating-works-w... https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/soloish/wp/2017/01/09/what-is-it-like-to-date-while-blind/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/soloish/wp/2017/01/09/wh... You might consider finding a local support group for people who've recently lost their sight.
- scott_s 7y agoI think a local support group is an excellent suggestion.
- jimbokun 7y agoThose are both written by women about their experiences. Any examples of men successfully dating after starting to lose their eyesight? Or other disabilities? I think I've read other articles in the past about women with disabilities having a relatively easy time dating, but men with disabilities having a lot more difficulty.
- ceejayoz 7y agoTwo men (one with glaucoma, which generally starts in adulthood) are quoted in https://metro.co.uk/2017/11/08/what-its-like-to-date-when-youre-blind-7041772/ https://metro.co.uk/2017/11/08/what-its-like-to-date-when-yo... - as you might expect, "non-notable recently blind men dating" isn't a super easy thing to Google for. The first mentions dating within the blind community, which would likely make things substantially easier on both parties. I've seen enough weird parings and horrible people in relationships to feel quite comfortable with the statement "blind isn't a guaranteed deal-breaker". I do suspect the recency matters a lot - grief after loss can be all-consuming and take time to come to terms with. Side note: My spouse is disabled, so I'm also quite comfortable with the concept of dating someone with a disability.
- jimbokun 7y agoHey, thanks for the link! Good to see concrete examples.
- avgDev 7y agoI have an invisible illness, after seeing more physicians that I can count. The conclusion appears to be some neurological issues with connective tissue problems which result in chronic pain and fatigue most likely caused by antibiotic I took 7 years as symptoms started right after my allergic reaction. I got married after symptoms began. It was not easy but life doesn't stop. I'm still coming to terms and searching for something that works meds/supplements/physical therapy. However, I don't considered myself disabled even though this is quite limiting and I require more rest. I think once one accepts your alignment and find ways of still being a member of the society, one will have a much better luck dating. I think the depression that these problems bring is just really hard to deal with and affects people around us.
- tristor 7y agoI am not blind, but I do have a condition which causes my eyesight to get progressively worse (luckily on an elongated timespan). I by happenstance ended up becoming best friends with a blind student when I was in college during a period where I was trying to learn about and understand my condition. That introduced me to organizations like the NFB, and I even attended some regional NFB conferences. I'd definitely recommend you get involved in blindness advocacy groups in your area. What I found might surprise you. Blind people have normal relationships just like anyone else, and conferences tend to be a hotbed of dating and connection-making beyond just the topic of the day. My best friend is happily married now for more than 10 years, and I am in a long-term relationship coming up on my 2nd year anniversary. I've since met multiple blind people in the tech industry and found most of them to be successful in their career and in their relationships. I'd heavily recommend you get involved in local groups and also to go out and do whatever activities interest you. Most people are more accepting than you might imagine. There's a lot of things that might be difficult due to visual acuity, but people are understanding are willing to give you space to be part of the group. For instance, I've found that board gaming and D&D are very popular activities with the geekier folks I know in the blind community, and for those who are partially sighted using assistive technology like magnification cameras on their phone or similar makes these things possible to do without significant impairment. You'll be more likely to meet someone you're compatible with if you get out of the house and go participate in mixed gender hobbies. You may not want to hear this, but it's the truest observation I've made. Those folks who are struggling in the blind community have often put themselves in a situation to struggle. There's pervasive negative feedback loops when someone becomes disabled, especially if they become disabled later in life. It's easy to become hopeless, and it's easy for your own insecurities about your disability to sabotage the relationships you'd otherwise have, both professional and romantic. In the words of my best friend, "You're blind. So what? So am I. Go make something of yourself." Don't get fooled into throwing yourself a pity party. Instead go do the things necessary in your life to be an attractive romantic partner, and you will find that your disability is not the impediment you imagine. Romance is about emotional connection, first and foremost.
- coldtea 7y ago>Show me some. If you are able to find examples, they will most likely be famous billionaires or actors. Are you saying this seriously? Go to a local club for blind people, or some club for people with some other disability, and you'll find many living perfectly normal lives, in relationships, etc. You will also find several who don't have a relationship (which also true in abled people). But it's in no way like you need to be a famous artist/billionaire etc to be blind/disabled/etc and have a relationship. Not even close. >You cannot discount my experiences and observations unless you have gone through this yourself. You can, if they are not accurate.
- xsmasher 7y agohttps://youtu.be/kGFdRkUEi8U?t=254 https://youtu.be/kGFdRkUEi8U?t=254
- astura 7y agoOne of my best friends in high school's dad was blind. He was married to her mom. The family was just as normal as could be, I didn't even know he was blind at first.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- dominotw 7y ago> There are plenty of disabled men in functional relationships That would be such an unacceptable response in any other context ( eg: there are plenty of women who are CEOs, there are plenty of <minority> millionaires. Please lose the victim angle). But somehow such cruelty is acceptable towards "incel" men. I personally know someone who is an wheelchair and was abandoned by their SO ( can't really blame her ) after his condition and has ever since been unable to find someone.
- frostburg 7y agoYes, and former house speaker Newt Gingrich famously left his dying wife while branding the GOP as the party of family values, for which everyone should in fact blame him. Anecdotes are useless, do you have any data that suggests that women are more likely than men to leave a partner due to illness?
- kareninoverseas 7y agoThese are all good points but they feel very insensitive in tone given that OP has shared something personal; I'm not sure if you realise what you're doing
- coldtea 7y agoWhen something personal is shared, it becomes something to discuss. Especially when its a larger observation concerning what others, not the person, do.
- dominotw 7y ago> Anecdotes are useless, do you have any data you mean excellent data backed, well laid-out argument like this ? > There are plenty of disabled men in functional relatioships
- nabnob 7y agoMen are more likely to leave their wives due to illness than women are - https://well.blogs.nytimes.com/2009/11/12/men-more-likely-to-leave-spouse-with-cancer/ https://well.blogs.nytimes.com/2009/11/12/men-more-likely-to...
- ulucs 7y agoComplaining about the dating scene does not make you an incel. You're being condescending for no reason at all. Nothing he said is related to the usual talking points of incels. Also, men are lonely and this reflects heavily in suicide rates by gender. If someone is lonely, they should be allowed to complain. Casting them away with a label only makes things worse for them. Don't you have empathy? Can't you garner sympathy for a person who is missing out on one of the basic human needs (emotional connection)?
- frostburg 7y agoThe "dating market" observation is straight out of incel dogma. I have significant sympathy for him missing out on sight (he's probably american, but if he lived in a country with working healthcare I would say that I'm glad that taxes would go towards whatever treatment might help him).
- throwno 7y agoAre you seriously bullying lonely disabled men on a programming forum?
- frostburg 7y agoI don't see how I'm bullying him. I told him that he should not resign himself to being lonely due to his disability, because I think that his understandable distress about his issues might lead him to perceive his situation as bleaker that it is from that standpoint.
- dang 7y agoTelling someone that their situation isn't how they think it is, unless you've taken the time first to establish a real connection with that person—one that they can feel—is likely to come across as a dismissal of their experience and a putdown. I'm sure your intention is to help, but this is a way to hurt rather than help. Bluntly firing facts at someone, assuming they are facts, is definitely not going to do it. The truer the information, the worse the effect: in order to shield themselves from the blow, they will defend against the truth, which moves them further away from a solution. If you want to help, the first question is how to create a felt connection with the other person, which will give them some reason to be open to what you're saying. That's not so easy to do on the internet, though maybe sometimes possible. Words like "I have significant sympathy for him" and "his understandable distress" aren't sufficient though.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- dang 7y agoThis crosses into personal attack, which is not allowed on HN. Please review https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and edit that kind of thing out of your comments in the future. Your comments in this thread have broken several of the guidelines, most importantly Be kind. It's already a bit dodgy when people respond to other's experience by telling them what's wrong with them, especially when their experience is painful. But blunt one-liners and internet tropes ("lose the incel angle") should be right out. Upping the ante like you did in https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21721545 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21721545 is seriously not ok. What to do instead? First edit out personal criticisms—they're unlikely to land well. Second, it's always ok to share your own experience. For example, if your comment here was based on experiences or observations of your own, it might have been both interesting and respectful to share some of that.
- pnutjam 7y agoSo, what I'm hearing is looks are not important to you.
- Woberto 7y agoI like this way of seeing things. Similar to how the author of this piece viewed cancer
- throw7754321 7y agoThere are men in prison that are able to find someone on the outside, that visit them, and want to date them once their time is served.
- adventskalender 7y agoThere may be something else at play in that case, not simply "there is somebody to date for everyone". Would actually be interesting to learn more about it. Could be women attracted to bad boys. Or many they like the safety of the guy being behind bars. Or not being able to see someone makes it possible to dwell on the imagination. Also, helper syndrome. Edit: this came up with Google, for example https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-5582019/Women-resist-dating-prisoners-risk-love.html https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-5582019/Women-resis... "Psychologist and psychometrician Dr. Robert Sternberg, a former president of the University of Wyoming who currently teaches human development courses at Cornell, said: ‘Falling in love with a prisoner reduces your risk while preserving some of the excitement. For people who have issues with intimacy and commitment, it gives them an out of a having a relationship in which you can have the exciting passion without having to put in too much intimacy or passion." "‘I think that what happens in these kinds of cases is that people, tend to build up a fantasy world. That’s what people do and who is to say to another person that you’re crazy and I’m not.’"
- watwut 7y agoTurns out, women do not prefer men with criminal record. And quite likely, dont like all those consequences on life after their release either. https://www.rand.org/news/press/2019/02/25.html https://www.rand.org/news/press/2019/02/25.html > arrested and convicted [...] we see an association with a variety of negative trends later in life, including lower chances of being married and less economic success,” Smith said. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4293638/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4293638/ > incarceration dramatically increases the odds of divorce
- ceejayoz 7y agoThe point wasn't "women prefer criminals", I don't think. I think it was more "if a serial killer can find love, so can a blind person".
- scott_s 7y agoI am sorry about your condition. But I don't think your understanding of dating and gender dynamics is accurate. Please don't give up on dating if you would like to be in a relationship. The dating apps are a minefield, but sometimes the only game in town. The best place to meet new people (not necessarily people to date) is through activities. Loneliness is awful, and dating sucks. But I assure you, the behavior from this woman's boyfriend is a human trait that can be found across all genders. Please do not give up and consider yourself undatable.
- mrj 7y agoYou're looking at it wrong, like a transaction. But imagine a guy who finds humor and joy while progressively losing eyesight. A guy who's passion for seeing things before they're gone livens and betters all who know him. That guy is somebody people will want to be around. If you sink into bitterness it'll form a self-reinforcing pattern that will ensure your loneliness. And please talk with a professional if you haven't, because that is a heavy thing you're facing and perspective can really be helped by the right person.
- datingthrowaway 7y agoWould you also congratulate a terminal cancer patient on their opportunity to become a better person? Did you honestly read what you wrote? I am a real person, with real feelings. This is not a feel-good movie: it is real life. This is horrid and you are telling me to be grateful for my suffering.
- ceejayoz 7y agoNo, they're telling you if you can't change it, how you deal with it has an impact on your relationships with others. Gloomy, angry, defeated people have trouble dating whether they're blind or not. Are you in therapy or a support group of some kind to deal with the very real, very legitimate feelings this change of circumstances causes?
- TurkishPoptart 7y agoHe is not telling you to "be grateful for [your] suffering." You are projecting a bit here or otherwise reading into it the wrong way. He is saying that despite your ongoing issue with your eyesight (and I am sorry to hear that), you are much more than that. What would happen if you met a funny, cute, good-spirited woman that was stuck in a self-defeating thought loop and letting a health issue define her outlook and worldview? I think it would make her less fun and less attractive and would more or less be awkward. I've been struggling with depression and anxiety for 15 years and haven't dated anyone since 2015 and can't afford therapy to "fix" this stuff, but as parent suggested, a change in perspective can be extremely potent.
- 7y ago