4 ms·
If you want something done right (like making sure your data is no longer on someone else’s hard drive), you should really do it yourself. Zeroing filling a ha
by bobthepanda 7y ago
If you want something done right (like making sure your data is no longer on someone else’s hard drive), you should really do it yourself.
Zeroing filling a hard drive isn’t hard.
- GrumpyNl 7y agoEvery hd i ever had and didnt use anymore, i smash a 2 inch nail through it. Thats permanent.
- bobthepanda 7y agoThey said they rented the disks, so that probably wasn’t possible. Renting physical hard drives does seem pretty dumb, though.
- tpmx 7y agohttp://www.asahi.com/ajw/articles/AJ201912060021.html http://www.asahi.com/ajw/articles/AJ201912060021.html The hard drives had been used for data sharing servers at the prefectural government office and were replaced with new ones in the spring. The prefectural government had deleted the data, but the successful bidder of the hard drives was able to restore them by using special software. The government is trying to locate the remaining nine hard drives, which were also sold online in July to August. The data servers had been leased from Fujitsu Leasing Co., which commissioned Broadlink Co. to scrap the replaced hard drives.
- bobthepanda 7y agoThere’s deletion, and then there’s deletion. Zero-filling, one-filling, and random-filling all the bits of a hard drive is sufficient to make previous data effectively unretrievable. That doesn’t sound like what happened here. https://skeptics.stackexchange.com/questions/13674/is-it-possible-to-recover-data-on-a-zeroed-hard-drive https://skeptics.stackexchange.com/questions/13674/is-it-pos...
- raverbashing 7y ago"deleted" I would bet a lot of money they dragged the files to the "recycle bin" then maybe emptied it If they were external drives it's likely they were on FAT32 which makes it even easier
- mysterydip 7y agoSomething to keep in mind when buying datacenter infrastructure is that "next day onsite support" might want to take the failed drive back with them in exchange for the new working one. I know Dell at least has a "keep your hard drive" option for an extra fee.
- avar 7y ago"Renting" hardware that you "own" is relatively normal. E.g. buy a 1U server with everything from a <provider>, pay some subscription fee so they keep upgrading it to the latest thing. It's a way to shift inventory management to the supplier, the alternative would be to employ people to try to sell used 1U servers & components. Those companies will then pick up your used server, wipe it, and sell it to someone else. Depending on the contract that'll include physically intact hard drives.
- gjs278 7y agowriting all zero to the drive does the same thing
- sharedfrog 7y agoFor anyone curious as to how, GNU `shred` can do that. Something like: `shred --force --zero /dev/sda` should wipe the whole drive, overwriting 3 times (the default) with random bits and once with all zeroes.
- a012 7y agoNothing is more secure than wipe them with a hammer
- seb314 7y agodepends on your threat model... if peaces bigger than dust are left over, they might still contain quite a lot of info, right?
- sharedfrog 7y agoDo both!
- tyingq 7y agoAren't commercial degaussers still a thing? A hammer still leaves big chunks.
- genera1 7y agoThey are, and aren't that expensive. Our IT support team has one for workstation drives in a company with around 1000 employees.
- vidarh 7y agoIf you mean a big sledgehammer, maybe. Speaking from experience, even with a chisel making more than a dent in a modern harddrive with a hammer in ways that can't be fixed by replacing a pcb or other parts is hard work.
- jki275 7y agoUnfortunately this is not necessarily effective on modern SSDs.
- viraptor 7y agoBut also not really guaranteed to do what you want in case of SSDs. It may. Or it may get optimised/balanced leaving lots of data behind.
- Aeolun 7y agoI guess a hammer takes care of that too :)
- washadjeffmad 7y agoYears ago we settled on using block device encryption for all flash storage and then destroying the headers or revoking all keys. This satisfies the infeasibility requirement of NIST SP 800-88 without relying on flash vendors to have appropriately implemented ATA command standards like secure erase, which almost none fully do.
- zmix 7y agoThis destroys the filesystem, but not the physical disk, right? I mean, will the SSD be usable after that, albeit, by installing a new filesystem and reformatting?
- washadjeffmad 7y agoCorrect. It's not like when degaussing wipes the track information from a HDD. This is also as opposed to relying on the self-encrypting feature on most modern flash. Whether you're dealing with high enough asset value to warrant this level of interest or are just beholden to the same standards, you should reach out to your flash vendor for clarification.
- toyg 7y agoNo OS handling sensitive data should ever save on unencrypted volumes, ever. Particularly nowadays - with BitLocker and FileVault it’s trivial to achieve this even on desktops and laptops. When you want to kill the data, you just destroy the/any key and you’re done. Why rely on hardware encryption, when software encryption is basically free?
- squarefoot 7y agoNot an expert here (suggestions welcome), but maybe short of having some thermite at hand, multiple passes of dd if=/dev/urandom of=/dev/disk would be more effective against well equipped parties. There are ways to extract data from zeroed platters in a clean room with the right equipment; writing random data multiple times should be harder to defeat.
- hvidgaard 7y agoI don't think anyone have ever demonstrated the ability to recover data after a few overwrites on any modern harddisk. The entire concept of "residual" magnetism that you can reliably measure sounds ridicules to an engineer.
- michaelt 7y agoAFAIK no-one has ever demonstrated the ability to recover data after a single overwrite. Someone offered a prize for such recovery, back in 2008 [1] which was never claimed (although the prize was only of symbolic value). [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=117588 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=117588
- squarefoot 7y agoI don't want to sound like a conspiracy theorist, but if I was a 3 letter agency with infinite resources (so also no need to claim any prizes, no matter how much tempting they can be) and succeeded in recovering data that way, I would never tell anyone. Doing so would reveal what I can do, and by extension send the message "next time do a multiple pass wipe" which in the end would reveal what I cannot do.
- hvidgaard 7y agoConsidering that brilliant physicists and engineers have private access to state of the art technology, I find it highly unlikely that NSA/FBI/CIA/??? have figured out how to do this, but no one else have.
- 7y ago
- jowsie 7y agoLast place I worked where we had to dispose of customer harddrives, we had some home made contraption that was basically a metal frame with a bottle jack that moved a pickaxe head. No data coming back after a few passes with that.
- tyingq 7y agoBasically a tabletop hydraulic press. You can buy those for under $200.