6 ms·
As a rule of thumb, a 10x increase in production of something halves the price. Purely through economies of scale. Much of what's been seen in lithium-ion batte
by Animats 7y ago
As a rule of thumb, a 10x increase in production of something halves the price. Purely through economies of scale. Much of what's been seen in lithium-ion batteries is just that.
Has Tesla got their act together with their US "Gigafactory" in Nevada yet? They had a lot of problems, most of them in plant management related to starting up a big plant in an isolated area.[1] Plus feuding with Panasonic.[2]
Eventually somebody will get this right, and there will be automated plants with very few employees. This is the ideal situation for automation - making huge numbers of identical products. It just takes a long time to get the automation working.
A big problem in the US is that few people go into manufacturing engineering. It's a big thing in China, but not in the US. Average pay for manufacturing engineers is about $78K, according to Glassdoor. Senior level, maybe $82K. This is for a job which today requires understanding real-time computer control, electronics, mechanical engineering, and organizational behavior.
[1] https://www.usatoday.com/story/money/cars/2019/12/04/tesla-elon-musk-reno-gigafactory-theft-nevada-investigation-report/2610328001/ https://www.usatoday.com/story/money/cars/2019/12/04/tesla-e...
[2] https://electrek.co/2019/10/09/tesla-panasonic-relationship-hits-hard-times-tesla-make-own-batteries/ https://electrek.co/2019/10/09/tesla-panasonic-relationship-...
- rwmurrayVT 7y agoThere are a lot of engineers that work in manufacturing. Typically they'd be referred under controls and automation or maybe industrial engineering.
- dver 7y agoControls Eng for plant level PLC/HMI, Automation Eng for interconnect with the higher layers (SCADA/MES/ERP/Cloud) is the general wording I see. But, yeah lots of mix and match with those words. In the middle of architecting the systems for a new pack line myself.
- bigger_cheese 7y agoHere in Australia "Process Engineer" is used a lot for this type of role.
- netcan 7y agoOn manufacturing engineering... Tesla is likely just an example of a general trend. Whether it's big leaps towards "fully automated" manufacturing or gradual, cheap labour is not as important. It's increasingly a "talent" paced industry. Manufacturing is becoming less la
- ogre_codes 7y agoDoesn't halve the price of raw materials though which is a big part of Lithium Ion battery pricing.
- Iv 7y agoI'd love to see a cost summary of a typical lithium ion battery if you have it. How much is labor, energy, materials?
- 9HZZRfNlpR 7y agoDepends entirely on the chemistry, but it's mainly Cobalt that is killing the price. Everyone tries to cut it out as much as possible. Tesla is trying to cut costs with less Cobalt but in general it means worse performance and a lot of safety issues with overheating or exploding. Huge amount of savings from the last years comes from cutting Cobalt by making better chemistries, trying to keep the safety record at the same time.
- darksaints 7y agoEconomies of scale often get mentioned as if it is some sort of magical property that makes things cheaper. Reality is often far more complicated. Amazon, for example, hasn't really had an improvement in fulfillment costs over time. They've gotten more expensive as they've pushed ideas that grow the company: faster shipping, more products, etc. Also, resource constraints tend to have overwhelming impacts: the cost of extracting oil from the earth got a lot cheaper on economies of scale right up to the point where they had to go after more expensive sources to get enough to fill demand. Economists have a name for this effect: diseconomies of scale. It is pretty safe to say that economies of scale has gotten us to where we are now with batteries. But that does not necessarily mean the trajectory will continue.
- narrator 7y agoThere's also Jevons Paradox[1]. This is that the more efficiently a resource is used the more demand there is for it. So if you increase the efficiency of electric vehicles, there will be more demand for battery packs because the battery pack's use value for transportation increases. For example, if there were technological improvements to Tesla that made them get 50% more range off the same weight of battery packs, that would greatly increase the demand for those battery packs because the value of those battery packs would be greatly increased. [1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jevons_paradox https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jevons_paradox
- outworlder 7y agoAh, I've been looking for a name for this. So this applies to software systems as well. We had a system where, every time we optimized the underlying database, it became slower . This puzzled us for a while. Turns out that people were used to the slowness. When they found out that the system became faster, they actually started entering more transactions. As more people noticed, the system got overwhelmed again. Until it reached a point where it could finally handle the load. The variable we failed to see is that people were leaving work earlier now. Even though the system's metrics appeared to degrade, that was a metric that markedly improved. They used to work longer hours to get all their work done.
- Iv 7y agoI wish I went into manufacturing engineering. I wanted to work on robot AI and am there now but studying software is the easy part, you can easily get access to all the software and documentation online for free. Learning automation and manufacturing is more costly in terms of time and money.
- hanniabu 7y agoMore expensive to learn and unfortunately pays much less.
- Gibbon1 7y agoNot lost on me that jobs working on systems to spy on and gas light people pay about three times what manufacturing engineering jobs pay.
- the_cat_kittles 7y agobut much cooler, at least to me
- stevenwoo 7y agoOne of my mechanical engineering suitemates in college cooped/worked at a Frito Lay chip plant for three semesters and got a job there in manufacturing after graduating, I remember because when he got back he always had boxes of product they gave him after each work period.
- Iv 7y agoI wish every government that invested in renewables would invest at least as much in batteries R&D.
- Retric 7y agoBatteries are getting literally hundreds of millions of dollars a year in R&D investments and have been for decades. We could increase that by a few Billion per year, but it’s not obvious what would make a good investment over just buying more batteries and letting the market develop.
- dzhiurgis 7y agoWhy don't govs give tax breaks for everything that's battery related? Extraction, shipping, manufacture, sales...? I feel the price would halve instantly.
- revscat 7y agoA carbon tax would help a great deal here as well.
- Causality1 7y agoI would be interested in a study on how many years it takes the average "battery breakthrough" that never goes anywhere because the lab technique is completely unscalable to be revisited with more advanced technology and declared impractical a second or third time.
- hyperbovine 7y agoI don't think government funding battery research makes as much sense now as it used to. Absolutely everything runs on batteries nowadays, to the point where they are the main source of expense and weight for a large swathe of consumer goods. The commercial incentive to build a better battery is just huge. I remember reading some years ago that the prospectus of a large oil company, ExxonMobil maybe, explicitly singled out a sudden leap in battery energy density as something that could torpedo their $250b/yr business. It's hard to see how the government finds a way to build something that the private sector can't, when there's a trillion dollars at stake.
- jartelt 7y agoYep, there are very often "learning curves" that can be used to accurately predict price trends as manufacturing volume increase. The same thing has played out with solar cells and led to big price drops. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Swanson%27s_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Swanson%27s_law
- mrdoops 7y agoThe PLC/DCS/SCADA world hasn't really caught up to modern open-source software in a lot of cultural ways. Lots of proprietary components and "pay-to-learn" practices. I expect there's software-engineer types who would venture into the hard-real-time control systems world if it were as open-source and tinker-friendly as something like Rails. Nowadays someone like Microsoft has to go open source to have any hope of capturing developer mind share for something like .NET.
- Animats 7y agoThe PLC/DCS/SCADA world hasn't really caught up to modern open-source software in a lot of cultural ways. That may be a feature. Otherwise you get a Raspberry Pi, with enough attack surface to drive a semi through, to control a pressure regulator.
- 827djdjs6 7y agoHas Tesla ever had their act together? They're a luxury car brand running one if the best pr campaigns of all time.
- mikorym 7y agoI am always surprised to hear how much programmers get paid in the US (third world disclaimer: It's a lot!). > Average pay for manufacturing engineers is about $78k This is more on par with pay for (top) programmers or engineers that I know of. In South Africa, actuaries get paid much more than programmers. From what I have seen on HN, US based programmers (in top-ish companies) get paid actuarial salaries. As a mathematician, I have a lot to say about actuaries, but alas, that is for another day. Maybe someone more knowledgeable can clarify this. Median pay at tech companies is sometimes > $100k annually. In my view as a not-a-US-citizen, that is a lot of money.
- GuthL 7y agoBear in mind you might not have the same way to report salaries. In France, for instance, when employees report salary, they don't include the tax the company pays for them. AFAIK, in the US, salaries are reported including them. I still have a very hard time making apple to apple comparisons. If anyone has a good methodology, please ping
- dx034 7y agoBut this shouldn't make a difference relatively. In most of Europe (every country I know salary data of), manufacturing engineers tend to get paid at least the same if not more than programmers.
- bb123 7y agoYeah and there is also the ridiculous cost of living in a lot of the tech areas. A household earning $117k is on the poverty line in SF.
- mikorym 7y agoIn SA salary before tax is used. So you lose from there between 20%–45%.
- Digory 7y agoIn the US, salaries are not usually described including tax, are they? When someone in the US says they make $100,000 per year, that is usually exclusive of any tax paid by the company. It is also exclusive of other benefits paid, with health insurance commonly being $10-20k paid by the company, if provided. The employee is responsible for their own income tax. There’s confusion because in the gig/entrepreneur/consultant world, people will say they “make” $200,000 in business income. But then they bear taxes and benefits out of that amount. So you may “make” more, but do worse than someone who is an employee of a bigger company. That is why it takes a substantial increase in income in the US to justify leaving a stable employer.