25 ms·
Apple Explains Mysterious iPhone 11 Location Requests
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- Wowfunhappy 7y ago...y'know what I find particularly nuts about this whole thing? That we only know about it because of that location icon in the status bar. Apple could have chosen to hide that icon for certain types of requests, and this story wouldn't exist. I really hope that after this update is released, someone with checkm8 goes and checks what has actually changed. Not because I distrust Apple per se, but because we shouldn't be making discoveries based on a cosmetic icon. Also, thank god for checkm8. Edit: donkeyd, below, reminded me that this behavior is only on the iPhone 11, which isn't vulnerable to checkm8. Sigh...
- dkonofalski 7y agoJust out of curiosity, how would you recommend that they do this without affecting the experience for the majority of people using their devices that, frankly, don't care? How else should we be discovering this as opposed to the icon? I feel like a prompt or something to allow this for something that happens so frequently is just going to get UAC'd.
- riazrizvi 7y agoThe majority of people aren’t going to ask all their apps and services to stop tracking them. This is for the minority of users who might be being tracked by an abusive ex, or an employee at a big company who wants temporary privacy to do a job interview at another company without it getting flagged by HR. If the data is being collected, we have seen in the press that the odds are high that it is being monetized/sold.
- dkonofalski 7y agoThis is talking about wideband location scanning, not location services for an app. Apple's location services already do allow you to turn them off on a per-app basis.
- metaphor 7y agoDelusional. Who cares if your Apple device constrains location information when, stochastically speaking, other devices within your proximity won't. This has been meta for a long time: WiFi, Bluetooth, cell towers, TPMS, just to name a few common mappings. UWB is yet another PHY contributing to the datapool.
- dkonofalski 7y agoWith Apple devices, at least, the location of said devices is never reported to anyone other than the device owner. Apple uses anonymous Mac addresses that are mapped on device to do their triangulation and they don't identify to other devices. Even if another devices were keeping a list of every device that attempted to connect to it, it would never get the same value twice nor would it get an accurate address so it would be functionally useless to anyone trying to collect it using that info.
- Wowfunhappy 7y agoSecurity researchers should be able to gain fully privileged access to their devices, via a process that is well-hidden from the average user. I hope those special iPhones for security researchers come out soon.
- wil421 7y agoDid you just say secret backdoor or secret root account for research purposes?
- Wowfunhappy 7y agoSorry, that's definitely not what I meant! I would like there to be a process similar to disabling System Integrity Protection on macOS, which requires booting into recovery mode. From there you can gain kernel access and inspect whatever processes you want. It won't happen, and I consider it a major problem with iOS.
- wil421 7y agoI’d imagine maybe a special mode in Xcode where you could connect via USB and get extra debugging.
- saagarjha 7y agoThen Cellebrite would spoof that.
- earthboundkid 7y agoI also feel like iOS should have such a mode, but I also imagine that if it existed there would be a million pages saying, "Hey kids, want to install this cracked game? It's easy, first get your dad's iPhone and turn off system integrity protection…" It already happens with enterprise certs.
- TazeTSchnitzel 7y ago
- aspett 7y ago> ...y'know what I find particularly nuts about this whole thing? That we only know about it because of that location icon in the status bar It seems to me like discovering this from that status bar icon is a _good_ thing. It gives me more faith that the system isn't hiding particular types of calls from the user; that it's tying the system call to the icon being present.
- Wowfunhappy 7y agoOh, the fact that researchers did find this absolutely speaks well of Apple! Although, there's a sort of confirmation bias here—if there's some other situation where requests go out and the icon never appears, we wouldn't know about it.
- ProfessorLayton 7y agoYes and no. One of the results of iPhone 4's "antennagate" is that Apple changed the way the phone signal is displayed. They changed the algorithm, and made the signal bars more prominent in low signal situations [1] I'm not suggesting they will change its behavior, but it wouldn't be unprecedented if they did. EDIT: Changed the video start time to specific reference. [1] https://youtu.be/b9eXYOA8TCk?t=672 https://youtu.be/b9eXYOA8TCk?t=672
- 0xffff2 7y agoWhere exactly in that 27 minutes long video are we supposed to be looking?
- hombre_fatal 7y agoThat was the first time I actually watched that conference. Steve Jobs presents a convincing case. It's now clear to me that the media hyped up a non-issue, or at least one that was ubiquitous across the state of the art at the time. And Apple's response is perfectly reasonable. What exactly is your problem with his explanation of the changes?
- ProfessorLayton 7y ago
- mrtksn 7y agoNot at all, iPhones are physical devices that obey the laws of physics(Apple would claim that they are magical but in reality, they are electronic devices). This means you can analyze these devices and deduct the way they are working. Having access to the system or the source code can make things easier but not having those doesn't mean you can't look for shenanigans.
- autoexec 7y agoIt does make it much harder though and you can hide shenanigans in encrypted communications during seemingly benign situations where use of location data is expected.
- mrtksn 7y agoSure, the more access you have the easier it gets, but even if you have full source code access and full hardware access it doesn't guarantee anything. There was a very serious security bug in OpenSSL that went unnoticed for a year(Heartbleed). If the attacker is sophisticated enough, they can introduce complex bugs that are very hard to reason from the source code and maintain plausible deniability.
- donkeyd 7y agoAFAIK, iPhone 11 isn't vulnerable to checkm8, so I don't think it's useful in this case.
- Wowfunhappy 7y agoOh, that's right, this is iPhone 11 only. :/
- saagarjha 7y agoYou don’t need a jailbreak to verify that this is fixed, fortunately.
- Wowfunhappy 7y agoHow would you verify the fix without a Jailbreak? All I can think of is continuing to rely on that stupid icon. I think I trust Apple to not just hide the icon and call it a day, but I find it quite disconcerting to think that if they did, we’d probably never know.
- saagarjha 7y agoYou could pull the binary from the OS and reverse it.
- dangero 7y agoReading location via GPS is passive with no outbound data transmission. As Apple explained, in line with the Apple engineer's prior response, there is a reason why this is not a privacy leak. It does not transmit the geo data off of the device at all. If they were transmitting it, people would see the data packets and want to know what it is.
- marc__1 7y agoand yet, this is OS 11 with no signs of camera and microphone access icon (we never know if a certain social media co is using our live camera in the background). Just saying that there is a lot of optics related to phone 'privacy'
- balabaster 7y agoI'm surprised there aren't hackers out there that have created a cell phone tower in a box to obtain all outbound traffic from a device and reverse engineered all the comms chatter to be 100% sure what's going on with phones. Given that these devices exist and are in use by law enforcement to catch criminals, we know this is feasible.
- willstrafach 7y agoMyself and my colleagues do exactly this every day. Relevant to current story: https://twitter.com/chronic/status/1202386593387966464 https://twitter.com/chronic/status/1202386593387966464 I am sure many companies in the information security field are doing the same. It would be nice if there was a simple way to allow anyone with a phone to easily analyze all of their own traffic.
- rudolph9 7y agoI never get why cell phones don’t have the indicator light that tells you the camera is on. Ideally this light would be physically linked to the power going to the camera and the light would be impossible to disable without physically altering the device. I’d like the same for the microphone. I think location based stuff is a little more instantaneous in turn harder to accomplish but generally speaking more indicators that cannot be disabled with software tightly coupled with sensors potentially violating our privacy.
- tenebrisalietum 7y ago> I never get why cell phones don’t have the indicator light that tells you the camera is on. Reduces BOM, manufacturing cost, board space needed, and battery drain to exclude it. LEDs on phones were all the rage (at least one Blackberry model had an LED accessible by apps IIRC) until Apple took the market by storm and then everyone started copying their aesthetic. > Ideally this light would be physically linked to the power going to the camera and the light would be impossible to disable without physically altering the device. There's no way for you to verify unless you built the camera yourself or can remove the camera.
- pletnes 7y agoiFixit can disassemble one and check with a scope.
- tjoff 7y agoMany phones have LEDs but do not have software support for it. Sometimes it goes a long time before someone recognizes that a LED hides in the speaker grill and then boom, someone writes an app to enable it. The manufacturer was contempt with adding a LED to a device and not caring if it ever was used. Cost was not part of it. Even google, on it's nexus 5, had a LED. A prominent RGB LED that could do everything you ever wanted. Well, unless you relied on google for the software which if possible made it worse than if it hadn't existed. Then you open up the phone to replace the dying battery. And behold, multiple SMA type connectors for external antennas(?) One wonders if a single person on earth found a use for them. Cost optimization don't seem to be that important. Now for the camera LED I don't think phone manufacturers want to even admit that it is something anyone should be worried about. So their strategy is likely to pretend that there doesn't even exist any issues to worry about. Probably works out pretty well for them.
- ogre_codes 7y agoAs I mentioned on the previous story about this, my phone checking where it is doesn't bother me. My phone sharing my location without me knowing does bother me. I'm far more bothered by the fact that my Roomba requests location data than I am this. Seriously Roomba, WTF.
- p1necone 7y agoRoomba's trying to get out of your house. Roomba wants to be a free vacuum cleaner.
- m463 7y agoSometimes checking is sharing. I think there are ways to design APIs to be more private, but noone seems to do it. For instance, one way to figure out your time zone is to send your location to a server, which will return the time zone. Another more private way might be to load a list of location vs timezones for a region of the US, then calculate your timezone locally.
- morganherlocker 7y agoI implemented something like this a couple years ago and the geometry files used for timezone lookup were surprisingly large (~200 MB at decent precision)! I ended up simplifying the geometries drastically to minimize data requirements and compute burden of the lookups, but if you need higher precision, server reverse geocoding may be your only option in constrained environments.
- m463 7y agoOn the other hand, with my example the timezone data can be stored and used locally until you leave the region.
- lern_too_spel 7y agoOn iOS, there is no way to do this. Every location request will ultimately send your location to Apple.
- chews 7y agoThis is because Apple is silently building a survailance network for lost devices, the UWB chip in the iPhone 11 is also in the Airpods Pro and will be on all future Apple things. Say I leave my Airpods pro in the conference room of an office I was at earlier for a job interview... with Apple's UWB magic, any iPhone 11 can be used to find my airpods, not just mine... This is for locational discovery of all future apple devices, this mesh network allows someone to use your device as the exit to apples location servers.
- NoPicklez 7y agoHow do we not know that they would only allow discovery of devices linked to your Apple account?
- supernova87a 7y agoThe description of the system so far has detailed that only you and one of your other devices can discover where your lost device is, and no one else.
- olliej 7y agoIf you read the white paper it makes it clear that location information isn't limited by policy (permissions, etc), but rather by actual cryptographic techniques that need your devices to access. It is designed so that you can always have find my X working without simultaneously requiring your (unencrypted) location being sent to apple.
- callalex 7y agoThe only way we will know that those claims are remotely true is if they release spice code. Until then, how can we know?
- olliej 7y agoI mean if you're unwilling to accept a published document from them, then you can't accept any claims by any company. Including Google + Android. At least, unlike android, iOS indicated that the location system was being used.
- jrochkind1 7y agoThe surprisingly positive aspect of this is that a piece of system software which is checking for location, which there is no toggle for in System Services, which nobody even new existed at all... ...still makes the the Location Services icon flash! The Location Services icon really does flash when anything uses Location Services, apparently. This is no trivial thing to be thankful for, and hardly something I'm confident will be universally true forever.
- netsharc 7y agoYeah, there's been cases where "This light means the webcam is active" and "This hardware switch toggles the WiFi on and off" were overridable. Well, then again, I don't want an Alexa or Google Home, but I don't mind having an always-on Android phone with a microphone and 2 cameras...
- autoexec 7y ago> I don't mind having an always-on Android phone with a microphone and 2 cameras... I'm not happy that I don't have the option of a hardware switch to disable the cameras and mics on a phone, but I can do everything a smart speaker does without bugging my home in the process. If a company like samsung, LG, or Motorola offered a phone that really took user privacy seriously I think they'd find a lot of people would be interested, but until then I just have to assume my phone is spying on me at all times and I limit how I use it and what data I enter into it as a result.
- pdimitar 7y agoThe reason I bought an iPhone was that in my eyes I'm picking the lesser evil: only Apple is spying on me. While in Android's case it's Google, the smartphone vendor (Samsung, Huawei etc.) and hell knows how many others. I of course don't have an irrefutable proof but judging by circumstantial evidence, news and PR, it's the best conclusion I can reach for now. But I'm pretty sure my iPhone is spying on me anyway.
- 7y ago
- dang 7y agoThe previous related thread: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21699576 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21699576
- BluSyn 7y agoThis brings up an issue I wish iOS and Android would solve. Location data is always very specific, as accurate as GPS or Cellular triangulation can offer (down to the centimeter in some cases). However the vast majority of use-cases don't need this level of precision. Maybe Maps for accurate directions require this, but rarely anything else. In this case the OS simply needs to know what country you are in, not what street corner you are on. Why can't apps request less precise location data, and maybe let the user choose this? Another common example is Twitter, Facebook, Instagram, and even dating apps, don't need to know your location with precision, they usually just want the city or zip code with relative accuracy. My Weather app doesn't need to know what rock I'm standing next to for accurate forecasting.
- jiqiren 7y agoiOS apps definitely do have this granular option. It's been around since iOS 2 SDK. https://developer.apple.com/documentation/corelocation/cllocationmanager/1423836-desiredaccuracy https://developer.apple.com/documentation/corelocation/clloc...
- sefrost 7y agoI wish we could do this on web, and see what location data we were going to send if we granted the permission.
- rootusrootus 7y agoYeah I have wanted this option since the beginning. Precise location, no, but want to provide just my zip code or city or state? Maybe I'll actually say yes.
- crazygringo 7y agoVery interesting. But when an app requests location permissions, it's still the same message right? There's no way of knowing whether the app will be using your exact location, or just the city you're in?
- simon_acca 7y agoIt seems that the answer raises even more of an eyebrow than the original question... why is UWB active in devices if no end-user application can yet benefit from it?
- comex 7y agoAirDrop already benefits from it.
- whoopdedo 7y agoDoes iOS still make location requests when AirDrop is turned off?
- walterbell 7y agoYes, https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21719040 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21719040
- saagarjha 7y agoBecause AirDrop is using it?
- worik 7y agoWhy does anybody still use iPhones? Expensive and incompatible they are simply not as good as the many cheaper and interoperable competitors
- helpPeople 7y agoMarketing
- autoexec 7y agoAs far as I can tell it comes down to their perception as a status symbol and/or buy-in to the apple ecosystem. When you're using apple everything an iphone might make sense.
- blazespin 7y agoThe only way to ensure location privacy is to interfere with GPS. When you wish to use the location feature, turn off the GPS interference. As such technique is pretty esoteric, it's unlikely Apple will develop counter techniques until it becomes more popular. As has been mentioned before, relying on some icon on your screen is rather naive unless Apple has provided some legal assurance that we can. It would be a good question to pose to Apple - can the icon be overridden to not be shown or shown so quickly that it is effectively invisible?
- CamperBob2 7y ago“Ultra Wideband technology is an industry standard technology and is subject to international regulatory requirements that require it to be turned off in certain locations,” the statement continues. “iOS uses Location Services to help determine if iPhone is in these prohibited locations in order to disable Ultra Wideband and comply with regulations. The management of Ultrawide Band compliance and its use of location data is done entirely on the device and Apple is not collecting user location data.” Ridiculous. The phone always knows very well what country and what regulatory region it's operating in. Otherwise, how could it know what cellular bands to use?
- endorphone 7y agoI think it's a bit more nuanced than being at the country level. For instance - https://support.apple.com/en-ca/guide/iphone/iph771fd0aad/ios https://support.apple.com/en-ca/guide/iphone/iph771fd0aad/io... "Australia: Ultra Wideband transmitters must not be operated within a nominated distance from specified Australian radio-astronomy sites." Further, your phone certainly doesn't have to know where it is to figure out what cellular bands to use, but instead that's based upon the SIM and cell provider settings.
- CamperBob2 7y agoa) Not all of the bands enabled by the phone's SIM are usable in all locations. Because this information is transmitted by the cell site, the phone does not have to enable location services. It knows where it is and what frequencies it can use, trust me. b) There are other locations where the entire phone isn't allowed to be turned on (the NRAO quiet zone near Green Bank comes to mind, unless this has changed recently.) So, no. This is not a valid excuse.
- kalleboo 7y ago> Otherwise, how could it know what cellular bands to use? By passively listening for what bands are being broadcast on? I mean, dumb phones without any kind of location support whatsoever could do that, without determining what regulatory region they are in.
- betoharres 7y agoin other words: "yes we can have your location at any time, and we are not collecting the data, I promise!"
- kalleboo 7y agoTurning off Location Services completely still turns this off. There is just no specific switch to turn only this off (so if you turn off all the other specific switches, this stays on).
- augstein 7y agoIt is astonishing to me, that one of the best known IT security researchers has to rely on a flashing icon to determine if location services were used or not. Apple could easily disable said icon in certain cases. This begs the question: Isn‘t there a more reliable way to determine if an iPhone uses location services and maybe even say for sure for what they are used?
- willstrafach 7y agoAbsolutely. You can reverse engineer components of iOS to find this out, and analyze outgoing network traffic as a quick way to see what data is going out to remote servers. The icon, in this case, was a helpful indicator allowing others to easily reproduce this test in minutes.
- lzsiga 7y agoI seem to have missed something: Apple claims Location Services cannot be disabled because it is needed for Ultrawide Band (UWB) compliance. And what about UWB? It cannot be disabled either? Do you have a say if someone wants to send you a file 'simply by pointing at your iPhone'?
- jrockway 7y agoAirdrop is not a new feature. You can whitelist people that can use it on you.
- walterbell 7y agoLocation-check icon still appears on iPhone 11 when Airdrop is disabled via Apple Configurator policy and location permission denied for all Apple system services. Is UWB used for features other than Airdrop? Location reporting of nearby tags/devices? One avenue of investigation would be to capture all iPhone 11 traffic via VPN (e.g. Charles Proxy) and correlate network traffic with appearance of the location indicator.
- willstrafach 7y agoThis test would not yield a useful result in this particular case, as the data is processed locally on-device and is not sent to a remote server.
- heliophobicdude 7y agoIf Apple introduces tile like competitor, would it lower the threshold for creepy and stalky folks to track others? Would it be as easy and slipping in a Apple Tile and its location be crowdsourced back to Apple and therefore to the stalker?
- chews 7y agoYep, it’s a beta called B389
- willstrafach 7y agoTechnically, that is the hardware product codenames (Closely tracking with AirPods it seems, B188 and B288)
- kkarakk 7y agoYou don't even know to go that far if apple's aspirations for devices helping you locate your things goes to fruition- "accidentally" slip your airpods into someone else's bag and apple will helpfully locate it for you until your airpod's case goes out of power There are going to be a lot of issues if apple just lets you track things at range
- yalogin 7y agoThis is actually awesome. If Apple wanted they could have made the indicator not show up at all when that feature uses location. This means they are staying true to the promise.
- newbalance 7y agoThis is simply a case of a new system service of which there are many: Location, Photos, Calendar, etc. and now, Ultra Wideband (UWB), being rolled out without being tied into the existing permission model. https://developer.apple.com/design/human-interface-guidelines/ios/app-architecture/requesting-permission/ https://developer.apple.com/design/human-interface-guideline...
- atemerev 7y ago"The management of Ultrawide Band compliance and its use of location data is done entirely on the device and Apple is not collecting user location data." Call me paranoid, but this statement is telling us that: "The management of UWB compliance and the management of its use of location data is done on the device" -- which okays that the data can be used outside the device, only the management needs to be done on the inside, "Apple is not collecting user location data." -- which could mean that some other parties (not Apple) _could_ collect user location data.
- GeekyBear 7y agoThe thing that I find amusing is that we are talking about an implementation of Google's own White Spaces initiative that is working as intended. To use the same frequency band allocated to uses like television and radio broadcasting without interference, you need a way to know which frequencies are already in use by the local stations at your location. >So-called "white space" frequencies have considerable benefits when compared to traditional Wi-Fi signals, and now Google has created an API to make the process of utilizing them easier. Companies using the Spectrum Database API will be able to search for frequencies unoccupied by TV or radio signals in specific areas of the United States, and register equipment that uses those frequencies to broadcast wireless internet. Google has championed unlicensed TV white space (TVWS) over the last few years. The FCC approved the use of Google's TVWS database in June, after tests began in March. https://www.theverge.com/2013/11/15/5106218/google-database-api-brings-white-space-broadband-closer https://www.theverge.com/2013/11/15/5106218/google-database-... Apple appears to be doing nothing more than querying a local copy of the database to look up which frequencies must be avoided at the current location. All the Android phones that adopt ultra wideband technology will have to do the same thing.
- jrockway 7y agoUWB is not White Spaces. White Spaces was a plan to make frequencies once allocated to analog TV broadcasters unlicensed (similar to the existing ISM bands). This would give things like WiFi access points more spectrum to use, without fundamentally changing how the protocols worked. (Same signal, different RF frontend for the new frequencies.) UWB is a very low-power spread-spectrum technique. It decreases power and increases the bandwidth used to achieve a usable channel capacity. The idea is that the power is so low that it won't interfere with licensed users, even though it's using licensed frequencies. The downside is that it's a lot more complicated and requires new hardware and electronics techniques to implement. (I assume the reason it's disabled in some regions is because they haven't convinced the relevant authorities that it doesn't actually interfere with licensed users while using their spectrum.)