6 ms·
If there's that much storage in cars if a large % of transport switches over, especially consumer commuters with long-range batteries, perhaps a service can all
by AtlasBarfed 7y ago
If there's that much storage in cars if a large % of transport switches over, especially consumer commuters with long-range batteries, perhaps a service can allow EV owners to get paid to allow their daily commute cars to store excess solar in the day and stream it back at night.
- basch 7y agoAt what point does switching to something more trolleybus like, where your car charges while driving down the road, maybe in contact with a rail, make more sense than all this self driving and battery capacity? Even if it was just interstates.
- toomuchtodo 7y agoLikely never (if you look at Tesla's luxury vehicles almost at 400 miles of range [S and X with Raven drivetrains] and their Supercharger charge rates [0-80% SOC in ~15-20 minutes]). Battery capacity per kg and charge rates are likely to improve faster than coordinating the deployment of nationwide rail or overhead wire electrical infrastructure on interstates (a Supercharger station only takes about two weeks to install, and costs ~$150k-200k). https://supercharge.info/map https://supercharge.info/map
- Jamwinner 7y agoYes, but energy density is terrible. You are having to move 3x the weight not to mention the huge effincicy hit . You arent taking reality into account.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- jsight 7y agoThe Model 3 weighs hundreds of lb more than its equivalent in an ICE car, not 3x as much. These numbers are still improving as well.
- basch 7y agoI dont think the comparison is to ICE but to a car on a rail/line that doesnt need to carry its energy at all (or only a small battery for the last 30 miles.)
- toomuchtodo 7y agoThat is an unreasonable comparison to make, considering EVs are competing with ICE vehicles, not trains or busses.
- basch 7y agoBut this is a tangent about rails and wires vs EV, not ICE.
- maxerickson 7y agoIt's a tangent about how to power personal vehicles, which are overwhelmingly powered by the gasoline. Is that just path dependence, or maybe there are advantages to having lots of built in range?
- scarejunba 7y agoThe economics do not make sense. There are massive capital and operational expenditures to build power rails/overhead wires everywhere. If you want to longbets.org this I will have someone put down $1000 this will not happen in any city of over 10k people in the United States in the next 20 years.
- cowmix 7y agoBMW 3 series: 3,582 to 3,764 lbs Model 3: 3,627 to 4,072 lbs At best the Tesla is 8% heavier (total weight).
- lazyjones 7y agoI'm still hoping that Teslas on AP will eventually begin to coordinate and drive very close together or even attach bumper-to-bumper in order to save energy on highways due to lower air resistance. Ad hoc highway trains more or less...
- m463 7y agoFor all practical purposes they have that now. The CD on tesla cars is very low, and even AP1 cars will follow other vehicles on the highway for hundreds of miles without a hitch. The AP follow distance setting can be set from 1 to 7, and setting it to 1 just ends up with more abrupt braking when traffic encounters a slowdown. A spaced out setting of 4 is a much more comfortable setting.
- lazyjones 7y agoIf the cars were able to push and pull each other, engines/batteries could be used optimally. Cars with nearly empty batteries would recuperate and recharge if absolutely needed, cars with full batteries would pull the rest. AP would put the most suitable car in front to minimize the total air resistance... Lots of possibilities. Might be worth designing a new type of car for this kind of use though.
- seanmcdirmid 7y agoEven buses are using batteries to move away from the trolley bus model. Maintaining those overhead lines is a pain, and they go offline all the time. I expect these will just go away outside of true rail usage.
- mdorazio 7y agoA company I worked with looked into this model. The problem is that most cars are not in garages near PV during the day, they're in parking lots at work or in shopping/errand locations. They return to garages and plug in just before sunset, so the load on the grid from EVs actually goes up right as the input from PV is going down. The model does work great with powerwall-type devices, though.
- sp332 7y agoBut if you offer to pay people who keep their cars plugged in during the day, probably more people would do it. Also, while car batteries are likely to be lower in the evenings, they're probably not completely dead. They could feed the remaining energy back to the grid at that time, then charge up later at night when the load is lower.
- mdorazio 7y ago1) The percentage of people with EVs who leave them plugged in at home during the day is very small. This is unlikely to change for several years. 2) It's a bad proposition to people because you're basically telling them they won't be able to take long trips in the morning and you're going to decrease the life of their battery (people are rightfully really concerned about this). 3) The big concern with utilities right now is how to handle home renewable excess power during the day. All the rooftop PV is feeding a bunch of power back into the grid when it's sunny, then all those homes are sucking down power from dusk to dawn. The utilities need daytime power storage or non-daylight generation to offset this. Storing power at night doesn't do much to actually solve the problem, so there's not much of a business model in it. Grid-scale battery installations are quickly becoming the solution here. If you're looking for a car-based model that could potentially work for this, it has to involve solar parking lots and also be car-specific. Charge your car at a parking lot during the day, drive it home and plug it in to power your house in the evening. Get a discount from your electric company as a result.
- oceanplexian 7y agoI sorta get the idea but who wants to burn cycles on your EV to save a couple of bucks a month? It makes no sense to me. You can just buy batteries for your house. We’re down to what? $200/kWh? Less? If there wasn’t so much mark up in the industry, you could buy a whole house battery for 2-3k that would be good enough to shift most of your energy usage. Utilities just need to incentivize it, which presumably would happen naturally due to market forces as solar adoption goes up.
- m463 7y agoEV car batteries are too expensive and overdesigned to be used for grid power (imho)
- mastre_ 7y agoHow so? We have two long range Model 3s which have 140+ kWh capacity in total (70kWh/car, conservatively). Even if you'd only allow 50% of that to be used for powering one's house (you don't want to run large batteries all the way down, or charge them to 100%, often, if you care about long-term capacity), each car could provide 35 kWh, or the equivalent capacity of ~3 PowerWalls. The proper electrical interfaces and monitoring needs to be engineered, but there isn't any good reason not to do this. Seems like such a waste. Even if you could only use 20kWh, that's still be a huge win. In states such as Florida (and, now, California) where power outages are frequent, this would be a godsend.
- YarickR2 7y agoOf course. Drain your car during the outage, get stuck with dead car when it turns out this outage is caused by the fire nearby.
- greglindahl 7y agoYou can skip the "stream it back at night" part. If you have a big battery, you don't need to charge it to full every day. So you plug in day and night, and have an algorithm pick when it actually charges... based on the wind/sun forecast and your calendar entries. Then there is no extra battery wear. There are quite a few people here in Palo Alto who can plug in at work. Facebook has more than 100 chargers at their HQ, and half of the EVs at my apartment complex never use our free charger.