10 ms·
It's exactly this. Within any organization, you can have 3 or 6 important people pushing in completely different strategic directions. And it can be clear to a
by crazygringo 7y ago
It's exactly this.
Within any organization, you can have 3 or 6 important people pushing in completely different strategic directions. And it can be clear to any unbiased observer that there's only one good, responsible choice, but within your org that gets met with essentially "but that's just your opinion, man".
So you call in a consulting firm and they deliver what most of the people already know. The consultants don't need to be rocket scientists.
But afterwards, nobody can say it's just your opinion any more. It's now expert analysis that you paid good $$$ for, and everybody who disagreed before now basically has to get on board.
So it's not even necessarily political "cover", but almost like a referee that brings enough credibility to settle otherwise intractable internal disputes.
Also, this lets the CEO appear unbiased to all the people who "lost". So they can get on board with the new policy but not feel like the CEO shot them down personally, which is bad for morale, can lead them to quit, etc. (Just because they believed in the wrong strategy doesn't mean they still can't be super-valuable in the future in executing the right strategy.)
- beambot 7y ago"Referee" is too unbiased a word. Shocking how frequently the consultants' conclusions mirror the arguments posed by the side that pays their fees.
- kube-system 7y agoMoney is one thing, but there's also just plain old information bias. Politics don't go away when the consultants come in. The consultants are going to be working closer with the group that brought them in. It's not uncommon in my experience for the 'other group(s)' to ghost the consultants.
- slg 7y ago>Also, this lets the CEO appear unbiased to all the people who "lost". So they can get on board with the new policy but not feel like the CEO shot them down personally, which is bad for morale, can lead them to quit, etc. The flip side is that it is also bad for morale for someone to be recommending a solution for some time, the recommendation is ignored, a consultant is hired, the consultant recommends the same solution, and then the recommendation is implemented. This is exacerbated when the consultant's fee is some large percent or maybe even a multiple of the salary of the person who originally recommended the solution. It makes the original employee feel worthless and doubt the leadership's ability to properly evaluate solutions.
- underdown 7y agoWouldn't one enjoy some benefits from being proven right?
- alistairSH 7y agoRight up until you realize the 23 year old snot who made the recommendation billed ~$3 million against your ~$100k salary.
- LameRubberDucky 7y agoThe person billed that for the consulting company, but I doubt they got that much. Consulting companies burn both ends.
- crazygringo 7y agoIf you look at entry-level consultant salaries at McKinsey and then divide by the fact that they're often working 7-day, 100-hour workweeks... you'll quickly discover that your "23 year old snot" is actually making around minimum wage on an hourly basis. They could be flipping burgers instead with a lot less stress. The consultants aren't the ones taking the money home, the firm is. So don't blame the 23 year old. He or she is honestly just doing their insane best to pay off their huge student loans.
- opencl 7y ago100 hours a week at federal minimum wage is less than $38k. These people are not making anything remotely close to minimum wage.
- solveit 7y agoBut federal minimum wage ($7.25) is a lot smaller than, say, the NYC minimum wage ($15), which is more relevant. At the NYC minimum wage, 100-hour work weeks get you about 80k a year, which is about the base pay for an undergraduate new hire at McKinsey.
- jkestner 7y agoI know y’all want to repeat the whole thing about consultants we've all heard before, which sure, is “exactly this”, but the article goes much deeper, and is specific to the government. Here, consultants are ripping off taxpayers because a Clinton-era rule financially incentivized the government to outsource work to “entrepreneurs”. This department is literally given a percentage of the money it gives to consultants.
- LameRubberDucky 7y agoIsn't this the definition of a kickback?
- defen 7y agoA kickback is when you personally get reimbursed for your decision, which isn’t the case here. A government office is being funded by a fee on services rendered.
- sailfast 7y agoGSA gets a cut of contract purchases that go through them but this makes sense because it incentivized them to be better alternatives than an agency’s own contract shops. Typically working through a GSA schedule like this can lead to faster turnaround and lower prices - nobody can charge the government more than their best commercial customer, legally, under this framework. If you don’t get value, put your own RFP on the street. The incentive to get more dollars if you get more under management as a contract-service-provider does make sense. They’re not a monopoly on procurement in government, despite the author writing a book about monopolies. Note: in some cases they have monopolies on some things in government, but not procurement.
- iudqnolq 7y agoThanks for providing the background on how this came about, it makes a bit more sense now. Could we get the same result by allocating the GSA a flat amount based on what they need and then penalize them by cutting the budget if no one uses their services, just like we do for other agencies?
- jrochkind1 7y ago> Within any organization, you can have 3 or 6 important people pushing in completely different strategic directions. And it can be clear to any unbiased observer that there's only one good, responsible choice, Or, there ISN'T a clear exactly one good responsible choice, it really is a matter of judgement and/or choice of priorities/values... and then whoever can exert the most control over the contractor can still get their way by getting the contractor to pick their side.
- draw_down 7y agoSeems like other parties to the disagreement could do the same thing, at which point you're back where you started except with less money.
- abbadadda 7y ago> "but that's just your opinion, man". TIL The Dude is a phenomenal businessman.
- ACow_Adonis 7y agoExcept the consultants don't always put forward the one best solution, they put forward the solution of the person paying the dollars. I remember one awkward situation i was familiar with where two diametrically opposed groups both notionally hired the same consultancy firm to write their respective proposals/submissions. No points for guessing whether the consultancy offered the same advice... Funny in one sense, but only because if you don't laugh you'll cry...
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- coffeemug 7y agoSee, the problem is that when companies get big they stop thinking in terms of values and start thinking in terms of equilibria. A values approach to this problem would be promoting people with good taste, and then building a culture of acquiescing when they decide to step in. If someone doesn't like that, fuck 'em. Yeah it might hurt in the short term, but every time you let people with bad taste stall the show you erode your culture a little, until one day you come to work and realize that nobody can decide anything anymore. An equilibrium approach is to say "well, a consultant will cost $3M/year, and potentially pissing off Alice and Bob and Carol and maybe Dan is painful and it's difficult to calculate how much that will cost, and $3M < UNDEFINED == TRUE so let's hire McKinsey". I have a huge soft spot for economics, but the thing about equilibria like this is that they never account for externalities and long term costs, and $3M < UNDEFINED is just bad logic to use, and also it's spineless and cowardly and people should know better.