3 ms·
The extremely adversarial approach to "justice" is an issue specific to the US (and probably some other countries), and is not universal. Do definitely have a
by mcv 7y ago
The extremely adversarial approach to "justice" is an issue specific to the US (and probably some other countries), and is not universal.
Do definitely have a lawyer present, but whether or not to talk to the police varies a lot per country. Personally, I think that not talking to the police being such vital advice in the US, is a strong condemnation of how the American system works. People should be able to trust the police, and the police and prosecutors should be working to do justice, not merely to lock up as many people as possible. Every innocent person behind bars is a failure of the system.
- matwood 7y agoIt has to do with incentives. When incentivized for the number of arrests and convictions, no one cares if it's the right people. Add in that there is almost zero penalty for prosecutorial misconduct unless it is extreme, and it's no wonder so many innocent people end up in jail. Prosecutors play fast and loose to win the game, justice be damned.
- mcv 7y agoYeah, the system needs to be fixed. Instead of rewarding people for number of convictions, right or wrong, they should be rewarded for reducing crime by independent measurement. Or simply be rewarded for doing their job as honestly as possible, with proper accountability and all that. But rewarding police and prosecutors for the number of convictions is like rewarding programmers for the number of lines of code. It rewards bad code and unjust convictions. Maybe there should be a justice-equivalent of code review for police and prosecutors.
- ryacko 7y agoIt was called the grand jury, they made reports on issues of public concern, and authorized private prosecutors to pursue cases against suspects. It isn't clear what sort of reforms are needed, but grand juries are the only democratic institution in our republic.
- goodluckchuck 7y agoIn both approaches the police investigate potential crimes, collect evidence, talk to witnesses, attempt to figure out who did it and why, they may prosecute the accused, and if convicted the person is punished, often with fines, imprisonment, and/or community service. We can disagree as to whether this is an adversarial approach, but the approaches are essentially the same. I think the US's view of the process is more accurate, but that's the issue. The incentives of the police, the numbers they may or may not have to meet, and their accuracy at finding the "right" person, are all beside the point when you're in a room with a officer that seems to be making a case. That's an adversarial situation; someone's future is in jeopardy and it very well might be yours.
- adrianmonk 7y agoI respectfully disagree that this is specific to the US. I think it has been an issue everywhere throughout history. Don't get me wrong. It's a great thing when a country overcomes it and manages to create a fair, even-handed justice system. But human nature is to want to see something done about it when crimes happen. That's why before formal justice systems existed (and still today in certain undeveloped areas), a mob would form and just take out -- as in kill -- the suspect on the spot. Without really being sure that they were guilty. The idea of deferring punishment, recognizing and protecting the rights of the accused, and conducting a fair, orderly trial is a wonderful thing, but it's not the default. It's really more like an achievement in human evolution.