8 ms·
'Shockingly High' Number of Injuries at Amazon's Staten Island Warehouse
- Spooky23 7y agoIt's amazing to think that a decade ago, Amazon was touting injury rates around 3-4 in fulfillment centers -- lower than grocery stores. Their Delaware center was recognized as one of the safest in the country by OSHA. I worry about Amazon workers in more business friendly places. If they are doing this in a regulation heavy city/state like NY, other places must be horrific.
- Pfhreak 7y ago> Amazon was touting injury rates around 3-4 in fulfillment centers Amazon's response sort of touches on this, saying they've pushed for recording every incident, big or small. 3-4 could be from underreporting or from better working conditions (or both).
- hurxnid 7y agoCompanies do that to muddy the waters while also pushing policy that punishes people for reporting “real” injuries. Also these are lost time accidents. They could not have been previously hidden.
- shadowgovt 7y agoThey could via a policy that quietly fires people who are too poor to afford a lawyer when they're injured on the job.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- grandmczeb 7y agoLost time or job restrictions. It could be true that Amazon is more aggressive about restricting work after an injury resulting in more reports.
- arkades 7y ago> The figures also show a "shockingly high" number of severe injuries at JFK8, Kearl said. According to the report, workers whose injuries were logged by Amazon were each forced to miss an average of 64.04 days of employment.
- jellicle 7y agoBut Amazon's response is bullshit. The data is from government stats, and the reporting threshold is the same as it ever was (basically, if an employee is admitted to the hospital): https://www.osha.gov/report.html https://www.osha.gov/report.html Amazon's PR people are pretending the high numbers are because they are reporting papercuts, but papercuts would be rejected for the government stats. This is "severe injury or death" reporting only. "According to the report, workers whose injuries were logged by Amazon were each forced to miss an average of 64.04 days of employment." Does that sound like papercuts? An average of three months off work, if they even return?
- Pfhreak 7y agoSorry, I agree with you. I think the 15 represents the truthful amount of serious injuries. I'm saying the 3-4 was likely underreported to some degree for whatever reason.
- grandmczeb 7y ago> The data is from government stats, and the reporting threshold is the same as it ever was (basically, if an employee is admitted to the hospital) This is wrong. It's from an analysis of Amazon's own incident logs that OSHA requires companies to keep (OSHA form 300A[1].) The government doesn't "reject" incidents from these logs. Additionally, a recordable injury is any of the following[2] - Any work-related fatality. - Any work-related injury or illness that results in loss of consciousness, days away from work, restricted work, or transfer to another job. - Any work-related injury or illness requiring medical treatment beyond first aid. - Any work-related diagnosed case of cancer, chronic irreversible diseases, fractured or cracked bones or teeth, and punctured eardrums. - There are also special recording criteria for work-related cases involving: needlesticks and sharps injuries; medical removal; hearing loss; and tuberculosis. That's very different than "severe injury or death" only. [1] https://www.osha.gov/recordkeeping/new-osha300form1-1-04-FormsOnly.pdf https://www.osha.gov/recordkeeping/new-osha300form1-1-04-For... [2] https://www.osha.gov/recordkeeping/ https://www.osha.gov/recordkeeping/
- kube-system 7y agoAnecdotally, I know a couple of people who work at Amazon warehouses which I haven't seen mentioned in the media, and they tell me they haven't seen any of the safety issues others are reporting, and that they take safety procedures pretty seriously. I'm in a locale that is very business friendly. Maybe this issue is specific to certain locations, markets, or segments of the logistics chain. I'd imagine that employee turnover, the products being shipped, the tasks being performed, and product volume varies significantly based on the particular location. They have a lot of facilities doing a lot of different things. The media usually mentions 'fulfillment' specifically with these articles, but that's only one part of their logistics operations.
- megascone 7y agoI suspect that a large part of this is that Amazon has (according to Wikipedia) more than 300 warehouses. If this is correct, then it would not be surprising if a few warehouses are outliers even if the overall figures are reasonable. After all, randomness (both in terms of overall luck, and the distribution of shitty managers) will end up skewing a few of the results very high or very low.
- rtkwe 7y agoA couple things go into that, their NY location is probably extremely busy for Amazon due to it's proximity to NYC with it's large fairly well off population and corresponding large number of orders. That business, without increases in efforts towards safety, means more going on which means more chances for injury. As for your anecdotal info about safety with so many locations there's bound to be lots of variance in business, contractor safety, and culture around reporting.
- irrational 7y agoHow would that explain Troutdale, OR, which has a much higher rate than the NY location? Portland is an order of magnitude smaller than NYC. I would hope the rate of injuries would likewise be lower.
- 7y ago
- jammygit 7y ago> Gizmodo first reported, the warehouse scored a 15.2 on its OSHA Incident Rate, which compares the number of serious injuries to the number of total hours worked among all employees at a given worksite. That figure is five times greater than the national average for all workers, and substantially more than rates found in other dangerous workplaces, such as coal mines and sawmills. The average OSHA Rate for general warehouse workers is 5.2, or roughly a third of the injury frequency at the Staten Island fulfillment center. I keep forgetting why I cancelled my amazon account but then I’m reminded
- throw1234651234 7y agoheh, this is pretty cyberpunk though
- rtkwe 7y agoThat's not a good thing! People have gotten mesmerized by the cool aesthetic and miss/forget the whole corporate hellscape aspect of cyberpunk.
- throw1234651234 7y ago"corporate hellscape aspect" - that's exactly what I mean.
- rtkwe 7y agoAh ok, I read your comment with much more enthusiasm for it being a cyberpunk hellscape.
- cronix 7y agoIt might be high there, but Troutdale, OR is #1. What a horrible company to work for. "The most dangerous facility, according to the piece, is Amazon's warehouse in Troutdale, Ore., which had a serious injury rate of 26 per 100 workers, more than six times the industry average." https://www.wweek.com/news/business/2019/11/27/amazon-warehouse-in-troutdale-under-scrutiny/ https://www.wweek.com/news/business/2019/11/27/amazon-wareho...
- Mvhsz 7y ago> serious injury rate of 26 per 100 workers Do you know the time period for this stat, I couldn't find it in the linked article.
- jellicle 7y agoThe OSHA incident rate is per 200,000 employee-hours, which is roughly 100 people, full-time, for a year. So for every 100 people that Amazon employs full-time-equivalent in that warehouse, about 26 of them will have a serious OSHA-reported incident each year.
- HarryHirsch 7y agoIn the chemical laboratory this would be unacceptable.
- cmcd 7y agoIt is unacceptable here as well.
- jandrese 7y ago> a serious injury rate of 26 per 100 workers What? A worse than 1/4 chance you will be maimed? That seems absurdly high. Deep sea crab fishing off the Alaska coast is a safer profession!
- hurxnid 7y ago
- FernandoTN 7y ago> "Ensuring the safety of associates in our building is our number one priority and we invest heavily in safety," Having pain medications on vending machines for their employees seems to me like scheduling to fix a leak after it rains.
- dfc-agency 7y agoThere are unseen externalities for getting a tube of toothpaste for $5.99 shipped to your door in 24 hours. Unfortunately, those externalities are our countrymen and women.
- literallycancer 7y agoI can order hardware from a local store at 7 PM and have it delivered by 9 PM the same day here in Europe. They also have better prices than Amazon and no work safety problems. You can do things well or you can do them badly. There's no rule saying that good customer experience has to take a toll on your employees.
- dobleboble 7y agoRelevant recent article from satire publisher The Onion: "Horrifying Series Of Unspeakable Actions Result In $39 Crock-Pot Being Delivered To Man Same Day" https://www.theonion.com/horrifying-series-of-unspeakable-actions-result-in-39-1840154888 https://www.theonion.com/horrifying-series-of-unspeakable-ac...
- MengerSponge 7y agoAs we've seen in Indiana, Amazon is powerful enough that state legislators will bend some rules for their favor: https://www.indystar.com/story/news/investigations/2019/11/25/amazon-indiana-governor-eric-holcomb-warehouse-accident-hq-2/4282653002/ https://www.indystar.com/story/news/investigations/2019/11/2...
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- BucketSort 7y agoWe were warned not to feed man to the machine, yet that's exactly what we did. I guess everyone that died fighting for this country did so to create a bunch of billionaires and slaves to serve them. Our nation was paid for by the blood of its people, but somehow this debt is always forgotten. The people, by the right of sacrifice, deserve better than this.
- kortilla 7y agoBy the right of sacrifice? Is this a veterans-only warehouse or something? The US created a bunch of billionaires, but it also created the richest middle class. Let’s cut back the drama a bit and maybe discuss a law to improve safety?
- jacobush 7y agoNo, it's a sombre note that the state conscripted men and sent them to their deaths. To defend a free country. Which was especially free to the rich, it turns out.
- BucketSort 7y agoDrama? What about the epidemic suicides and drug overdoses happening in this country? What about the absolute destruction of rural communities by monopolies emboldened by the lack of antitrust enforcement? The people of this country are being abused in so many ways and nothing is being done for them. Laws aren't going to help this situation, it's our stinking attitude that's the problem. It's our complete disregard for human life that's the problem.
- HashHishBang 7y agoI may be off base here but this sounds an awful lot like perfect being the enemy of the good. Or, framed another way, idealism being the enemy of the pragmatic. Waxing poetic about everyday tragedy is all well and good as a rhetorical device. However, it doesn't really do anything except to sow the seeds of division now does it? Especially when you cap the whole bit with the idea that it is thought that is wrong and not action. And your proposed solution to this is effectively a paradigm shift in the perception of human value?
- sequoia 7y agoAny bets on when people who are "shocked, shocked" about Amazon's treatment of its workers are going to put their money where their mouth is and actually forgo the convenience of next day delivery & rock bottom prices? Americans have it tough in so many ways (health care system, lack of public transit, kleptocratic federal government), it's sad to see us making it even worse for our fellow small-guys like this to buy ourselves some convenience and save a few dollars on consumer goods. (Notwithstanding the many people for whom home delivery etc. is a godsend without which they'd have a much more difficult life. It's complicated.) We vote with our dollars and currently we are telling Amazon "this is OK, keep doing it" loud and clear.
- homonculus1 7y agoSome of us are doing it! I no longer do business with Amazon due to their association with law enforcement and surveillance.
- tudelo 7y agoI mean, when it comes down to it, is individual action really going to convince Amazon to have higher working standards? Or, will it come down to law?
- EdTsft 7y agoI don't think it's reasonable to expect the average consumer to research the worker quality of life (and the product safety history, and the environmental record, and the political donations, and the tax evasion tactics, and ...) of all of the hundreds or thousands of companies that they give money to. These aren't the kinds things we can expect to solve with consumer boycotts.
- sequoia 7y agoYes but you and I and the royal We of hackernews are aware of the issues. Further research is not required. So how are We reacting to it with our actions? Continuing to give amazon gobs of money & data?
- GaryNumanVevo 7y ago
- williamDafoe 7y agoGood thing everyboy took Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez to the woodshed over Amazon settling in NYC. We need more of these worker-maiming lower class jobs to keep the lower classes in their place!
- conanbatt 7y agoAOC taking Amazon away from NYC did not help neither these workers nor NYC citizens.
- all_blue_chucks 7y agoThat was regarding office jobs, not warehouse jobs.
- notTyler 7y agoThey're running employee testimonial ads about how great it is to work at their warehouses on national broadcasts pretty regularly now. That's all I needed to know that it's going downhill faster rather than slower.
- pjscott 7y agoThat just means that they have a PR problem. It doesn't necessarily indicate a problem with their actual warehouse conditions, though there may be one; it's enough that people believe there's a problem.
- chopin 7y agoBut these adverts raise even more suspicion. I had a very awkward feeling when I saw them the first time in the German TV. Everybody knows that adverts are the poster-child of lying. Why should this be different? And if those are real workers being interviewed (I doubt that) who in his right would voluntarily step in front of a camera and say "this is a great and safe place to work". If they are for real, I'd think they are coerced. If they are not for real, what's the point?
- hangDogNigger 7y agoSee, the thing is, if you think for a minute about the size of the boxes that show up at your home, and the amount of hazard experienced by the delivery person handing them off to you, it's hard to form any opinion of this which doesn't blame the workers. I get that there are other things happening in a warehouse, and that it's not your typical environment, especially considering sheer volume and scale, but knowing that everything in play is reducible to a cardboard box that your mom can lift and carry from the front door to the living room, it's hard to summon sympathy. I suppose I should have some kind of appreciation for how scale works against efficiency, and so too, safety, so maybe the demand for speed plays a role, and upper echelon nabobs thus belong in the line of fire as well. I have at least one friend who worked in an Amazon warehouse, and he said the stress is real. The pressure to perform, to deliver numbers attached to worker productivity tracking devices is constant and merciless. One last layer to this onion, organized crime. Staten Island is as notorious as any New York borough for the usual infestation of insidious high stakes blue collar crime, organized by low key bosses operating behind the scenes. Don't discount this possibility. The warehouse is an alternative opportunistic point of insertion, perfect for escalation beyond low level theft at the front door, after delivery. What would organized crime have to do with workplace accidents? There are a variety of angles, but if the overall rate seems unnatural, it may be a clue that the activity is somehow malicous.