13 ms·
My personal taste complaint with a lot of people who open a brewery... Everyone seems to think that more hops = better beer. There are so many other possible f
by walrus01 7y ago
My personal taste complaint with a lot of people who open a brewery... Everyone seems to think that more hops = better beer. There are so many other possible flavors and types to a beer than some type of IPA that is absolutely overloaded with hops. But that seems to be a very common type of thing to brew. When I open something and am assaulted with the aroma of hops, it's not appealing anymore.
It was interesting 7-8 years ago. Now it's just "oh here we go again".
I have a personal theory that the overwhelming aroma and taste of hops in a beer can be used to mask many errors and missteps in the brewing process, which might be more easily tasted by the customer if it were, for example, a weissbier.
- milquetoastaf 7y agoIPAs are some of the simplest beers to brew and they also happen to be very in demand, hence the glut of overly-hopped beers.
- cafard 7y agoIt is quite odd, the dominance of IPA. I wasn't aware of it until I walked in Rodman's in NW Washington, DC, and found that what appeared to be 80% of the American beer offerings were IPAs of one sort another.
- walrus01 7y agoAnd even more so in the Pacific Northwest, relatively close to the hop-growing area in central WA, and full of small craft breweries.
- zwieback 7y agoThey are easy to brew and hide fermentation or sanitation defects well.
- LargeWu 7y agoI don't get out to too many taprooms anymore, but I used to be in the habit of ordering their pils or lager first, since it's much harder to hide the quality behind the hops. Generally speaking, breweries that have good beers of those styles are good across the board, while those that don't have a lot more variance.
- ljm 7y agoI haven’t seen the appeal of many craft beers beyond the ideal of buying small/local. Pretty much all of my favourite beers come from Latvia. I haven’t tasted much better than I did out there.
- mbrock 7y agoLiving in Rīga, I like drinking Latvian beer from Labietis, Malduguns, Nurme, Alķīmiķis, Hypnos, and a couple of other breweries. But I have to say that there are some Estonian breweries that are really world-class, especially Põhjala and Pühaste made some of my favorite beers ever.
- ljm 7y agoI lived in Jūrmala for a year myself and besides the bars, stocking up for 70c a bottle, or about 1€ at most, was fantastic. Good quality beer for cheap.
- zwkrt 7y agoThis is a west coast phenomenon, I’ve found the Midwest and east coast to have a lot more variety. It feels in Seattle like beer bars have a “token” stout in the same way that they have a single house wine. Hops must be what sells though.
- sithadmin 7y ago>Hops must be what sells though. I'm increasingly suspicious that (typically) high relative ABV of high-IBU beers is a significant factor in influencing consumer choice, perhaps moreso than hops enthusiasts would like to admit.
- ericmcer 7y agoI definitely do fast math of $ vs % alcohol and volume. It’s less that I want to be drunk and more of a “super size me” feeling, like I’m getting a better deal.
- anfractuosity 7y agoI haven't looked at IBU, but I found ratings people seem to give beers, increases with ABV - https://www.anfractuosity.com/projects/beer-review-analysis/ https://www.anfractuosity.com/projects/beer-review-analysis/ (see the Alcohol By Volume graph). I'd love to see data on sales of beer in relation to ABV though.
- philsnow 7y agoExtremely hoppy beers aren't just a west coast thing, though; it seems there are a lot of bandwagon breweries that latch onto trends. 10 years ago it was 2k+ (yes, >2000) IBU IPAs, lately it's more sours. SF and Portland seem to be the epicenters. I feel your comment about the "token" stout; I used to go to the Refuge (https://www.refugesc.com/ https://www.refugesc.com/) quite often but one of the reasons I stopped is because their beer list is so overwhelmingly Belgian and I just want a regular stout or porter now and again.
- LawnGnome 7y agoAt this point, it might even just be an Oregon and Washington thing: if anything, it was the year of sours in BC. There are still breweries pumping out ten different IPAs, but most seem to have pulled back to a couple of core varieties and there's a bunch more experimentation going on up here.
- madengr 7y agoI have given up on IBU for predicting hoppiness. After a brewery tour, they said IBU is all subjective, with no quantitative measurement (unlike Scoville units for hot sauce). After home brewing, I have never had a bad batch. I just use soap and water to clean. Maybe it’s the risk of losing 600 gallons instead of 6. Some of the lambics are exposed to open field air (the one with the monk on the front). Is the cleanliness overblown?
- zwieback 7y agoCouldn't agree more. I live in Oregon, the craft beer center of the universe, and find that the vast majority of craft beers is too overwhelming to actually enjoy. There are more breweries learning how to do good lagers but still few and far between.
- sithadmin 7y agoTo be fair, there's more risk in lagers and other 'light' styles. If you want to produce a consistent product, they're not particularly forgiving to variance in the mash and brewing processes.
- Eric_WVGG 7y agoThis surprised me but Portland, Maine actually has twice as many craft breweries as Portland, OR.
- RandallBrown 7y agoI don't think that's true. I've been to both, and while Portland Maine has a surprising number of breweries for its size, Portland Oregon had way more. A quick google search confirms Portland OR has more than twice as many as Portland ME. If you include the Portland OR metro area, it has more breweries than the entire state of Maine.
- inferiorhuman 7y agoThere are more breweries learning how to do good lagers but still few and far between. That may be but Portland, Oregon has some excellent cider as well. Belmont Station in Hollywood is pretty much my go to place, they've a diverse selection of beer and cider.
- walrus01 7y agoThere are also a number of good ciders coming out of the apple growing regions of central WA. Usually located within 15-20km at most of the major cold storage warehouses where apples go after being picked.
- Bootwizard 7y agoYou're telling me. I've been into craft beer for around 8 years, a bit after IPAs really took off in the US. I have acid reflux, and nothing triggers it more consistently and quickly than having an IPA. It just tastes like straight up acid to me. I equate people who like really strong IPAs to people who are into extreme hot sauce just for the sake of injuring themselves with something that's overly hot. Is there really any flavor to IPAs with IBUs that are through the roof? No, not at all. I'm glad on the east coast I have a variety of beer to choose from that aren't IPAs
- tomjakubowski 7y ago> Is there really any flavor to IPAs with IBUs that are through the roof? No, not at all. Yes, there is good, tasty flavor to hops, provided you're not on the sensitive side of the bitter tasting spectrum. The bitter flavor overwhelms everything for some, but not all. If you're curious, there are bitter tasting test strips like these which not everyone is sensitive to. https://www.amazon.com/Nasco-PTC-Paper-Strips-Vial/dp/B001D7FF5E https://www.amazon.com/Nasco-PTC-Paper-Strips-Vial/dp/B001D7...
- joe_the_user 7y agoAnother thing thing I think I've found about the IPA crazy is that it has driven out the variety in IPAs themselves - once there was a spectrum in high-hop tastes between citrus-y and cider-y tastes in high-hop beer but now citrus-y is the only taste that's considered acceptable. The cider-y taste ("green-apple character" I believe) you can taste in the Belgian beer Orval is considered an off-flavor in IPAs and I'm pretty it was reasonably common high hop beers in the 90s and early 2000s. Indeed, my suspicion is that homebrewing first create a wide variety of flavors and approaches through accidents but once the machinery for determining the correct flavors became established, small brewers followed with beers that has nothing strange or unusual at all and so could only distinguished by their hop-levels.
- anfractuosity 7y agoThe funky flavour from orval comes from bottling with brettanomyces, I'd not noticed an applely flavour though myself.
- burmer 7y agoYup, in my opinion adding tons of hops can be a way to “cheat” and make a better beer, similar to some heavily flavored strong dark beers: if you overwhelm the palate you can cover up all kinds of issues, and nuances! Also in the NW a lot of hops are grown there, so it’s kind of a regional pride thing too. Even though WA also grows a ton of barley, there isn’t nearly as much interest in it.
- sickygnar 7y agoEvery brewery I've been to offers lagers. They can be hit or miss though since it's harder to mask off notes in them. The session ipas (low abv / preferably low ibu) are usually more dependable at small breweries. I personally like the crisp juiciness of those provided they don't overdo it with the hops. I can't stand the syrupy IPAs/double IPAs, fortunately those have been waning in popularity. They were fun for a bit but not anymore.
- trianglem 7y agoI can’t stand the east coast hazy ipas. They’re so disgustingly fruity and most make me want to throw up. Living on the east coast, it’s getting hard to find a nice piney west coast ipa.
- digitalsushi 7y agoi've wondered a few times if the extreme hops flavor is an inevitable way for people (like myself) who know barely anything about beer to effectively measure a single attribute and participate. a Goodhart's Law of flavor, if you will. If cranking the hops up to 11 gets a reaction that otherwise better beer doesn't get, then we're going to end up with hops on 11.
- scottlocklin 7y ago>I have a personal theory that the overwhelming aroma and taste of hops in a beer can be used to mask many errors and missteps in the brewing process, which might be more easily tasted by the customer if it were, for example, a weissbier. It's not just your personal theory! It's absolutely correct. In my neophyte brewing years if something came out bad, I'd just chuck more hops in the carboy and call it an IPA (back when it was rare and unusual). It's also arguably not very good for men. Hops are fairly estrogenic. Might help with post-menopausal bone density though! https://www.naturalmedicinejournal.com/journal/2010-04/beer-drinking-and-bone-density https://www.naturalmedicinejournal.com/journal/2010-04/beer-...
- amyjess 7y ago> Hops are fairly estrogenic. Phytoestrogens don't really work on humans though. They mostly just antagonize the estrogen receptor, which means they bind to the receptor without activating it. This means they can actually be harmful to women on HRT because they make the HRT less effective.
- FooHentai 7y agoBut isn't the net effect of that still going to be making men more sensitive to estrogen? I don't know if it's comparable, but my understanding is that over time caffeine's binding to adenosine receptors causes more receptors to be produced, leading to increased sensitivity to adenosine and so you get more drowsy than you otherwise would when caffeine's not present. If that same effect applies to estrogen receptors, that would make men more sensitive to estrogen?
- scottlocklin 7y agoIt caused premature menstruation in girls picking hops. It works on humans. https://www.reliasmedia.com/articles/120078-hops-and-women-8217-s-health https://www.reliasmedia.com/articles/120078-hops-and-women-8...
- seiferteric 7y agoSame here, but for me I swear overly hopped beers are a migraine trigger for me. I have had some beers that will give me a headache before I have even finished them! The bad association was enough for me to no longer like the taste of these beers. I only go for lighter ales/loggers or dark porters/stouts now but the stores are overloaded with extremely hoppy IPAs, but I guess that's what sells unfortunately.
- mturmon 7y agoThis has been my experience also with hoppy beers. Sometimes the migraine will start after only a couple of ounces. I mostly drink lagers and wheat beers now.
- epx 7y agoAnd then they start putting lots of kümmel (caraway seed?), corandier, oregano...
- smogcutter 7y ago100% agreed. I think a few things go into it: - Americans don’t really get exposed to good lagers and pilseners. We get Bud[1], not Budvar. So there’s no expectation that beers in those categories could possibly be “good”. IPAs don’t have the same baggage. - For the same reason, it’s easier to differentiate from the big brands on a supermarket shelf. You get to be your own category, not just the more expensive version of what people think of as regular beer. - Maximalist American food culture. It’s like when bacon became a meme and suddenly everything was covered in bacon. Fatty ramen became a trend for the same reason: it’s a simple, super-saturated flavor that’s easy to crank up to 11. - Like you mention, it’s easier to brew. The worst is when you’re given a menu of 40 indistinguishable IPAs all called like “HOPULATOR 9000” or whatever. Sometimes I just want to go out for a brewski, why did that have to get complicated? [1]You know what? Bud on draft is fine. It’s not the best, but I like it, and I’ll certainly take a $3 pint of bud over a $9 snifter of “gnarly Steve’s surfs up mango hop smasher” or whatever.
- hyperbovine 7y ago> Bud on draft is fine. Oh man, was with you till the very end. Most places will have something on tap that qualifies as real beer. PBR, Yuengling, Stella, and Pilsner Urquell are all great lagers. Confronted with 40 taps of HOPULUS PRIME (or whatever), I'll happily swill them all day in a non-ironic, non-cheapskate, non-hipster fashion. But rice adjuncts? No thank you.
- floren 7y ago$5 pitchers of Yuengling are the best part of the Northeast US.
- blaser-waffle 7y agoonly thing about PA that I miss
- smogcutter 7y agoI also enjoy all of those more than bud (except maybe PBR), but it’s worth pointing out that they’re all brewed with corn. There’s nothing wrong with that, but it’s not any better than using rice. It’s still a grain sugar that isn’t barley.
- legitster 7y agoI love me a good IPA, but there is a certain type of person I call the "IPA bro" who goes out of their way to order whatever has the highest ABV or IBU every time. I think it's like how hot sauce guys must have the hottest thing. I've talked to many brewers and they said they would love to make more pales and lagers and sessions but that they don't sell.
- dsfyu404ed 7y ago>I have a personal theory that the overwhelming aroma and taste of hops in a beer can be used to mask many errors and missteps in the brewing process, which might be more easily tasted by the customer if it were, for example, a weissbier. This is exactly it. An IPA is much more forgiving to lackluster consistency of material inputs and process control making it a perfect match for small operators that don't have those things dialed in yet (or can't afford to dial them in)
- tashoecraft 7y agoYou’re still seeing it? Feel like I’m rarely seeing a beer list of mostly ipas and almost all of my friends order something different now a days. I’ll occasionally order one, but it used to be my got to. As another commenter here posted, I think a lot of people formed an identity to it. As the person who likes craft beer and ipas were the king of craft beer. Now I just find them too much. Funny thing happened to me, my friend said he liked ipas so I would always get them for him, he always said I knew what he liked. Years later he told me he actually hated ipas but wanted to seem like he liked them and eventually did.
- electricslpnsld 7y agoThis might have been true a few years ago, but even in my middle of the road rust belt city you can get a huge variety of beers now. There are entire breweries dedicated to sours alone! Even within the IPA genre the crazy hopped to death west coast IPAs from the early 2010s seem to be getting pushed out by New England IPAs, milkshake IPAs, and a smattering of super weird stouts.
- mrbrowning 7y agoThe Midwest is far ahead of at least the West Coast on this. I saw much more variety of brewing methods, beer styles, and flavor profiles when I lived in St. Louis than I do here in the Bay Area. A lot of the great breweries from the other side of the Rockies (Left Hand, Odell, Bell's, etc.) are either difficult or impossible to find products from here, too.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- randomdata 7y ago> middle of the road rust belt city you can get a huge variety of beers now. There are entire breweries dedicated to sours alone! Heck, I live in a small rust belt town of 2,000 people and we even have a brewery dedicated to sours alone. Travel 20 minutes up the road to the next town over, with a population of not even 1,000 people, and you'll come across a major – as in their production capacity is pushing the limits of what can be reasonably considered craft – craft brewery. Although not necessarily always available, they have 35 beers in their catalog. I'm not sure any of them resemble the west coast-style IPA we're talking about. If you include hazy, milkshake, etc. takes on IPAs then 9 of the 35 are considered IPAs. Still not a lot of emphasis on IPAs in general. As an aside, this "rural" craft beer industry is rather interesting. The primary business model seems to be set up production where operations is cheap and then ship the product into the city. That sour brewery is basically a tech company, selling the vast majority of their beer online. Although that major craft brewery I spoke of does put a lot of effort into beer tourism, attracting people to their facilities, as well.
- S_A_P 7y agoThere was a similar trend with sour beers that had fruity syrups added a few years back. I live in the Houston area and it seemed there was a micro brew bubble that started around 2012-2014. In the southwest suburb of Houston where I live (30 miles away from downtown) there were 3(!) breweries within a couple miles of each other. One of them jumped on the sour beer trend full fledged. While everyone is entitled to their own sense of flavorful beverages. I think this particular brewery overestimated the demand for beer that smells like feet and tastes like sock sweat. They have since abandoned their brewery, and were brewing on a batch for hire basis. I think they finally have ceased all together. It also seems with the success of Titos vodka a similar trend is happening with spirits here in Texas.
- Ididntdothis 7y ago”I have a personal theory that the overwhelming aroma and taste of hops in a beer can be used to mask many errors and missteps in the brewing process” I think there is something to this. the same happens to other foods too. Just make them extremely spicy, cheesy or sweet and you don’t have to worry about taste subtleties anymore.
- mumblemumble 7y agoFormer home brewer and, for a short time, amateur beer judge here. You've got it right. It's not that more hops = better beer. It's that more hops = easier beer. Malt-forward beers are much more difficult to get right, and require a lot of very careful attention to detail. Hops are easy: Just throw them into the batch and set a timer. Their strong flavor is also useful for masking a lot of consistency problems and off-flavors that might stem from other, trickier parts of the brew process. The brewmaster of a new craft brewery is likely an amateur who recently went pro, and has very little practice brewing at an industrial scale. It's an over-crowded market right now, too, so they're operating on very tight margins and working with a clientele that can afford to be very picky. The days when one could get away with marketing something like Shiner Bock as a bock are long gone. So they can't afford to burn a lot of money working out why a recipe that yielded a perfect malt aroma at a 5 gallon batch size comes out flat and lifeless when scaled up to 30 barrels. They'd be out of business before they got it pinned down. Hops are easy, though, so the hoppy beer brewer is more likely to survive. I suspect that this effect continues on to packaging and distribution: Hoppy beers can handle some amount of oxidation where cream ales and lagers quickly start to taste like cardboard. That's useful in an overcrowded market where your beer might spend a few months sitting on a shelf before anyone drinks it. (Hopefully this becomes less of a thing as cans, which have a longer shelf life than bottles, increase in popularity.) And there's no way that your local TGI Bennihan's or the "537 beers on tap" bar is staying on top of cleaning their tap lines, but, again, hops can help mask the funk. It's also something of an open secret among beer judges that hoppy beers are at an unfair advantage to win the "best in show" prize. Because the final selection for that prize comes at the end of the day, after the judges' palates have been deadened by endless beer tasting, and hops are about the only flavor component that is as subjectively noticeable at the end of the show as it was in the morning. Any amateur brewer who's involved in the beer competition circuit is going to be influenced by that.
- fizwhiz 7y agoThese are the kind of insightful comments I come to HN for! What a stark contrast against another comment lamenting that men get overly competitive/nerdy about their hobbies thus engaging in "mentrification" or whatever tf that is.
- oh_sigh 7y agoStraight IPAs are waning, at least where I am. Now you are just as likely to find a new england IPA, or a 'hazy IPA', whose hop blast is far less than a traditional IPA
- chadash 7y agoAs far as I understand it, IPAs don't require specialty equipment and they don't take as long to brew, so you get quicker turnaround and need less storage space. When you are running a large beer company out of warehouses on the edge of town, storage isn't as much of an issue. But when your beer is being made at a downtown microbrewery, there's a huge cost to that extra storage space. If your beer takes two weeks to brew instead of six, you can produce 3X the beer in the same space.
- lokimedes 7y agoOh yes, if the world had just locked in on Rochefort 10 as the most godly beer ever, we would all have been in heaven rather than hops hell by now.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- vkou 7y ago> My personal taste complaint with a lot of people who open a brewery... Everyone seems to think that more hops = better beer. Microbrewers don't actually think that. The reason that a lot of them flood their beer with hops, is because: 1. It is extremely difficult to brew consistent batches of beer, week after week, month after month. 2. The extreme bitterness of hops masks the taste of pretty much everything... Including the inconsistencies. So even if they aren't papering over actual errors in the brewing process, they are papering over inconsistencies.
- NauticalStu 7y agoI love IPAs, but the market is definitely oversaturated with them. And after a while a lot of them just kind of blend together, so over time I've lost interest in trying new ones and mostly just stick to the solid ones I'm familiar with (Bells Two Hearted Ale or Deschutes Fresh Squeezed IPA) unless there's something truly unique, Ballast Point Habanero Sculpin being a good example. Along those lines, I wish more microbreweries would put out sessionable beers that still taste good. Despite the variety of styles, it seems like most beers are in the 6%-7% at least, often more. As much as I love a good stout or IPA, sometimes I want something with lighter body in, say, the 4% ABV range. Guinness is my go-to for that reason even though I think it's just fine, not great. Deschutes Black Butte Porter is the best compromise I've found, but is rarely on tap where I live.
- kls 7y agoIt just means you are not a Psycho: https://vinepair.com/booze-news/if-you-are-a-fan-of-ipa-science-says-youre-more-likely-to-by-psychotic/ https://vinepair.com/booze-news/if-you-are-a-fan-of-ipa-scie...
- bostik 7y ago> taste of hops in a beer can be used to mask many errors and missteps You are not alone. A microbrewer here in London said it really well: most small breweries go with IPA and in general overdo their hops because it allows to hide faults. Without the overpowering hoppiness their beers wouldn't taste good at all. As a casual home brewer, I try to avoid hoppy concoctions. And at some point I will learn how to do proper German style weissbier...
- jofer 7y ago> ...I have a personal theory that the overwhelming aroma and taste of hops in a beer can be used to mask many errors and missteps in the brewing process... For what it's worth, more hops absolutely masks errors in brewing. It's something that any homebrewer finds out very quickly. IPA's/etc are very easy to get a drinkable beer out of no matter how many mistakes you make. (To be fair, it's not just IPA's that are forgiving. Weissbiers are actually quite easy to brew due to the yeast hiding off flavors nicely, and ambers can be easy due to lots of caramelized, unfermentable sugars hiding off flavors. You can overdo the sweetness in an amber or mess up the fermentation in a wheat more easily than you can make an undrinkable IPA, though.) That's not to say that really good IPAs are easy to brew, just that you'll get something drinkable no matter what. Any commercial brewery _should_ be beyond basic mistakes, but scaling brewing is hard. What I'm saying really only applies to homebrewers, but I suspect it carries over to smaller breweries as well. The hardest beers to brew well are actually Pilsners, Lagers, and American-style pilsners/mega-brews. Anything with very clean, crisp flavors. I hate to say it, but if you want to really test your skills, try brewing a miller lite clone... This is especially true in homebrewing, where proper lagering/aging and fermenting at low temps needed for lager yeasts used by pilsners/lagers/etc is difficult. At any rate, my hat is off to Czech brewers. Trying to brew a really good pilsner or bohemian lager is damned hard to perfect, and it's an absolutely sublime style when done right. Sadly, it's somewhat rare to find a brewery in the US that can do it well.
- logfromblammo 7y agoIn ages past, before the Reinheitsgebot, the brewers would have their own proprietary blend of gruit, some of which even included hops. I believe some modern brewers have attempted to revive the tradition, many using Sitka spruce tips as the primary flavoring element. A unique proprietary blend of flavorants would certainly be a competitive advantage over all those beers that just use the four major bittering herbs: hops, more hops, even more hops, and a final "screw you" shovelful of hops. In double-blinded taste tests conducted in my home, the adults concluded that Vienna lagers are the best, and IPAs are the worst. So I would like to subscribe to your theory that brewers that are bad at brewing just throw more hops at the problem, so they can more easily sell their mistakes. Got some skunk's bathwater? Throw some hops in it! The IPA was invented because beer shipped to India acquired off flavors due to the longer travel times. It is almost by definition bad beer.
- couchand 7y ago> The IPA was invented because beer shipped to India acquired off flavors due to the longer travel times. It is almost by definition bad beer. More porter was shipped to India than pale ale. Would you consider porter by definition a bad beer?
- logfromblammo 7y agoI'd have to do a double-blind taste test using beers shipped to India on a slow boat without refrigeration, but I'd hypothesize that all beers subjected to such conditions would be ranked poorly when compared with beer that hadn't made the trip. Porter was already strongly hopped--a practice that overwhelms other flavors introduced in the brewing process, not just those that develop during transport. As a style of beer, yes, it is worse than more lightly hopped styles. Or at least that's what the subjective testing in my household shows. De gustibus non est disputandum. Your own testing might rank porters differently, according to your own tastes. But if the test subject does not specifically enjoy the flavor imparted by hops, then all strongly-hopped beers will rank poorly. For someone that does really like hops, all the beers that are basically carbonated alcoholic hop juice will rank highly. As for myself, I hate IPAs. In a double-blind test, I will always rank all the IPAs in the test set as dead last, with tasting notes such as "worst beer I have ever tasted" and "this beer causes suicidal ideation". It's still okay for other people to like them, I suppose, but I will never be able to understand those who do.
- gregkerzhner 7y agoPretty much the opposite here, I only drink IPA - hoppier the better! Having traveled and sampled IPAs all over the world, I can say that for the most part, its a style that people can't really get right. Not really sure why, but my general experience has been that the further your IPA is from the west coast, the worse its going to be. My world ranking would be 1st tier - California, Oregon, Washington - if its from a smallish brewery, it will be a good, hoppy IPA 2nd tier - Colorado / Idaho / Nevada / Montana - has some good IPAs, but could be hit or miss 3rd tier - Rest of USA - very hit or miss. At best it will be as good as a good west coast beer and at worst it will be strange and malty 4th tier - Australia / New Zeland - maybe best non USA IPAs ive ever had was from Pirate Brewing in Australia. This might be because of the high quality of new zeland hops. 5th tier Europe - Good luck! Had some pretty good IPAs in Ireland, and maybe some half decent ones from Britain, but overall the stuff they market as "IPA" tastes wrong, malty and flat. 6th tier Asia - Had a good ipa (on tap!) from Demo Pizza bar in Yangshuo China. Also some good ones in Hong Kong 7th tier: Africa - had one or two good IPAs in South Africa but for the most part its not really IPA Overall, I think a good predictive equation for the quality of your IPA would be quality = 1 / (distance_from_usa_west_coast * distance_from_a_city_with_brew_scene).
- OJFord 7y ago> 5th tier Europe - Good luck! Had some pretty good IPAs in Ireland, and maybe some half decent ones from Britain, but overall the stuff they market as "IPA" tastes wrong, malty and flat. Ha! Because what you're expecting and looking for is an 'American IPA' (style not origin). The other half are English or Imperial (there is sometimes a technical and sometimes only marketing distinction to be made between the latter two) IPAs. Personally, the stuff America 'markets as "IPA" tastes wrong" - citrusy and way over-carbonated! It's unfortunate that they're made to sound so similar in my opinion, they're pretty different styles. Classic IPAs are much closer to other British bitters than they are to 'American IPA' (or to 'IPA' sold in America).
- zerocrates 7y agoCitra, and citrus flavor in general, is definitely still very much in vogue for American IPAs, but I don't really think of there being a huge difference in carbonation levels. British beer is usually less carbonated than American as a rule, but carbonation is actually one of the few areas where often-extreme American IPAs are relatively restrained, so it's not this massive gulf. "Imperial" is a tough descriptor for a British style, at least in America, because here it's usually used to signify something akin to "double": more alcoholic, more hoppy, just generally "more."
- asdff 7y agoBrewerys usually have dozens of beers. If it is predominantly IPA, then that's because it's selling like hotcakes. Personally, I don't really care for the taste. I can take it or leave it. But if I'm looking to buy >$10 beers, I'm going for the highest ABV which is going to be an IPA. Sometimes you get two for one, essentially. You can't even trust bartenders to pour proper wells these days, charging $13 for an 8oz glass of Coca Cola and a drop of well brand just so you can see them reach for the bottle. The IPA fits in line with my boozehound on a budget lifestyle and always is the stated ABV.
- Obi_Juan_Kenobi 7y ago"Cheating" with hops is a dumb myth that needs to die. High hopping rates present a number of challenges that make this notion ridiculous. Shitty brewers make shitty hoppy beers just as much as they make shitty lagers, ambers, etc. The real story is that hoppy beer sells. That's the whole story; there's no other reason why they are so prevalent. The end. To make these beers, here's what you have to deal with: * The Hop market! Congratulations new brewery, you're either paying 2 or 3 times as much for popular hop varieties, or else you're going without and can suck on some Cascade. Good luck negotiating a reasonable contract for next year buying in pitiful amounts. You get to subject yourself and your razor-thin margins to the spot market. * Hop quality. Hops age and oxidize fairly easily, and variability year to year is substantial. If you want any kind of quality and consistency, it's a big job to closely monitor your key ingredient. * Hopping technique. Bittering, flavor, aroma, Whirlpool, hopstands, dry hopping, double-dry hopping, each pose unique challenges and opportunities, and brewers fuck it up all. the. time. Good hopping requires careful attention to process, and depends greatly on your highly variable ingredients. Get it wrong and some common flavor descriptors are: cat-piss, vegetal, astringent, etc. Truly, there is a whole cornucopia of shitty IPAs. * DO - dissolved oxygen. Oxygen destroys hoppy beer very easily. Your process better be perfect, or else you better be pushing that shit out within a week or two. Distribution is a fool's errand unless you're a big fish. * Hop bite. Basically this comes down to filtration, which smaller operations may not do. Fairly easy to avoid, but so very, very common. FWIW, weissbier is a lot easier to brew. Find a maltster that works for you, test a couple different yeasts and fermentation profiles, and you're done. Maltsters are fucking legends that make a terrifically consistent product (not the bougie 'indie' guys, the real legends). And yeast suppliers aren't far off. Now, the Germans will faff off about decoctions and hot-side oxygen and all that, and they do make good beer, but you can make really solid beer without even thinking of all that. I will drink a fresh weissbier every time over getting something imported from Germany to the US. Most of the time, I'll pick it over what you get in the German supermarkets.
- schnevets 7y agoI think craft beer has an inferiority complex compared to wine, and the diversity in hops are another attempt at a beer equivalent to terroir (where wine takes on different characteristics based on climate, soil, and other factors). The rise of sours and wild yeast strains are being marketed similarly, as are limited-run stouts that should be aged by the buyers. All of this on a beverage whose legacy has been the quest for consistency. It's a strange side effect of craft beer's "elevated" status. Multiple breweries in the same town need to differentiate themselves as if they are farms growing the same product acres apart. The more I think about the bizarre trends in the industry, the more I appreciate beer history.
- Tiktaalik 7y agoYeah it's weird. This sort of ultra high IBU IPA remains really popular and all over the shelf when I go to Seattle or Portland. This style of beer used to be popular in Vancouver, BC a few years ago too, but at this point the local craft brew scene has largely moved on from bitter west coast style hoppy IPAs, to the point now that when someone makes one its a bit of a novelty.
- crazygringo 7y agoI dunno... I think it's easily explained by the market, that there are a ton of people who like hops. I personally love super-hoppy beers. In a weird way, it feels kind of similar to the way I love super-spicy food, or 90% dark chocolate, or black coffee. It's just a big "kick" that's fun in and of itself. With all these things, the flavor balances are certainly important, but obviously an aspect of it is out of balance and that's the whole point, what I like about it. So just, to each their own. I know plenty of people who despise hoppy beer. I'm just glad there's a proper full range of flavors at my local average supermarket. There wasn't before.
- jdpigeon 7y agoAs a homebrewer, my experience is that adding a bunch of hops is just the easiest way to ensure your beer tastes good. Hops are really good at covering up off-flavors. Making kick-ass beers in other styles, especially subtle ones like hefeweizens and blonde ales, usually requires masterful control of the brewing and fermentation processes.
- specialp 7y agoI think IPAs have made for peak craft beer and it is going down. You are right about IPAs being easy to cover up poor brews. I brew, and people are really surprised when I tell them one of the hardest possible beers to brew would be a Budweiser clone, and one of the easiest is an IPA. Most IPA's have a very simple single malt and mash cycle, and it is essentially a hot tea made with hops. Then most of them are fermented. with some Safale high attenuation pretty bland US-05 yeast derivative. Any error or not even error with a pale lager like Budweiser would be exposed. It also takes a long time to make lagers due to the lagering progress and fermentation needing refrigeration. The problem with people drinking these fresh dank double IPAs all the time is that every other style then seems bland as your taste buds are completely destroyed from drinking 100 IBU triple dry hopped beer. Then eventually you get sick of it, and every hazy juicy IPA starts becoming the same. There are way too many breweries now making generic silver cans filled with double IPA with some interesting art sticker. I'd short the craft beer industry if it were a stock.
- Aloha 7y agoOddly this doesn't surprise me at all - I figured IPA's were popular because it was a relatively easy way to make a consistent small batch product. I'm not really a beer person, but when I am its usually Coors Banquet or Pacifico, both of which I find tasty and refreshing (particularly on a hot day, with BBQ or Mexican). I also love Yuengling when I'm in the area for it, its the only beer I've gone out of my way to order.
- TravHatesMe 7y agoDo people honestly enjoy a 100 IBU beer? I never understood the hype around strong IPAs. What percentage of consumers honestly enjoy it and what percentage are riding the bandwagon. I have often heard "ah this isn't bitter enough" when someone is drinking a high IBU beer.. is this some way of flexing on others? I enjoy beer but not these crazy IPAs. To each their own I suppose.
- specialp 7y agoIt is known that 100+ IBU is no longer perceptible as 100 is the max bitterness we can discern. Even regular IPAs weigh in at 50-60 IBU so they are also extremely bitter in the scheme of beers. Most styles of beer are 10-30 IBU. In general IPAs turn the hops component up to 11 in beers. And I do think IPA drinkers enjoy it. It isn't just flexing I think (although I am sure there are some that do), because I see in beer distributors that other styles I enjoy like Belgians and stouts are cleared out for more IPA space. And I think due to the intensity of the taste, that they get more and more conditioned to find other beers not bitter enough and not floral enough in notes. It is market demand now but I think it is self limiting because once people are in the category of "IPA drinker" I find many of them drink nothing but IPAs and then eventually get sick of them. I personally will drink an IPA from time to time, but will gladly drink any style really and particularly like stouts, German/Belgian beers. I also agree with the other child comment and will crack open a Budweiser gladly on a summer day on the beach. It is actually a very well executed beer, it is designed to be smooth and mild. I think the aversion to lagers is some amount of snobbery. I don't drink beers for image so don't care!
- projectileboy 7y agoI wish I could hug you for saying this. I thought I was the crazy one.
- cameldrv 7y agoI have another theory. There tends to be a taste balance between hops on one hand, and sugar and alcohol on the other hand. The super hoppy beers also have loads of sugar and alcohol. After drinking hoppy beers for a while, your brain associates the pleasure from the sugar and alcohol with the taste of the hops. You think you like the hops, but you really just like the sugar and alcohol. Without the hops though, the beer would be unpalatable.
- fbernier 7y agoA weissbier can mask a lot of errors because if its phenolic and estery yeast. A proper example of a beer that will showcase the slightest mistake is a simple pilsner.
- regulation_d 7y agoI think you're partly correct. Hops cover a multitude of sins. But another reason I think brewers use hops so extensively is that they're the ingredient that will get you the closest to something approximating terroir. New Zealand hops, for example, are really popular right now because they bring a new and interesting character to the table, unique to where they are grown.
- jhbadger 7y agoOr it could be that people who don't get IPAs are rather like the people who don't get authentic Indian food. Yes, at first, you may only taste hops or chilis, but as your palette matures, you begin to realize that that there's more to these drinks or foods and that they are in the end more interesting than the bland steaks or weissbiers one once liked.
- yellowapple 7y agoThis is exactly why I'd consider getting into brewing. IPAs seem to be flooding the market, leaving lots of room for literally anything else. I love dark beers (porters, stouts, brown ales, etc.), and while there are plenty of those, too, at least there are interesting directions to take there besides "shove as much hops into the brew as possible". I also like light beers or ciders on hot days, and both of those seem to be absolutely neglected in the microbrew world.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- kurthr 7y agoI totally agree... it's like over-roasting coffee beans. You trade bitterness of flavor but get consistency. That's a legit process control approach to manufacturing. And consistency of brewing beer is a huge deal... it's not that hard to make a decent home brew (it helps that it's usually fresh like home baked bread), but it's REALLY HARD to make the same beer (that people are coming back for and paying money) batch after batch. You need control not only of ingredients (and the damn things change), but also the yeast, time @ temp... and cleanliness! It's a lot easier to add lots of hops.
- Foobar8568 7y agoI hate most IPAs I tried, enjoy most double IPAs, what gives? Doesn't make much sense to me...
- Xelbair 7y agoExactly - craft beer has been taken over by IPAs over here - and variations about them. I personally love stouts and porters - yet there is a severe shortage of them. There was a 'whiskey/bourbon barrel aged RIS" craze short while ago, but it was all the same.. and they were available only in brewery pubs. When i go to store the beer wall is full of IPAs, another one is full of lagers(I'll pass on them).. and maybe 2-3 types of stouts/sours/porters are mixed with IPAs.
- TheAdamist 7y agoIt's almost like the customers love hazy ipas, and breweries do gangbusters selling them. There are a few pilsner/lager breweries but they have to be so much better at their styles and are still missing out on a large portion of the market. Specialized sour breweries exist and do somewhat well, but the market is limited and the product takes years to age.