17 ms·
Busyness leads to bad decisions
- birdyrooster 7y ago"And humans enjoy feeling busy and productive." I have never enjoyed feeling busy.
- AstralStorm 7y agoThe opposite is idleness, which we also do not particularly enjoy and will make ourselves play to avoid. It's a spectrum. Too busy or too idle for too long and we break. Some people do not perceive this, they're either workaholics or aboulics. Tiredness and boredom are good things evolved to prevent damaging ourselves. If you ignore these you get burnout on one end, but no idea what is the opposite called.
- throwaway72873 7y agoIt is perfectly fine to be idle and bored; lay on grass and watch clouds or just do fishing... Not everyone comes from puritan american culture.
- whitebread 7y agoNot every American feels like it isn’t okay to be idle and bored. I guess you haven’t been following the real noise about moving to a four day workweek in America. Can we leave the sweeping, judgmental comments on the drawing room floor?
- tonyedgecombe 7y agoYet the reality is Americans do work long hours. https://www.citylab.com/life/2019/12/americas-white-collar-workers-cant-escape-office/602989/ https://www.citylab.com/life/2019/12/americas-white-collar-w... You might not realise it but this stuff gets exported to the rest of the world. I frequently see American lobbyists on British TV pushing a low regulation agenda with the intention to weaken workers rights.
- ThalesX 7y agoI was working for a project with a small company in Scandinavia. For those unaware, Scandinavia as a region in Europe is very much pro socialist policies and pro work-life balance. We got two consultants from the US of A and that was a hell of a month, constantly pushing us to overwork our employees, saying that we need to show them the carrot on the stick. Their idea was that people will work for 80 hours per week out of their own initiative because life is all about money made and time saved. Whenever we would argue anything, they would start almost chanting Wolf of Wall Street style: "Time & money!". I've never felt more relieved to have someone leave as when they got back to the US. It took us almost half a year to get back on track after that whole shebang and the CEO still has nightmares of how much was payed for them to come there and bro up the place. I was intending to write a short message but it turned into a little rant. What I mean to say is that yes, I believe you are correct and this American way of doing business is pushed around the world in what I think is a real bad direction for work-life balance.
- ssivark 7y agoIf you/your CEO/folks from your company could write an article/blog post about the experience, it would be a great resource to share and point people to — to seed discussion. Please consider :-)
- crispyambulance 7y ago> puritan american culture [ => busy busy busy ] There's definitely something to that. Calvinistic thinking that labor is pious seems to have been a part of American workplaces forever, especially tech. It's even a part even of the stackoverflow ethos-- god help you if you ask a question without showing that you've "done the work" up front. But it's all over the place. Look at the China tech sector with their popular 9-9-6 workweek. Is that an import from Western Calvinist thinking? I'm not sure, maybe? Whatever the case, "busyness" certainly has been exploited to serve "the man" and not "god".
- Juliate 7y agoI think China has a well enough set of different traditions to gather from (that perhaps have common antique roots), rather than having been influenced by US' or European's puritanism currents. :)
- mtberatwork 7y agoI think it's the "rugged individualism" ethos at play (although maybe that is a tangent of Calvinist thinking?) - the fear that if you ask questions you will come across as inferior to your colleagues and risk losing a promotion at best or a job at worst. It's quite terrible thinking and leads to isolation which compounds anxiety at work.
- gerbilly 7y ago> rugged individualism Rugged individualism was probably never a thing. The first thing that settlers did when they moved west was to create towns and communities. Anyone believing otherwise should try to live in the equivalent of the 19th century west without the support of a town and the services it provides. (I.e.: no blacksmith, no doctor, no general store, no post office, no telegraph...)
- the_af 7y ago> god help you if you ask a question without showing that you've "done the work" up front I think that's different. It's not about puritan work ethic or whatnot, it's about showing the minimum respect for the people you're asking to make an effort for you. Questions which don't show any effort [1] are shunned in tech circles, and this isn't something particular to StackOverflow. And there's a good reason for it: many are asked by "help vampires" [2], people who will burn honest answerers with pointless, ill-researched questions with no follow-up, no useful feedback or even a thank you. Extreme help vampires will even ask the same question repeatedly, apparently too lazy to even see it has been answered already. Some of them just want people to do their homework for them, free. Once or twice may not seem much, but if you don't cut them short, they'll overrun your community. The mere act of thinking how to phrase a question well, showing you've made all the research you could before finding yourself at a dead end, is often enough to actually find the answer for yourself! So the StackOverflow community may be a bit trigger-happy, but I completely understand why they'd be upset at people lazy enough to not even bother to formulate their questions clearly. [1] "How to ask questions the smart way": http://www.catb.org/~esr/faqs/smart-questions.html http://www.catb.org/~esr/faqs/smart-questions.html [2] "What is a help vampire": http://slash7.com/2006/12/22/vampires/ http://slash7.com/2006/12/22/vampires/
- matwood 7y agoI don't like being busy, but I also like to be doing something active. I can only watch a couple episodes of a show before I have to create something or work with my hands or exercise. I don't think this has anything to do with a puritan culture. BTW, no fishing I've ever done has been idle or boring. Fishing is generally a lot of work.
- ssivark 7y ago> The opposite is idleness, which we also do not particularly enjoy and will make ourselves play to avoid [...] It's a spectrum. Too busy or too idle for too long and we break. Nope, there's a hidden axis you're implicitly ignoring. It's possible to be active and "in flow" doing something without feeling "busy". So it's not just a 1-dimensional spectrum of whether one is idle or doing things, but also the psyche/attitude experienced when doing those things. The corresponding analogue to idleness is "leisure", where it is possible to enjoy idling or acting without coherent purpose. It takes a particular kind of anemic perspective to ignore the experiential axis, and just consider the axis corresponding to "things done" or "output produced". For a more detailed exposition on what goes into achieving a "flow" state, I recommend checking out Mihalyi Csikszentmihalyi's book titled Flow. For more on "leisure", I recommend Bertrand Russell's essay In praise of idleness.
- fhennig 7y agoI found that a very nice observation! I've been struggling with stress lately and I feel like I'm surrounded by a culture where being busy is valued a lot, and people boast about how they stayed up very long to finish something, and it feels like that is a behavior that is reinforced. I really like tackling things on my own time, and I feel this "tunnelling" a lot and I don't like it at all. Sometimes it can be nice, but I feel like due to stress I tunnel too much. And I noticed that after being stressed for a while (weeks/months) it is very hard to come back and enjoy idleness. I think this is a problem in cultures with a "busy" work ethic.
- AstralStorm 7y agoFlow state can be a trap. You can accomplish a lot of task checkboxes that are irrelevant. This is exactly what the article talks about. You must ask questions on whether what you're doing has any value - ultimately for you or someone/something you value. And while in flow state you cannot ask such questions as they're not directly related to what you're doing. Company values are at least a few degrees removed from this ultimate value. If you spend all the time in the flow state, you're likely are achieving nothing for your own goals, because you're not setting any. (Or worse, the goals are not thought out.) Flow is the same as hyperfocus physically, and overdoing will ultimately harm you physically, if not psychologically or socially first. It's also related to meditation. Like meditation it is not always beneficial, especially in excess. If this author has some other definition of flow, be careful, there might be a tautology or "no true Scotsman" involved.
- lukebuehler 7y ago> but no idea what is the opposite called Acedia
- P_I_Staker 7y agoYou're making assumptions that aren't necessarily true. For instance, I'll avoid play in order to enjoy some idleness. I've figured out why I think; because I don't want to lose track of time, then have to go to work. The same reason I can sleep fine before my day off, but not before a work day. I don't even think I hate my job that much. I'm not really even working crazy hours; yet it still seems like there's no free time, and I don't want the little time available to fly by.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- romanovcode 7y agoExactly, best inner-feeling I have is when I know I don't have to do anything, literally anything. So I know I can do whatever I want.
- OJFord 7y agoI suspect 'humans' is an attempt to avoid stereotyping/sexism - but some people certainly do if not enjoy actually being busy, enjoy talking about how busy they are and how little time they have. i.e. the enjoyment I think is in projecting a certain image of oneself; not necessarily actually embodying that image.
- tonyedgecombe 7y agoI'm not sure it's about enjoyment. At the extremes I suspect it's more of a compulsion.
- AstralStorm 7y agoThere can be enjoyment too, either normal or masochistic. Alleged accomplishment tickles reward centers in the brain. In most people, reward from repetitive tasks fades quickly, in some others it does not. (Perfect employees for assembly line. Except we have robots.) A masochist instead may thrive on the discomfort of it.
- _pmf_ 7y ago> I have never enjoyed feeling busy. Clearly, you are not manager material. Managers like to flaunt their busyness. It's their essence, their halo.
- thejackgoode 7y agoI have the opposite, feeling busy means I am focused and doing meaningful challenging work
- Ididntdothis 7y agoI guess you are in a good situation. My work often keeps me very busy but almost nothing of it is meaningful or challenging. It’s mainly just a repeat of the same thing.
- brianmcc 7y agoMost people would surely agree that neither under- nor over-stimulation is ideal on any kind of long term basis. A 2 week project crunch can be exhilarating, but 6 months? No thanks! Similarly a few weeks of beach vacation can be wonderfully relaxing, but months, years of "doing nothing" will soon become boring.
- saiya-jin 7y agoThat's why you don't go to isolated places like Maldives (unless you are utterly addicted to diving and surfing) but rather Indonesia... you can spend years travelling around discovering places, culture, people, food etc. Met plenty of people stuck in travelling mode for years, but yeah they don't just lie around the beach (most of the time).
- leggomylibro 7y agoHow about feeling idle with nothing to do but consider your own mortality? Not many people enjoy that, and Pascal wrote an interesting paper about it: http://stmaryvalleybloom.org/pascal-diversion.html http://stmaryvalleybloom.org/pascal-diversion.html Personally, my main takeaway can be summarized by this passage: >And those who philosophise on the matter, and who think men unreasonable for spending a whole day in chasing a hare which they would not have bought, scarce know our nature. The hare in itself would not screen us from the sight of death and calamities; but the chase, which turns away our attention from these, does screen us.
- EGreg 7y agoWhat if you realize that distracting yourself from major things is foolish and your thoughts return to the topic every few hours a day? Have you figured anything out? Perhaps this can give you some practice every day: https://existentialcomics.com/comic/1 https://existentialcomics.com/comic/1
- gerbilly 7y ago> The hare in itself would not screen us from the sight of death and calamities The irony is not lost on me that the man in this anecdote is bringing untimely death to the hare, to distract himself from his own. Death probably feels just like you felt before you were born. Why not celebrate that there is anything to experience at all? It seems so improbable.
- leggomylibro 7y agoHaha, yeah. But hunting is just one of the examples that Pascal uses because of the times, along with gambling and war. Metaphorically, that passion project or artistic pursuit that you can't quite explain a practical use for is more or less the same idea.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- bigred100 7y agoSome folks in fact think you should do that quite a bit. For example, this guy wrote quite a well-regarded (in his community) book about it: http://www.documentacatholicaomnia.eu/03d/1696-1787,_De_Ligorio_Alphonsus,_Preparation_For_Death_Part_1,_EN.pdf http://www.documentacatholicaomnia.eu/03d/1696-1787,_De_Ligo...
- hef19898 7y agoPersonally, I think there is a big difference between busy and occupied and lazy and idle. I love being productive / occupied, yet I hate being busy. And that has nothing to do with stress or pressure, but rather with impact. And yes, being busy resulted in a couple of less than perfect decisions on my behalf. The worst ones just for the sake of doing and deciding something.
- twoquestions 7y agoCan personally confirm. A while ago my car died, so I suddenly needed transport right now. I was considering renting a car, but my family loaned me an extra vehicle they had on hand that they keep around for just these emergencies. EDIT: No, there is absolutely no public transport out here. People who can't drive for whatever reason have a very hard time of it. I would have made a much worse decision if I had to pay for every day I took to make it. Given the luxury of time, I made a much better buying decision for the new-to-me vehicle. One of the many ways it's expensive to be poor.
- Frost1x 7y ago>One of the many ways it's expensive to be poor. These sort of time luxury, magnitude of free/disposable income, and free cognitive load (less stress, etc.) aspects are all too frequently overlooked when shunning the working poor and now, even many working middle class Americans. I remember the sort of stress I had first starting out simply keeping up with utility bill payment schedules to avoid late fees. I had the luxury of enough assets and steady income that I quickly setup autopayments on my credit card and never had to think about it again. I had relatives and friends who couldn't setup autopayment because they were never sure if they'd have enough in their account or ability to pay their credit card and had to strategically optimize when and what they'd pay. The amount of cognative load folks endure juggling many of these artificial constructs makes it difficult for them to pursue and seize opportunity when it arises to get ahead. Arguments could be made as to why some should or should not be in such situations but this is just one example. I often think about how difficult it is to fit certain necessary things in my schedule and then remember I don't ride the bus in the work which dramatically reduces my commute time. There are many such aspects people deal with daily and it can be daunting. If you're very wealthy, a lot of these problems you can throw relatively marginal money at and the problem is solved while focusing on furthering yourself.
- Ididntdothis 7y agoVery true. I always feel like that when people’s first recommendation for a problem is to get a lawyer. For a lot of people this is prohibitively expensive.
- DarwinMailApp 7y agoI could not agree more. For years I was just doing things for the sake of being busy.. crossing tasks off my todo list on a daily basis. I felt so accomplished, however, I was not really getting a lot of useful work done! -------------------------- What did I do? - I started thinking about the tasks I needed to do, assessing if they were actually important to begin with. - I often found that they were not adding value to my product (DarwinMail[1]) and so I discarded them. - I also quickly completed any task that would take 5 minutes or less to complete. -------------------------- What was the result? - About a year on and I have a successful product (well, success in my head is a product which has thousands of users of which at least hundreds love the product and could not live without it). - I feel more successful, more fulfilled and a greater sense of accomplishment. [1] https://www.darwinmail.app https://www.darwinmail.app
- afarrell 7y ago> assessing if they were actually important to begin with. I've found answering "Is this important?" very hard. I find it much easier to answer "What is the impact if I do this?"
- DarwinMailApp 7y agoYou and me both buddy! I like your style.. and sometimes I ask myself other questions like will it matter to me in 10 hours, 10 days or 10 weeks? The longer into the future it matters to me, the more important it is to get done IMO :)
- AstralStorm 7y agoI'd phrase it differently: think what will it won't happen if you reorder the tasks, and how long it will take to achieve. Mind that both are estimates and can change.
- DarwinMailApp 7y agoNo that is a more powerful motivator. Thanks for the tip!
- automatoney 7y agoSo the article mentions "that one study found people preferred giving themselves electric shocks rather than have nothing to do" which sounded like an interesting study. The link provided was to https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/20548057 https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/20548057 , and after searching I found this https://faculty.chicagobooth.edu/christopher.hsee/vita/Papers/IdlenessAversion.pdf https://faculty.chicagobooth.edu/christopher.hsee/vita/Paper... which strangely doesn't mention electric shocks at all.
- FernandoTN 7y agoThe study mentioned is "Just think: The challenges of the disengaged mind" https://science.sciencemag.org/content/345/6192/75 https://science.sciencemag.org/content/345/6192/75 >Next, participants received our standard instructions to entertain themselves with their thoughts (in this case for 15 min). If they wanted, they learned, they could receive an electric shock again during the thinking period by pressing a button. We went to some length to explain that the primary goal was to entertain themselves with their thoughts and that the decision to receive a shock was entirely up to them. Many participants elected to receive negative stimulation over no stimulation—especially men: 67% of men (12 of 18) gave themselves at least one shock during the thinking period [range = 0 to 4 shocks, mean (M) = 1.47, SD = 1.46, not including one outlier who administered 190 shocks to himself], compared to 25% of women (6 of 24; range = 0 to 9 shocks, M = 1.00, SD = 2.32). You can read the complete study here, https://wjh-www.harvard.edu/~dtg/WILSON%20ET%20AL%202014.pdf https://wjh-www.harvard.edu/~dtg/WILSON%20ET%20AL%202014.pdf I´m quite intrigued about the outlier who managed to shock himself every 4.7 seconds for 15 minutes straight. Was he trying to go for a record or just plain masochism...
- RobertRoberts 7y agoIt's too bad studies like this have errors (obvious only in retrospect). I learned as a kid to entertain myself with thoughts and can do so easily for a long time. But I will shock myself at least once just to see how bad the shock is... not because I would be bored. (unless they took this into account and let everyone shock themselves before starting the experiment? That would be smart of them... didn't have time to read the study)
- loceng 7y agoBusyness - or rushing?
- AstralStorm 7y agoYou don't have to rush to have no spare time to think.
- pklingens 7y agoBusyness is the path to the dark side. Busyness leads to tunnelling. Tunnelling leads to bad decisions. Bad decisions lead to suffering.