10 ms·
> At a public protest just days before her firing, Rivers told the 200 Googlers who rallied in opposition to her suspension that Google had wiped her personal p
by michaelt 7y ago
> At a public protest just days before her firing, Rivers told the 200 Googlers who rallied in opposition to her suspension that Google had wiped her personal phone when it suspended her, erasing many months of photographs
Ouch. Presumably this would have been MDM?
I've never understood why phone makers make this possible for non-device-owners, as it seems like a gigantic foot-gun. To say nothing about the ethics involved.
- asdfasgasdgasdg 7y agoAll my stuff is backed up off my phone anyway, so I would only be mildly annoyed if my employer wiped it. I'm glad they have the capability, because otherwise they'd require me to carry a separate work phone, which would be super annoying. As to the ethical question, under some ethical systems, voluntary agreements without coercion are by-default ethical. My employer doesn't force me to install a work profile. They're happy to supply me with a separate phone if need be. But I voluntarily take on that risk for the convenience.
- rorykoehler 7y agoYou are glad your employer has deep access into your personal phone?
- asdfasgasdgasdg 7y agoYes, that is indeed what I said. I even explained the tradeoffs and why they are acceptable to me. Was something unclear?
- rorykoehler 7y agoI'm just trying to understand the world we live in. Your position is the opposite of mine. It's so far the opposite that I had trouble believing what I was reading but it's valid so sorry if you to feel like my question was a personal attack.
- solipsism 7y agoI have trouble understanding why people get so worked up about it. I don't know what you people use your phones for, but all of my activities are incredibly boring. And the idea that my personal activity or data would be worth the effort to my employer, enough that they actually implement whatever they'd have to implement to snoop on me, is laughable. I also don't freak out if there's a window open in my bedroom when I'm changing. The chances are small anyone wants to take a peek, and if they do it's not much skin off my back. So, maybe there are just different kinds of people? The kind that irrationally think everyone is interested in snooping on them, and the kind who have more important things to worry about.
- rorykoehler 7y agoGo ask the ceo of your company for unfettered access to his personal phone and see what he says.
- raxxorrax 7y agoReally? A second phone is awesome. Pretty big fan of compartmentalization of business/private, even if i am not a heavy phone user and not prone to change employers much. But I do have my own phone anyway. We even have a separate wireless network for private devices and guests that is not subjected to any filtering or security screening. All that is really worth having 2 devices in my opinion. There are also a lot of security benefits if work phones are only used for specific tasks and are locked down as much as possible.
- izacus 7y agoAndroid supports clear isolation between work and personal profiles, so you don't need to lug around two phones just so you can have your separation. Unfortunately it seems that said people used iOS which doesn't allow that.
- asdfasgasdgasdg 7y agoI guess I just don't see much downside to putting both on the same device. I have trouble picturing a situation where I'm significantly worse off because of the path I've chosen compared to having two devices. The 99% worst case scenario is something like what happened to the person who was fired: my phone gets wiped when I didn't want it to be. Ah, well. With Android's backup capabilities, it takes me about an hour to be back to normal from a completely wiped device. I've wiped my device voluntarily just to give it unlocked to a repair person. It would not be that much worse to have to recover it involuntarily. The 99.9999% worst case scenario is that my employer is monitoring my private communications for some sinister reason, but I consider that pretty unlikely. I just can't see a way that would benefit them, and I'm not sure they even have the capability in the first place -- compartmentalization is what work profiles are for. On the other hand, having to manage two devices would be a daily tax. So, yeah, I'm happy with my choice, but I'm happy to accept more information if you have other things I've not thought of.
- saiya-jin 7y agoImagine having time off from work, leaving your work phone off/at home, but still able to check online topo maps/restaurants/flights/weather/connect with people with your normal phone. It can be annoying, or not. Depends a lot on personality, type of work, boss etc.
- throwaway_tech 7y ago>I'm glad they have the capability, because otherwise they'd require me to carry a separate work phone, which would be super annoying. A lot of people have a phone for work separate from their personal phone...Still, there is a perfectly reasonable middle ground, Google could have requested the employee backup the phone before wiping it since they knew or had reason to know there was personal data on the phone.
- saalweachter 7y agoI gave up on having my work accounts on my phone. I just don't check work emails or messages on the weekend or at lunch. If anything actually urgent comes up, they have my phone number and can call or text me. This was mostly out of laziness; I have relatively low patience for doing lots of fiddly configuration on a new device, and don't like the bother of setting up a second account on my phone whenever I get a new one. The only real downside is when I go to a meeting, forget which room I was going to, and need to get out a laptop or go back to my desk to figure out where I was going. But it's done wonders for my work-life balance and just not thinking about my job when I'm not actually working.
- m-p-3 7y agoI use a workspace/sandbox for my work app on a personal device, and it works quite well. The only feature I wish was available would be to schedule access to the sandbox, for example turning it off after my work hours, and turning it back on in the morning. That would reduce the amount of notifications I get from work after-hours. I still don't check them, but having them out of sight would be nice.
- bluedino 7y agoKeep a personal and work phone separate.
- jakelazaroff 7y agoThe claim is that Google wiped her personal phone. Furthermore, companies like Google have worked hard to blur the lines between their employees' personal and professional lives. I'm not particularly sympathetic to them suddenly drawing hard boundaries when it benefits them.
- rayvd 7y agoThe only way that's possible is if the employee agreed to it.
- Chinjut 7y agoEmployees are pressured to agree to many things by their employers.
- missosoup 7y agoIt's pretty easy to say 'no, I will not connect my personal phone to the corporate network in exchange for allowing my employer to remotely manage my personal phone'. Get a second company phone like anyone with a sliver of opsec intelligence does.
- el_s3v3n 7y agoNo, I'd rather blame the world for my ignorance and expect them to pick up the tab on that bill. /s Many years ago ago, at my first tech job, the employer provided a smart phone as part of work/on call responsibilities. (This was still around the era when smart phones were just blossoming as useful devices). Every other employee there decided to use their company phone as both their personal and professional device, while I opted out for what are very obvious reasons. I had my phone and I had the company phone; the latter was only on my person when professionally necessary. It was common sense then, and it's common sense now. You always keep professional and personal assets separate. (Fun fact worth noting: not too long ago the company decided to either boot personal usage of company devices, or stop providing those phones altogether. Can't say that I didn't warn them.)
- formercoder 7y agoIndeed, one also has to install a root CA at Google to use the device for work. No thanks.
- cameronbrown 7y agoDefinitely untrue.
- c0achmcguirk 7y ago+1, untrue
- c0achmcguirk 7y agoThis person chose to have their free phone from the company as their personal phone too. This is completely optional at Google, a really nice perk, and it's made very clear that anything under your work profile will be wiped if you leave. They will not wipe your personal phone or your personal profile on your phone. This is completely avoidable and shouldn't come as a surprise.
- missosoup 7y agoIt's not a perk, it's a liability. This was an option at pretty much every company I worked at and I never understood what moron would choose to put their personal data/life on a corporate device (or connect their personal device to the corporate network and its management policy) with typical policies dictating that not only can the device be remotely wiped, it can also be remotely snooped. The only brief moment of this being acceptable was Samsung phones being able to have completely split personal/corporate profiles across 2 sims in a single phone and have 2 copies of each app, but that seems to have died. If your employer is managing the device you're choosing to also use for personal data, it's 100% your fault and 0% surprise when it backfires on you. If you work in tech and don't have a separate work phone+laptop and personal phone+laptop, you're either a founder or an idiot.
- threatofrain 7y agoIt is a net perk because phone calling or mobile messaging is inevitably part of work and you don't want to buy your own separate phone. It's only awkward for anyone who isn't used to having two phones.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- LadyCailin 7y agoCalling and messaging are paid for by my company, and I can also sign in to my email. They have a program where I can get full access to all work resources, but it’s optional, and I will never sign up for that program, because exactly what’s being discussed here. But I still only have one phone, and they still pay for it, so.
- DoofusOfDeath 7y agoWouldn't erasing her personal phone be a felony?
- Someone1234 7y agoIf you did it, perhaps. If a corporation did it, unlikely. The law isn't applied equally, and companies aren't often subject anyway. That's why Wells Fargo can literally break into random people's home, destroy every possession they have, and get zero criminal charges[0]. [0] https://abcnews.go.com/Business/wells-fargo-mistakes-home-neighboring-foreclosed-home/story?id=17185239 https://abcnews.go.com/Business/wells-fargo-mistakes-home-ne...
- geofft 7y agoNot if she consented to allowing her employer to do so. My own employer has us sign an additional document (an addendum to my employment agreement) to get email/calendaring on our personal devices. (Also my employer is in a regulated industry - trading - where if we talk about work-related stuff on personal devices that don't go through work's logging proxy, the SEC can start digging through my personal text messages in an investigation, in some fashion. I don't know precisely how this works legally, and I hope to never find out.)
- geofft 7y agoSee https://twitter.com/lizthegrey/status/1198346989286690816 https://twitter.com/lizthegrey/status/1198346989286690816 and https://twitter.com/lizthegrey/status/1198345256678445057 https://twitter.com/lizthegrey/status/1198345256678445057 (for context, Liz is also ex-Google and was an outspoken internal activist at Google, and now happens to be a G Suite admin at her new employer). I believe that on newer Android devices, the option is to wipe your work profile only, but on devices that don't support it, yes, MDM lets you wipe the entire phone. My own employer just rolled out an MDM option that gives them the ability to wipe my personal phone (this is my personal iPhone, acquired before I joined the company, not a corporate perk or anything) in exchange for being able to use native apps like Slack instead of doing everything inside a work-specific specialized browser. I'm steadfastly refusing to install it, and I'm on the older config with the work-specific app until it stops working.
- crazygringo 7y agoIf you keep important photos on your phone and don't back them up, the brutal truth is -- it's your fault if you lose them. She could have just as easily lost her phone in a car, or had it break. So this seems entirely irrelevant. And yes, of course Google wiped her phone: if you're not actively working there, you're not allowed to have access to your past business emails that have been cached, photos of whiteboard drawings you took at the end of meetings, offline copies of strategic Docs, Sheets, and Slides, etc. and other resources that are stored on your phone. If you use the same device for work and personal, this is just what happens.
- michaelt 7y agoIf it's expected you back up your photos, and it's expected that when fired all your whiteboard photos are wiped remotely, does that not also imply your photo backups should be remotely wiped? After all, you might have backed up a whiteboard photo.
- Infinitesimus 7y agoGood point... now I kind of hope thus escalates to Google itself for never deleting data and having trade secrets
- dawnerd 7y agoMight be a good time to check your phones / tablets to make sure there’s no mdm profile setup that maybe you didn’t realize got installed.
- dboreham 7y ago>I've never understood why phone makers make this possible for non-device-owners They don't. You need to adjust your frame of reference to who is the "device owner" here. The history to this is that smart phones were originally bought by employers who were concerned about the security of their data on said phones. Or at least concerned enough for BB to upsell them on the capability to remote wipe. In Enterprise IT sales you tend to evolve a bewilderingly large set of marginally useful features because each one was used to clinch some large sale over time. Remote wipe would have been one of these. Fast forward to the introduction of "consumer" smart phones (first WM5, then iPhone 1.0, Nokia S60, ...) those guys entered a market already dominated by BB with the aforementioned huge set of Enterprise features. In order to make inroads into the market, they implemented a subset of the BB feature set. Remote wipe was in that subset. This is because for a period in history you couldn't sell a phone to businesses if it didn't have remote wipe. The last evolutionary stage was when people mostly started to own their own devices: users wanted the convenience of carrying just one device while Enterprises wanted to keep as many of their vast set of features as they could. The compromise was that device vendors shipped the phones with remote wipe disabled, however if the device is connected to an enterprise data source (e.g. via Active Sync), then it is programmed to ask the user to opt in to remote wipe. The choice is between : you get Enterprise data on your phone and also allow the Enterprise to remote wipe; or you pound sand. Separating "personal data" from "Enterprise data" was a final tweak on this arrangement, although it wouldn't surprise me if devices have a hard time supporting "don't wipe personal data" since the wiping is done by discarding a volume encryption key (for performance reasons -- you don't want to take 5 min to wipe the device while a hax0r is also trying to exfil the data). Of course from the present day perspective this all looks very odd, but it came about through a series of quite logical steps, like how you make a Duck-Billed Platypus.. Source: I was involved with implementing remote wipe (server side) for all the various phones though this epoch.