5 ms·
Corporate debt is a very different animal from consumer debt. In the current environment of very low rates, it is often cheaper/prudent for a corporation to tak
by matwood 7y ago
Corporate debt is a very different animal from consumer debt. In the current environment of very low rates, it is often cheaper/prudent for a corporation to take on debt rather than use its cash. See Apple, who has ~100B in corporate debt outstanding. For them it was cheaper to pay dividends and do share buybacks using debt than to take a hit repatriating cash at that time.
Corporate debt is so cheap now, that it is also often better to issue more bonds than to do any public offering. Giving away ownership is probably the most expensive form of financing long term.
Finally, as a percentage of GDP 10T just isn't very interesting. It's akin to the 500 point market swing headlines, and uses large numbers to make it sound more exciting.
- yowlingcat 7y agoThis comment gets it. I think it's disingenuous and borderline immoral to use a big number to drum up sensationalist panic without explaining how it even behaves or contextualizing what it exists inside of. People are reflexively going to complain about how it seems like 2008 all over again even though the beast is, as you say, entirely different.
- raducu 7y ago10T is a huge number, but that's not the issue -- the issue is that as a percentage of GDB that's also at an all times high value. It is like 2008 in the sense that a bubble popping (corporate debt this time) is forcing the FED to bailout irresponsible corporations yet again (see the recent balance sheet increase).
- aguyfromnb 7y ago>the issue is that as a percentage of GDB that's also at an all times high value. When you have historically low rates for a historically long time, it makes sense that debt would reach historically high levels, because it's cheap.
- raducu 7y agoThat's just a bit like saying when drug prices are so low it's ok to have a lot of overdoses, because, hey, people are taking advantage of those low drug prices. If we entered a new era where such low interest rates are necessary for the "econony", great let's all accept this new fact. However the interest rates were cut in 2008 so that elites could be bailed out, lest they default and drag everybody else and they were supposed to be brought back where they used to be; the central banks balance sheets were supposed to be brought back to where they were historically -- none of this has happened. Nah, the interest rates being so low serve mostly the elites while propping up massive bubbles in financial markets, real-estate and big corporations too big to fail. The central banks/states get to pick who is saved, involve themselves more and more in the economy and replace what should be regular market mechanisms and create huge systemic problems. What's so wrong with savers receiving decent yields for their bank deposits? Why should everybody all of a sudden use their savings to buy houses that they let? Just so they can fuel the vicious bubble cycle of the de jour investment vehicle the elites have picked? Why should central banks exchange money printed out of thin air with negative interest rates for ill performing bonds, locking in the profits of bond-holders? The only answer is "because otherwise it will lead to cascading series of defaults that will bring down the economy" -- then the problem is the financialization of the economy and no actionable way of removing the bad apples from the basket, in which case we're allready in for a catastrophic failure of the current financial system when all the apples will go bad.
- raducu 7y agoWhere was corporate debt, as percentage of GDP 10 years ago? Has that ratio changed in the recent past? nevermind -- I looked it up and it's at all time high.
- matwood 7y agoYes, an all time high of ~47% which is ~1% over the last all time high. Not as big of a doomsday headline though. It also doesn't take into account that corporate profits are also at highs. I'm not saying that continuing to increase corporate debt is necessarily good. But, the fear mongering of 10T alone without looking at the whole picture is disingenuous. A much better article with more of the picture is here. https://libertystreeteconomics.newyorkfed.org/2019/05/is-there-too-much-business-debt.html https://libertystreeteconomics.newyorkfed.org/2019/05/is-the...
- frockington1 7y agoRates have been very low for a very long time, you would expect to all time high debt with current interest rates. It would be more concerning if people were not taking advantage of the essentially free money.
- raducu 7y agoI'd be concerned if the idiots taking decisions and crashing the financial system when interest rates were at 5% were not severly punished and let loose when interest rates were at 0%, almost like an arsonist being put in charge of a gas station. Oh wait, they weren't....
- C1sc0cat 7y agoExactly its only if you have an expensive debenture xxx Mill at 8.5% for example
- jonahbenton 7y agoThis should be top comment.
- akvadrako 7y agoThis is just like consumer debt. It's better to get a 3% mortgage and put all your cash in the stock market then to payoff your house. Not only do you get a higher return, but you save on taxes.
- mdorazio 7y agoI think the difference is in the types. Mortgage debt can make sense assuming you're borrowing within your means to pay, but consumer debt also includes credit cards, auto loans, personal loans, and student loans that often have questionable financial logic behind them.