10 ms·
I enjoy the topic of debt but the more time I spend staring at it the more frustrating the framing around it seems. Modern loans don't work the way a classic m
by roenxi 7y ago
I enjoy the topic of debt but the more time I spend staring at it the more frustrating the framing around it seems.
Modern loans don't work the way a classic model of lending would suggest. That has implications - loans represent a redistribution of real-world resources away from people who have worked for them and towards people who the banks like.
This is a very concerning dynamic given that the 2007-2008 era financial crisis revealed that the bankers are incompetent at assessing risk. They should not be the ones choosing who gets a home or who gets to succeed in business. There is an ongoing trend where people in credit exposed markets (housing, other assets) are raking in unreasonable returns at a lower-than-advertised risk as more and more easy credit is created. It isn't fair or clever.
- mayukh 7y agoThe article is about corporate debt. Banks don't 'choose', investors do.
- roenxi 7y agoI'm going to draw an analogy with mortgages. Superficially someone who wants to own a home has the option of taking out a mortgage or not. However the 'no debt' option means you must find a home in a market where nobody else has access to a lender. The choices in any competitive market are basically to take on debt or bow out and rent. In a competitive market, the person who lends the money tips the scales and decides who gets resources - in this case a house. So back to corporate debt; yes on the one hand investors choose to take on the debt. On the other hand, if they aren't willing to take on debt then the rational choice is more to bow out of the market than to put in long hours and compete. The alternative to debt is competitors that simply have more resources without having to work particularly hard for them. Much like taxi companies v. Uber - how do you compete with a company that from a profit perspective pays passengers to ride with them? Why do you compete? The short term answers to those questions are challenging. Only people who are willing to take on excessive debt for some other reason will be left after a few years. Or companies with a tolerance for pain. I wouldn't have a problem with this dynamic except for the fact that the banks clearly have government backing and are only surviving because of it - if investors had control and had to bear the consequences of the bankers action there would have been profound changes after the last financial crisis instead of Quantitative Easing and a return to business as usual. There is substantial evidence that the people who control the money are very bad at what they do. They should be replaced with people who are, at a minimum, are an unknown quantity rather than legitimately incompetent. I know technically all this debt is probably being purchased by retirement funds. But the major contributing reason the retirement funds are willing to buy such low quality trash is because the banks (and central banks) have been pumping money into the system to compete for anything that could possibly return a yield. Competition is usually a good thing, but competition by people who can literally print money is not helpful.
- skunkpocalypse 7y ago> 'no debt' option means you must find a home in a market where nobody else has access to a lender. > the person who lends the money tips the scales and decides who gets resources Hey, you need to stop speaking the truth so much... if you keep doing that the NAR lobbyists will start shrieking at the top of their lungs again.
- Ma8ee 7y agoThe people that control the money is not bad what at what they do. It’s just that the incentives are wrong when the system is rigged so that either they win, or we lose.
- ddebernardy 7y ago> I know technically all this debt is probably being purchased by retirement funds Actually, a material chunk of that debt is held by big tech. https://www.theguardian.com/business/2019/nov/08/how-big-tech-is-dragging-us-towards-the-next-financial-crash https://www.theguardian.com/business/2019/nov/08/how-big-tec...
- whatok 7y agoIt's not a material amount vs overall outstanding market and a majority of the holdings are in higher quality, short-dated bonds that will likely be paid at maturity long before any credit stress is seen. Corporate treasurers are not in the risk taking business. They are squeezing out incremental yield from cash on hand.
- lazyjones 7y ago> However the 'no debt' option means you must find a home in a market where nobody else has access to a lender. As someone who bought several houses without debt, I really don't understand what you are trying to say here. Please explain...
- zdragnar 7y agoNo kidding. Pretty much anyone selling a property will pick a cash offer over a financed one, if nothing else to eliminate a long wait period for underwriting.
- TeMPOraL 7y ago> the 2007-2008 era financial crisis revealed that the bankers are incompetent at assessing risk I think we need the inverse of Hanlon's razor[0] to be a thing. "Never attribute to stupidity that which can be adequately explained by systemic incentives promoting malice." A Hanlon's handgun, if you like. What I remember from reading about the 2008 financial crisis isn't that bankers were incompetent. It's that various parties started packaging up financial instruments to make them look like less risky instruments, so that they could be sold to suckers. Then they insured themselves against those instruments blowing up. This suggests they knew well what they were doing. In fact, banks aren't in the business of assessing risk. They're in the business of making money, which they often do through assessing risk. The important point is that assessing risk (or giving loans, or mortgages, etc.) isn't their raison d'etre, but a way to make money they've specialized in. If there's a way to make easy money by doing something else entirely, or by compromising their core competence, there are strong economic incentives to do that. This applies to all other companies doing anything else as well. There's few organizations that consider doing things they do well as a terminal value; usually, it's only instrumental in getting money. That's something IMO we have to keep in mind if we're trying to make accurate predictions of future behavior of a company. -- [0] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hanlon%27s_razor https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hanlon%27s_razor
- ThrustVectoring 7y agoThe loan packaging and insurance was a symptom of the underlying problem that drove the 2008 crisis: transatlantic transactions that worked to evade regulations to control systematic risk. This process started, if you had to pick a place, with a US bank issuing a mortgage. The cash part eventually wound its way to various short-term "risk-free" assets, one of which being short-term asset-backed loans to European financial institutions. The mortgage asset got packaged up and sold on to the broader capital markets, of which European financial institutions participated. So, the US banking system basically created a market in which European financial institutions could buy mortgage-backed paper, financing the purchase at good short-term rates generated by the cash created by issuing the backing mortgages. Of course, banking regulators know that just letting banks go hog-wild creating asset-liability pairs is going to end up badly, so this is where the regulatory arbitrage comes in. Under US banking regulations, banks had limits to the assets on their books. There's a strong incentive to offload them into the capital markets - the banks realize an immediate profit, and clear out valuable space on their balance sheet. European banks, on the other hand, had a more complex leverage limits that took into account the perceived riskiness of various assets that they owned, with AAA-rated assets giving the highest leverage limits. So that, in a nutshell, is what happened in the run-up to 2008. Banks generate more profits when they create more risk, so there's regulatory limits on risks. US banks evaded those risk limits by selling the risk on to the capital markets, and US regulators assumed that this process was systematically safe. EU banks evaded those risk limits by blindly levering up to buy whatever AAA-rated dollar-denominated assets the US capital markets handed to them, and EU regulators assumed that high leverage on AAA-rated assets was systematically safe. Neither regulatory regime had a good holistic view of the financial asset vortex brewing in the Atlantic. Anyhow, my overall point is "so that they could be sold to suckers" doesn't really tell the entire story. The asset packaging was done in order to take as much risk as possible under US and EU banking regulations, taking advantage of transatlantic differences in regulatory regimes.
- tkyjonathan 7y ago> 2007-2008 era financial crisis revealed that the bankers are incompetent at assessing risk. They are not incompetent at assessing risk. That is entirely their job. It was that the government intervened in the housing market and to do so, assumed risk from the 1993 Clinton initiative to offer minorities access to mortgages and purchase their own homes. Mozilo from Countrywide exploited this.
- PeterStuer 7y agoThen how do you explain that at that time in Europe asset based finance (for things like car leases, trucks, boats etc.) changed from fairly rigid due diligence on the borrower to almost auto granting the loans?
- ianai 7y agoThey assessed risk then sold their mortgages to third parties. How accurate do you figure their assessments were if they knew they wouldn’t hold that debt? Then the financial instruments created from that debt were valued by models trained on RE prices that grew for something like 8 years then tanked. So those same instruments grew then tanked. Nobody called them out on it because they hid the functioning behind models no one could really understand at the Fed.
- matwood 7y agoCorporate debt is a very different animal from consumer debt. In the current environment of very low rates, it is often cheaper/prudent for a corporation to take on debt rather than use its cash. See Apple, who has ~100B in corporate debt outstanding. For them it was cheaper to pay dividends and do share buybacks using debt than to take a hit repatriating cash at that time. Corporate debt is so cheap now, that it is also often better to issue more bonds than to do any public offering. Giving away ownership is probably the most expensive form of financing long term. Finally, as a percentage of GDP 10T just isn't very interesting. It's akin to the 500 point market swing headlines, and uses large numbers to make it sound more exciting.
- yowlingcat 7y agoThis comment gets it. I think it's disingenuous and borderline immoral to use a big number to drum up sensationalist panic without explaining how it even behaves or contextualizing what it exists inside of. People are reflexively going to complain about how it seems like 2008 all over again even though the beast is, as you say, entirely different.
- raducu 7y ago10T is a huge number, but that's not the issue -- the issue is that as a percentage of GDB that's also at an all times high value. It is like 2008 in the sense that a bubble popping (corporate debt this time) is forcing the FED to bailout irresponsible corporations yet again (see the recent balance sheet increase).
- aguyfromnb 7y ago>the issue is that as a percentage of GDB that's also at an all times high value. When you have historically low rates for a historically long time, it makes sense that debt would reach historically high levels, because it's cheap.
- raducu 7y ago
- pjc50 7y ago> loans represent a redistribution of real-world resources away from people who have worked for them and towards people who the banks like. This is simple, appealing, and extremely misleading; loans are more a temporal redistribution of resources. You get something that you will have worked for before you do the work, but that doesn't really absolve you from getting the income to pay the loan back. > They should not be the ones choosing who gets a home or who gets to succeed in business Who should? > There is an ongoing trend where people in credit exposed markets (housing, other assets) are raking in unreasonable returns at a lower-than-advertised risk as more and more easy credit is created. It's not that the risk is lower, but it has become horribly correlated. All the homeowners win or lose together. Globalisation of the housing market as a "safe asset" makes the problem worse. Perhaps we need a crackdown on owner-non-occupiers like the Vancouver foreign purchasor tax.
- IanDrake 7y agoTo add on "who should decide who gets money" ... Let's not forget the equity capital markets and private lending institutions. Banks don't have a strangle hold on providing capital.
- roenxi 7y agoActually they do; banks can create new money. It is practically impossible to compete with an institution that can create new money when providing capital. It is called Fractional Reserve Banking and only licensed institutions can do it as far as I recall. I'm not intimately familiar with US markets, being Australian, but the M2 suggests that half the money currently in existence was created since 2007. If whoever is creating that money doesn't have a stranglehold on providing capital they are going to, at a minimum, have massive influence. It is worth focusing in on, it may only be half the money in the system but that is actually a big deal.
- pjc50 7y agoTo the extent this is true, anyone can create new money by extending credit - such as when issuing an invoice with delayed payment terms. There's a not-inconsiderable amount of money floating about in trade credit.