4 ms·
I just hope the “courseware” isn’t random videos with unsubstantiated claims. That is to say I’d hope what they are watching is current and medically accepted
by mc32 7y ago
I just hope the “courseware” isn’t random videos with unsubstantiated claims.
That is to say I’d hope what they are watching is current and medically accepted information.
The article does claim that most of the ones accessed by profs are produced by professionals in their field —apparently in an effort to market their skills and help other professionals...
But one would hope there is some vetting going on.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- DiabloD3 7y agoI just hope their actual accredited courses they took in college isn't just random videos with unsubstantiated claims. Sadly, that isn't always the case; given how much Doctors pay to graduate, you'd think everyone coming out of college would be highly educated, and that isn't true at all.
- Scoundreller 7y agoA lot of health care education and training is clinical placements. It’s great for learning techniques, but it also means the right answer is the preceptor’s desired answer. Which isn’t much different than random videos. In other words, old bad habits don’t die, they get reinforced. Book-learning has its advantages, but it isn’t as fun.
- omegaworks 7y agomost information medical doctors get in their training about nutrition is generally unsubstantiated
- thaumasiotes 7y agoSure, but it's official unsubstantiated information. ;D
- mywittyname 7y agoNutrition science is hard. It has long timelines and relies largely on self-reporting and meta-analysis because it's unethical to study humans like we would mice and perform actual control studies. That's not even getting into the monetary and political factors involved. It took decades for society to agree that smoking was bad for your health, because of all the money paid to bribe scientists, doctors, and politicians. And this was obvious. The food industry is orders of magnitude larger in monetary terms, and involves far more people, many with political influence worldwide. I give doctors a pass on this.
- thaumasiotes 7y agoIt would make sense to give them a pass on not knowing correct nutritional information if they admitted they didn't know correct nutritional information. The situation that actually obtains is that they're passing off incorrect information as correct. That shouldn't be excused by the fact that knowing correct information is difficult.
- PeterisP 7y agoIt's absolutely justified to pass off the information that according to our best current knowledge is the approprate recommendation as of now - the fact that knowing the underlying correct information is difficult, and noone knows for certain if it's entirely correct or there are more nuances to be found doesn't mean that we should just shrug and act as if we have no information whatsoever. We do have some data that allows us to make useful decisions that are more likely than not to be correct. As long as that's the best we have, we should use that information.
- autoexec 7y agoI'm not sure it's a good idea to give doctors a pass because of how easy they are to bribe. It's a fair point that we can't allow unethical studies, but the fact that doctors and scientists are so vulnerable to bribery is a larger issue that should be addressed and would probably improve a lot more than just nutrition science/medicine. I don't see many easy answers, but giving doctors or scientists a pass for the current situation seems a bit too generous.