5 ms·
At a local Safeway woman loads cart with bottles of liquor. Walks out. She yells “I know my rights, I know my rights”. What are the cashiers and security goi
by mc32 7y ago
At a local Safeway woman loads cart with bottles of liquor. Walks out. She yells “I know my rights, I know my rights”. What are the cashiers and security going to do? Nothing, they let her go.
At another place kids get caught stealing they turn over a display and run out. Again, nothing done. All those costs are borne by the paying customers.
People are gonna get sick of it; the progressive supes are gonna rue this move. The DA race in SF was close. I think it’s gonna go the other way next election.
Also word on the street is apparently thieves prefer SF to Daly City because San Mateo county doesn’t play as nice as SF.
- StuffedParrot 7y agoI believe what you’re describing is nation wide and doesn’t have anything to do with SF.
- mc32 7y agoIt’s the frequency and brazenness of the crimes that’s out of line with respect to other stats.
- StuffedParrot 7y agoSure, but the underlying difference is that people actually know their rights, not that SF is somehow soft on crime as implied.
- Jamwinner 7y agoIn most places people can be stopped. Mega business tends not to chase them because they can absorb the costs, making possible litigtion not worth it. The small business owner is the one made powerless by these laws, which are, indeed, different from the rest of the country.
- kevin_thibedeau 7y agoTheir customers absorb the costs. Always.
- WarDores 7y agoThe right to steal unimpeded?
- mc32 7y agoIt’s almost as if you’re wanting to imply shoplifting is a right. They are not imploring a right. I could make s citizens arrest under my rights but people will tell you, it’s a losing proposition because you subject yourself to other frivolous claims that take money and time to clear up. So the reason people aren’t detained for police is because police will do very little in these cases because they are classed as misdemeanors. So why risk lawsuits, etc. when there is no upside?
- coreless 7y ago> I could make s citizens arrest under my rights Very debatable. If you as a non-LEO attempt to detain someone who you suspect of having committed a crime, and they feel threatened, you could easily end up in jail. “They did a crime” does not, in fact, give you the right to crime too. Edit: Can someone help me out? I’ve posted a bunch of controversial opinions in this thread, so why is the one factual claim the thing getting downvoted to oblivion without comment? Am I somehow wrong about this? Like... can I actually crime someone just because they crimed someone else first and I don’t want them to get away with it? I need to know this.
- jnosCo 7y agohttps://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/codes_displaySection.xhtml?lawCode=PEN§ionNum=837 https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/codes_displaySectio...
- chrisseaton 7y ago> so why is the one factual claim It's not factual - it's false. > Am I somehow wrong about this? .. can I actually crime someone Making a reasonable citizen's arrest is not a crime. That's what you have wrong. (And you don't 'crime' someone, that's a noun not a verb.)
- anxman 7y agoExcept SF is soft on crime ... we have the lowest arrest and conviction rate in all of California.
- dx87 7y agoMost companies tell their employees to not stop shoplifters for because they don't want to risk a lawsuit, not because they legally can't do it. I've seen loss prevention employees at my local Target detain shoplifters until the police arrive. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shopkeeper%27s_privilege https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shopkeeper%27s_privilege
- everdrive 7y agoWhether or not this is on the employer's mind, I also can't imagine risking getting shot over my $12-$14 an hour retail job.
- dx87 7y agoMy retired grandfather works at Wal-Mart part time just to get out of the house, and he said the same thing. He was working on black friday last year and was assigned to a display where the item was limited to one per customer. He said a big guy came up to him and asked what my grandfather would do if he tried to take more than 1. My grandfather told him that they don't pay him enough to try and stop people from breaking the rules, so the guy grabbed an armful of the item and left.
- coreless 7y agoWell, just imagine that you can’t risk losing your $12/hr job, either.
- throwaway5752 7y agoWhat you are describing is a particular sort of story that's meant to inflame and probably speaks to where you get you news, which sounds like it's political and partisan. Both of the things you describe are corporate policies. They have nothing to do with state law anywhere, and they are there because of liability. Safeway doesn't want to get sued for 1) if an employee is an idiot/racist and misidentifies someone and harms them 2) employees get harmed substantially trying to stop a shoplifter. In these cases you have rare and small losses that are miniscule compared to bad financial outcomes of intervention. It would be easy to stop, but that costs money. It's a very simple business decision for retailers: is the cost of loss prevention higher than the loss. The fact that this surprises you is surprising to me, this problem is many decades old in retail. Car burglaries are a much different dynamic, and another poster mentions that it's a felony that was reclassified to a misdemeanor, and that law probably does need to be changed and is a problem for lawmakers. edit: and can we raise the elephant in the room, which is that this is fairly solvable with a national facial recognition database and fairly low end iptv/image capture tech?
- beat 7y agoHasn't anyone ever watched the opening scene of Pulp Fiction? Tarantino got right to that... no one is going to stop if you if you decide to rob a diner.
- mc32 7y agoI get neighborhood news from one of the various social neighborhood apps. These apps aren’t political or partisan in so far as I can tell. In my neighborhood there are lots of progressives but after a few years even some of the died in wool progs see that there are problems. And to your point. Yes different crimes but the point is there has been a surge in both as well as a new crime in the form of package theft.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- BurningFrog 7y agoOne point is that grocers shouldn't have to fend for themselves against crime. Supplying the public good of crime fighting is the main reason to form governments in the first place.
- undefined1 7y ago> “I know my rights, I know my rights”. What are the cashiers and security going to do? Nothing, they let her go. I've seen a shoplifter (also in SF, Safeway) take it to the next level, repeatedly yelling, "I'm pregnant! The guards are killing me and my baby!". None of which appeared to be the case, and security was as nervous as you might imagine. This kind of stuff happens a lot at Safeways in SF (also Starbucks and CVS, but mostly Safeway it seems). Other times you'll just see someone running out the door, guards look into the distance for a moment and that's that. My wife calls them Unsafeway, heh.
- souprock 7y agoI find it hard to imagine that. How do they stay in business? At my supermarket, I have never observed proper going-out-the-door shoplifting. I am still able to get offended when somebody eats a grape that they haven't purchased. I'm sure worse crime happens, but in-store grape consumption is the worst I've ever observed.
- rambojohnson 7y agogoing deeper into these threads has got me asking, wait, am I still on hackernews?
- apta 7y agoWhy? Not everyone on HN is a far leftist.
- rambojohnson 7y agoI know and that's fine, I meant the politics in general.
- nradov 7y agoMy local Safeway in a middle class area of the South Bay Area also has a significant shoplifting problem. It's often kids who come in after school and steal small items, as well as homeless adults. Unfortunately the management appears to have a policy of not prosecuting or even confronting shoplifters. I sort of understand why they don't want to do anything, but it's disappointing because tolerating lawlessness brings down the whole neighborhood.
- anxman 7y agoTechnically, all of the customers like yourself are paying for it.
- oceanghost 7y agoIn So Cal, a supermarket I go to remodeled and removed the entrance closest to the liquor, leaving only one (rather busy) entrance where a security guard is posted. I've seen people stealing liquor there as well.