11 ms·
The rise of solar is ‘jeopardising the grid’ and it's a lesson for Australia
- zmmmmm 7y agoFunny how things are a matter of perspective. I view the baseload / coal generation as what is jeopardising the grid. It can't react to fluctuations in demand or supply so it's just not a tenable solution for a modern power grid where demand is intrinsically variable. Having said that, I feel like some regulation mandating a certain amount of storage be supplied with rooftop solar wouldn't be a bad thing. It doesn't seem responsible to set up generation capacity without the storage to buffer the effect of that capacity's generation on the grid.
- stjohnswarts 7y agoSorry not everyone in SW Australia has a solar energy supply, so just because you have that advantage doesn't mean others should have to suffer with blackouts. Has the whole world forgotten how to compromise and work together as a society rather than "my solar tribe" vs "your coal/poverty stricken populace who can't afford solar roofs tribe". I thought you Aussies were more civilized than us people in the States.
- toomuchtodo 7y agoJust researched this today after talking to some Aussies about it! The problem is that Australia is so married to coal that they have no national electrical grid strategy, including transmission line investment, so it’s harder to get generation to load centers (“follow the sun” generation”). They also don’t have natural gas to fill in when renewable generation dips (unlike the US). The solution is going to be a lot of utility battery storage (Hornsdale Power Reserve Tesla battery is currently being expanded, for example), more renewables, and actual transmission infrastructure investment.
- wisdomdata 7y agothat comment (while technically correct) is undoubtedly from someone who has obviously never driven across the nullabor.
- mustntmumble 7y agoI also have never driven across the Nullabor. Would you kindly elaborate on what you mean?
- birdyrooster 7y agoOne does not simply drive across the Nullabor.
- jwhite 7y agos/Nullabor/Nullarbor/ (no trees). The Nullarbor is a vast, arid, unpopulated plain over 1000km wide. I think the comment was meant to suggest that infrastructure projects like this are challenging in Australia, because the distances involved make them expensive, but the low population density makes them much less profitable than in places like the US and Europe with high population densities. Many tourists from other parts of the world come to Australia thinking they can "just drive" from Melbourne to Cairns or Perth to Adelaide, not realizing how much of an undertaking that is because they don't have a good sense of the distances involved.
- toomuchtodo 7y agoHaven’t been through the Nullabor myself, but I can’t imagine it’s so treacherous that you can’t drag a few five inch HVDC conductors through it (which only need to be buried, no concrete channel or conduit required, to support ~2500MW of transmission capacity). If I recall, that’s where the latest Mad Max film was filmed.
- 9nGQluzmnq3M 7y agoIt's not that it can't be done, it's that the Nullarbor is 1,100 km of absolutely nothing. More broadly, it's ~3000 km from Perth to Adelaide, vs ~4000 km for the continental US. Also, the last Mad Max was mostly filmed in Namibia. The older ones were filmed in Australia, notably Coober Pedy, which is north of Adelaide and not near the Nullarbor.
- perilunar 7y agoAustralia does not have a national electricity grid. We have this: https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/d/d4/NationalElectricityTransmissionLinesMapAustralia.jpg https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/d/d4/National... Also, we have plenty of natural gas: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_in_Australia#Natural_gas https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_in_Australia#Natural_ga...
- toomuchtodo 7y agoI’m familiar. Note the lack of East<->West transmission capability between coasts (important for solar generation to follow the sun), and the lack of almost anything to the Northern Territory (who doesn’t even expose their real time generation data on the internet!). Also, there are natural gas reserves, it just doesn’t appear it’s used extensively for electrical generation based on historical ElectricityMap.org data.
- caf 7y agoThe Northern Territory has a total population of only 250,000, of which 180,000 live in the Darwin area. There is no way that spending the enormous amount required to connect it to the east coast grid would be an efficient use of resources.
- toomuchtodo 7y agoReally depends on the path an East-West line takes, cost per mile (edit: kilometer), existing generation fuel costs, possible future generation locations, etc. It’s not just about existing load centers (the population you mention), but possible future generators (big solar plants in the middle of the desert).
- caf 7y agoThere is no shortage of suitable locations available for big solar plants that are thousands of kilometres closer to the big load centres than the Northern Territory is.
- Thorentis 7y agoAn interesting technical problem to face, but it had to be solved eventually. All sorts of solutions need to be combined to upgrade the the grid to something which is ready to accommodate so many renewables. Breakthroughs in battery technology need to happen very soon (globally). Hopefully the push from large nation states and the accompanying investments in it will make this possible. An interesting problem here is energy security, especially for places like hospitals or the military. You do not want a country who's critical infrastructure relies on the power generation of suburban rooftop solar but unfortunately the large amount in WA, Aus seems to indicate that might be a possibility. At the very least, a move away from coal is needed. Even though natural gas isn't ideal as a final destination, it might be needed in the iterim. Quick fire up/down during rapid demand change periods is needed to allow the shift to renewables to happen. Sadly, building natural gas generators - even if with the aim of supporting renewables long-term - would probably be met with opposition by some on the eco-left in WA. Worth a shot though.
- api 7y agoNuclear requires something to help load follow too since reactors don't throttle quickly. The French use hydro and import/export. Load leveling is a problem that must be solved to go beyond fossil fuels, and even without climate concerns we will run out of cheap easy fossil fuels eventually anyway.
- rossdavidh 7y agoSo, "jeopardising" in the seense that, say, me driving west on a road which comes to a north-south "T" in the road, would be "jeopardising" the car's safety...if I don't turn the car in an appropriate manner when I get to the "T". Yes, if you add solar with absolutely no changes elsewhere to accommodate that, you will eventually have problems. But, that's like saying smartphones jeopardized the cell phone infrastructure, which they did except the cell phone companies added capacity. Bicycles can jeopardize the road network of a city if they become widely used, and you don't do anything (e.g. bike lanes) to accommodate that change. Every change in technology can jeopardize the network it is part of, if nothing else is changed to accommodate it. But, you know, there are several (already known, developed) methods of handling this (big batteries, utilities being able to turn off your solar like they can currently remotely control my thermostat). It seems a bit of an overstatement to say that it's jeopardizing the grid.
- perilunar 7y agoYeah, it's a stupid headline. The real story here is that the government owned energy utility made a massive loss and is blaming rooftop solar. The headline should say: "Energy planners fail to account for obvious and foreseeable structural change to energy generation".
- grecy 7y agoThe powers that be in Australia are very, very, very friendly (read: in bed with) the coal industry. For the last 5 years they have been doing everything possible to discredit renewables, and there is a lot of money at stake. It's a fascinating view into what happens when a few very rich and powerful people control essentially all the media in an entire country.
- hanniabu 7y agoThat pretty much describes governments around the world, it's nothing exclusive to Australia unfortunately.
- EdwardDiego 7y ago
- ngcc_hk 7y agoShould say better and smarter management. It should not be accusing the solar panel. Computer jeopardising a lot of things otherwise.
- ZeroGravitas 7y ago> The only way to manage the solar was to scale back or switch off the coal- and gas-fired power stations that were supposed to be the bedrock of the electricity system. Oh no. What a tragedy.
- 9nGQluzmnq3M 7y agoThe problem here is the fluctuations in supply: you still need that coal & gas power for when renewables aren't producing. And the specific problem is that coal plants are not good at starting up and spinning down rapidly. Gas plants, however, are quite fast, so if this leads to coal plants becoming obsolete, that's win all around even if it requires more gas power in the interim.
- ceejayoz 7y agoWell, you need something. Diversity in renewables, diversity in their placement (it's unlikely for the wind to be zero everywhere), and stuff like energy storage (which Australia is very successfully experimenting with on moderate scales: https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2019/feb/18/tesla-big-battery-is-holding-its-own-in-a-burgeoning-energy-storage-market https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2019/feb/18/tesla-big...) goes a long way.
- EdwardDiego 7y agoStorage, I think, is where our existing grids will need to invest in heavily. I'm thinking "Batman villain with a warehouse full of giant capacitors" storage. Or, at the very least, a system where excess grid power is used to store gravitational potential energy in a reservoir.
- EdwardDiego 7y agoExactly - gas is better at responding to rapid spin ups/downs, and releases less CO2 than coal. So replacing coal with gas is still an improvement.
- 7y ago
- technofiend 7y ago>On those days, excess solar power from households and businesses spilled uncontrolled on to the system, pushing the amount of power needed from the grid to increasingly low levels. >Ms Zibelman said WA's isolation amplified this trend because the relative concentration of its solar resources meant fluctuations in supply caused by the weather had an outsized effect. >The only way to manage the solar was to scale back or switch off the coal- and gas-fired power stations that were supposed to be the bedrock of the electricity system. >The problem was coal-fired plants were not designed to be quickly ramped up or down in such a way, meaning they were ill-equipped to respond to sudden fluctuations in solar production. Sounds like it's time rebalance the system with lower baseload assumptions for coal and gas plants. I'm quite sure the incumbents are loathe to suggest that since it means investment in buffers to soak up so-called excess power from solar panels and splitting the profit with solar panel owners.
- jjeaff 7y agoHow does a lower baseline estimate factor in when you have a particularly cloudy day or week?
- ceejayoz 7y agoThat's a particularly easy fix in Australia - site your solar plants in the readily available 90% of the country that's largely desert.
- buzzkillington 7y agoSlight problem that the dessert will get to around 50C on sunny days. No infrastructure on earth is designed to operate at those temperatures. That's on top of distances like those between Huston to New York between the main sun light areas and the population centers.
- int_19h 7y agoWhat is the problem with operating the power delivery infrastructure at those temps, exactly? And as for distances - power grids have been built at similar scale, and even longer. When there's essentially free power for the taking, why wouldn't you invest into delivering it where it needs to go?
- fghorow 7y agoIn 2008, when I was working in geothermal in Australia, I was at a meeting where the 2008 AUD price of a transmission line was quoted at 1.4 million/km. Multiply that by 1100 or so km across the nullarbor (rough guess; what really matters is the path between closest transmission lines of sufficient capacity) and you begin to see the scale of the problem. Oh, and Australia has roughly the land area of the lower 48 of the US, with roughly the population of Southern California. In other words, it's bloody empty.
- grecy 7y agoAdd to that 95% of the population of Australia lives in 5% of the landmass. Yes, empty is an understatement.
- a_bonobo 7y agoTo be nitpicky: you don't have to multiply by 1100 since Australia has two power networks that are not connected - one for Western Australia, one for the rest
- fghorow 7y agoAnd you are going to connect those two networks precisely how? The point in the article is that WA's grid is isolated from the Eastern States' grid. If there was any hope of "following the sun" (or indeed the wind) to leverage the geographic diversity that is Oz' one true strength, those networks would need to be interconnected.
- newnewpdro 7y agoIt's not like they're on opposite sides of the planet. Sounds like a case of perfect being the enemy of good enough. Split the energy storage capacity across the two and get on with it.
- fghorow 7y agoThese are resource problems. Economics is essentially everything. However, I agree that storage in both grids is a good way to go. The Eastern States have that already -- recently most visible in the Tesla battery project in SA, but also in pumped hydro in the Snowys. WA, not so much...
- mushufasa 7y agoThis sounds like the "Utility Death Spiral" and also happened in Germany, Hawaii, and Nevada. Best article on it IMO (2014): https://www.greentechmedia.com/articles/read/this-is-what-the-utility-death-spiral-looks-like https://www.greentechmedia.com/articles/read/this-is-what-th... tldr: Renewables require additional grid maintenance costs (storage + two-way distribution) while simultaneously prompting more consumers to buy less conventional energy from utilities. Historically, utilities made money from selling electricity. Now they have fewer customers and higher costs. They have to charge higher prices to the fewer customers. Then more people want to choose renewables. This keeps going until the utilities bankrupt. The solution is to change the business model for utilities, which are regulated monopolies. So it's a policy question. Absent strong leadership, the utilities tend to claw back against renewables instead of innovating (saga of Nevada)... fun fact: this is named after ants, where some species will literally march around in circles to starvation if the pheromone scent trails get tangled up.
- cannonedhamster 7y agoThis is exactly right. There's utility in being an as needed source of power as well as storage point. There's so many different types of storage options as well. There's batteries, liquid potential energy storage, potentially flywheel but this hasn't worked out too well, there's adding wind capacity. As a business model they get to charge for storage maintenance and generation when needed. Storage is a consistent amount of money with extra coming in from power generation as needed.
- BLKNSLVR 7y agoStrong motherfucking opinion warning. South Australia is the driest state in the driest continent. It's the most perfect place for solar power. Australia as-a-whole is a perfect place for solar power. A university lecturer of mine got one of the first solar panel installations in South Australia, it was mentioned in the local Adelaide paper, that's how much of a big deal it was. This was around 20 years ago. Twenty years! South Australia (still) has some of the highest priced electricity in the world. There's been talk of privatization as the cause of this, which has been somewhat debunked[0], and the primarily agreed reason for the high prices is what's referred to as "gold-plating of the network" in which there was an agreement that the 'poles and wires' companies could not lose money on any infrastructure investment they committed to - the regulator would allow them continually increase the prices they charge in order to cover the cost of the infrastructure investment[1][2][3]. So, despite how perfect Australia is for solar power, private or commercial, despite the fact that solar panels have been getting commercially installed on private homes for 20-odd years, and despite the networks being given carte-blanche for infrastructure investment, somehow, Australia is un-prepared for a flood of solar power. The various organizations that are meant to be on top of this shit have been asleep at the wheel for fucking YEARS. This was highlighted by the big power failure in South Australia in 2016 when a number of wind farms shut down due to 'safety settings' being set at overly paranoid parameters, which was a problem that had already been solved in Europe (the frustrating irony of this is that the wind farms were being blamed for the power failure, when the actual situation was that the wind farms could have PREVENTED it, if their configurations were 'best practice' - the problems in the electricity network that caused the wind farms to trip were powerful winds that took down some big-arse transmission lines)[4][5] Australia's issues with renewable energy are entirely of their own making. And it's far more likely attributable to incompetence than malice. I'd almost prefer it was malice because malice comes and goes. Incompetence is systemic. Off on a tangent, here's my 10-years of electricity usage / costs investigation: http://electricity.atcf.com.au/economics/ http://electricity.atcf.com.au/economics/ [0] https://www.abc.net.au/news/2015-03-25/fact-check-does-privatisation-increase-electricity-prices3f/6329316 https://www.abc.net.au/news/2015-03-25/fact-check-does-priva... [1] https://www.abc.net.au/news/2014-10-02/senate-inquiry-to-probe-gold-plating-of-electricity-networks/5786578 https://www.abc.net.au/news/2014-10-02/senate-inquiry-to-pro... [2] https://www.abc.net.au/news/2018-03-25/grattan-urges-consumers-to-be-compensation-for-energy-grid-22g/9585284 https://www.abc.net.au/news/2018-03-25/grattan-urges-consume... [3] https://www.abc.net.au/news/2018-01-04/energy-policy-solar-electricity-bills-air-conditioning-costs/9298346 https://www.abc.net.au/news/2018-01-04/energy-policy-solar-e... [4] https://www.abc.net.au/news/2017-03-28/wind-farm-settings-to-blame-for-sa-blackout-aemo-says/8389920 https://www.abc.net.au/news/2017-03-28/wind-farm-settings-to... [5] https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2016/oct/19/south-australian-windfarms-revise-safety-settings-after-statewide-blackout https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2016/oct/19/south-au...
- D_Alex 7y agoWhat a dumb article. To begin with, nothing is jeopardising the grid right now in Western Australia, it is running just fine. The claim seems to be that if we do not account for the increasing share of solar power in the future generation mix, then we may grid stability have problems sometime in the future... Given that the solutions to such problems are well known and inexpensive - how about we don't plod stupidly into the future? Was that ever the plan? And the "lesson for Australia" is what, exactly? Plan ahead?
- dazlari 7y agoThis really is just another poor-me major piece of spin that we Aussies have had to cop in the media in the last decade - following on from these other two gems: 1. too much air-conditioning is overloading the grid; 2. the power bills have been high because they've over-spent on the grid (apparently preparing it for future demand); 3. too much solar is stressing the grid... Looks like the grid is the weakest link. Time to go off grid perhaps? 1. could be loosely verified - mid-day black-outs were a common occurrence on extremely hot days in Sydney, esp. in the noughties. Or was the grid just not up to it? Lucky they over-spent on it. 2. price gouging is still be rampant, the rates are still as high as ever, and solar feed in tariffs are a joke; If we're swimming in free/cheap electricity, where is the lowering of the rate? and why is green energy still much higher for the consumer? Good reasons I'm sure... probably something along the lines of "the grid can't handle it". 3. Given that we're now (apparently) swimming in all this extra grid-damaging power, maybe it was the solar that really stopped the blackouts - after all, the air-con comes on when the sun shines! Just tell everyone to turn on their air-con. That should solve it! Good luck to anyone trying to get a clear answer on any of it - like it's been noted, too many vested interests in politics and the media. My view: go-off grid as soon as you can.
- Const-me 7y agoCan't they do something useful with the energy? E.g. aluminum is used everywhere, the ore is also everywhere it's 8% of the crust, the major cost to convert ore into metal is electricity. Can't they engineer a robotic aluminum factory which scales fast enough to capture the cheap power?
- int_19h 7y agoGiven that this is one of the most arid regions in the world, with a huge oceanic coast line, how about water desalination?
- keanzu 7y agoIf you invest in a aluminium smelter you will want to run it 24/7, not just when there's cheap power. Also Australia enjoys the most expensive power in the world because of grid costs.
- Xylakant 7y agoModern aluminum plants can operate in a fairly wide band around "expected power" and are often used in a load shedding/load taking capacity to use excess capacity or make up for lack of capacity. They get cheaper electricity prices to pay for that grid stabilization service. It seems that at least some of australias smelters haven't caught up with that development yet: https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2019/oct/31/australias-aluminium-sector-is-on-life-support-it-can-and-should-be-saved https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2019/oct/31/austra...
- AtlasLion 7y agoAustralia should be ashamed that a third world non democratic country like mine (Morocco) is doing much better when it comes to renewable energy. Get your shit together Australia.
- keanzu 7y agoSolar did not just rise mysteriously - it was driven by government policy, first by huge feed in tariffs (US$270/MWh) and later with massive rebates. "West Australians who applied for rooftop solar panels from the 1st of July 2010 till the 30 of June 2011 could lock in a 40 cent feed-in tariff for 10 years and those who applied in July 2011 could lock in 20 cents for 10 years." [1] "The current Rebate subsidises 54% of the price when purchasing a Solar System for a home or property." [2] [1] https://www.solarquotes.com.au/systems/feed-in-tariffs/wa/ https://www.solarquotes.com.au/systems/feed-in-tariffs/wa/ [2] https://www.solarmarket.com.au/wa-solar-rebate-scrapped/ https://www.solarmarket.com.au/wa-solar-rebate-scrapped/
- sandoooo 7y agoOn the other hand, if a technology requires higher levels of organizational competence than is available from the government of a major first-world country, maybe it isn't ready for primetime.
- henearkr 7y agoI would love to see all this surplus energy used in direct-air-capture stations to pump CO2 from the air and transform it (either store it as a liquid, or convert it into plastic precursors, etc).
- tyzerdak 7y agoNeed to make big accumulator. Problem solved. xD
- 8bitsrule 7y ago"excess solar power from households and businesses spilled uncontrolled on to the system, pushing the amount of power needed from the grid to increasingly low levels.... The only way to manage the solar was to scale back or switch off the coal- and gas-fired power stations that were supposed to be the bedrock of the electricity system." Wow, that sounds like a great problem to have. Note the aggressive rhetoric ... 'spill', 'uncontrolled','pushing', 'bedrock', 'solar smashes utility finance'. Well-crafted FUD from ABC's Mercer, if he wrote it all. Coal and gas being endangered sounds perfect, if you give a rat's ass about climate change. But let's do everything we can to get in the way of progress by painting the result as blackly as possible. Maybe instead of pushing that excess onto the grid, people can sell it their neighbors instead ... or 'the industry' could install more batteries to store it in.
- Reason077 7y ago> "excess solar power from households and businesses spilled uncontrolled on to the system" ... Wow, that sounds like a great problem to have. It's also a problem that has already been solved at the technology level. Australia just needs an equivalent to California's updated "Rule 21" regulations for smart inverters, which came into force in 2019. These rules require inverters to support "remote control" management by utilities, so that their output can be throttled back in low-demand scenarios. Rule 21 also specifies features like dynamic volt/VAR (dynamic reactive compensation), so inverters actively work to stabilise the grid in the event of voltage deviations, as well as ramping and "ride through" requirements to prevent large numbers of inverters tripping simultaneously during voltage/frequency deviations which could result in a cascading fault.
- makomk 7y agoYes, that is in fact exactly what the original article is arguing - that the stability of the Western Australian grid requires a switch to "smart" solar which the grid operator can remotely curtail the output of on demand. Hence all the rhetoric about how excess power "spilled uncontrolled" onto the grid which the previous comment complained about. This is also not, in fact, a good situation to be in. The stability of the power grid depends on balancing supply with demand in real time, and if that can't be done then the whole thing fails. Not only that, the old-fashioned gas and steam power plants have inertia that helps stabilize the grid and as that decreases overall stability margins fall. I think wind farms can emulate this inertia to a certain extent, but that doesn't always seem to work so well...
- ourmandave 7y agoReading all the comments, remote, cheap powered Western Australia sounds like the perfect place to set up shop if you're a super villain. (There's only so many extinct volcanoes to go around.) If it weren't for that pesky non-compete clause with the evil villain run government.
- syllable_studio 7y agoThis is another real-world example of why our lack of energy storage is becoming a crisis. Without energy storage, large amounts of wind and solar energy will wreck our power grids. We must build more storage immediately to prevent a climate crisis. This is why our project, Terrament, is studying this problem and working on a solution. https://www.terramenthq.com/ https://www.terramenthq.com/
- Junk_Collector 7y agoI'm curious how you approach the earthquake problem with underground pumped hydro storage?