9 ms·
Never mind the 1 percent Let's talk about the 0.01 percent (2017)
- the_gastropod 7y agoIs anyone else getting bored with this kind of “analysis”? Yes—people in the 99.9th percentile are significantly more <anything> than people in the 99th percentile. “Never mind the 0.01 percent. Let’s talk about the 0.0001%!” would be even more crazy, considering the exponential distribution of wealth.
- VeninVidiaVicii 7y ago"...considering the exponential distribution of wealth." _That_ is the point
- Enginerrrd 7y agoWhat is the point exactly? No policy is going to change the fact that the natural equilibrium for such systems is a Pareto distribution, AKA it follows a power law. We can definitely hope to change the constants of the distribution, but to fundamentally change such a distribution would really be a fool's errand.
- richardwhiuk 7y agoIs there any theoretical reasoning for expecting a Pareto distribution to result? Would a distribution closer to normal not be equally valid?
- Enginerrrd 7y agoWell for starters, such a curve would be fundamentally impossible. You draw such a curve by sorting the data points from wealthiest to least. But I suppose, adding no additional logic you could have one half of a normal distribution, normalized by multiplying everything by 2 to account for that. However, that doesn't strike me as a very natural distribution for a self-organized system with some randomness, and exponential growth. Power and wealth always seems to find its way to some type of power law distribution. You could only enforce such a distribution by concentrating power to the most extreme limit of a power distribution to exert control over the rest. And it's likely that for any definition of wealth you could come up with, people would just find a proxy for wealth that isn't counted by which they could start to exert more control.
- sharpneli 7y agoDepends on the kind of system obviously. Power law is reasonably easy to get. Even with identical starting wealth just having chance + compound interest is enough to produce it. No need for anything more complex than that.
- username90 7y agoThe distribution looks like it does because you often can't substitute quality with quantity, so the money gets dis-proportionally funneled to the top few. So for example if we in the future figure out good ways to collaborate so ten average people can replace a top CEO then you'd see CEO pay go down the drain.
- rklaehn 7y agoWrite a simulation where you have n entities with an equal amount of resources. Now choose two entities at random and let them "trade", where the outcome is random but fair. You will get a "wealth distribution" that is not a gaussian normal around the average but more like a poisson distribution. And this is even with no difference in competence of the market participants. You can add various corrective terms to make get "equality of outcome", but to get to a gaussian distribution around the average you need really drastic/totalitarian measures. The best system from a pure math POV would be a flat tax combined with universal basic income. But unfortunately it is naive to assume that this is politically viable. Politics largely is selling a particular group an advantage over the general population in exchange for votes. And a flat tax / basic income system is just too simple for that.
- VeninVidiaVicii 7y agoAs someone who holds a master's degree in economics, and is getting a PhD in genetics, I can tell you virtually everyone studying the "soft" sciences conflates observations with natural laws. There is nothing stating that a Pareto distribution is optimal. It's only a distribution based on observation, and it just happens. The underlying mechanisms are not immutable.
- throw0932 7y agoEh, what are you saying is mutable here, exactly? The only way of getting a 0.5 Gini ("absolute equality") is if everyone is earning the same, which is ridiculous. As soon as you throw any randomness in there, well, all of a sudden you get inequality. Next, there are the (totally reasonable) winner-take-all mechanics of skilled labor. Are you a better CEO (where "better" here could just mean better at pitching/selling/hiring/picking a market)? Then you can end up capturing all of the market share vs your competitors. That ends up paying nicely. You still could have rent-seekers and people who cheat, but from the article itself, the top driver is differentiation based on skills. Don't like winner-take-all mechanics? Introduce income pooling. But I wouldn't expect that to be the revolutionary change people are looking for, just a way to guarantee people on the same skill ladder end up in roughly the same outcome bracket. I don't think "guarantee top ivy leaguers make >$400k/yr" is what you're looking for.
- Applejinx 7y agoNo, you're mistaken. There's a computer simulation that's been posted here, where you run a population and each element gives 'a dollar' to a randomly chosen other element every step, if possible. For no reason: no merit, no purpose, no meaning. This produces not just 'inequality', but the power-law distribution. The only thing you can't know is which element will be the '0.01%' master of the universe, because nothing distinguishes it from the 'poor' elements as it's only a simulation. The point this establishes experimentally is that through simple value exchange you get the same distribution people associate with meritocracy and market dynamics, without any elements of choice or distinctions of merit being applied. Skill and value have nothing to do with it: the problem is purely mechanical, the system will substantially punish and reward elements in the system quite outside of any consideration of merit. Once you introduce merit, skill etc. you're only exacerbating the problem. Wealth tax, even in very tiny amounts, is quite good at turning the power-law distribution into a more random-looking distribution as one might expect it should be. And usually people aren't talking about Gini 0.5, nor does anyone aspire to that unless it's as a form of rebellion against the extreme opposite. People will tolerate an enormous amount of inequality if their own lives aren't too acutely threatened.
- hannasanarion 7y agoIt is not a universal principle that wealth must follow a power law, and even if it was, the coefficient need not be so extreme. The wealth inequality in America is higher than it has ever been. This did not come about naturally.
- sharpneli 7y agoIt actually does come about ”naturally”. You just need compound interest and bit of randomness. See https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0020728 https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal... This does not mean it’s good. The source even presents some methods of avoiding it. But the key point is that it doesn’t need some sort of conspiracy of the rich to happen. It will happen inevitably without being anyones fault if steps are not taken to address it.
- hannasanarion 7y agoWhat you also need is self-multiplying investments and a lack of wealth, income, and capital gains taxes. The current financial system didn't happen by accident. It was intentionally built in the 1980s by the Reagan administration, at the behest of rich Republican donors. It was not inevitable, it was engineered.
- sharpneli 7y agoIt will just slow it a bit. A non progressive capital gains tax even at 99.999% will still lead to power law distribution. And I don’t think anyone would say a tax that high is exactly done at behest of the rich. (EDIT: compound interest literally is self multiplying investment) One has to rather specifically design a progressive taxation system to avoid a power law. Read the paper. The conditions for power law are very simple. I live in Finland. A place one hardly can say is friendly to the rich. Yet we too have a power law, just with different constants than what US has.
- peteradio 7y ago
- conception 7y agoThe point is that extreme wealth distributions push towards non-democratic societies. You like democracy, you like policies that promote it. Also, “you can never change how it is!” is a nirvana fallacy; you certainly can make things better. It’s been done before.
- Enginerrrd 7y agoI'm fine with changing the alpha value, and finding an optimal alpha value is actually what we should be doing IMO. But we can't act like it's not gonna still be close to some type of power law distribution at the end of the day.
- zxcmx 7y agoThe wealth distributions we see have a mathematical flavour to them but are the result of a system created and governed by humans. In fact vast disparities in wealth can only be created and sustained through significant social effort. It takes an incredible degree of social co-ordination for multi billionaires to exist. Outside of a strong rule of law you have be to a strongman or warlord to keep your hands on all that stuff. As a society we could choose to cap wealth. For example we could say "it's illegal for an individual to own more than a billion dollars worth of assets". The excess would effectively be tax. I can immediately think of a huge number of problems with this (oh no, all the multi billionaires leave!, offshoring, transfers between family members, "schemes" in general) but it's obviously possible to pass this kind of law, were there the social will to do it. It is not possible to amass huge assets without deep support from society at large. Police, judges, guards and the goodwill of the public are ensuring the safety of the billionaire's property.
- Chinjut 7y agoIndeed, the very concept of asset ownership exists only by virtue of social recognition. We make up the rules that define ownership/property/wealth/etc, they are not handed down by God, and we could just as well define/design them differently (as your example of a wealth cap astutely illustrates).
- avanderveen 7y agoAre you suggesting that it's not possible to revise and enforce tax laws? I can see the argument that, if a country attempts to close the gap with taxes, they will just lose a great deal of wealthy citizens and successful businesses, but that can change too. Nations can make new trade deals and treaties.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- gist 7y ago> Is anyone else getting bored with this kind of People who write don't earn a great deal of money. Nor (typically) do they have the potential to do so. Other professions can at least dream that they will hit it big or earn a good steady income if that is not the case. People at the bottom can't even dream but 'they know their place'. News articles with head lines like that draw readers sure but I think it's more than that ('people who write...'). This is human nature. Very generally the middle class that are employed and not taking on credit card debt and spending over their means (which they do) don't care that there are super wealthy people. What is to stop people in some dirt poor foreign country from talking about how it's not fair that people in the US, even our poorest, very likely have it better than they do? (Well nobody other than the writers in our country will say anything and quite frankly nobody in our country would care enough to give them anything that we have so it doesn't matter). When was the last time you heard of a tax specifically to help people in dirt poor countries? (Not talking about aid but actual 'we will take your income', well never). You know what has changed more than anything? What we know about what others are earning and what they have that is what material goods. As many older HN readers will probably agree when I was growing up their were the Rockefellers, Howard Hughes and maybe a few other people. There were movie stars and the Beverly Hillbillies. You didn't really care that they were wealthy it was just the way it was. There was no revolt of the masses. Sure there are more people will money today but what there is grossly more of is attention and that it's in everyone's face (and of course the people who write and broadcast about it).
- rgoulter 7y agoIt kinda reminds me of this visualisation from some survey of Americans in 2011. https://www.businessinsider.com/inequality-is-worse-than-you-think-2013-3 https://www.businessinsider.com/inequality-is-worse-than-you... The respondents weren't opposed to an exponential distribution as such; but the images of the disparities between what they thought was ideal, what they thought the reality is, and what the surveyors say the distribution is is still striking.
- ananth22by7 7y agoI agree with you. These blogs seem to be full of resentment and insecurity, leading to whining and finger pointing. It seems they’re always interested in other people’s money and their success. It’s tiresome. Let’s maybe focus on how we can do good to the world, instead plotting how we can bring other people down.
- xwdv 7y agoEvery time you talk about the top 1% or even the top 0.01%, you eliminate an opportunity to talk about how you can really help the bottom 50%. By constantly painting things as hopeless and unfair, all you do is stimulate rage.
- hannasanarion 7y agoThat rage needs to be there so that we can change the system that produces and perpetuates the unfairness. Rage is a tool for electoral mobilization.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- algaeontoast 7y agoNo, it’s not. Rage removes the ability to discuss anything and fuels the “us vs them” mentality which has been proven time and time again to be unhealthy and NOT productive.
- hannasanarion 7y agoProven when? Proven how? You think that the ultra-rich don't have an "us-vs-them" mentality? You think that they aren't lobbying and fighting and advertising and campaigning to keep their unearned wealth and power for themselves?
- algaeontoast 7y agoI’m not super rich but I wouldn’t call their wealth “unearned”. Why are you privy to their money? The rich have an us vs them mentality because the media demonizes them for working hard. I dislike rich people as much as anyone but the productive response isn’t rage. Rage gives the rich even more power and reason to look for more reasons to hide their wealth and exploit. If you’re so convinced the rich have “harmed” you why not try to move somewhere where you believe your ideals are more aligned?
- 3fe9a03ccd14ca5 7y agoMy issue with all of these discussions is that they invariably present ideas that are just too complicated, and our tax code is just too complicated as it is. Create a system that can be applied evenly, and fairly, from the top to the bottom and then I think you’ve got a great and novel idea.
- crooked-v 7y agoWhen it comes to taxes, "evenly" and "fairly" are not the same thing. That's the whole reason we have tax brackets in the first place.
- 3fe9a03ccd14ca5 7y agoWhy is it impossible to be both even and fair?
- crooked-v 7y agoTaking 30% of a yearly income of $14,000 has a much greater negative effect on standard of living than taking 30% of a yearly income of $14,000,000.
- swebs 7y agoThe Fair Tax plan was a neat idea. Tax everyone at X percent, while giving everyone back Y dollars per month as a form of UBI. The values of X and Y are chosen so those below the poverty line gain more money than they are taxed. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/FairTax https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/FairTax
- rklaehn 7y agoI was a huge fan of this concept. It has been invented independently by people on the right (Milton Friedman) and the left. But unfortunately that is not how politics works. Politics is selling a particular group an advantage over the majority in exchange for votes. That is true both for the left and the right, the only difference is which groups they target. And a fair tax is just too simple. Politicians wouldn't have anything to sell anymore...
- hacker_9 7y agoIf you provide a service people want/need, you are going to end up with more money.. It's not rocket science. This is how the capitalist cogs turn.
- lobotryas 7y agoYou are right. What some people want is to punish your success by arbitrarily deciding how much money is “too much” and using taxes to take away what they think you should not have.
- hannasanarion 7y agoWhat "Service" does Bill Gates provide? He hasn't worked in 15 years, but his net worth has more than doubled.
- lucaspm98 7y agoIs that a serious question? Bill Gates provided a very valuable service that runs most personal computers to this day along with productivity tools that have improved almost every business in the world. He also built one of the largest companies in the world that now employs over 100 thousand people. If there is anyone who should be disproportionately rewarded it would be Bill Gates. He now has a large fortune, which after paying the highest tax rates possible he can invest in other companies further adding to the economy or give away to improve the world altruistically.
- hannasanarion 7y agoYeah, and he stopped doing all that in 2004. Why does he deserve the profits from the hard work done by thousands of engineers to make Vista, 7, 8, and 10, which he had absolutely nothing to do with?
- AnimalMuppet 7y agoWhat is your alternative? That when a founder retires, should they be stripped of all ownership of the company they founded, because they are no longer working? Or should the owners of a company receive zero of the profits of the company? Either of those will have rather large consequences, at least some of them rather negative. So... what's your plan?
- dijit 7y agoWasn’t that always the case. Nobody cares about the guy earning 250k/y. It’s the handful of people who control 90% of all wealth. “1%” was a catchy soundbite but it was always the 0.0001%
- rboyd 7y agoSeems like there were plenty of people in the 1% cohort that would have taken up the movement if they had found an even catchier soundbite.
- Mountain_Skies 7y agoYes. Call it "The Millionth", which would include the 300ish wealthiest Americans. Everyone in the Forbes 400 has a net worth of over two billion. Even though within that group there is a wide gap between the top and bottom of the list, it's nothing compared to be difference between the top and bottom of the 1%.
- dmitryminkovsky 7y ago> Nobody cares about the guy earning 250k/y.
- lobotryas 7y agoNo, because it’s easier to go after and strong-arm or pass legislation against a guy earning 250k than a guy earning 250mm.
- algaeontoast 7y agoYeah, unfortunately this is a sad truth.
- jjeaff 7y agoThat's not really the issue. The thing is, taxing people making 250k year amounts to a lot more revenue than taxing only people making 250m+. The wealthiest make a lot of money, but it's nothing compared to the aggregate of millions of Americans making upper middle class wages.
- nine_zeros 7y agoI'm not sure wtf they were expecting when they did QE, and kept it running for so long. It's literally cause and effect.
- refurb 7y agoI’d love to see an analysis of who the top 0.01% are, in terms of income. My guess is the people who make the list this year, drop off the next and never end up on it again. The top people (again income) are the folks that sell their company or equity stake. It’s a huge windfall, but they never make that much again.
- Ma8ee 7y agoMy guess is the opposite. The top people are the owners of very large, very often inherited, fortunes. Few people leave that group and few people enter it.
- wyldfire 7y ago> very large, very often inherited, fortunes The article addresses inherited wealth: > On the 2016 rich list, two-thirds were self-made and one-third had inherited at least part of their fortune. More than 10 percent were immigrants to the US.
- cmdshiftf4 7y ago>More than 10 percent were immigrants to the US. I wonder what portion of that 10% fits into the inherited wealth bracket also. Anecdotally I've met a lot of rich Indian and Chinese immigrants in tech, however they came over with family money, with strong family power networks, attended top schools and then parlayed their wealth + connections into something even greater. It feels as though we throw "immigrants" out there to be synonymous with "broke" and "powerless".
- refurb 7y agoThat’s wealth, not income. And if you own a large company, you have no income (beyond a salary) unless you sell equity. There are probably people worth $1B+ who aren’t in the top 0.01% because they’re money stays invested and they don’t pull income from selling.
- Ma8ee 7y ago
- allovernow 7y ago>Smith, Yagan, Zidar, and Zwick find that the 1 percent’s income is being driven by owner-managers, mostly of small and medium-sized companies—specifically S corporations, partnerships, and limited liability companies. These are talented managers: the researchers find that profits of companies run by these 1 percent-ers are far higher than those of businesses owned by people in the top 5-–10 percent >“The demand for top skill has outpaced its supply, with the returns to top skill increasingly taking the form of business income.” This really doesn't come off as a problem that needs solving and instead sounds like a purely political war cry. These aren't lords abusing powerless peasants, they're contributing members of society being disproportionately rewarded for their disproportionate contributions. Wealth inequality needs to be considered in the context of overall prosperity and despite the fearmongering you see online, most Americans are doing well. Even our poor have modern conveniences, access to emergency healthcare, generally safe food and infrastructure - eating the evil rich and redistributing their wealth is unlikely to solve any of the major issues in the country, as we're already throwing tons of money at schooling and healthcare and the like.
- FireBeyond 7y ago> Even our poor have modern conveniences, access to emergency healthcare It'd be far nicer if even the poor had access to non-emergency medicine, too, though. Ironically, the poor tend to contribute a disproportionate amount of their income to things like taxes and infrastructure, being without the ability to shield their "wealth".
- fzeroracer 7y agoAs a poor I certainly didn't have access to many modern conveniences. Especially when I had to deal with rotting teeth and dental abscesses without a way of affording the fix.
- blunte 7y ago> disproportionate contributions Do you really argue that the people in the top 0.01% are contributing to society at a rate hundreds or thousands of times higher than the rest of the people? And in the case of heirs, such as the Walton family, are they contributing so vastly more than the guy who mows people's lawns during the day and cooks their dinners in a restaurant at night? Or how about the Renaissance folks. They (whether fully legally or secretly illegally) reap huge rewards yearly, certainly using some advantages and situations most people do not have access to. Are they likewise contributing to society so much more than the average person? Oh wait, let's talk nurses and schoolteachers. They pretty clearly contribute very heavily to society, and they get paid pretty poorly. Are they really contributing less, by factors of tens or hundreds, than Larry Ellison?
- parrellel 7y agoAnd this is exactly why the 99% campaign was stupid and destructive. The world isn't being screwed over by the professional class. It's being screwed over by the population of a midsized town with more money then sense.
- nnnmnten 7y agoHere in Denmark the highest tax bracket applies to almost 10% of the Danish population. The Top 1%, Top 0.01% and billionaires are not taxed more than the Top 10%. I belong to the Top 10% and I'm fine with that. Why do Americans focus so much on the "ultra-rich" and the billionaires when you can build a successful welfare state by just taxing the Top 10% a little more?
- anderber 7y agoIt could be because income inequality is much higher in the US.
- annoyingnoob 7y agoIts because those that control the majority of the money also control the majority of the power. Us plebs don't have the power to fix the tax code. The US tax code is a mess and its very unbalanced, where the folks in the upper middle pay all of the taxes with the outliers on either side paying very little (on a percentage basis). I know a few folks in the top percentiles that feel like they pay the same number of dollars or more than everyone else - they see this as fair. They seem to miss the fact that they get to keep a larger percentage of their money every year. If you get to keep more of your money every year than everyone else then its easier to build your wealth at the expense of everyone else.
- parrellel 7y agoIn America the top 1% control about 40% of the money, with most of that, as this article shows going to the wealthiest. In Denmark its roughly 20% of the money to the top 1% - the lowest inequality of any of the OECD nations. At the same time we have political movements dedicated to wrecking our social safety nets in an attempt to get us back to "The Jungle" style nastiness - often funded by that same fraction of a percent at the top. So, some bitterness there. :D Or, more simply, your country doesn't have anywhere near the same systemic and cultural issues the US does currently.
- ghouse 7y ago> Here in Denmark the highest tax bracket applies to almost 10% of the Danish population. The Top 1%, Top 0.01% and billionaires are not taxed more than the Top 10%. Because in America, the top 0.01% makes their wealth through investment income, which is taxed at a lower rate. So, the top 0.1% pay a considerably lower rate than the balance of the top 1%.
- jvanderbot 7y agoI'm getting mildly amused at the spate of articles that zoom in on exponentially-distributed phenomena and find some kind of scale invariance.
- known 7y agoAppropriate Inheritance tax can cure it;
- Applejinx 7y agoSurprisingly tiny Wealth Tax is even more effective at curing it. The part that's interesting is not where it's transferred from one entity to another, it's the extremity of the phenomenon in the first place. The distributions we currently see have no excuse or purpose. It's fine talking about the value of exceptional individuals, but if a Jeff Bezos is even ten thousand times better than your average schmoe, never mind 'millions of times better', then he would be able to have his influence without the aggregated power given him through accumulation of capital. Never mind whether his dumb kid deserves to have the accumulated power of entire countries abstracted into the form of capital: HE himself has no business possessing that kind of power on top of his functional exceptionalness. He can damned well fend for himself, and will likely still be a big winner and have all he could wish. He has no right to the accumulated power our system awards him, on top of what he can do with his own intelligence and efforts. It's a magnifying effect, fully exploited by just the sort of person Bezos is. Concerns of inheritance only highlight the problem. The parent is not that much superior to the dumb kid, and humans do not merit so much importance (as 'exceptional individuals') as our system claims they do. The BEST you can hope for is a crazy person like Elon Musk, aiming for some quixotic goal while they blunder around causing damage… and that's a best case scenario.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- blunte 7y agoThis essay presents interesting comparisons and data, but then it goes on to try to explain that the top 0.01% are getting richer faster because they have special skills and technologies (such as being able to scale a business up using foreign workers, or manage 20bn assets because of computers). What is not mentioned but certainly plays a key role in one's ability to perform so well financially is the special opportunities the top 0.01% have and circumstances they operate within compared to the lessers. If we were to review each person in the top 0.01%, I expect most of them would be making their huge gains not by exercise of special skills but rather by exercise of special circumstances. RISK - As we have seen with the 2007/8 financial crisis, there is a small group of very wealthy, very powerful finance people who can take enormous risks with other people's money, profiting whether they win or lose. The 07/08 crisis cost the general public (in bailout using public funds (debt)) hundreds of billions of dollars. But the stratospheric executive bonuses paid to fund managers and bank executives during the lead up years was not retracted. So the people that took unreasonable risks profited greatly, and the public paid for their profit and then some. Even during the following years, the executives and fund managers received significant bonuses. And thanks to golden parachutes, the exit/firing of some of them resulted in even bigger profits for that group. OPPORTUNITY - The wealthier one is, the easier it is for them to get credit. Even in cases such as Trump where he has a long history of running businesses into the ground and leaving debtors unpaid, he was famously able to secure very large loans to take even bigger actions (which similarly often resulted in underperforming businesses which would later seek forgiveness or reductions of debts). The point is, once you're rich enough, you need never risk your own money. You can borrow huge sums to seize opportunities. When you win, you win big. When you lose, you can probably get away with no personal loss. LAWS - With wealth and power comes influence. You can afford to lobby (sometimes a polite term for bribe) to get special laws or loopholes that have direct financial benefits for you. Perhaps it relates to a defense contract, and you hold a lot of Boeing stock. Or perhaps it relates to an FAA regulation and you hold a lot of Boeing stock. Or it's a special rule that lets you write off the purchase of a piece of luxury property as a business expense. TAXES - This is a huge space for gaining an advantage over the normal people. Not only do you have the means to play the offshore/shell-company game (reducing your tax burden, perhaps to zero), but you also can do strange things like deferring your taxes indefinitely if you're a hedge manager. I could go on with plenty more examples of special advantages that the top 0.01% have compared to everyone else. These advantages, even if modest, represent an exponential benefit in terms of financial growth over time.
- bradleyjg 7y agoThe purpose of these exercises is always to push the perceived issue on to some other. So if you are union tradesman in NYC pulling down $90k/year you don't want to hear about the top quintile, you'd rather talk about the top 5%. If you are software engineer making $250k you don't want to talk about the top 5% but instead point to the 1%. If you are a specialist physician making $600k/year (or the subsidized journalist child of specialist physician) then it's not really about the 1% but instead about the .1%. And so forth and so on. This is far more about resentments and insecurities than policy. The fact of the matter is if you want to re-adjust the economic landscape towards the poor in a meaningful way it is going to realistically require harming the economic interest of all the current winners -- from the $90k/year tradesman all the way up to Jeff Bezos. In all likelihood it will probably also mean higher prices for goods and services as well as higher unemployment. Maybe those trade-offs are totally worth it, but we should be adults about these things and not pretend there's some magic policy that's going to make everything great for everyone except some tiny cabal of not-us that's probably evil anyway.
- georgeburdell 7y agoAs the article notes, an increasingly common path to the 1% is through skilled labor. I think this type of earner would have more in common with a 50%er than a 0.1%er. My family has been in the 1% for a few years and we’re just bottom-rung individual contributors at FAANGs. 50% of our net worth is in our house. We don’t run or have stakes in any private businesses. No investment properties. The only thing that sets us apart is while an upper middle class family might do a European vacation one year, buy a car the next, and redo their bathroom the next, we do in the same year. Otherwise, I imagine our lives and aspirations are similar.
- hailwren 7y agoI was skeptical, then I checked [1] and apparently even if you separate by state you only need a household income of $512k to be in the top 1%. High, but certainly not unfathomably so to HN readers. 1 - https://www.cnbc.com/2018/07/27/how-much-you-have-to-earn-to-be-in-the-top-1percent-in-every-us-state.html https://www.cnbc.com/2018/07/27/how-much-you-have-to-earn-to...
- appleiigs 7y agoImportant to note it's household income. If a family has 2 software devs at a FAANG (not the OP specifically), quite likely to get to 1% with work experience. If they are doing a european vacation, bathroom and a car one 1 year, definitely top 5%.
- bretpiatt 7y agoMany people end up in the 1% for a single year via sale of business, stock, etc. There's a huge difference between that type of 1% for a year and age 30-40 dual (or very high single) annual income earners. The former may retire with a $1-5M net worth, the latter is either spending heavily or retiring with a $10M+ (and likely $20M+ with reasonableiinvestment returns) nest egg.
- Gibbon1 7y agoThere is also a difference between a $150k/y family with two wage earners and one with a single wage earner. The former is likely paying for day care, etc and have higher family expenses. And a lower quality of life in general. Gets worse as you go down in income. Try two wage earners at $60k/year.
- fnord77 7y agobeing ultra-wealthy gives a person tremendous amounts of political power. the ultra-wealthy are literally an unelected shadow ruling class.
- lucaspm98 7y agoThere is definitely some truth in this. However, what would you proposed to either prevent people from becoming ultra-wealthy or prevent them from having political power?
- ghouse 7y agoThe tax code enables and reinforces outlier wealth using tired arguments like "encouraging investment" and "double taxation." United States centric observations: For example, charging lower tax rates on capital gains than ordinary income promotes a concentration of wealth to people with wealth. Suggesting this is purposeful policy for society to encourage investment is comical -- what else would wealthy people do with the wealth? Store it under the mattress? Or spend it (in which case that would accelerate the velocity of money, also good for society). Capital gains taxes are only on the gains -- income that had not yet been taxed. Actual double taxation is a wealth tax. Similar tax policy that results in concentration of wealth are: 1) 1031 transfers (where income on sale of real property isn't taxed so long as the proceeds are used to purchase real property), 2) Qualified Small Business Stock (where federal tax isn't paid on gains of sale of small business stock) 3) Economic Opportunity Zones (where tax is deferred on gains so long as the gains are invested in an Opportunity Zone, and all additional gains aren't taxed).
- jogjayr 7y ago> charging lower tax rates on capital gains than ordinary income I don't have a problem with the idea. It recognizes that income derived from investments is riskier than income from a paycheck, and applies a discount. The problem is with the execution. Why is the top rate for cap gains only 20% - even if you earn $10b, but 37% for a mere $510k in ordinary income? Surely there should be some amount of cap gains that can be taxed at 37%. Maybe it's $5m instead of $510k (to recognize the riskiness of the income stream) but it shouldn't cap out at 20%. Simply put, why aren't there more tax brackets for cap gains and other investment income?
- Razengan 7y agoHaving a guaranteed basic income, free money, or whatever you want to call it, would assuage a lot of the resentment surrounding the perceptions of effort, luck, opportunity, merit, worth, earnings, taxes, parentage, connections etcetera that inevitably come up in these discussions, as they have on this post.
- patja 7y agoI also find this idea appealing. Reading the end of Gehttoside was an eye opener where the author describes how getting on SSDI (argued as being a limited form of basic income) for being unemployable (disabled) due to their history gang banging gave some former gangsters enough financial breathing room that they could break the cycle of relying on crime to get by. Sounds a little Polyanna-ish but it does have the ring of truth. What are your thoughts on the counter-arguments that basic income will lead to a dystopian future where an underclass just sullenly gets by as dependents of the state. Plenty of scifi speculative descriptions of this future are a bit scary, but are they just scare-mongering?
- jquery 7y agoI’m not convinced that markets don’t work when high pay is involved. If this was true, there is a fortune to be made by creating a mutual fund that invests in companies that avoid superstar pay tiers. Does anyone know of such a fund? How is its performance? I think we evolved the emotion of envy in a time when being rich meant hoarding. Markets break that evolutionary intuition.
- sandoooo 7y ago1. somehow the hate against the 0.01% always turns into policies that tax the upper 20%, or 10%, or 5%. why is that? Is there a way to formulate the arguments / policies so that it doesn't do this? 2. the wealth of the 0.01% are numbers stored in computers. They are claims on future production, yes, but the whole system only works because 99.99% of these claims never gets cashed out, because there are physical limits to what a handful of billionaires can consume, no matter how opulent their lifestyles. If you try to distribute this virtual wealth, people will try to turn it into physical consumables, only to find there really isn't enough for everybody, and the whole system will go to shit. 3. at some point, a guy I know made the observation that revolutions don't really redistribute much, mostly they just take the wealth from the wealthy and burn it. Well maybe how it works is the most important and expensive physical good - land - gets redistributed, most other physical goods are destroyed, and the virtual wealth is zeroed in a very expensive accounting exercise.
- chongli 7y agoIs there a way to formulate the arguments / policies so that it doesn't do this? No. The upper .01 percent have tax lawyers and accountants and many other staff members (not to mention lobbyists) working full-time to reduce their taxes. In theory, anyone could do the same. In practice, the tax code is so enormously complex that only people who can afford to hire multiple college grads full time can pull it off.
- eevilspock 7y agoNever mind the 1 percent, let's talk about the 10 percent. The richest 10% own 70-80% of the wealth in the U.S. My point is that the entire wealth distribution curve should be looked at, and any serious discussion needs to go back to first principles and determine what the curve would look like in a fair society. Of course there are wide philosophical-moral chasms between different notions of fairness, with HN readers, by nature of the hand that feeds them, skewed heavily toward the belief that market forces are the best arbiters of worth and fairness.
- m0zg 7y agoAn old and fitting Soviet joke about this: An old man is relaxing on the couch in his apartment in 1917 Saint Petersburg. His grandson runs excitedly into the room and proclaims: "Grandfather, the revolution has begun, we're killing the rich, and nobody will be rich anymore." To which the old man wearily replies: "My generation fought so that nobody would be poor." Simple arithmetic shows that if you were to completely strip the 0.01% of their wealth (which just isn't going to happen, since they own the Congress) and "give it all to the poor", the poor would still be pretty poor: 6T between 350M people is $17K per person, or about 3 years worth of Obamacare. And that's pre-tax. The way you prop up the poor is by creating opportunity and competition for lower skilled labor and trades, by rejecting some parts of globalism, which forces "the rich" to pay more for their labor supply. That propping up seems to be happening as we speak: unemployment is at a 50 year low (https://www.wsj.com/articles/u-s-september-nonfarm-payrolls-grew-steadily-11570192288 https://www.wsj.com/articles/u-s-september-nonfarm-payrolls-...) Historical reference: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Decembrist_revolt https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Decembrist_revolt