5 ms·
The earlier models were premium not economy pricepoints. Why is the ECU designed around low cost on-board, non-replaceable constructs like this? A premium produ
by ggm 7y ago
The earlier models were premium not economy pricepoints. Why is the ECU designed around low cost on-board, non-replaceable constructs like this? A premium product, would not nickel-and-time the SD card, it would have engineered it as a field replaceable unit, with an insert,format, wait (for download) and go mode.
Replacing the entire ECU feels like an admission like Apple and increasingly Lenovo (thinkpad), they have driven premium to the wrong place. "please give us soldered on memory and soldered on SSD" is not actually what we said, on our feedback forms to Apple, or IBM (X1 Carbon).
Nobody asked Tesla to shave $1 on the ECU assembly and the incremental cost of recall and fix, along with goodwill now outweighs the cost saving in any sense I can understand it. If the authorities demand he fix for free, it becomes another shit show of the TSLA share price. This wasn't a good choice against all the other choices.
- jchw 7y agoLenovo still makes Thinkpads that are extendable. My P51 has 3! m.2 (2 of which support NVMe,) 4 RAM slots, easily replaceable keyboard and more. But I think most people want thinner laptops, and the thinner ones have less of this. I don’t think this is a headphone jack type situation: people value portability a lot on laptops, and the difference between a rugadized, user expandable laptop and an “ultrabook” are striking.
- jdnenej 7y agoMy dell xps is super thin and it still has easily replaceable ram and battery. The massive use of glue, rivets, proprietary screws and cryptographic verification in macbooks is not for slimness but for planed obsolescence
- Aloha 7y agoUnpopular opinion, but from where I sit the serviceable lifetime of a computer is effectively about a decade, so long as all that non-replaceable stuff lasts the serviceable lifetime of the object, then it doesn't matter how repairable or not it is. Apple charges like 200 bucks for a battery and top case, which is pretty competitive for a replacement OEM keyboard and battery combo.
- ksaj 7y agoI think that's about the typical life span of a modern car, too. Anything older than a decade tends to be quite an awful drive. Unless it was built in the days before we decided everything needed to be so expendable.
- Aloha 7y agoYou'll find the average age of vehicles on the road is around 11 years, and continues to grow longer and longer. Cars cost more, and last longer, so we tend to keep them longer and longer now too. https://www.statista.com/statistics/261877/average-age-of-passenger-cars-in-the-united-states/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/261877/average-age-of-pa...
- kozak 7y agoA car can be maintained well as long as parts for it are available. That people don't want to spend on maintenance of >10 yo cars is a different issue.
- saalweachter 7y ago... if you live somewhere they don't salt the roads.
- gambiting 7y agoI mean.....in Poland the average age of a car is 14 years, and we have very harsh winters with plenty of salt being used. I don't think there's anything weird about driving a car that approaches 20 years old, or anything particularly tricky about maintaining one either.
- kozak 7y agoI think it depends on the quality of sheet metal. I live in a place where it's all mud and salt throughout the winter, and somehow my car doesn't rust even where the paint is scratched. I think it's because of a good-quality galvanized coating under the paint (it's a boring normal non-luxury car made in Korea, if someone's curious).
- lorenzhs 7y agoYou can also replace the battry on the X1 carbon (RAM is soldered, though). Lenovo even provides videos showing how to remove the battery and other components: https://support.lenovo.com/us/en/solutions/ht508716 https://support.lenovo.com/us/en/solutions/ht508716. No glue, rivets, or weird screws. It's really mostly the macbooks that are terrible in this regard.
- silon42 7y agoLighter maybe, not thinner. I There's no reason for laptop to be thinner than ethernet or VGA ports. Give me full size mechanical keyboard instead (minus numpad).
- dorfsmay 7y agoAnd serviceability!
- dorfsmay 7y agoI don't want thinner, but I want the 13 inch form factor. I could change the memory, the HDD and the keyboard by removing a single screw on my old x220, and with zero risk of breaking little plastic legs.
- rtpg 7y agoI think normally for automotive components you are obligated to use electronic components that have already been stress tested and are rated for more violent environments (like next to an engine). I wonder if Tesla maybe skirted this (like "oh this computer isn't in the car it's an attachable add-on). Source: I interned at an electronics component company back in uni as a chip tester. Mostly same chips to everyone but ones rated for automotive or space tended to get a lot of extra testing (since failures on electronics are bimodal, running tests in extreme environments just for a bit catches a lot of the bad apples).
- varjag 7y agoThis particular problem had nothing to do with temp rating however. A simple case of wearing out by exceeding the specified number of erase cycles.
- kabes 7y agoIt's worse. Elon Musk used to be bragging that they used consumer grade electronics instead of automotive grade (which is higher than industrial grade). And it's already caused more issues: https://www.thedrive.com/tech/27989/teslas-screen-saga-shows-why-automotive-grade-matters https://www.thedrive.com/tech/27989/teslas-screen-saga-shows... This + the horror stories I read about getting replacement parts when you damaged the car is what keeps me from buying a model 3.
- zaroth 7y agoThey used an industrial rated screen years ago, because no one in the world made an automotive rated screen large enough at the time. They did accelerated wear tests on it and worked with the manufacturer to make some customizations to try to improve the heat resistance, as well as adding cabin overheat protection into the software. Yes, this was not enough to entirely prevent the yellowing issue on some screens. Look at, for example, what Sandy Munro says about the electronics quality specifically on the Model 3, and you will appreciate they have come a long way since then. There is no automotive company I would trust more when it comes to quality of the electronics. This is a group which taped out their own custom silicon for their APv3 hardware, designed by famed chip designer Jim Keller, and will field upgrade it into existing cars. What other manufacturer sells hardware upgrades to their late model year vehicles?
- AceJohnny2 7y agoAt the rate they were rushing to design and build that hardware. I'm absolutely not surprised they chose not to go through the extra steps of qualifying a connector/mount for a flash daughtercard. It's very likely the hardware designers didn't expect the software living on that flash to iterate that many times. In too many ways, Tesla was and still is a hardware startup.
- Aloha 7y agoEvery write up I've seen indicates the amount of stuff being put into /var is inappropriate for flash, beyond that, those logs should be kept in RAM until shutdown then you commit them to disk. I'd have no issue with this stuff bricking if Tesla replaced it free (even more galling that they won't on a 50k+ vehicle), you'll have a hard time convincing anyone that a ECU should last less than a decade under normal operation, Nor should you need to replace the ECU before you replace the battery pack on an electric car. If storage space was alone an issue, then they shouldn't have extended the features of those firmware loads so much - as far as I know the owner has no choice on if you update or not.
- pmorici 7y agoOwner absolutely has control over installation of firmware updates.
- Scoundreller 7y agoI wonder how many dealers do updates without your notice/consent when you bring the car in for repair/warranty/recall work. They probably plug in their dongle for diagnostics and hit « yes » if it prompts them for an update.
- Aloha 7y agoCan I still use the supercharger is I've not upgraded my car?
- pmorici 7y ago
- dpacmittal 7y agoThe worst trend is the non hot swappable batteries. I used to carry an extra battery pack and it used to be so convenient for travelling.
- kube-system 7y agoNow with USB-C PD you can just plug in an external battery to just about any laptop.
- lazyjones 7y ago> . Why is the ECU designed around low cost on-board, non-replaceable constructs like this? What's not replaceable or too expensive about a $400 or so nVidia Tegra board in a $100k car? > Nobody asked Tesla to shave $1 on the ECU assembly Are you suggesting it would have cost Tesla $1 per car to go from an industry standard board used in many cars to a custom solution with all parts tested in-house?
- ggm 7y agoWhy doesn't any other manufacturer of cars have a similar problem? Did I miss the story where BMW or Mercedes demand $1200 to replace this part? Tesla knew it wanted a highly digital logging investment and they didn't design for use life. Doesn't feel like a sensible place to be. But to your main point, no. The actual cost per board of getting a design done for replaceable parts would have been higher. Once they hit volume the amortization would kick in. But for the earliest, yes,expensive. Strangely in the world of eg routers, the first gen often has more hackabilty, more removable parts and it's the later ones which shrink down, gets the bill of materials down. Seriously, they should comp all the replacements for the life of the car, just for p.r. value.
- pmorici 7y agoNo other manufacture does over the air software updates. This problem stems from the fact that the firmware image got bigger with each update as incredible new features were added leaving the logs to be written over a smaller area. Also soldered on eMMC is probably less prone to failure than removable microsd under typical automotive conditions.
- Merrill 7y agoIf you buy an expensive car, produced in low volumes, with little competition in the independent repair shop and aftermarket parts industry, expect to pay through the nose for maintenance, repairs and body work. That also applies to other expensive consumer durable goods.
- maxsilver 7y ago> "please give us soldered on memory and soldered on SSD" is not actually what we said, on our feedback forms to Apple, or IBM (X1 Carbon). I don't know why you are lumping Lenovo ThinkPad in there. Their units are still highly repairable. Even their thinnest model (X1 Carbon) still has the replaceable SSD. It accepts any standard NVME M.2 drive - https://www.windowscentral.com/how-upgrade-ssd-lenovo-thinkpad-x1-carbon https://www.windowscentral.com/how-upgrade-ssd-lenovo-thinkp...
- Cuuugi 7y agoA lot of t400 series have soldered DIMM's, but i agree with you.
- NikolaNovak 7y ago>> on our feedback forms to Apple, or IBM (X1 Carbon). Whoa Whoa Whoa ;-) As somebody who has 9 ThinkPads around his house, including the controversial T25, don't forget Lenovo completely bought and owns all Thinkpad design production branding etc for the last decade. Would IBM have maintained their priorities if they owned the product today? Not sure. But Applezation of the ThinkPads has happened strictly under Lenovo :-< The P series is still pretty good; X1 was never about modularity but strict portability; it's the devolution of T series that bothers me personally the most - the T420s was barely thicker than modern T490, but had swappable battery and hard drive. Not "user replaceable", literally push a button and swap it out. [Disclaimer: IBM employee, but in a completely unrelated part and a ThinkPad fan before my IBM employment; I work in software consulting on large ERP projects and haven't seen an IBM hardware person in my 15 years of service:]