6 ms·
New research: Dark Energy might not exist after all
- taneq 7y ago"Hmm, maybe we're assuming something is constant that isn't, and that could account for the observations without inventing 'dark energy'." "Don't be stupid!" ... "Huh, something we thought was constant isn't constant and dark energy might not be a thing."
- dang 7y ago"Please don't post shallow dismissals, especially of other people's work. A good critical comment teaches us something." https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- ncmncm 7y agoSo, "never mind" the supposed 70+% of the universe's mass-energy, now attributable entirely to local motion? Who awards these Nobel Prizes, anyway? (My first thought when I heard about this Dark Energy thing was, "which part of Occam's Razor don't you get?")
- knzhou 7y agoIt was an application of Occam's razor. Dark energy arises automatically in the Standard Model. That is, you don't put it in by hand -- it emerges no matter what you do. In fact, we often get too much of it; this is the cosmological constant problem.
- The_rationalist 7y agoMOND is epistemologically far stronger.
- iamaelephant 7y ago> (My first thought when I heard about this Dark Energy thing was, "which part of Occam's Razor don't you get?") Well, you would know.
- Cougher 7y agoOccam's Razor is not a law.
- dang 7y ago"Please don't post shallow dismissals, especially of other people's work. A good critical comment teaches us something." https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- ncmncm 7y agoThis is not a dismissal. The work posted is important.
- acollins1331 7y agoWhich anyone who didn't drink kool-aid already knew. What's next? A paper coming out saying everything isnt made of tiny 1 dimensional vibrating strings?
- nixpulvis 7y agoIDK, some part of me finds string theory at least more intuitive than "dark energy". But I'm not an expert.
- knzhou 7y agoIt's not about first impression intuition. I'll bet you'll find relativistic quantum field theory less intuitive, at the popular level, than either string theory or dark energy -- but it has more empirical support than almost anything else in physics.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- edw 7y agoIntuitive appeal is overrated. Aristotelian physics (motion derives from continuous application of force) was intuitive to a lot of people for a very long time. And then Galileo came along.
- NikolaeVarius 7y agoNot the best example, Galileo argued plenty from positions he saw as intuitive, even though he was completely wrong. Also, according to the physics of the day, its completely understandable as to why they thought that way, intuition comes from observing nature, even if those observations may be incorrect simply from not being able to gather the data properly.
- edw 7y agoI encourage folks to read Einstein and Infield's _The Evolution of Physics_ and decide for themselves whether the comment above makes sense.
- empath75 7y agohttps://physicsworld.com/a/dark-energy-debate-reignited-by-controversial-analysis-of-supernovae-data/?fbclid=IwAR2jTe1-7EHUyGUR51lGKs6o8cWuu9Ufzv7PVPTXYd5RLz0UVStPQaAASzU https://physicsworld.com/a/dark-energy-debate-reignited-by-c... According to this article, using the model from this paper with more up to date data sets completely reverses their results.
- chime 7y agoYeah, r/physics doesn’t have a good opinion of this either: https://www.reddit.com/r/Physics/comments/e01bxe/dark_energy_debate_reignited_by_controversial/ https://www.reddit.com/r/Physics/comments/e01bxe/dark_energy... I would love to see a PBS SpaceTime video explaining all of this. They do a fantastic job with new papers such as this one.
- jbotz 7y agoSorry, but the article you linked says nothing about "reversing the results" of the OP article, it is about the same research as the OP article... Which at best you might say reverses the results from the 90s which originally found acceleration of cosmic expansion.
- empath75 7y agoAccording to Riess, however, the supernovae data used by Sarkar’s group are out of date. He says that he and some colleagues, including D’Arcy Kenworthy of Johns Hopkins University, plugged data from a sample of about 1300 supernovae with lower systematic uncertainties into the model used in the latest work. The results, he says, were unambiguous, with the existence of a dipole rejected at more than 4σ and cosmic acceleration confirmed at over 6σ. More importantly, says Riess, the objections against Sarkar and colleagues’ original statistical analysis still stand, as do the criticisms of neglecting other data. “The evidence for cosmic acceleration and dark energy are much broader than only the supernovae Ia sample, and any scientific case against cosmic acceleration needs to take those into account,” he says.
- jbotz 7y ago
- joe_the_user 7y agoOK, looking at the comments, I have to note that Dark Matter[1] and Dark Energy[2] are two different but related hypotheses. The basic existence of Dark Matter is on a fairly strong footing experimentally and afaik this article doesn't cast doubt on its existence (it has been observed, on the cosmic scale, as accurately as many form ordinary matter, for example). Again, this is the dark energy issue. Just sayin' [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dark_matter https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dark_matter [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dark_energy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dark_energy
- mikhailfranco 7y ago'Dark Matter' is physicist code for: gravitating stuff that we cannot see. 'Dark Energy' is physicist code for: anti-gravitating non-stuff that we cannot see. (i.e. Dark Energy, aka Einstein's Cosmological Constant, is a property of the vacuum.)
- gus_massa 7y agoAnother important difference is that: Dark Matter is not uniformly distributed, for example if forms big blobs that surround the visible parts of the galaxies. Dark Energy is uniformly distributed, but the (equivalent?) density is very small, so the effect is important in the very empty space between galaxies.
- astro123 7y agoNot to go into much detail, but these author's views are not shared broadly in the cosmology community. There was a recent paper [1] put on the arxiv that talked a bit about this. I'm not an expert on supernova cosmology (I work on cosmology using other methods) but people I know who are experts claim there are issues. There are also a ton of other reasons to think that the universe is flat (see the CMB [2]) and to think that there is dark energy (large scale structure [3]). We still have no idea what DE is and it might not be an "Energy" but rather some modification of gravity or something else. But we're pretty confident in the phenomenology - there is something there that appears to be pulling things apart. [1] https://arxiv.org/pdf/1911.06456.pdf https://arxiv.org/pdf/1911.06456.pdf [2] https://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/439535/why-does-the-first-peak-of-the-temperature-power-spectrum-of-cmb-imply-a-flat-un https://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/439535/why-does-... [3] https://www.darkenergysurvey.org/supporting-science/large-scale-structure/ https://www.darkenergysurvey.org/supporting-science/large-sc...
- 1e10 7y agoSo if the universe is flat does that make the earth flat as well? :-D
- tanilama 7y agoIt might exist it might not exist. Papers published anyway.
- knzhou 7y agoA paper containing only things we already knew for sure is not a real scientific paper at all. It's easy to sit back and feel smug because physicists might be wrong -- but it's impossible to do anything worthwhile without taking on that risk.
- _of 7y ago> A paper containing only things we already knew for sure is not a real scientific paper at all. It could be. Confirming results is part of the scientific process.
- dragonwriter 7y agoThings that are “known for sure” don't need confirmation; they are already as confirmed as can be. Of course, very little ever meets that description.
- Cougher 7y agoBefore these people waste too much time trying to disprove dark energy, they ought to visit my ex.
- LessDmesg 7y agoAs my physics lab teacher taught us, all breakthroughs in physics happen after new better measuring instruments become available. Modern cosmology is starved of such new equipment, hence devoid of any real progress, having to wallow in theoretical bogmires instead. I would suggest all those funds and scientists be instead diverted to researching nuclear fusion, which is the more pressing goal for humanity right now.