5 ms·
The truth is that even the reinforcement they are going to do is more for PR than for actual safety. This test was intended to push the plane to its limit. No
by lisper 7y ago
The truth is that even the reinforcement they are going to do is more for PR than for actual safety. This test was intended to push the plane to its limit. Not close to, but actually up to the limit, so it was actually expected to fail somewhere around this point. What they call 100% for this test is actually 150% of what the plane is expected to experience in a worst-case real-world situation. The difference between failing at 99% and failing at 101% (which is what happened the last time they ran this test) is negligible from a practical point of view. You'll almost certainly get more variance than that in practice just from manufacturing non-uniformities, random environmental factors, age, etc.
Boeing has committed a lot of sins recently, but this isn't one of them.
- abeppu 7y agoDoesn't the incidental damage like blowing out a cargo door suggest that, while they expected to push the plane to close to it's limit, that prior to the test they assigned very low probability to this kind of failure? Even if this barely-a-failure isn't on its own evidence of a practical safety risk, anytime you're surprised by new data, it does suggest something about your model needs to be updated.
- lisper 7y agoIt is possible to design systems that fail in predictable ways (tear-strips on consumer packaging are an example of this) but airplanes aren't designed that way. It just doesn't matter how the plane fails when it reaches its structural limits, so no design effort is put into this. So no, it is not at all surprising that the energy dissipated in unexpected ways. That's one of the reasons they ran the last test past 100% so they could find out how it would fail because no one knew.
- scoot 7y ago> tear-strips on consumer packaging are an example of this The ring pull on a can might be a better example. Tear-strips are notoriously unpredictable.
- leobakerhytch 7y agoNice video on the design and manufacturing of aluminum drinks cans here: https://youtu.be/hUhisi2FBuw https://youtu.be/hUhisi2FBuw The whole thing is pretty ingenious, but the way the internal pressure helps vent the can while the tab is acting as a second class lever, then as soon as it’s vented becomes a first class lever to push the scored section of the top into the can — that’s great engineering.
- jacquesm 7y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8098146 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8098146
- Pinus 7y agoIsn't there an ancient joke about an aircraft manufacturer having problems with the wings breaking off, and some engineer suggesting performating the wing roots, because have you ever seen toilet paper actually tear at the performation?
- aunty_helen 7y agoThat's not true at all. A good example of this would be the requirement that under a blade out condition on an engine it remains contained. They even test this, https://www.youtube.com/results?search_query=ge90+blade+out https://www.youtube.com/results?search_query=ge90+blade+out
- inferiorhuman 7y agoThat's not true at all. A good example of this would be the requirement that under a blade out condition on an engine it remains contained. They even test this About that… https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Southwest_Airlines_Flight_1380 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Southwest_Airlines_Flight_1380
- WalterBright 7y agoNot always. The pins that hold the engines on to the wings are "fuses" in that they are designed to break away if the engine is vibrating violently, before it breaks the wing.
- awalton 7y agoSure. They'll update their models saying "yeah, this can happen sometimes at 148.5% of max designed wing load. So... don't fly the plane into any >F5 tornadoes." These max overload wing tests are scary dangerous, but they don't represent real flight situations. 99% of their target safety factor is within the margin of error for manufacturing variance. While they'll most certainly investigate the causes of the damage down the fuselage from the wing rupture, it's not likely much of it will be unexpected - if a plane experienced that load, the plane is considered a Loss of Hull even if it lands successfully somehow. I'm immensely paranoid about flying on planes, I have a terrible fear of heights... and nothing I've read in that article bothers me in the slightest.
- jodrellblank 7y ago> What they call 100% for this test is actually 150% of what the plane is expected to experience in a worst-case real-world situation. [..] The difference between failing at 99% and failing at 101% So, what is it 100% of? Not that I even care enough about Boeing clickbait to skimread the article, but this discussion makes it seem like "percent" is a really poor fit for whatever this is actually measuring and trying to communicate.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- bencoder 7y ago100% of its expected actual failure point, based on its design. The plane is rated to 2/3rds of that (I think this is pretty standard in aviation) - the other "100%" - meaning it should never go above that in flight, and if it does it would require a very costly teardown/inspection.
- mlyle 7y agoSo, first, airliners aren't really expected to experience more than 1.3G's of loading in normal or even unusual operation. They are expected to be able to survive 2.5G's (limit load) without structural damage. The 777X satisfied this. They are expected to be able to survive a few seconds of 1.5x this-- 3.75G-- without outright failure but possibly with (irreparable) structural damage. Instead, it catastrophically failed at a loading corresponding to 3.70G's. They are going to reinforce and fix the specific failure that happened at 3.7G's, and make an argument based on strain gauges and instrumentation that another, distant failure was not likely before 3.75G's.
- inferiorhuman 7y agoSo, first, airliners aren't really expected to experience more than 1.3G's of loading in normal or even unusual operation. This is 100% true. But the unexpected happens. China Airlines 006 saw 5G due to pilot error. Everyone survived and the plane (Boeing 747-SP) saw another 25 years of service. Additionally planes age. What's your failure point after 10-15 years of service? Another part that's worrisome is the original angle. Originally the failure was reported as a cargo door blowing out. The pictures released show otherwise. So the question remains: who got reporters to go with a cargo door failure and why? They are going to reinforce and fix the specific failure that happened at 3.7G's, and make an argument based on strain gauges and instrumentation that another, distant failure was not likely before 3.75G's. That depends on how much you trust Boeing's modeling and assembly skills. IMO the pickle forks on the NG cast at least a little bit of shade on Boeing's reputation.
- rumanator 7y ago> This test was intended to push the plane to its limit. Not close to, but actually up to the limit, so it was actually expected to fail somewhere around this point. I would assume that even in a failure scenario the fuselage is expected to fail gracefully instead of catastrophically. By gracefully I mean having a fuse-like failure mode, where the whe system remains operational while a controlled failure is observed in a specific component. For example, a safety valve door blowout or at best a window/door blowout. This test shows none of that. This test shows that Boeing's planes fail catastrophically.
- zuppy 7y agothere is no way to fail gracefully, because what this test does is to test the breaking point. when there is such a stress, there's no middle ground. for example, look how the wing was tested: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ai2HmvAXcU0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ai2HmvAXcU0