8 ms·
> The relatively good news for Boeing is that because the test failed so explosively at just 1% shy of meeting federal requirements, it will almost certainly no
by tzs 7y ago
> The relatively good news for Boeing is that because the test failed so explosively at just 1% shy of meeting federal requirements, it will almost certainly not have to do a retest. Regulators will likely allow it to prove by analysis that it’s enough to reinforce the fuselage in the localized area where it failed.
I don't understand this. So they did a test, and it failed at 99%. They reinforce that one area where it failed, and show by analysis that the reinforced area would have made it to at least 100%.
OK, but what about the rest of the fuselage? The rest was only tested to 99%. Couldn't there be another place that fails at, say, 99.5%, which wasn't detected in the first test because the place that fails at 99% stopped the test?
Edit: I would guess that during this kind of test they have the plane heavily instrumented with things like strain gauges so they can understand how it reacts and see if it is behaving according to spec. So maybe it is the case that the data from the rest of the fuselage showed that it would have made it to 100% if the test had continued, and only the area that failed was in trouble. That could explain why they aren't require to do another test.
That still leaves me unsatisfied, though. Presumably analysis of the design before the test said it would make it to 100%. If the failure was not due to a manufacturing defect in that particular fuselage, then it suggests that they analysis was not adequate. But then what assurance is there that their analysis that shows that the reinforcement would hold is good?
- capableweb 7y agoAbsolutely. I think Boeing has proven with these statements that they no longer care about safety or engineering standards. They should have continued to run tests to prove that they meet 150%, make a video of it and continue to run, in order to regain the trust of the public. But they seem unwilling to get back the trust. Also, I think this also shows that the interaction that Boeing have with the FAA and vice-versa, has been heavily corrupted by something (money?) and FAA is no longer trying to keep Boeing in check. They are trying to make sure that Boeing passes whatever certification even if they might miss some details.
- tlb 7y agoThe 100% already factors in a large safety margin.
- LoSboccacc 7y agothat's not how safety margin work, is not a budget leftover set aside for known unknowns, it's there for unknown unknowns. e: downvoters might want to read Feynman again "If a bridge is designed to withstand a certain load … it may be designed for the materials used to actually stand up under three times the load … But if the expected load comes on to the new bridge and a crack appears in a beam, this is a failure of the design. The O-rings of the solid rocket boosters were not designed to erode. Erosion was a clue that something was wrong. Erosion was not something from which safety could be inferred" if you fail a test before your margin you haven't established that your safe up to 90% margin, you've established that the hypothetical on which your design was based are wrong and no further inference might be warranted, regardless of whether you fail at 99% or 60% of where you expected to fail
- tempestn 7y agoThat doesn't apply in this case. Modeling will never be a perfect representation of reality. IE you're never going to have tested failure at 100.00% of the expected failure load. If it had failed at 90% I would agree that they should take another look at the design, but at 99% it's within expectations. And you still maintain essentially all of the designed safety margin for the unknown unknowns.
- alkonaut 7y agoThey didn't get a pass at 99%.
- LoSboccacc 7y agoI didn't address my reply to FAA either
- perl4ever 7y agoYou aren't paying attention to the phrase "expected load". If, in the bridge scenario, it cracks under 2.95x the normal load, vs. 3.0x or 3.05x, that is not what Feynman was describing. He was explicitly talking about a partial failure under about 1.0x. Which based on other comments is not what happened here.
- lastofus 7y agoBack in March, the FAA was still insisting the 737 MAX was airworthy, even after it had been grounded by other countries. It seems like at the very least, the FAA is worried about the business interests of manufacturers.
- Retric 7y agoAirbus A380 failed a similar test at 3% less load and Airbus responded in a similar fashion. Boeing has problems, but this is practically a pass.
- inferiorhuman 7y agoAirbus A380 failed A similar test at 3% less load and Airbus responded in a similar fashion. Boeing has problems, but this is practically a pass. Airbus was testing a new (higher MTOW) variant of the A380. It's likely Airbus was expecting the premature failure as the fix was quickly deployed. I'm pretty sure you can't say the same about the 777X. Note that wing spar cracks were later found in pretty much every early build A380 in service. Airbus then spent around 500,000,000 EUR to remedy the problem. I'm sure Boeing can make the 777X safe, but it's likely a matter of motivation.
- apta 7y agoFurthermore, what guarantees that another similar test would fail in the exact same spot that they want to reinforce?
- LoSboccacc 7y agoor that the reinforcement doesn't cause it to fail earlier because due to the increase rigidity in that area another nearby areas get more stressed than before
- lisper 7y agoThe truth is that even the reinforcement they are going to do is more for PR than for actual safety. This test was intended to push the plane to its limit. Not close to, but actually up to the limit, so it was actually expected to fail somewhere around this point. What they call 100% for this test is actually 150% of what the plane is expected to experience in a worst-case real-world situation. The difference between failing at 99% and failing at 101% (which is what happened the last time they ran this test) is negligible from a practical point of view. You'll almost certainly get more variance than that in practice just from manufacturing non-uniformities, random environmental factors, age, etc. Boeing has committed a lot of sins recently, but this isn't one of them.
- abeppu 7y agoDoesn't the incidental damage like blowing out a cargo door suggest that, while they expected to push the plane to close to it's limit, that prior to the test they assigned very low probability to this kind of failure? Even if this barely-a-failure isn't on its own evidence of a practical safety risk, anytime you're surprised by new data, it does suggest something about your model needs to be updated.
- lisper 7y agoIt is possible to design systems that fail in predictable ways (tear-strips on consumer packaging are an example of this) but airplanes aren't designed that way. It just doesn't matter how the plane fails when it reaches its structural limits, so no design effort is put into this. So no, it is not at all surprising that the energy dissipated in unexpected ways. That's one of the reasons they ran the last test past 100% so they could find out how it would fail because no one knew.
- scoot 7y ago> tear-strips on consumer packaging are an example of this The ring pull on a can might be a better example. Tear-strips are notoriously unpredictable.
- NikolaeVarius 7y agoThe point that the FAA made is that it doesn't matter. A plane should not be experiencing these conditions ever outside of a test environment. The concern over 99.5% is splitting hairs, since at this point the plane is probably in the middle of a tornado or something Additionally, this test was done while the plane was over-pressurized, which is not required, which adds a lot of stress to the airframe, and added to the "blow up" factor.
- phkahler 7y agoI would expect the analysis is done via FEA. Those models are not perfect but.. Suppose the FEA indicated the highest stress at the same point it failed. Maybe it predicted failure at 102 percent. In that case, doing a reinforcement that allows the whole plane FEA to reach 104 percent should really be sufficient. I still believe in retesting, but I can see how confidence could be high without it. In this case I'd actually prefer letting it pass vs making a change without retesting since the loads are way outside of normal and it came so close. Best of course is to make the change and test again.
- JustSomeNobody 7y agoWhat if the reinforcement weakens another area?
- guywithahat 7y agoWell I’m more than happy if it passes at 99% lol, this doesn’t seem like a problem to me. I mean there are extreme stress tests
- starpilot 7y ago1% is well within the normal variation in strength that parts exhibit. Even with modern materials and precision machining, parts will always vary in performance to a degree that is known. That said, predicting critical points is very deterministic process. Strengthening the critical point that failed in this test by a reasonable margin should, for all reasonable likelihoods, eliminate this point of failure. Predicted performance has error bars, and actual performance has scatter. If we bump up the strength, we can make sure the tail end of that scatter has less overlap with the failure strength scatter (theoretically we can never reduce the overlap to zero). All of experimental mechanical engineering is a comparison of statistical odds. It's quite possible that if they tested another identical fuselage, it would have passed the test and this would have never made the news, rightly.
- jussij 7y agoIf I was in Boeing's shoes I would be doing everything to ensure the real test is repeated and the test is passed. They already face a MAJOR plane credibility issue with the MAX and to have another plane enter service without it actually having achieved a physically passed would do nothing for the credibility of that new plane. While a prove by analysis pass might be fine for the regulators, in terms of public credibility a real pass would be a far better outcome for Boeing.