13 ms·
Ubuntu 19.10: It’s fast
- mmcnl 7y agoAm I the only one who doesn't notice a huge difference between 19.04 and 19.10? I wouldn't have noticed if these articles didn't explicitly mention the performance improvements to be honest.
- mixmastamyk 7y agoUsing Gnome3? If not, it doesn't sound like the fixed performance regressions would apply.
- boudin 7y agoA bit more information about the work done around performances and what's still being worked on: https://discourse.ubuntu.com/t/boosting-the-real-time-performance-of-gnome-shell-3-34-in-ubuntu-19-10/13095 https://discourse.ubuntu.com/t/boosting-the-real-time-perfor...
- ZeroCool2u 7y agoThis is a _great_ read with extremely clear breakdowns of what are clearly complex bugs.
- LeoPanthera 7y agoGNOME 3.34, which the article attributes most of the speed increase to, has been available on Fedora for a while already. But I wouldn't think that running GNOME on "old hardware" is a good idea anyway. Except for very generous interpretations of "old".
- sosodev 7y agoYeah, I’ve been running the latest Gnome on Arch for awhile and it’s really stellar performance upgrade. It’s worth noting that later releases of Gnome are now targeting less resource usage now that they’ve worked out most of the critical performance issues for high end hardware.
- markosaric 7y agoSame here. Been running it on Debian and it looks and works great. I'm relatively new to Linux (moved from macOS last year) so don't know much about the past, but I really don't get all the negative comments about Gnome the way it is today. It's a perfect way for a macOS user to get introduced to Linux too.
- LeoPanthera 7y agoMost of the negativity is on ideological grounds - they don't like that it is "opinionated" and offers minimal customisation compared to KDE. And there's some backlash against the fact that a lot of the UI uses Javascript. (Though recent benchmarks have shown that it doesn't cause any kind of performance hit.) Frankly, I don't think that Gnome is particularly un-customizable, it just does it in a different way, using extensions that you can install. I do occasionally try out new versions of KDE to see what I'm missing, and I'm always surprised how buggy/crashy it is.
- cheald 7y agoIt's worth it to try KDE Plasma rather than GNOME. It's lighter and faster than GNOME by a fair margin, and it's far more customizable. GNOME is great for your OS X convert who isn't used to anything being customizable, but KDE is an utter delight for everyone else.
- phyrex 7y agoYou can make an argument for something, without demeaning something else
- cheald 7y agoI'm not demeaning GNOME at all, I'm contrasting against it. GNOME is a great product, but I didn't like that its recent incarnations seem determined to smooth out the user experience by removing user choice. I tried out KDE (having used it long ago) and was very pleasantly surprised to find it both faster and more tweakable than GNOME. I'd expected tweakable, but the performance was unexpected. Plasma is a far cry from the KDE of old. The GNOME project seems to have made a conscious decision to go for the consumer market, which usually cares more about things "just working" than their being tweakable. That's a good thing - that market needs to be served - but it's not what I wanted. A big part of the reason I run Linux is for detailed control of my user experience, and KDE is the better product in that regard for my use case.
- 5Sgx2pChWKtUMc2 7y ago> OS X convert who isn't used to anything being customizable, > KDE is an utter delight for everyone else The way you frame it as OS X convert vs everyone else is kind of rude. I would say the hardcore Linux customizer is the minority, and everyone else prefers the easy to use out of the box UIs of OS X and Windows.
- SmellyGeekBoy 7y agoI'm a "hardcore Linux customizer" in many ways, but I'm also a happy Gnome user on my day-to-day development machine. I do love KDE but fiddling with it was distracting from my work. To be fair, this probably says more about me than it does about either environment.
- klyrs 7y agoThe review doesn't touch my longest-running gripe with Ubuntu... does it still run tracker/nautilus/baloo in the background, sporadically choking on a developer's filesystem and hanging the entire UI? Because I'm really not impressed by a clean install being snappy.
- pmontra 7y agoTracker does run in the background. I disabled some of the things it indexes. I don't experience any slowdowns. Nautilus is there, it's the file manager. I installed Nemo because I want to keep using type ahead in the local folder. I still get Nautilus in the file dialogs and tracker in the full screen modal opened by the super key (is it the dash?) Baloo, no idea what it is. Overall 19.10 it's faster than 16.04 on the same laptop. It's 3 years of work and a clean install (dual booting for now, two different SSDs.)
- ac29 7y agoBaloo appears to be the KDE equivalent of GNOME's tracker. Not sure why both would be running on the same system.
- doubleunplussed 7y agoIt wasn't implied that they were on the same system. The grandparent was either implying that they don't remember which is which, or that which one is running depends on which Ubuntu flavour (gnome or KDE) you're running.
- klyrs 7y agoIndeed, I've used multiple flavors over the years, and these have been culprits on various occasions. I'm not an expert on OS's so the uncertainty I conveyed was deliberate.
- softwarelimits 7y agono, use xfce. Ubuntu is many systems and as a "Hacker" of course you make it your own - that is the reason for running Linux, you control every process.
- politelemon 7y agoI don't normally try non-LTS, I decided to give 19.10 a go, and I noticed the performance boost. What was a real pleasant surprise was that my NVidia GPU drivers were automatically installed, something I've always had to do myself before.
- CoolGuySteve 7y agoGlad to hear it. 18.04's NVidia on Wayland situation is so broken it's ridiculous. It's a major headache for any kind of machine learning workstation.
- opencl 7y agoNVIDIA on Wayland is still ridiculously broken and NVIDIA has zero desire to fix it. The "solution" is to continue using Xorg.
- nickserv 7y agoUnless you need CUDA, the solution is to use AMD.
- CoolGuySteve 7y agoThat may be true but it's no excuse for Ubuntu's gdm + desktop setup refusing to work out of the box without a bunch of command line fiddling. It's like they didn't QA it at all despite it being a very common setup on an LTS release.
- non-entity 7y agoIf been having serious issues with my Nvidia card and 18.02 (driver is installed properly, but games either dont recognize the card name or misreport card details). Is there anything in 19.10 that might improve this? I've already updated my kernel so excluding that.
- undersuit 7y agoI upgraded my Intel Compute Stick to 19.10 Lubuntu last month from 16.04LTS. It's running great and I didn't have to mess with any of Ian Morrison's wonderful tools he made for running Linux on the Intel Atom platforms. Not saving my resolution settings across reboots is a slight issue, but that is something I can fix. After reading the article maybe I should try Gnome again.
- slantyyz 7y agoDoes that mean you didn't need to use a boot drive with a 32 bit boot loader? I've been having trouble getting any of my sticks (one an ASUS Vivostick, the other a no-name) to even boot a Linux installer off USB or CD, but that could be because I've been trying to get Ubuntu Server, which may be part of the problem. If the Ubuntu desktop path is better, maybe I'll try that.
- zozbot234 7y agoFedora supports 32-bit boot out of the box, even on actual 64-bit OS's. The Debian multiarch image does as well, but the 32bit-boot/64-bit OS arrangement fails if secure boot is on, so make sure to turn that off beforehand in the firmware UI. AIUI, Ubuntu doesn't support this.
- slantyyz 7y agoAfter seeing @undersuit's comment, I decided to try the Ubuntu Server 19.10 ISO and it booted fine off a USB drive. Good to know that no tricks are required (such as these: http://www.linuxium.com.au/home http://www.linuxium.com.au/home). I had been banging my head against the wall trying to get older versions of Ubuntu Server installed on my stick PC.
- undersuit 7y agoGood to hear!
- paulcarroty 7y agoBe honest, Ubuntu feels fast 'cause people compare it with bloatware/telemetry overflowed Windows 10. If you wanna a really FAST distribution - try Clear Linux from Intel.
- mileycyrusXOXO 7y agoMaybe it's time I give Ubuntu another shot. Unity was too bloated for my tastes and Gnome has always seemed kinda subpar. Lets see if the gnome changes can change my mind. Does Ubuntu still have advertisements for Amazon search and whatever other crap they were pushing?
- hatch_q 7y agoI don't see much difference between GNOME 3.4 and Unity tbh... I'll stay on MATE or Cinnamon.
- proverbialbunny 7y agoYah imho Mint is just a more pleasant experience. You still need to set the gpu to handle vsync or you'll get page tearing though.
- thibran 7y agoUnity2D was super fast. So sad that they didn't continue to develop it, and instead went for GNOME. If Ubuntu GNOME is now quick, good – it took a long while to get there. It's important for Linux and FOSS to have well known and widely used software. Without Ubuntu, we would probably have no Steam Linux client.
- zozbot234 7y ago> So sad that they didn't continue to develop it You can run MATE with the Mutiny desktop preset, if performance is an issue. It's essentially the same workflow as on the old Unity 2D, and it isn't even Ubuntu specific. > Without Ubuntu, we would probably have no Steam Linux client. SteamOS is actually based on Debian, and Steam is even in the Debian non-free repos.
- branon 7y agoThe distribution of the proprietary Steam client you can install on GNU/Linux systems ships a 32-bit Ubuntu runtime, I believe based on 12.04.
- audidude 7y agoWow, I've never had so much of the hard work myself, colleagues, and individual contributors have done misattributed to one company. For those interested in what actually was improved, and some attribution for those involved, see https://blogs.gnome.org/shell-dev/2019/11/22/a-review-of-gnome-shell-mutter-3-34/ https://blogs.gnome.org/shell-dev/2019/11/22/a-review-of-gno...
- Jasper_ 7y agoCome on, Christian. Daniel van Vugt at Canonical did a huge number of performance fixes on mutter and gnome-shell this release. Some of those I had to personally vouch for because your colleagues wouldn't land them otherwise.
- audidude 7y ago3.34 wasn't a one-person show Jasper. This article reads like it was a one company thing.
- Jasper_ 7y agoSure, there was a ton of great collaboration, but "mis-attributed" is wrong. Canonical's desktop team definitely lead the charge of compositor performance. Be nice; there's no reason to keep the Canonical/GNOME rift open anymore. They did absolutely fantastic work this release.
- audidude 7y agoAnd thankfully we've been lucky enough for your important contributions as well.
- traverseda 7y agoCan you elaborate on that a little? I've always gotten the impression that gnome is actively hostile to new contributors and anyone who isn't part of the "inner circle", so I'd be interested in hearing more about what that actually looks like, from someone who isn't very anti-gnome.
- simosx 7y agoThere is an article [1] by an Ubuntu engineer that describes the performance boost. For Ubuntu 20.04, there will be extra work for performance boost on high-end computers. For Ubuntu 20.10 there will be extra work for performance boost for low-end computers. 1: https://discourse.ubuntu.com/t/boosting-the-real-time-performance-of-gnome-shell-3-34-in-ubuntu-19-10/13095 https://discourse.ubuntu.com/t/boosting-the-real-time-perfor...
- jagger27 7y agoI'd like to see them quantify/qualify what they mean by low and high-end. I would have considered low-end to be a dual core i3-class CPU with no dedicated graphics but by the time 20.10 is out I'd be more inclined to say a quad core is low-end. Obviously a Threadripper is high-end today and will be even higher-end next year, with 64 cores perhaps.
- dannyw 7y agoLinux supports hardware for a much longer duration than windows and Mac OSX. I wouldn’t be surprised if low end is an Intel atom.
- farisjarrah 7y agoWhen Canonical says low-end hardware, I'm inclined to believe they mean actual cheap low-end hardware. Ubuntu has supported the raspberry pi for years now. A raspberry pi is much much lower end then even a bottom of the barrel i3 processor
- Tsiklon 7y agoI think you're being far too generous. Low end would be systems which just about meet the system requirements, regarding CPU, GPU and Memory.
- sandGorgon 7y ago>Most improvements in 19.10 can be attributed to the latest release of GNOME 3.34, the default desktop for Ubuntu. However, GNOME 3.34 is faster largely because of work Canonical engineers put in At least everyone can stop hating on Gnome now. Secondly, Fedora 31 has had Gnome 3.34 for more than a month now. This article does seem like a disservice.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- Spivak 7y agoFedora, despite being awesome, doesn’t have the name recognition or market penetration that Ubuntu does. Ubuntu shipping with 3.34 is realistically when the bulk of Linux desktop/laptop users will see it.
- proverbialbunny 7y ago>Ubuntu shipping with 3.34 is realistically when the bulk of Linux desktop/laptop users will see it. Fedora is up there. In 2019 Fedora may potentially have a larger "desktop" user base than Ubuntu. Often times people will lump in Ubuntu based distros as Ubuntu, inflating Ubuntu's popularity, but in this day and age Mint probably has more desktop users than Ubuntu. Ubuntu's popularity is being reduced to AWS these days, but lets be fair here: Who uses Ubuntu as their primary desktop of choice when there is better distros for every user need? Right now, Ubuntu is the goto desktop OS for those who want to run two gpus on a laptop and that's about it.
- rlpb 7y ago> ...but in this day and age Mint probably has more desktop users than Ubuntu. I find that claim very hard to believe. I'm an Ubuntu developer. I see both bug reports from users, and fixes being landed. It is rare to see a report from a Mint user, and even rarer to see any fix that is attributed to having come from the Mint community, whether that's landing in Ubuntu directly or via upstream. Either the Mint community keeps fixes to themselves (I doubt it because it's very difficult to maintain a derivative distribution that way), or Mint users and developers aren't affected by or don't report/fix any bugs affecting them whose root cause is upstream (seems unlikely, given the firehose of reports and patches Ubuntu developers send upstream), or there are relatively far fewer Mint users than you think. Disclosure: I'm also a Canonical employee. However this opinion is my own and I am not representing my employer in making this comment.
- vilhelm_s 7y agoBased on my experience from using Ubuntu, it's perhaps more accurate to say that the Ubuntu 19.04 (and earlier) compositing window manager is slow enough to make new hardware feel old. It's extremely noticeable. The blogpost they link to says as much: > Gnome Shell 3.32 in Ubuntu 19.04 feels slower than Unity and other desktops. If you have a slow machine then it won’t run smoothly. Perhaps more surprisingly even if you have a fast machine then it still would not run completely smoothly. (https://discourse.ubuntu.com/t/boosting-the-real-time-performance-of-gnome-shell-3-34-in-ubuntu-19-10/13095 https://discourse.ubuntu.com/t/boosting-the-real-time-perfor...)
- zozbot234 7y agoWell, before 3.30 GNOME wasn't even remotely usable, so I would still call that progress. Make it work, then make it fast.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 7y agoWhenever I see claims like this "Old Hardware" seems to invariably mean "5 years old" and "fast" means "not as perceptibly slow as the bloated crap, but noticeably not as fast as actually fast things".
- dannyw 7y agoI’d give it a try yourself. It’s really fast.
- DanCarvajal 7y agoImagine if that Unity experiment didn't suck up five years of time.
- fabrice_d 7y agoImagine that they learned a few things working on Unity and they applied them to improve Gnome Shell.
- anewguy9000 7y agoso i just installed it, and like, right away i notice every app always opens in the top left of my screen and their positions are not remembered?? :( speed seems irrelevant if windows cant be arranged lol. google is coming up empty. is this a bug?
- anewguy9000 7y agoupdate for posterity: windows seem to open in some kind of a logical fashion, so they use all the available real estate of the screen dynamically. its pretty cool! generally i prefer it cuz i never have to move new windows out of the way. but it would be nice to have a setting to remember some windows in a fixed position. as is the case w gnome lately many such settings are hidden/removed for the sake of simplicity. cheerz!
- ZeroCool2u 7y agoCurrently running this on my XPS 13. Works beautifully and honestly battery life is insane. _Much_ better even than just 19.04. It's easily on par with my 2015 MBP. I'm getting almost a week out of a charge using it for a few hours a day running just Chrome, PyCharm, and Signal most of the time.
- KitDuncan 7y agoI think I am doing something seriously wrong then. My 2015 XPS 13 only lasts a couple of hours.
- cmm 7y agowith laptops, it really pays to make sure your kernel as recent as possible
- softwarelimits 7y agotry to put powertop --auto-tune into /etc/rc.local (before 'exit 0'!)
- egdod 7y ago4 years is long enough for lithium batteries to decline pretty noticeably.
- mceachen 7y agoYup, my xps 15 battery of that same vintage had to be replaced at the beginning of the year (under warranty).
- ZeroCool2u 7y agoSorry, the MBP was my old work computer. I don't have it anymore. I was referring to its battery performance at the time.
- ZeroCool2u 7y agoI think the big differentiator is power top actually. When I upgraded to 19.10, I was prompted to check the differences between the old/new versions of the power top config file. The new version had a few more comments and was clearly updated, so I used the new config file during the upgrade process and went through all the options to make sure they made sense for my laptop.
- kingosticks 7y agoI've been running it for a while and it's great except it still takes a ridiculous amout of time the time to launch gnome calculator. Ever since they changed it to a 'snap' it's been awful. Edit : It looks to be pretty easy to swap the snaps for regular debs: https://blobfolio.com/2019/10/psa-upgrading-to-ubuntu-eoan-might-convert-some-local-apps-to-snap/ https://blobfolio.com/2019/10/psa-upgrading-to-ubuntu-eoan-m...
- akerro 7y agoI noticed absolutely no difference after upgrading from 19.04. Do I need to do anything?
- proverbialbunny 7y agoIs your monitor running at 30fps? I imagine in that situation the changes wouldn't be noticeable. Also, upgrading from 19.04 to 19.10 isn't super stable, so it could be it didn't upgrade properly.
- akerro 7y agoIt's a Dell latitude laptop, screen is at 60Hz
- mikhailt 7y agoA little off topic but mentioned in the article, does anyone know why macOS does feel slower than Windows and Linux on the same hardware? Does it have to do with the 2x scaling Apple is doing all the time?
- proverbialbunny 7y agoI don't know what hardware you're using or what "slower" exactly means here, but OSX has always been silky smooth at 60fps for me, focusing on that nice feel, more than an instant responsiveness. To be fair, MacOS is still highly responsive, but it's polished, causing an intentional minor frame delay, which increases smoothness. Windows, on the other hand, is responsive, but has incremental stutters from time to time. It happens in video playback, to the point when I'm out and about and at a mall a tv with a video is playing, I can tell if it is on Windows or Linux. It's more obvious in video games which has these microstutters all over the place, starting with DX9. Linux has page tearing, and depending on the desktop can be highly responsive or not at all. Many linux desktops can be manually configured to turn on gpu acceleration on the desktop so the gpu handles the vsync and everything else making it butter smooth like OSX with more responsiveness, but you have a trade off at that point between how much responsiveness vs how much polish you want. (When you drag your mouse across the screen, it skips pixels. When you're dragging a window, does the compositor follow the mouse flawlessly, skipping around, or does it smooth behind the mouse a frame or two making it look nicer?) Maybe you're running a 4k60 external monitor out of a 2015 MBP. In that example, you'd be maxing out your GPU on the desktop, potentially causing a delay when dragging windows around that may or may not be noticeable. On this hardware setup, Linux and Windows are both lighter weight and will be more responsive. ie, ymmv depending on your setup.
- mikhailt 7y agoI tested this with my iMac 5k with 32GB of memory and Radeon m295x (4gb of vram). The apps start slower than what I noramlly see on Windows but I don't have a lot of the same apps, so it's hard to compare. I agree that it has to do with responsiveness but I don't know, sometime I prefer the responsiveness. I do see stutter in Safari once in a while, it is not always 60fps for me. The screen is set to default for display. My previous 2012 rMBP was the same difference between Windows 10 (Bootcamp) and macOS. iOS on my iPad Pro (first gen) is very responsive and smooth at the same time. I wish I could get the same experience on my Macs.
- tsar9x 7y agoWhile Gnome 3.34 is great, there is still some basic (for me) functionality missing (talking about Wayland, because I can't stand screen tearing on Xorg): - no option to set mouse scroll speed - hidpi support - no tray icons (and extensions doesn't work great...) - notifications system - gestures/trackpad I'm planning to move to MacBook to see how it is, in case I need more power, I will just use my workstation/gaming PC (with Nvidia, right now I'm using AMD with the only reason being Wayland support, because hardware is much worse).
- gambiting 7y agoI tried upgrading a fresh installation of 19.04 to 19.10 and it permanently broke itself during the upgrade process. Twice. So it seems like there's some issue with the upgrade process at the moment.
- useryman 7y agoDoes wayland+gnome work with propietary nvidia drivers yet? I've been using unity since 18.10 because gnome always blackscreens on my 1070. (I'd been using it since it became the default, for the sake of support. But preferred unity)
- karmakaze 7y agoTL;DR Ubuntu 19.10: Gnome 3.34 is fast, like “make old hardware feel new” fast.
- crispinb 7y agoIt's fast and also magical, transmuting my laptop into an effective heater.
- rebelwebmaster 7y agoMeanwhile, Gnome still can't manage to display a desktop wallpaper when running at 4k resolution and 200% scaling. https://gitlab.gnome.org/GNOME/gnome-shell/issues/1175 https://gitlab.gnome.org/GNOME/gnome-shell/issues/1175 Kind of hard to get excited about perf improvements when relatively basic functionality manages to be broken for at least 7+ months and counting.
- proverbialbunny 7y agoThis is why I am on Mint. Turn off CPU vsync, turn on full-frame composition (which uses the vsync on the graphics card), and bam! silky smooth 60fps, with quick responses and no lag. I haven't tested it, but I imagine this new "fast" version of gnome will still feel slower and choppier than cinnamon when vsync is handled on the gpu. (I just wish it was the default setting.) That and I'm not a fan of the side bar in Ubuntu. Most people agree, Mint's desktop UI and UX is just more pleasant.
- SmellyGeekBoy 7y agoStrange, I have this exact setup and my wallpaper displays just fine.
- Frenchgeek 7y agoOr maybe (not so) current hardware is insanely fast, and windows really slow: Just to see if it could work I tried to install linux on a Chuwi Hi8 (windows/android atom based chiinesium tablet. Not enough space for windows now and really ancient android) Ubuntu was so slow, by the time I finally managed to begin copying files to the disk, the tablet ran out of battery. (And the thing eat more power than its charger can provide) (as for the result of the experiment: it can work, but the amount of work needed was way beyond what I was ready to invest. And not exactly stable)
- mixmastamyk 7y agoReading between the lines I gather this release fixed a performance regression in a previous Gnome3 release. So it is not a clear performance boost in the absolute sense. I suppose those of us on Ubuntu Mate, KDE, XFCE, etc can disregard that aspect of the article. Unless there are some perf improvements in the kernel or X as well?
- anthk 7y agoIf you like Ubuntu and Gnome services such as the account manager, install Ubuntu Budgie, it will run much faster. Try getting the future LTS release, it will be safer.
- grizzles 7y agoI had to downgrade. There is a regression and you can't run it off a USB stick anymore.
- FullyFunctional 7y agoThe Raspberry Pi 4 info is out of date AFAICT. The initial release had non-working USB on my 4 GiB RPi4, but fixes came a few(?) weeks ago that apt update (over ssh) picked up. As best I can tell, it works flawlessly now. Mindbogglingly, I can comfortably do serious development work on $55 computer (albeit overclocking recommended). At the other end of the spectrum, it's also running on my 5K iMac and that it just worked. On the Dell XPS 15, the audio didn't work out of the box, but there's a common workaround for that.