5 ms·
No, they aren't. India's per capita CO2 output is tiny. China's is middle of the road. Per capita is the only way we can talk about CO2, because otherwise we ge
by vkou 7y ago
No, they aren't. India's per capita CO2 output is tiny. China's is middle of the road. Per capita is the only way we can talk about CO2, because otherwise we get true absurdities, like Denmark or Ireland being allowed to pollute as much as the US. (The world will not support 200 countries polluting ad much as the US.)
There's also a simple solution to getting trade partners on board. It's called a carbon tariff.
- DataWorker 7y agoPer capita may not be the best metric. China’s population isn’t going to shrink any time soon. If the environment is the concern the total emissions seems like the appropriate figure.
- yibg 7y agoDon’t see how that would make sense. Comparing the emissions of China vs that of Iceland just doesn’t make sense. We can talk about total global emissions, but then bring it down to the total per capita contribution per country. e.g. China has 20% of the worlds population so are “allowed” 20% of the worlds total emissions.
- dominotw 7y ago> India's per capita CO2 output is tiny. being tiny now implies incredible room for growth given growth rates of those countries, which is actually an arugment for more action not less. > Per capita is the only way we can talk about CO2 Wouldn't it also mean India and china won't have to do anything for decades till they get to same per capita as USA ?
- yibg 7y agoIt would mean China needs to stop emitting more per capita and the US (and other developed countries) needs to reduce its emissions per capita.
- dominotw 7y ago> It would mean China needs to stop emitting more per capita No it doesn't following GP's chain of logic. It doesn't need to do anything till the point it hits US per capita.
- wutbrodo 7y ago"doesn't need to do anything" is a qualifier that _you_ added, apparently based on a gross misunderstanding of the conversation. We're talking about defining an ideal target here, with deference paid to the fact that the status quo poses some inertia. If we're talking about an idealized frictionless vacuum, everybody would snap to the same emissions per capita, at the level required to forestall the negative effects of climate change. This would imply a substantial reduction of US emissions and perhaps an increase or small decrease in Indo-China emissions; increasing China to US levels doesn't make sense in any model, idealized or otherwise. Given that inertia means that the US reduction can't be immediate and drastic, it still suggests that mroe of the burden for emission reduction falls on the US than on India and China.
- dominotw 7y agoI admit don't really understand what target would china and india have per capita under this model. Why would any burden fall on china/india given they are already on the low end of per capita. Can you define what burden falls on them under your per capita model?
- vkou 7y ago> Wouldn't it also mean India and china won't have to do anything for decades till they get to same per capita as USA ? If the US does not reduce it's emissions, yes. (In China's case, it's emissions are currently per-capita similar to most of the EU). This is a great argument for the US, and the EU to reduce their emissions, instead of sitting around, pointing fingers are China. Again, if you aren't using per capita metrics, you will get absurd conclusions. If a country splits in half, does that mean it should be allowed to emit twice as much?
- Supermancho 7y agoWhen talking about global action, you need to involve the political organizations of populations where effective action can be practically enacted. Per capita isnt as useful a measure as you think when talking about large scale change.