6 ms·
Senate Considers Banning Dial Phones (1930)
- dmix 7y agoThe last paragraph makes it sound like old people struggling with the UX of new technology. > the dial phone "could not be more awkward than it is. One has to use both hands to dial; he must be in a position where there is good light, day or night, in order to see the number; and if he happens to turn the dial not quite far enough, then he gets a wrong connection." I’m guessing with the previous version you just picked it up and had an operator to route the calls?
- pmontra 7y ago> The last paragraph makes it sound like old people struggling with the UX of new technology. With the insight of some extra 90 years we know that the dial is a horrible UX. Actually, we're getting back to voice, by telling to the phone who we want to talk to. But they had very little choice back then.
- ronilan 7y agoCorrect. Senators are required, since the installation of dial phones in the Capitol, to perform the duties of telephone operators And also seems that it was more than UX that bothered them...
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- squiggleblaz 7y agoBut since they weren't performing the duties of telephone operators - a machine was - this was just an expression of the problem, namely they didn't like the ui. Previously, they communicated to a human being the identification of the person they want to connect to, and a human being connected the wires. Now, they connected to a machine and told the machine an identification standing for the person they wanted to connect to, and the machine connects them. There was no substantial difference to the responsibilities of the senators, except that they no needed to know an additional way of identifying a person. If they had spoken into a computer and said the name of the person who they wanted to talk to, and the computer routed the call, they would have been doing the duties of telephone operators exactly as much as they were when they were twisting a disc with their finger. But they would not have objected to the ux and they would not have said they were "required ... to perform the duties of telephone operators". It is important to understand what a person is saying when trying to interpret their meaning. Give as full force to their words as possible, without turning them into a fool or an idiot who says things that are patently untrue.
- undecisive 7y agoI think that statement is more an expression of perceived motive. The senators were used to having a trained human employee making their connections "just work", suddenly this technology puts the onus on the end user. Why? Because in the long run, the technology is cheaper than employing a trained human. Are the telephone companies going to pass this saving on to the tax payer? Unlikely, certainly not in the near-term. So the senators are objecting to having to put their cup of coffee down, steady the phone with one hand, turn the dial with all their might with another hand - five (?) whole times - pick up their coffee again, only to find out that they've misdialled and have to start the whole process again. Just so that some telecoms fat cat gets a bigger paycheck.
- michaelt 7y ago> they weren't performing the duties of telephone operators - a machine was [...] There was no substantial difference to the responsibilities of the senators Would you also say there is no substantial difference between typing a document yourself and dictating a document to a typist?
- mola 7y agoDoes the last paragraph still holds? Today a lot of public talk is about the manipulation (as opposed to genuinely convincing, i.e. presenting the actual argument and not the most effective and machiavellistic argument ) of public opinion, and when we have masses of people specializing in this sort of manipulation, with help from social (psychology etc) scientists, and automated ('machine learning') optimization. In this climate, I'm not sure if it does. That's bad, because we lost the basic trust in human communication to say what you mean. Of course this is not meant to be nostalgic, deception was always present, but never so normalized, natural and _not_ a social taboo as it is today.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- ben509 7y agoYou could, in fact, dial them one-handed. A rotary phone uses pulse dialing; as the rotor turns it opens the circuit briefly, if you dial 5 it sends 5 pulses. So you can do the same by pushing the switch repeatedly and pausing in between each number as though the rotor was spinning back. Same trick works on touch tone phones since the networks still support pulse dialing.
- tlb 7y agoYou needed really fast fingers for this. The minimum is about 8 Hz. I could do it as a teenager, but I don’t think 70yo senators are going to like it.
- toast0 7y agoSome of the networks don't support pulse dialing anymore. Many of the Analog Telephone Adapters people use to access voip accounts don't either.
- agildehaus 7y agoThey make adapters to allow rotary on such systems: https://www.dialgizmo.com/ https://www.dialgizmo.com/
- sjcsjc 7y agoI recall a friend of mine (when we were teenagers in the 80s) whose parents had a physical lock on their phone to prevent the dial turning (to prevent their kids running up phone bills I assume). Unlike his parents, my friend was aware of the "trick" you describe.
- bargle0 7y agoThere was an information kiosk phone in the student union of my alma mater that could make long distance calls with pulse dialing using a button on the handset. It was well used.
- bemmu 7y agoOnce as a kid I managed to misdial the emergency number (112) by just randomly pressing the switch, unaware of the trick and with no intention of calling anywhere. I wonder if the emergency worker believed me when I apologized for accidentally calling him.
- leoc 7y agoSure. Switchboards were actual plugboards (often using the 1/4" jack, which was invented for this application). The operator would plug her headset into the user's socket to talk to him or her, then unplug the headset and (for a local call, or an internal call on a private exchange) connect the caller's socket to the callee's using cables. This is one of the odd things about the fad for rotary-shaming today's teenagers: the rotary-dial system hasn't even been around all that long. Bell produced how-to-dial-your-new-rotary-phone films in the mid-'thirties and the mid-'fifties https://thekidshouldseethis.com/post/introducing-the-dial-telephone-films-from-1936-1954 https://thekidshouldseethis.com/post/introducing-the-dial-te... https://techchannel.att.com/play-video.cfm/2012/5/30/AT&T-Archives-Introduction-Dial-Telephone https://techchannel.att.com/play-video.cfm/2012/5/30/AT&T-Ar... , to say nothing of the rest of the world. There are undoubtedly still some people who are so old that they still aren't comfortable with rotary dialing. (In fact, I read someone on Twitter claiming to know some old English women who don't know how to dial a telephone, as they always used to get their husbands to do it for them. I'm guessing they may be pretty posh old ladies, as the early-twentieth-century public-school set had a reputation for being technophobic.)
- grawprog 7y ago> some old English women who don't know how to dial a telephone, as they always used to get their husbands to do it for them. My grandma was Scottish but she was like that. She eventually learned but, when I was a kid she'd always have me or my sister or cousins dial for her because my grandpa had always done it for her. I'm pretty sure she always knew how, I think she just didn't want to or like doing it. She'd always make this big act about how it was too hard to figure out though, would make attempts at dialling, dial the wrong number a bunch then tell us to do it but it always seemed like she was just doing it on purpose.
- magduf 7y agoThis sounds like a guy I used to know who told me about how, when he got married, he'd intentionally pour a bunch of bleach in the laundry and ruin the whole load, just so that his wife would forbid him from ever doing laundry again and do it herself.
- gmueckl 7y agoThe rotary dials are a pretty horrible user interface: You have to turn the dial all the way to the stop and release it there. If you don't do that properly, you dial a wrong number. You need to know that you have to let the dial return to its original position before you can dial the next number. If you don't, you dial a wrong number. There is no feedback regarding the digits you already dialed. If you're trying to dial a long number and forget which digit you're at in the process, you have to hang up and restart. I remember that I struggled with all of these things as a child. The whole thing was a brilliant invention in its time, but I'm glad that it's obsolete.
- leoc 7y agoHm, number input is slow but once one is used to it it should be reliable. The problem of forgetting where you are (or being unsure if you dialed a wrong digit) is probably mostly down to the lack of any display of the digits dialed, which isn't inherently a problem of the dial interface, and indeed earlier touch-tone phones also lacked a display. That said, the slow dial speed, and maybe the slightly higher mental effort of dialing a digit, probably do increase the chance of losing your place, or feeling as if you have.
- lscotte 7y agoIn practice it's really not that hard. We had a rotary phone until I was a teenager and never had any of these issues. Also note that 10 digit dialing for all numbers is a fairly recent thing. We had 7 and 5 digit dialing - less to remember where you are in dialing.
- Frondo 7y agoReading between the lines of gmueckl's post a little, it's not hard for most people, but there are several aspects to the process that would challenge people with one or more disabilities: > Mobility and dexterity, being able to dial the dials > Memory and cognition, remembering where you are in the process > (he didn't mention this) Sight, being able to see the dial accurately and consistently I was also able to use the dial phone as a kid, but I'm glad it's gone, too. (By the way, is there any way to make a bulleted list in hackernews text?)
- balfirevic 7y ago> One has to use both hands to dial I don't understand why would you need to use both hands to dial. Were those old dial phones different than what we imagine today when we picture a dial phone?
- mikequinlan 7y agoYou have to lift the handset off the hook and hold it in one hand and use the other hand to dial, meaning dialing required using both hands. This picture shows an example https://www.alamy.com/man-uses-old-rotary-phone-image227240534.html https://www.alamy.com/man-uses-old-rotary-phone-image2272405...
- balfirevic 7y agoThanks! I had a dial phone growing up and we would often just use the same hand to both hold the handset and dial the phone (just stick one finger out a little bit while holding the handset and use it to dial).
- bluejekyll 7y agoI’m intrigued by the distinction between manual and dial. I am assuming manual in this context means: pick up phone, ask the operator to connect you—which doesn’t sound manual at all.
- jonny_eh 7y agoManual for the phone company, not the end-user.
- chrisseaton 7y agoWhen you dial a connection is made automatically. When you use an operator they're having to manually make that connection (literally manually using a wire in their hand back then.)
- bluejekyll 7y agoYes. I’ve seen the pictures. Still, I wouldn’t call that manual. “Operator assisted” seems like a better name.
- jonny_eh 7y agoIt reads like they went ahead with a compromise where they got phones that worked in both "manual" and "dial" mode. When were those replaced with dial-only?
- ben509 7y agoWikipedia has an interesting history of manual switchboards[1]; they broadly died out in about the '60s with some still used in rural areas into the '90s. And while the switchboards were automated, I don't think even today our phone systems are "dial only." Certainly through the '90s I recall dialing an operator for international and reverse charge calls and I think operators still serve customers with disabilities. That's not even counting all the customer support positions that are mostly redirecting calls. The funny thing is you'd think the web would have ended it, but more sites are adding chat boxes, or they want your phone number to set up an account... [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Switchboard_operator https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Switchboard_operator
- flomo 7y agoSomeone with a landline should dial "0" for the operator and see if it still works. (Assuming it does, they will charge you.)
- ijiiijji1 7y agoBikeshedding is older than the bicycle.
- tomohawk 7y agoThey still have elevator operators for the elevators at the US Capitol building. If you watch old movies, you can see the pre-dial telephones in operation as the operators set up calls. It would take a while. One convenience is that you could have the operators call you back when they had reached the other party.
- vpilcx 7y agoThat was actually the entire comedic premise of an I Love Lucy episode. The gang is in Italy and wants to call back to the states so they have to wait for a long distance operator to call them back with an open line. They, unfortunately, are on a higher floor with no elevator. So every time they have to talk on the phone they have to get 3+ flights of stairs.
- perl4ever 7y ago"They still have elevator operators for the elevators at the US Capitol building." Some years ago, I was shown how to operate a (enclosed) freight elevator by someone who apparently thought I was kind of dumb not to know how they worked. I don't know how common the setup was, nor how old or typical it was, but among the features it lacked that modern passenger elevators have - it didn't travel to and stop at a floor automatically; you had to start and stop it with a control at the right spot; it didn't open and close the doors automatically; you had to pull on a strap, and close guards separately, and I'm not sure I even recall any locking mechanism.
- wlll 7y agoI used to work in an old mill (NW UK) converted to industrial units and we got to the top floor using an old lever operated lift. The lever had three positions, up, down, and stop. The door was a couple of sets of sliding gratings. I seem to recall that there was a locking system but I can't quite recall what it was. It was either that here was some sort of piece of metal that stuck out from the lift shaft and only allowed the doors to be opened at certain positions in the shaft, or that the lift wouldn't operate without the doors being closed, or some combination of both.
- ramigb 7y agoI was born in 84, My city had the manual phone mixed with the dial phone until early 90s, so I remember as a kid my grandmother picking the phone and asking the operator -whom I knew since it was a small city- to connect her to someone ...
- russfink 7y agoResulting alternative reality: "Hoy hoy, Watson, come here at once. I wish to dictate a text message."
- profmonocle 7y agoThere's another fascinating anachronism in there: > The Congressional Record would not be mailable, he said, "if it contained in print what Senators think of the dial telephone system." "Not being mailable" is probably a reference to https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comstock_laws https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comstock_laws The idea of being unable to send "obscene" mail, even private correspondence, is hard to imagine compared to our modern understanding of free speech.
- voxic11 7y agoIs it? Obscenity is still not protected by the first amendment in the United States.
- analog31 7y agoAmusingly, there are modern analogues. Word processors were harder for many people to use than typewriters, at first, and those were harder to use than secretaries. Operating a personal computer was harder than assigning a task to the computing department. We got over those things because those technologies eventually made most of us more efficient. I do my own programming and typing. But there are still people who have other people do those things. The thing that probably got the Senators to use dial phones was the realization that they didn't want the operator listening to their conversations. Today they probably all have burner phones. But I doubt that Senators do their own typing, and they probably still use a secretary to make official phone calls for them.