5 ms·
The case against this here is fascinating. It’s basically a bunch of people who will likely never be able to afford their own beaches cheering on a billionaire
by arcticbull 7y ago
The case against this here is fascinating. It’s basically a bunch of people who will likely never be able to afford their own beaches cheering on a billionaire as he takes the beach they currently have access to away from them because “freedom.” Yeah Mr Khosla, you take my beach! Wooo! You’re right, I shouldnt be allowed on there, I am the rif-raf after all.
This is basically the problem in a nutshell: people voting against their own interests because one day they may be rich (they won’t though, probably, because if everyone was rich nobody would be) and when they get there they want their own beach too. So they give their beach away to the wealthiest, and now nobody but Vinod has a beach. If instead they just agreed to share the beach they’d all have it now, but of course that’s un-American, apparently.
- aetherson 7y agoIt seems on-the-face-of-it unlikely that any significant population imagines that they will one day be able to own a private beach, even if they are unjustifiably optimistic about their future wealth. I've been around a lot of people who have hopes about their level of future wealth, and that's not a level anyone thought they would achieve. So, look, have you considered that when you try to make common cause with the whatever non-super-elite class of people you're trying to make common cause with, you do it in a way that doesn't make you a patronizing asshole? Because you're assuming that people are too dumb or brainwashed to "vote their interests" rather than that they have a different conception of their interests than you do
- arcticbull 7y agoYou are of course right that I was being neither tactful nor political and wasn’t really expecting to sway anyone already committed to the idea. However I’ll ask openly and genuinely: what does anyone stand to gain by allowing a wealthy individual to cudgel away their right to access a large swath of beachfront as enshrined in the California state constitution? To what benefit to ones self can you possibly point?
- satyrnein 7y agoSome people may view it as a matter of right and wrong; that forcing a public accommodation onto a private citizen is unjust, even if they would benefit from it. I say, forget what the previous owners thought. If the public needs a way to access some public land (the beach), build a public road. If the way is blocked by private land, that's what eminent domain is for. Seize some land and compensate Khosla. That's what would happen to regular people.
- bnjms 7y agoThat's what was done before he bought the land though? An easement was placed on it allowing for people to pass through to the beach right? It's the same situation as having a sidewalk in front of your house.
- jonathlee 7y agoNo, the actual previous owners of the were running access to the beach as a business. It was a road (driveway) they built and charged fees to use, not public.
- arcticbull 7y agoThat may have been illegal too, honestly.
- Excel_Wizard 7y agoLiving in a state that respects property rights has benefits. When you know that your state respects other individuals' property rights, you know it's less likely that they will trample your rights as well. The case hinges on the previous landowner performing "public dedication" of the road by letting people use it. The concept of "public dedication" without the previous owners of the land creating any legal documentation, and possibly unaware of the legal consequences, that they are willingly performing public dedication of the road is absurd.
- homonculus1 7y agoThis is an uncharitable and condescending take, although it does follow a sadly pervasive rhetorical pattern. Essentially it erases the question of whether this might be a case of protecting the fundamental rights of our society from erosion, and reduces the problem to the immediate material circumstances. With all of that difficult nuance and caution gone, anybody who disagrees with the foregone conclusion is just a poor and stupid rube.
- luckydata 7y agoWhat about my fundamental right of enjoying the public natural beauty of my state?
- homonculus1 7y agoIt's perfectly valid for you to argue in defense of that right, even that it trumps property rights if that's what you believe. What's not okay is to say that the people siding with the issue's other concerns are dumb greedy idiots who shoot themselves in the foot because they can't understand sharing.
- strbean 7y agoEvery person in the United States has had the right to access any beach in California for almost 50 years. To act like this case represents an "erosion of property rights" is disingenuous. Next we'll be talking about "eroding the rights of people to buy the ocean".
- WillPostForFood 7y agoNot exactly. There is a right to be on the beach up to the mean high tide line, (except government owned/controlled beaches), but there is no guarantee of access, which is the issue here, and in places like Malibu colony.
- strbean 7y ago
- tdhoot 7y agoRight. I'm never going to get arrested or be on trial (statistically), so why defend the civil rights of those accused? I'm much more likely to be a victim, so why vote against my own interests?
- arcticbull 7y agoTo be clear you are the victim in this case. It’s also in your interests as an individual to reduce incidence of crime and strict policing and minimum sentences don’t, prison reform does. That would in fact lead you to vote for whatever reduces the likelihood of your being victimized too, and that’s Scandinavian prisons and policing. You should vote for reduced recidivism and a functional rehabilitation system and not a punishment system that’s so utterly failed.
- tdhoot 7y agoWhat does strict policing have to do with civil rights, like the right to face your accuser, the right to a jury trial, protections against double jeopardy, etc.? My point being sometimes people vote or defend ideas that they believe are fundamentally right -- regardless of whether they themselves benefit from those ideas.
- arcticbull 7y ago> What does strict policing have to do with civil rights, like the right to face your accuser, the right to a jury trial, protections against double jeopardy, etc.? I'm suggesting that as someone who doesn't want crime to happen to them, this is the kind of thing you'd optimize for anyways. Jailing people in and of itself doesn't reduce crime, in fact, the US recidivism rate is so high, if you locked up innocent people and people guilty of low-level crimes you'd probably increase the crime rate. That's how ineffective America's police/prison industrial complex is at reducing crime. As such these procedures are something you'd want to keep people out of America's wildly ineffective prisons. > My point being sometimes people vote or defend ideas that they believe are fundamentally right -- regardless of whether they themselves benefit from those ideas. Sure. However, a rich man refusing to let the people of California onto their beach in support of exercising their constitutional rights isn't one of them. I'm not saying rich to engender animosity against his wealth, he earned it, that's great. I'm pointing out how many other options he has. He could literally use his money to build his own synthetic ocean in the middle of California and put a beach house on that. Instead, he's chosen to spend his largesse to keep Californians from being able to exercise their constitutional rights so he can have a slightly better view. That's the definition of a dick move.
- tinkerrr 7y agoThe argument on the other side is that this is a matter of what's good for society in the long-term. For example, supporting a law that says "let's take all the money of class X and give it to the rest" would always be "in the interest" of the majority in the short term. That doesn't make it right.
- arcticbull 7y agoIt's called progressive taxation and no, it's fine.