4 ms·
Huawei sure, no one knows who really owns/controls them. But Baidu, Alibaba, actually have fairly transparent ownership structures, they aren’t that subject to
by seanmcdirmid 7y ago
Huawei sure, no one knows who really owns/controls them. But Baidu, Alibaba, actually have fairly transparent ownership structures, they aren’t that subject to party control beyond say an American company operating a branch in China.
- esmi 7y agoAn American company is likely run by American citizens which comes with some protection from the Chinese government. Chinese companies owned by Chinese citizens don’t have that luxury so it’s similar but not the same.
- seanmcdirmid 7y agoKind of sort of? American companies heavily use local talent, or people from Taiwan, often Chinese expats with American citizenship. The government could still apply pressure to family, I guess, but in general the publicity alone is enough to make sure they don’t interfere much. Likewise, American branches want as good relationship with the government as they can get, which tends to temper their actions. Working in China for 10 years, I can’t say that I didn’t feel the party at all, but their influence in our work was pretty much nil. They mostly interfered in the distribution of benefits and such.
- eznoonze 7y agoIt depends on whether the party considers your business useful to their rule or helpful in implementing their policies. For example, Wechat, Alipay, etc are all very useful. Their policy is trickling down gradually. They recently inserted Commissars into a list of Hong Kong real estate companies. So even non-mainland chinese companies are not immune.
- seanmcdirmid 7y agoCommissars or just trade union representatives? If the latter, Microsoft China had that also, but it didn’t have much of an influence on the company. Commissars would be really strange since that is a role in the PLA.
- eznoonze 7y agoBoard of Director. The title of course is not called "Commissar", but they serve as a defacto one. Some are public. Some hide their identities (but serve similar purpose). Secret ones usually are used in dealing with foreign entities (i.e. non-mainland). So you may not even know there is one except if you are in the top management.
- eznoonze 7y agoChina would not hesitate to use your Chinese branch as a leverage to influence your business even in the US, e.g. Airlines, NBA, etc. Unless you are decoupled from China, you are not immune.
- nashashmi 7y agoSame goes for the US. US will use branches of foreign companies to leverage its rules.
- bassman9000 7y agoPlease https://twitter.com/adamscrabble/status/1195069077028581376 https://twitter.com/adamscrabble/status/1195069077028581376 http://www.deepthroatipo.com/just-one-thing-about-the-alibaba-september-quarter-2019-investor-call/ http://www.deepthroatipo.com/just-one-thing-about-the-alibab... https://twitter.com/adamscrabble/status/1180205067321970688 https://twitter.com/adamscrabble/status/1180205067321970688