5 ms·
The privilege to take an action is not a justification of the action. Google designed their calendar this way to support work. It doesn’t sound like these peop
by Spooky23 7y ago
The privilege to take an action is not a justification of the action.
Google designed their calendar this way to support work. It doesn’t sound like these people were using resources for work purposes. That’s almost certainly a violation of the work rules. Pushing blame on the employee being tracked is ridiculous.
Companies are not democracies, and unless you are an executive with a contract or are in a collective bargaining agreement, you serve at the pleasure of your management. If you’re irritating your management for reasons and want to stick around, you need to work in the rules.
- koheripbal 7y agoThe fact that screenshots of those calendars were later found outside the company, helps to demonstrate intent here. Also, it might be legal for me to follow a person around in public and film them, but doing that is still incredibly creepy and indicative of mal intent.
- jagged-chisel 7y agoAt some point those behaviors cross the line into stalking. I don't know where exactly law enforcement and prosecutors draw that line, but I'd prefer to get them involved sooner rather than later.
- wolco 7y agoNot really. Different groups may follow you. PI trying to determine marriage issues, health issues for insurance reasons, etc If you are famous or have something to add to the news cycle reporters or people trying to sell your picture may follow you around. Most people post where they have been publically to create their personal brand that they share with others. These have no mal intent. The overused word creepy is subjective.. and doesn't make it wrong. I know someone who feels creepy going outside at night. We shouldn't morally make a judgement for everyone based on someone's feelings. I don't think going outside is creepy.
- Marsymars 7y ago> PI trying to determine marriage issues, health issues for insurance reasons, etc From my perspective, either of those have ill intent towards me.
- bradlys 7y agoSure - but maybe you have ill intent towards others (filing dubious claims, an affair without spousal approval, etc.) and this is to see it happen. It is no different than police doing a stakeout - it is just a private citizen than a public defender.
- wolco 7y agoYou can look at it as decreased insurance rates. If insurance companies could not investigate your insurance would cost 10 times as much. The marriage investigation is a mixed bag. If you are running a drug running operation I should get the kids and you need some proof to make that claim.
- maxlybbert 7y ago> Pushing blame on the employee being tracked is ridiculous. I’ve never worked at Google, so while I can’t say for certain, I doubt the calendar has a “notify me about the juicy bits” checkbox. It’s certainly useful for me to know when my manager will be in the office or in some meeting, and if my manager marks the meeting “private,” I can know that he won’t be available at a particular time even if I don’t know what he’ll be busy doing. If he finds it creepy that I know when he’ll be at the dentist, or be in a 1:1 with his boss, he needs to make sure the appointment is marked as private; I can’t do anything about it. So, yes, I believe in this case, it makes sense to blame the people being tracked for publicity posting information that they didn’t want others to know.
- briffle 7y agoWhich is also the case of pretty much any other enterprise calendaring system, like office 365, or heck, even <shudder> lotus notes...
- ic147 7y agoFrom the article: > an individual subscribed to the calendars of a wide range of employees outside of their work group. Following your manager's calendar makes sense. Doing the same for people outside of your group is suspicious imo, unless you're working with that team/person.
- emiliobumachar 7y agoHow plausible is it that they were following people outside their group for union reasons, e.g. to call them for a union meeting, rather than anything more nefarious?
- antpol 7y agoThat is ok usage, but in the discussed case we already know that people followed were later doxed not called to discuss unions. Big difference
- 7y ago
- bartread 7y agoI tend to agree, and it's also worth pointing out that calendars in O365 work similarly. We have them configured to be public by default because it makes it much easier to book meetings, particularly when you need to find a slot that works for several people. With that being said it does assume that you have the common-sense to make appointments that should be private, private. I tend to do this for any personal matters, along with any meetings that involve discussing sensitive work-related matters. (I also use private appointments to ensure I get a lunch break if a day is looking particularly full of meetings. If I don't eat something at lunchtime I tend to be bad-tempered in the afternoon, which doesn't really help anyone.) Worth pointing out that we've clearly communicated that calendars are public by default, which hopefully helps people to know they need to make appointments explicitly private if that's what they want.