2 ms·
> It's a hugely privileged position to be in, and the idea that it comes with exactly zero responsibility to Rest of World is nonsensical. and tell me if you a
by chii 7y ago
> It's a hugely privileged position to be in, and the idea that it comes with exactly zero responsibility to Rest of World is nonsensical.
and tell me if you also spend a portion of your income on donations to under-developed countries. Because that's what you're asking the billionaires to do - altruistic giving.
I m of the position that if they legitimately made their money (i.e., nothing illegal), they are entitled to spend it however they see fit. It's _good_ if they spend it on altruism - but it's not an entitlement that i expect of them.
- macintux 7y agoThere was once a tradition of public service among the elites; they recognized that their position was good fortune at having been born into a family of means, and that selfishly speaking without a strong civic society their position would be fragile (even setting aside the altruism many of them felt). This notion was reinforced by the Ivy League system. Bushes, Kennedys, you can see the tradition of service (even if we may tire of political dynasties). Selfishly, if you're wealthy and wish your progeny to be the same, it's not a bad idea to make sure the cathedral doesn't collapse around you.
- anigbrowl 7y agoLegally speaking sure. Pragmatically, extreme wealth is as much a product of luck and timing as innate superiority or diligence, and often that wealth is expanded through political lobbying; eventually the resulting asymmetries will become unsustainable and the wealth will be redistributed one way or the other. The less prospect people have of economic security through normal effort, the less incentive they have to uphold the property rights of those with structural influence.