4 ms·
Why? The service and/or product provided by their business is providing significant value to society (lest they wouldn’t be collecting profit). Is the reward fo
by kortilla 7y ago
Why? The service and/or product provided by their business is providing significant value to society (lest they wouldn’t be collecting profit). Is the reward for creating a successful business really more responsibility to just give back instead of using it to create more business?
- pjc50 7y ago> The service and/or product provided by their business is providing significant value to society (lest they wouldn’t be collecting profit). This is assuming the conclusion. They could just be collecting a monopoly rent or a land-rent or an IP rent; for example, when Martin Shkreli raised the price of insulin dramatically he wasn't "providing more value to society", he was extracting that value, potentially at the cost of human lives. https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2018/07/shkrelis-former-company-is-now-losing-money-even-with-the-5000-price-hike/ https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2018/07/shkrelis-former-...
- chii 7y agoThere's a lot of confounding issues here in relation to the insulin problem: the fact that medical patents are poorly structured - insulin is hard to make, and making it via a biological mechanism means the "molecule" is slightly different, and so the FDA needs time and money to assess it. This creates a defacto monopoly, and thus, said monopoly can raise their prices. The fix isn't to force billionaires to give out their wealth for free - but instead to fix monopoly laws, as well as to stream line the way approvals can be made for generic molecules made via biological means (like the way generic drugs are today). In fact, an insulin factory _should_ be easy for a billionaire to fund and if the relevant regulations are better, there'd be more insulin sellers as there's profit to be made (seeing as Shkreli has raised the price).
- jacobush 7y agoThis close to the money, there's no distinction between what you are proposing (fixing the monopoly laws) and force billionaires to do something. Currently, the companies write the laws. You want to force them to stop writing the laws.
- kortilla 7y ago> there's no distinction between what you are proposing (fixing the monopoly laws) and force billionaires to do something Of course there is. One is punitive and accomplishes no long term positive effects. The other encourages competition and subsequently innovation.
- kortilla 7y agoYou’re joking, right? You do know that when people pay rent for land or for a property they get something in return? I get immense value out of my apartment that I pay rent for.
- CharlesColeman 7y ago> The service and/or product provided by their business is providing significant value to society (lest they wouldn’t be collecting profit). Making a profit is not proof of providing value to society. It's a tempting simplification to make, but it's false.