4 ms·
Unless they have alternative access to paper books, I don’t see how this does not violate their 1A right to books.
by mc32 7y ago
Unless they have alternative access to paper books, I don’t see how this does not violate their 1A right to books.
- jmpman 7y agoPrisoners have the right against cruel and unusual punishment. They certainly aren’t protected by the 4th amendment. Do they have 1st amendment rights?
- mc32 7y agoCruel and unusual is a thing that gets interpreted and re interpreted. The 1A is pretty unambiguous. I believe they enjoy a subset of 1A rights, though not all as felons lose some rights.
- JumpCrisscross 7y ago> I don’t see how this does not violate their 1A right to books There’s a First Amendment right to books in prison? (Genuine question.)
- mc32 7y agoYyyyy-es? I mean they have the right to read books and other materials[1, 2] (whether the prison is required to furnish them is a different question). But generally, I believe yes, prisoners have a limited right to the 1A in prison. There are some restrictions for security purposes as well as they lose some rights (like right to vote) if they are felons. [1]https://ncac.org/news/books-behind-bars-the-right-to-read-in-prison https://ncac.org/news/books-behind-bars-the-right-to-read-in... [2]https://jailhouselaw.org/your-first-amendment-right-to-freedom-of-speech-and-association/ https://jailhouselaw.org/your-first-amendment-right-to-freed...
- Scoundreller 7y agoMeanwhile in Canada, you can still vote while you’re in prison.
- wmeredith 7y agoPretty sure the bill of rights doesn’t apply to prisoners.
- Cougher 7y agoPretty sure that you're wrong about that.
- Coffeewine 7y agoI suppose it depends on how you interpret the 2nd and 4th, but prisoners certainly can’t bear arms or refuse arbitrary searches. Similarly they lack the right to freely assemble.