4 ms·
I wish this comment was banned from HN. Every time someone says that some free software is in any way flawed there's always the completely useless reply "well d
by IshKebab 7y ago
I wish this comment was banned from HN. Every time someone says that some free software is in any way flawed there's always the completely useless reply "well did you file a bug?" or even worse "it's open source - why didn't you fix it?"
I'd hope it's obvious why these comments are bad, but I guess not so:
* Not everyone has time to fix a bug or even file one.
* The ability to fix or file bugs doesn't mean that the bugs don't exist!
* The ability to fix or file bugs doesn't mean that one shouldn't talk about the bugs.
* The possibility of fixing a bug doesn't help if you don't have the time or ability to fix it and actually want to use the software.
* Not everyone is able to fix all bugs
* It's not nearly as easy for people outside a project to fix bugs as it is for people familiar with the code.
* Everyone already knows it is possible to file and fix bugs in open source software so you're not adding anything to the conversation.
- xtracto 7y agoSpecially because you usually have to jump through a lot of hoops to file a bug. I remember some time ago trying to file a bug for some major open source software. It was so painful that I gave up before finishing.
- boomboomsubban 7y agoWithout context, it was likely painful as they need that information to have any chance of fixing the bug.
- ubercow13 7y agoI don’t mind collecting useful information, it’s the having to create accounts on some hard-to-navigate project-owned bug tracking thing that kills it for me.
- bityard 7y agoThere's a word for people who expect to get things for free without giving anything back to the authors or community that made it possible.
- Dayshine 7y agoCould you point me at the paid for equivalent for excel on Linux? If he donated even a thousand dollars he wouldn't get the product he can get for almost free on windows.
- SyneRyder 7y agoDoesn't Excel run under Wine? That might actually be the better option. (LibreOffice user here on Windows, donated in the past, but I find LibreOffice Calc really unpolished. It puzzles me because NeoOffice is really quite good on the Mac. I should probably just switch to MS Office.)
- stjohnswarts 7y agoCertain versions yep :) . Although I'm not sure it's flawless. Crossover office is best if you're going down that route, or just put windows in a VM and run it there if it's crucial to your work. That's what I do.
- Yhippa 7y agoThere's also a phrase for people who give things away for free and expect something in return.
- esyir 7y agoThis just turns Foss into the inferior but free option, and I don't think that was the intention.