13 ms·
ICANN races towards regulatory capture: the great .org heist
- Svip 7y agoDid ICANN ever become a UN agency, or is it still technically under the jurisdiction of the USA? Or really neither, and nothing will probably happen?
- consp 7y agoSearched about it because it might matter and came up with this article: https://www.internetgovernance.org/2017/11/07/jurisdiction-icann-belong/ https://www.internetgovernance.org/2017/11/07/jurisdiction-i... Apparently it is under Californian State law so US law.
- chx 7y agoAccording to https://finance.yahoo.com/news/u-government-no-longer-controls-160017929.html https://finance.yahoo.com/news/u-government-no-longer-contro... from October 2, 2016 > As of Saturday, October 1, the federal National Telecommunications and Information Administration no longer exercises control over the Internet Corporation for Assigned Names and Numbers (ICANN) > Instead, as an autonomous not for profit organization, ICANN will now answer to international stakeholders across the internet community, including a governmental advisory committee, a technical committee, industry committee, internet users, and telecommunications experts. According to https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/ICANN https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/ICANN > From its founding to the present, ICANN has been formally organized as a nonprofit corporation "for charitable and public purposes" under the California Nonprofit Public Benefit Corporation Law. It is managed by a 16-member board of directors composed of eight members selected by a nominating committee on which all the constituencies of ICANN are represented; six representatives of its Supporting Organizations, sub-groups that deal with specific sections of the policies under ICANN's purview; an at-large seat filled by an at-large organization; and the President / CEO, appointed by the board > There are currently three supporting organizations: the Generic Names Supporting Organization (GNSO) deals with policy making on generic top-level domains (gTLDs); the Country Code Names Supporting Organization (ccNSO) deals with policy making on country-code top-level domains (ccTLDs); the Address Supporting Organization (ASO) deals with policy making on IP addresses. So yes, the State Of California has jurisdiction but no control. AFAIK California has no power to intervene in the internal affairs of any corporation if they keep the law and while this whole thing stinks, I doubt it broke any laws.
- wbl 7y agoSee also AHC stealing from Medicare to fight housing projects that would block the CEO's view.
- syshum 7y agoThere are several indications that there could have been laws broken. There is certainly enough for several agencies to start investigations over and at least block the sale until the investigations are completed
- chx 7y ago> There are several indications that there could have been laws broken which ones you think of
- ApolloFortyNine 7y agoI remember when this happened people were raving about how great it was that ICANN was no longer under U.S control. It's likely to only get worse, until an alternative DNS-like system arises.
- WorldMaker 7y agoThere was a very brief attempt by early ICANN to pretend like it was an internet user's organization and would respond to general votes from just about all users of the internet through representative proxies. Unfortunately that scheme seemed to have just been marketing and they very quickly dropped it. It bought a lot of nerd favor for the early ICANN, but yet they've never really fulfilled any of the original promises.
- DoctorOetker 7y agoWe need a NameCoin rewrite, preferably based on Algorand (for energy efficiency). And perhaps a rent-oriented namespace instead of a buying oriented one. If a sybil-free system can be erected, every host would be renting namespace from the public, as it is a burden for the public to have to memorize more complicated strings for their actual favourite sites.
- Legogris 7y agoWhat's your opinion on ENS? (https://ens.domains/ https://ens.domains/)
- DoctorOetker 7y agoethereum is based on Proof of Work, so can not be as efficient as consensus algorithms designed to not require PoW (like Algorand, which has the clearest mathematical / algoritmic underpinning / proof under a very strong attack model, if you know of others, I would certainly be interested)
- bitxbitxbitcoin 7y agoThe trilemna (trade off) between security, decentralization, and human-readability is known as Zooko's Triangle [1]. One Namecoin inspired blockchain project that has solved Zooko's Triangle is Handshake [2]. [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zooko%27s_triangle https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zooko%27s_triangle [2] https://handshake.org/ https://handshake.org/
- m12k 7y agoThis is one of those situations that really encapsulates the essence of IP for me: There is something virtual (the .org tld) that comes with legally enforced scarcity and a monopoly that governs it. And some guys realize that you can acquire this monopoly cheaply, and milk it for massive profit, at the expense of millions of people. It's not even like there's some investment that needs to be done, some new fancy tech around tld's that need to be funded - it's just a plain as day money-grab, rent-seeking in its most obvious form.
- swiley 7y agoMy understanding is that running resolvers at the kind of scale they need to handle attacks is actually difficult and expensive. The registries themselves are just a couple of machines with databases on them. Maintaining namespaces is just hard and the DNS, with groups of people running TLDs, is the best we’ve come up with so far. I personally thought namecoin was a creative alternative and I’m a little disappointed it hasn’t become more popular but until something like that does we’re going to continue seeing things like this.
- dmos62 7y ago> DNS, with groups of people running TLDs, is the best we’ve come up with so far. Is it? I'm not very familiar with the domain, so I'm actually asking. Generally, I'm very cautious when someone says that current state of affairs is the best we have come up with, because it doesn't acknowledge the inertia to keep things as they are.
- dangerface 7y agoNo, there are properly decentralised domain name projects like namecoin which uses blockchain to control ownership of domains and zone edits in a more secure way. There are a few other projects that decentralise domains and fix security issues, but our current federated system has become a heavily established billion dollar industry and the people in control of it have no incentive to give up that control. Any move to a new system will have to come from end users who don't know there are issues, and don't care enough to spend the effort understanding the issue and solution.
- et2o 7y agoLooking at the only two members of “Ethos Capital” (ironic name) 1) CEO: A Harvard MBA with typical PE experience 2) “Chief purpose officer” - Former SVP at ICANN responsible for corporate outreach. The structure of this stinks. I’d be not at all surprised to learn of some kind of back channel dealing. Edit: The former (2016) CEO of ICANN registered ethoscapital.com? After ICANN he went to the former PE firm of (1) above. He is certainly involved in this now, even if not named. Unbelievable. This heist was planned for years with money raised specifically for it. I can’t believe this is legal.
- bhickey 7y ago> I can’t believe this is legal. I doubt that it is. The directors of a non-profit can't wake up one morning and decided to pillage the org's resources for their benefit. They must transact their business at arm's length. Chehadé buys Donuts from Nevett, Nevett turns around and sells dot-org to Chehadé's PE firm. This looks like a kickback scheme. PIR is headquartered in Virginia, we should be calling and writing to the Attorney General there.
- bhickey 7y agoI spoke with the operator at the AG's office. This is regulated through the VA Dept of Agriculture and Consumer Services. I was instructed to file an ordinary consumer complaint with VDACS and it will get escalated as appropriate.
- nojvek 7y agoThank you for doing your part as a citizen. We can rage all we want on HN but you’re actually showing us how to make a difference by going through the proper channels.
- kelnos 7y agoAny idea how to do this? I googled "VA Dept of Agriculture and Consumer Services consumer complaint", which took me to https://www.oag.state.va.us/consumer-protection/index.php/file-a-complaint https://www.oag.state.va.us/consumer-protection/index.php/fi... -- but that looks like the AG's office.
- pojntfx 7y agoSeize the means of registration. Seriously, why on earth are the domain registries of the world not in the hands of the people? This stuff is far to important to be under the control of cooperations.
- input_sh 7y agoYou may want to look into OpenNIC, in which anyone with the know-how can operate a TLD. They have domains like .geek, .cyb, .null, .libre, .oss, and you use them by simply switching your DNS server to one of OpenNIC's mirrors. They also support TLDs for "emerging nations" like .ku for Kurdish people, .uu for Uigurs, .ti for Tibet. Though I'm not sure what would happen if ICANN decides to sell one of those domains one day.
- plange 7y agoAlready happened. OpenNIC had to move the users from .free over to .libre
- jandrese 7y ago> .uu for Uigurs, .ti for Tibet. Well, I guess mainland Chinese people won't be using this.
- DarthGhandi 7y agoMost of them live in a very different digital world anyway.
- pjc50 7y agoWhich people? There's no "world government" representing us, and having it annexed by the US isn't a great substitute.
- syshum 7y agoHaving the US Dept of Commerce over it is the least bad option right now though
- GrumpyNl 7y agoWhat can we do to stop this?
- tszyn 7y agoSign a letter to Internet Society here: https://savedotorg.org/ https://savedotorg.org/ Write to news outlets. If this blows up in the mainstream media, public pressure may be too high for them to go ahead with this deal.
- blackearl 7y agoThis comes across as alien language to the average person, I doubt the media finds it a juicy enough story to report on.
- rocqua 7y ago"Backroom deals at a organisation that used to be governed by the US will probably be used to extort wikipedia for $100000 to keep the address wikipedia.org. The same extortion will be aimed at unicef.org, (add list of common .orgs here)" That isn't alien language, and whilst not strictly true, it isn't stretching the truth more than the news already does habitually.
- bitxbitxbitcoin 7y agoThat isn't alien language and while it isn't strictly true, it captures the issue more sincerely than your typical clickbait. Nicely written.
- fanf2 7y agoI think The Register counts as part of “the media” https://www.theregister.co.uk/2019/11/20/org_registry_sale_shambles/ https://www.theregister.co.uk/2019/11/20/org_registry_sale_s...
- bitxbitxbitcoin 7y agoWe the internet absolutely need a decentralized way to manage internet names that replaces the centralized ICANN. That is the only way to avoid these types of corruption.
- CommieDetector 7y agoWorked in THE SOVIET UNION!
- JimWestergren 7y agoMy proposal: assign the management of the old core generic top-level domains to the United Nations. Raise the price to maybe $50 per domain. This will make domain hoarders/squatters unregister millions of domains. Use the money collected for the benefit of mankind (earmark the money).
- vegardx 7y agoThen you've effectively made it impossible for certain people to buy a domain name. And I wouldn't really trust that UN would be the best beneficiary of such money, it's bureaucratic hell.
- JimWestergren 7y agoPeople that cannot afford $50/year for a .com/.net/.org domain name can choose a cheaper tld. For some poor countries owning such a domain for your business would signal commitment - a good thing. Yes, UN is a bureaucratic hell but I see no other existing option.
- vegardx 7y agoWhy should these TLDs be exclusive for certain people, even more so if they're going to be managed by some kind of global entity? You see no other existing options because the premise is to raise the cost significantly and make it unavailable for most people. It clearly doens't have to be that way. And you don't solve anything by funneling that money into an extremely inefficient organization.
- JimWestergren 7y agoOk, well. What do you propose?
- vegardx 7y agoKeep the current system, as it seems to be working well. There are other ways to stop domain squatters, like not letting them abuse the registrar status to hold domains without paying for them.
- shahin841 7y agocertified ethical hackers for hire : https://www.hackerslist.co/ https://www.hackerslist.co/
- rch 7y agoIt seems like this presents an opportunity to establish a decentralized alternative registry, initially populated with .org domains acquired prior to some reasonable point in the past.
- tszyn 7y agoAlready in 2015, Emily Taylor warned [1] that ICANN could become the Internet's FIFA -- a small organization with great power that doesn't answer to any government. Here we are. A private company run by former ICANN people will be given the right to collect massive rent from a locked-in client base on a public resource. [1] https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2015/sep/21/icann-internet-us-government https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2015/sep/21/icann-int...
- C1sc0cat 7y agoIt was already obvious in the 2000's the analogy with FIFFA is a good one as its the some of the playbook ICANT are using holding meetings in out of the way places and leveraging small countries to maintain power. BTW I was a member of poptel who owned the .coop registry.
- scandox 7y agoFrom a linked source [1]: > Vint Cerf, former Chairman of the Board of ICANN and founding President of the Internet Society, said in a statement: “When the Internet Society won the bid to operate the .ORG registry, it enabled a productive and sustainable future for the organisation. Public Interest Registry exercised its stewardship to the benefit of the registrants and the Internet Society’s mission. I am looking forward to supporting Ethos Capital and PIR in any way I can as they continue to expand the utility of the .ORG top-level domain in creative and socially responsible ways.” And then an outline of what "expand" might mean in that context: > Going forward, PIR and Ethos Capital are planning to launch several new initiatives aimed at promoting and supporting the .ORG Community, including: Establishing a Stewardship Council that will serve to uphold PIR’s core founding values and provide support through a variety of community programs; Launching a Community Enablement Fund to support the financing of current and additional initiatives undertaken by key Internet organisations; and Expanding a program to award .ORG prizes to promote the success and positive impact of non-profit organisations. Which is surely the most transparent flimflam imaginable and which anybody in the business world would interpret as doing absolutely nothing at all. /s I can't wait to see the fabulous prizes /s... [1] http://www.domainpulse.com/2019/11/14/pir-eyeing-growth-ethos-capital-takeover/ http://www.domainpulse.com/2019/11/14/pir-eyeing-growth-etho...
- 0x0 7y agoWhat happened here? Did Vint Cerf become a villain?
- scandox 7y agoWell it's not about heroism or villainy. It's just imperfect humanity.
- nullc 7y agoThe Matrix called it. :) Jokes aside, this sort of stuff is complicated. Seen from Vint Cerf's position it might sound legitimate. Certainly some form of reorganization which might collect more funding for development and maintenance of the internet in the public interest wouldn't by itself be bad on its face. It wouldn't be the first time some up-in-the-clouds authority had too much trust in their friends and colleagues that what they were up-to was actually kosher and, as a result, carelessly dispensed with the required ritual corporate-speak niceties only to suffer embarrassment later. You should also keep in mind that any time you see someone quoted in a press release there is a very high chance that the press release author wrote the quote. It's the norm to suggest copy and pass it over for approval. Some people have their staff accept boring pap like that from friendly organizations without ever seeing it themselves. I personally never let someone write a quote for me and I found that this turned me into a nuisance... but lots of people do (presumably they don't like being nuisances!). I think they deserve what they get for it, but understanding what might have happened can make it more explicable if not more excusable.
- gorgoiler 7y agoIt doesn’t really matter how benevolent the intentions of Ethos Capital are, the control of a public commons like .ORG has to be held to the highest standards. With the amount of negative PR already generated by the proposed move, it’s hard to see a way forward for ICANN that is untainted. It is not at all unlike what is captured by the phrase: justice has to be seen to be done.
- feistypharit 7y agoI can just see the ethos capital whiteboard: 1. Dot org 2. Dot net 3. Dot com 4. The world! Dot org will only be the testing ground and only the beginning if they pull it off.
- SXX 7y agoDot com and net will be operated by Verisign at least until 2024 so it's unlikely to happen.
- jsjohnst 7y ago> at least until 2024 That’s barely over 4 years away.
- SXX 7y agoI guess after .org scandal it's will be much harder for ICANN to take control away from Verisign under guise of some anti-monopolistic practices. On other hand they already make tons of money from control of their domain zones and since they are public company they'll less likely try to pull of something ugly.
- foobiekr 7y agoIf they tried it tomorrow, yes. If they wait four years everyone will have forgotten.
- ohashi 7y agoVeriSign wants price caps removed like .ORG managed. They are salivating. Their fingerprints were all over removing price caps for .ORG. Those same lobbyists are still involved now at ICANN in the groups, subverting the public interest. I wrote about it originally here when I made a case for ICANN being captured: https://reviewsignal.com/blog/2019/06/24/the-case-for-regulatory-capture-at-icann/ https://reviewsignal.com/blog/2019/06/24/the-case-for-regula...
- jrochkind1 7y agoWhen you pay $1 billion to buy a 501-c-3... where does the money go? A non-profit has no owners/shareholders.
- bitcurious 7y agoTypically endowment, programmatic expenses, and operational overhead are the big three. You might also see a reserve (emergency) fund or a capital campaign. If you a interested, in the details of any given 501c3 look for the tax form “990”. It’s where the 501c3 report income, governance, and expenditure out to the IRS. Any nonprofit worth their salt will have a copy published on their website. They typically run 2, 3 years behind the calendar year, so right now expect 2017. Example 990: https://www.icann.org/en/system/files/files/icann-fy-2017-form-990-15may18-en.pdf https://www.icann.org/en/system/files/files/icann-fy-2017-fo...
- jrochkind1 7y agoIt's described in that article as "a deal to acquire the 501c3 non-profit" -- won't the 501c3 no longer exist independently after being acquired by a for-profit? So it won't have any endowments or capital campaigns, and won't file any 990s anymore. Googling in general, it seems that when 501-c-3's cease to exist, any assets they had end up being donated to some other existing 501c3, as decided by the 501c3 board. (I am sure some amount of bonuses to salaried staff can also happen, but probably not a significant proportion of a $1 billion acquisition price, without seeming illegal). $1 billion is a pretty big number. Still curious where $1 billion paid to acquire PIR will end up going. Obviously existing 990s for past fiscal years from PIR won't tell us that (even less so existing 990s from ICANN, which I don't think is involved in ownership of PIR or a party to the transaction at all?).
- fanf2 7y agoI believe the money is supposed to go to the Internet Society, which uses it to pay for things like the RFC Editor
- neurostimulant 7y ago
- capitalistpigs 7y agoYet again, capitalists ruin another public resource.
- microcolonel 7y agoThey made a private resource.
- sudosysgen 7y agoVery disputable. They haven't made the .org tld, it wasn't a private resource (read: private as in used to generate profit), they just captured it and turned it into private property.
- microcolonel 7y ago> private as in used to generate profit That's commercial, not private.
- sudosysgen 7y agoNope. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Private_property https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Private_property
- ajani 7y agoI don’t understand. Does this mean that my existing .org registration will likely become more expensive at any arbitrary rate, and I have to pay the high fees or lose it? How do I stop this from occurring?
- jobigoud 7y agoYou can start here https://savedotorg.org/ https://savedotorg.org/
- echelon 7y agoCan someone put together a competitive bid and turn `.org` itself into a non-profit corporation? That sounds like the way to go in order to protect `.org` in the future.
- fanf2 7y agoPIR, the owner of .org, is a non-profit corporation.
- jobigoud 7y agoI think that by being acquired and now having owners and stakeholders, PIR is no longer a non-profit corporation. Their own press-release state they will consider seeking B Corporation certification. https://thenew.org/the-internet-society-public-interest-registry-a-new-era-of-opportunity/ https://thenew.org/the-internet-society-public-interest-regi...
- andrewstuart 7y agoIt certainly appears .org has been "lifted". Maybe a broader look at corruption within ICANN is needed.
- ohashi 7y agoIt's been corrupt for a long time and beholden to registry interests. The fox is watching the hen house and they don't even hide it.
- zingola 7y agoWhat questions shall we ask at the IGF?
- zingola 7y agoWhat questions to ask at the Internet Governance Forum 2019 where the ICANN board is present?
- metasj 7y agoThis outcome is worse than any of the 'worst-case' scenarios hypothesized by the ICA when they filed their open letter of complaint in May when the price cap was listed. In hindsight, why would ICANN classify .org (with its enormous base and community) the way it does new TLDs? Would ICANN have any recourse if, after allowing this sale, the established registry dramatically raised prices?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- metasj 7y agoNice to see this much interest; sadly it's not clear what to do. Thanks bhickey for the pointers below to the VA AG and IRS. I'll try to keep that blog post up to date. Today: PIR posted an official response -- low on content, no additional redeeming tidbits. https://www.keypointsabout.org/ https://www.keypointsabout.org/ Tellingly, they do not once mention the word "endowment" or derisking [for ISOC]... which seemed like the one plausible argument in favor of this move: ISOC sacrificing the public registry for the rest of its mission.
- nikolay 7y agoICANN is the biggest legalized mafia today! The domainers (just like Bitcoin junkies) are the worst human material. When it comes to domains, imagine yourself not paying your phone bill on time, and in 30 days it goes on an auction and your competitors buys it and routes all calls to their sales team - that's what GoDaddy and most registrars do today employed by the crooks at ICANN! This has to stop! Don't just stop at .org, wipe out all the assholes at ICANN!