5 ms·
A fundamental assumption of mainstream economics is that market prices are approximately correct. This is more for pragmatic reasons than anything; you need som
by skybrian 7y ago
A fundamental assumption of mainstream economics is that market prices are approximately correct. This is more for pragmatic reasons than anything; you need some sort of prices to compare unlike things and it's often easy to get some consensus on what the market price is.
If you want to calculate GDP some other way then you will need to decide what millions of prices "should" be and persuade others with your argument. Coming up with an alternative scheme is probably the easy part. Agreeing on a new standard would be much harder.
Consider also that those millions of prices are also changing, often rapidly.
The problem is that, even within mainstream economics, we know market prices aren't correct. Pricing externalities is something pretty much all economists can get behind, and that's just the beginning. Does anyone really believe health care prices are correct? How about all the other subsidies? Asset prices for things like startups are even worse.
In areas where there are no market prices or the market is obviously artificial, price and value become nebulous. Without any objective standards of value, what things are worth becomes a matter of opinion and politics. I am pessimistic on there being consensus on a better way of understanding value any time soon.
More likely we will muddle through with patches to the system we have. Philosophically, even major changes like a carbon tax or universal basic income are basically just patches to get prices somewhere closer to what we think they should be.
- Nasrudith 7y agoI would say the assumption of correctness is a "if you are so smart why aren't you rich" sort of heuristic. Essentially if you knew that and that it was wrong then it would lead to massive arbitrage opportunities. Personally I believe that treating value in terms of "should" is asking the wrong question. The actual questions are chains. * What is the current production cost? Can we do better? * What does it cost to produce production if we can? How long does it take to get it producing? * Can anything substitute for it acceptably?
- skybrian 7y agoHaving the idea of doing arbitrage doesn't matter if you can't build a canal or railroad or pipeline to make it happen. It's only in financial markets where it might be realistic to pretend this is only a matter of being smart enough to come up with an idea. (Because they assume you have the money and that's the only thing you need.) Also, focusing on cost ignores markets where the marginal cost is nearly zero and price is set in other ways.
- crdoconnor 7y ago>Does anyone really believe health care prices are correct? Yes. Market clearing prices are set by the intersection of desire/need and scarcity. Health care prices can be virtually as high as you like if you can make health care scarce enough, because pretty much everybody wants to live. The greatest profits are usually found where scarcity meets desperation. This is also why most large corporations spend half of their time trying to tweak the desire side (advertising) and the scarcity side (market manipulation/intellectual property/contractual exclusivity/lobbying) in a bid to secure margins. De beers is probably the clearest example of success in these endeavours.
- WalterBright 7y ago> Health care prices can be virtually as high as you like if you can make health care scarce enough, because pretty much everybody wants to live. Everybody needs food, too, but food is as cheap as dirt.
- Red_Leaves_Flyy 7y agoThere's a lot more competition in the food market. Bananas too expensive? Just get oranges. Asthma meds too expensive? Take out a loan, drive to anthercountry, or roll the dice and maybe die.
- WalterBright 7y agoGovernment interference has severely limited competition in health care. For just one example, after Obamacare passed my health insurance provider decided to exit the business, and there is only one provider left in the county. They have a monopoly. I pay far higher premiums now, and can only go to "network" doctors.
- crdoconnor 7y agoThe whole idea behind Obamacare was that people like you would pay more so that others got coverage on pre existing conditions and HMOs could make a bit more profit.
- nixpulvis 7y agoIf my understanding of the math is correct, a carbon tax is somewhat more fundamentally meaningful than UBI vs other forms of welfare. A carbon tax is in a way trying to model a previously external factor in the market, i.e. the environment or earth itself.
- skybrian 7y agoRight, but there are no prices on an uninhabited planet. The prices placed on environmental changes is something humans decide on. It's a subjective, arbitrary number. It's good to avoid environmental degradation but the prices we use to do that are going to be arbitrarily set by government.
- AnthonyMouse 7y ago> If you want to calculate GDP some other way then you will need to decide what millions of prices "should" be and persuade others with your argument. It's a bit worse than that because cost, value and price are all different things. The amortized cost of making water available from the tap is pennies per gallon. The value of water is nigh infinite because without it you die. The price is presumably somewhere between those two values, but it could be anywhere -- an efficient water company might charge close to the cost but a robber baron with a hard monopoly on water might charge close to the value. The market only tells you the price, not the cost or the value. In a lot of cases it doesn't even tell you that. Consider what happens when a person spends time on a hobby. The cost is not zero, the value is not zero, and there is no price. Even more complicated, suppose the hobby is writing free software. Then there is no price (or it's zero, which isn't very informative) but you have value being derived by people all over the world, who may each value it in a different amount. > Philosophically, even major changes like a carbon tax or universal basic income are basically just patches to get prices somewhere closer to what we think they should be. A carbon tax is definitely about pricing an externality. A UBI is kind of the opposite. It's basically admitting that we don't know how to value everything correctly so instead of that here's the money, go choose what you need for yourself.