6 ms·
YouTube Premium is literally the service HN wants: honest payment to support a Google service costs and creators publishing on it. It's a sustainable service wh
by izacus 7y ago
YouTube Premium is literally the service HN wants: honest payment to support a Google service costs and creators publishing on it. It's a sustainable service which actually earns more for creators than ads and data mining (at least according to last CPC values I've seen for video ads).
And yet, it seems like the author of this piece still feels entitled to complain about being asked to pay the price of service and these comments are full of people advertising products that still use the service without paying the asking price. It's like demanding that music authors just send you MP3s for free without paying for it at all.
I personally hope that more companies allow me to pay for their services instead of being plagued by behavioural ad tracking.
- Kye 7y agoNo one asked for constant nag screens. edit: HN won't let me make any more replies. I don't know why people are fine with someone accusing me of entitlement with no basis, while me calling them out on it with a level of civility they did not deserve is out of bounds. I don't understand this place. This is ridiculous.
- izacus 7y agoYou're only getting them because you're not paying anything for the service. Why do you think your "ask" matters? Do you feel the same entitlement in other stores? When using Spotify? When visiting the movies?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- Kye 7y agoThis is not a good post. You should rethink it. Some suggestions: 1: Making assumptions will never go over well. Entitlement is an especially touchy one. The implicit assumption is that I use YouTube, or that I use it enough to justify the subscription price. Google is not owed my business any more than Spotify (which I don't use), the movie theater (same), or physical businesses with pushy sales people (this pushes me right out the door). 2: You asked four questions in rapid succession with further (wrong) assumptions. The term for this is sealioning. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sealioning https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sealioning Good luck with future posts!
- lordgrenville 7y agoI hadn't heard the term before, but after reading the page you quoted, that sounds like a mischaracterisation of your parent.
- saagarjha 7y agoBeing condescending and assuming bad faith isn’t a great look either.
- danShumway 7y agoSealioning is a bad-faith discussion strategy where someone inserts themselves into either a semi-private, self-contained, or narrowly focused public conversation insisting that the conversation stop until a speaker justifies every point they're making to an arbitrary degree that the sea lion chooses. It's considered bad-faith because even though sea lions act with civility, they're really trying to derail the overall conversation by preventing it from moving forward, or by forcing the speaker to apply a standard of rigor beyond what the current conversation requires. Sea lions selectively demand debate in inappropriate contexts, and demand that they be unconditionally given the intellectual and emotional energy to sustain that debate. It doesn't just mean, "someone disagreed with me and asked a question about something I consider settled." A Hackernews thread is an appropriate place for civil debate, especially in the context of GP responding to criticism you raised on their post. It's good for us to assume the best of critics in this context, and not to be skeptical of their motives.
- Kye 7y agoAccusing me of entitlement knowing nothing about me, the way I use YouTube, or what a good value proposition for it looks like to me is not civil. Civil questions wouldn't go off on tangents asking if I feel entitled to various things.
- dawnerd 7y agoNot entirely true, they have nag screens even when you subscribe.
- izacus 7y agoI'm not really receiving any for a long while. Is it a regional thing?
- danShumway 7y agoIt's the opposite for me. I've been paying for Youtube Premium since back when they were calling it Youtube Red, and the nag screens haven't gone away. When I'm signed in, Youtube still sticks up banners that remind me that I have exclusive content I don't care about. I still get reminders about all of the "cool" features I don't want. I still have to jump through hoops to archive content that I care about. I'm paying money for exactly 2 reasons: - I want to support creators. - I want to watch #%!@X videos without distractions. Youtube Red only helps me with the first point -- I can support creators, but it's even questionable there whether I'd be having a bigger impact by directly giving money on Patreon. In the meantime, I'm still paying money for Youtube Premium right now and I've gotten to the point where I don't use it, because the experience with an adblocker and proxies is better than the experience I pay for. At some point, when someone is paying money for a service and then going out of their way to avoid signing into their account or using the thing they pay for, you have to question whether the service is designed well.
- dawnerd 7y agoHey did you know you can get notified? Just hit that bell icon. Every single damn video if it’s not the YouTube app telling me it’s the creator, or both.
- dbuder 7y agoHow many years of human existence have been spent watching creators beg for likes, subscribes, clicking the bell, going to patreon every damn video.
- viraptor 7y ago> and the nag screens haven't gone away I'm also there since Youtube Red and I'm not sure what you mean. I've never seen a nag screen so far. I wonder if it's some bug, or some kind of targeting failure?
- rahidz 7y agoHi did you know YouTube Kids exists? Even if you don't have kids (I don't, and I'm sure Google's almighty tracking is well aware), but oh man here's another reminder! And while you're at it, I bet you really miss watching CNN and Fox! Why not check out YouTube TV! For "only" $49.99 a month! Don't forget to smash that subscribe bell so we can send you push notifications to consume even more of your attention!
- yborg 7y agoUnfortunately, you will pay and still get the behavioral ad tracking. There was a time when cable television's premise was "TV with no commercials!"
- amelius 7y agoBack in the old days, a telephone company listening in on conversations of their customers was a deadly sin. Perhaps we should just classify these big (e.g. >1M users) media companies as telecommunications companies (which they are), and let the law deal with them. This would also solve issues involving the network effect.
- icebraining 7y agoWhen using YouTube, who are you having a private conversation with? That model seems appropriate for messengers and such, but not really for the site under discussion here.
- wazoox 7y agoNo, it's literally the service a monopolist would naturally come to after it killed all competition. First, kill everyone in the field by offering a service for less than what it costs; once the field has been cleared, begin harassing people for their money. This is absolutely despicable. Break Google up, it's way past time.
- zamadatix 7y agoWhy can't we want to break up Google and fund creators without ads at the same time? Neither of these preclude the other.
- cptskippy 7y agoMost Creators aren't making money from YouTube, if they were then most wouldn't be on Patreon, have merch stores, or put ads in their videos. Pretty much every channel I subscribe to does one or all of those things. Many creators, AvE springs to mind, are pretty candid about how useless YouTube monetization is to anyone who isn't a PewDiePie with multimillions of subscribers.
- icebraining 7y agoSupposedly YouTube Premium viewers are much more profitable for video creators than regular ad-watching users.
- nemothekid 7y agoMost creators have other forms of income, because it's common sense to diversify your income when you can. For most YouTubers, they make most of their money from YouTube, and patreon, merch, and brand deals are just supplemental. Very few YouTubers actually do make most of their money from Patreon or Brand deals. Content more generally marketable, such as comedy, or content targeting a different demo (such a Makeup/Beauty) have a very different make up, but are still heavily ad driven, and this is the type of content that broadly makes up YouTube. AvE, and his type of content, is relatively niche, and it's unsurprising he makes most of his money from Patreon. Patreon, in general, skews heavily to audiences that have discretionary income and can afford to pay peicemeal to their favorite creators.
- zamadatix 7y agoI switched to YouTube Premium recently and the one downside is it largely only pays for the delivery. The actual creator content itself seems to be inundated with in video ads or promotions. For something that costs nearly the same as the Disney+, Hulu, and ESPN bundle it's a bit disappointing I can't purchase what I really want to purchase still. That being said it's a step in the right direction and that's the reason I decided to switch.
- cptskippy 7y ago> YouTube Premium is literally the service HN wants: honest payment to support a Google service costs and creators publishing on it Except that's not what it is. They've bundled Ad Free with YouTube Music and YouTube Originals, which I personally have no interest in. How much of that ridiculous price is going to the production of that original content and music licensing fees? $15 a month is a big ask when I see zero value in 2/3 of the offer. Bundling is what is driving cord cutting and piracy. People don't want to subsidize crap they don't want and didn't ask for. \* I would probably think differently if I was a YouTube Red or Music subscriber and they gave me access to Ad Free and Originals as bonus for my subscription fee but I'm not and don't want to be. Amazon Prime did something similar but by bundling Video and Music but I was already paying for Prime just for the free shipping so it was just extra.
- bestnameever 7y ago> Amazon Prime did something similar but by bundling Video and Music but I was already paying for Prime just for the free shipping so it was just extra. This is an interesting statement. Users are paying for Amazon Prime Video and Music one way or the other. I'd happily pay $79.00 instead of the current $120.00 a year for Amazon Prime without the Video and Music.
- cptskippy 7y agoMy usage of Prime has shifted pretty heavily. I no longer order much from Amazon however we watch as much Prime Video as we do Netflix and I use Prime Music regularly at home, work, and in one of our cars. I would pay $6 a month for either music or video so $120 a year is fine with me. The free shipping and discounts at Whole Foods are now the bonus.
- lonelappde 7y agoWhy do you care how they spend your fare? You should care if you are getting a fair value for your fare.
- cptskippy 7y ago
- blibble 7y agoif the app didn't constantly pop up modal dialogs trying to trick me into signing up for the trial I might have considered it however I refuse to reward that sort of dark pattern, and yesterday created a new google account for youtube and installed youtube vanced on my phone
- matheusmoreira 7y ago> It's like demanding that music authors just send you MP3s for free without paying for it at all. That's exactly what should happen. Creators need to figure out how to get paid before the work is created. They need to get paid for the work of creating, not for the end result which should be public domain. They should also publish a lossless FLAC instead of an MP3. > I personally hope that more companies allow me to pay for their services instead of being plagued by behavioural ad tracking. You are still being tracked. Also, the service isn't likely to remain free of ads. Cable TV was once ad-free but the opportunity to milk even more money out the audience was just too irresistible to pass up: https://www.nytimes.com/1981/07/26/arts/will-cable-tv-be-invaded-by-commercials.html https://www.nytimes.com/1981/07/26/arts/will-cable-tv-be-inv...
- CamelCaseName 7y ago>Creators need to figure out how to get paid before the work is created. They need to get paid for the work of creating This has downsides too. After all, what are those paying for the creation getting in return? I imagine creators, such as musicians, already get paid for the work of creating... In the form of embedded advertising. Listen to any top song and you'll be barraged by the names of luxury brands. Is this really the ideal world of music?
- Marsymars 7y agoYou could probably find people to make the argument that music went downhill after the end of the European patronage system.
- trashface 7y agoGoogle isn't going to stop tracking my every move and building/selling a secret advertising profile on me just because I pay them a monthly fee.
- on_and_off 7y agoThis is why I have been paying for this since a while ago when it was called .. youtube red or something ? This has has so many names that I lost count. Anyway, for the standard 10$ a month price, I get Play Music + Youtube without ads (while supporting creators and paying the platform for its infrastructure, unlike adblock). Play Music is an ok music streaming solution. It has all the features I expect from such a service + I can import (and export) my own albums. This is the killer feature for me. Getting Youtube without ads was just a cherry on top for me. At the time I was living in Europe where there were anyway not that many ads on Youtube. It is very valuable now that I live in the USA where there are ads everywhere. Now, all I want is : - for Google not to fuck this up. I fear that Youtube Music will be a disaster and that I will lose some of the features I care about in Play Music. The very long transition is giving me some hope that they have enough time to carry things over.. but I am not too optimistic. - I was going to write to remove tracking but I don't know how I feel about it. All the streaming services I know do track what you listen to in order to give you good suggestions and automixes. So that's pretty much a feature at this point and a way to discover new artists, although there is a tunnel effect in place. So as long as that info does not leave Youtube, I guess I am relatively fine with it until proven otherwise.
- Doxin 7y agoBack when I was deciding between spotify and youtube red (which included youtube music if I recall correctly) there was no way for me to give them my money, so I went with spotify. I haven't the foggiest if they allow reasonable non-creditcard payment these days, but they removed the automatically generated music playlist anyways so I'll stick with spotify as I can't be arsed to re-figure out how youtube works for half of my use cases. Protip for big multinationals trying to get international customers for their service: Not everyone has a credit card, or a desire to get one specifically to pay you. Provide alternative payment methods.
- TheCapeGreek 7y agoI don't know if I'm missing some important detail here (correct me if so), but just my experience in the web over the last decade: Any form asking for a credit card accepts debit cards. Same format anyway.