7 ms·
Let’s be honest. They aren’t building a company to take on Intel and AMD. They are at most “building a company” to either be an acquisition for one of the major
by scarface74 7y ago
Let’s be honest. They aren’t building a company to take on Intel and AMD. They are at most “building a company” to either be an acquisition for one of the major chip producers (maybe even Apple) or to be acquihired.
- tyingq 7y agoAmpere seems to be in the same space and shipping product. Why couldn't this company?
- scarface74 7y agoIt’s also only two years old and venture backed. Any venture backed company is by definition looking to have an exit strategy and not just trying to be a “lifestyle business”. Statistically, it’s via an acquisition. Look no further than YC - only two YC based companies have ever gone public.
- 1996 7y agoYC is not very successful in my measures of success. Profitable, yes, but all companies together = less than bitcoin Spawn companies, yes, but total number of public companies that IPOed = 2
- soup10 7y agoThis is an incredibly insightful post, YC companies are overhyped CRUD apps mostly. Meanwhile bitcoin and crypto has a a far larger market cap and is reshaping the entire economy. /s
- Kye 7y agoYour measure of success would make a lot of good companies look like failures.
- scarface74 7y agoSo what if we measure success by profitability? Neither Pagerduty nor Dropbox are profitable.
- Kye 7y agoI'm not a capitalist. Profitability is helpful under capitalism for survival, but it's a poor measure of anything other than whether one number is higher than another. YC funds a lot of companies who do cool things that aren't very profitable. I don't know what most of them do, and that's great. So many of them serve niches I haven't even heard of. If they break even making someone's life better, then they're a success. Imagine a world without Stripe or something like it. The current boom in membership services might not have happened. Even VC-juiced Patreon, which I use, handles payments through Stripe. How many successful companies by your measure glue their business together with companies that got their initial funding and guidance from YC?
- scarface74 7y agoSo exactly how do you run a business as an ongoing concern if you continuously lose more money than you make?
- Kye 7y agoThe answer is get bought by an ad-funded behemoth or a VC-funded behemoth or struggle to get by. I didn't say better measures of success were viable under this system. There's a reason I'm not a capitalist. Profit as the only measure of success is how we ended up in this hell world. You're welcome to only care about that, but I prefer to imagine and work toward better futures.
- scarface74 7y agoSo did you give up all worldly goods to live in a monastery and live on the charity of others or do you work for a company that seeks to make money?
- rvnx 7y agoThe thing is, YC is like a school for newbie entrepreneurs, it's not their role as a seed-fund, and you can't expect them to find you an exit. What they offer is to give you some money and tell you how to spend it. That's basically it, all the rest you are on your own, it's your company.
- 1996 7y agoIt is a bit like a social club - say the Lions club of SV. Socially it sounds important and people network and know the brand. But if you ask a random person in the street, they will know what crypto is, they may know dropbox if they are computer litterate, but they won't know YC unless they are a geek. And for those who want to be successful by creating their company, I have strong doubts. Profitable businesses are laughed at as "lifestyle business", and profitability itself is considered less important than network effects. In the end, I'm not surprised companies like wework are happening, where no sane person should invest a dollar. It's like the dot com boom again.
- tyingq 7y ago"It’s also only two years old and venture backed" Ampere is 3 years old, though PE and not VC backed.
- scarface74 7y agohttps://www.crunchbase.com/organization/ampere-computing https://www.crunchbase.com/organization/ampere-computing Private equity vs VC is a distinction without a difference as far as the investors motivations.
- suyash 7y agoDon't be a hater, exits can be of multiple types including IPO and that could very swell make this company become a formidable competitor to the big 3 Chip Makers.
- scarface74 7y agoIt’s not about being a “hater” in what world will this company be able to design better server chips than their much better financed competitors? Even Apple has a better chance of designing high performance desktop chips if they decide to move Macs to ARM and neither Amazon nor Google can be discounted. They both have a desire to produce better server chips in house for their own use. Come back in a year when this company is either acquired by one of the big tech companies or they go out of business.
- suyash 7y agoOk, so you're a pessimist.
- scarface74 7y agoI’m a realist. What is the percentage of startups that ever become public? Again, without doing too much research, just look at YC companies.
- jccalhoun 7y agogoogle's watch products have really been held back by lack of good chips for phones so I would not be surprised to see google following apple's lead to make their own chips. This looks like a very tempting buyout if that is the case.
- scarface74 7y agoWhy would Google care about how good chips for Android are? Google only cares about the Android ecosystem being good enough to deliver ads. Google doesn’t care about performance only ubiquity. Google doesn’t even care about operating system and security updates being delivered across their ecosystem. It’s estimated that Google only sells 3 or 4 millions Pixels a year. What’s the motivation for them to care about the watch market? Screens on watches are too small to display ads.
- CDSlice 7y agoOne motivation could be to have a competitor to the Apple watch for people that really want a good smartwatch to go with their phone. Right now there is nothing Android compatible that even comes close to the Apple watch. Having something comparable and Android exclusive could help with locking people into the Android ecosystem.
- scarface74 7y agoAgain, why does Google “want” anything that’s not going to generate significant profit? The average Android user isn’t willing to spend more than $300 on a phone (the average selling price of an Android). They definitely aren’t willing to spend $300-$500 on a watch. The high end Android market is minuscule. The whole Android hardware ecosystem is a profitless race to the bottom. I doubt Google “cares” if you use Android or not. If you use iOS you still get Google ads and you still probably at least watch Youtube.
- mrep 7y ago> Why would Google care about how good chips for Android are? Google only cares about the Android ecosystem being good enough to deliver ads. Considering Google paid Apple 12 billion dollars this year to be the default search engine on iOS [0], they have a very big incentive to build a high quality android phone to get iOS users to switch over. Those 3 or 4 million pixels could have been iOS users as I was one of those people last year when I decided to try out android again and the pixel was the first android I have ever used that didn't suck compared to my iphones (looking at you samsung galaxy s4). With apples draconian enforcement of what I can run on my iOS devices and set as defaults, I think I'll even stick to android unless it goes to shit or apple makes something radically better. [0]: https://fortune.com/2018/09/29/google-apple-safari-search-engine/ https://fortune.com/2018/09/29/google-apple-safari-search-en...
- leoh 7y agoYikes, this is incredibly cynical.
- scarface74 7y agoIt’s not cynical it’s the truth. Why else do you think investors give money to startups?
- leoh 7y agoIt's possible that the end goal is acquisition or an aquihire-like situation. Even if that's the goal, it could be pretty cool — they may get to the point where they build a team that can execute and build chips with different design goals in mind, adding diversity of ideas to the industry. How cool is it to be part of a team that is capable of building their own chips? Your tone ("building a company"), however, suggests that something useless is occurring here, that they are just playing house as opposed to creating value. That's the part that feels like coded cynicism.
- scarface74 7y agoNo. I’m saying it’s naive to think that it is their investors intention of building a business that takes on the big chip makers. That seems to be thought in many of the comments. After seeing Apple design processors that are performance competitive with Intel except on the very high end and they will probably make better modem chips than Intel could by acquiring PA Semi and the remnants of Exponential Technology and seeing Amazon design custom server and embedded chips for its own use, I think we are seeing a renaissance in chip design we haven’t seen since the 80s and 90s. Microsoft and Google are also dipping their toes in custom designed chips.
- leoh 7y agoThat's fair. I can see why you felt that way. The headline of the article did imply that the founders were going after Intel/AMD, when in fact the likely outcome is more modest in scope.
- sneak 7y agoremember: corporations are abstractions, they aren’t real. human beings are going to do the work and be paid for it, corporations are simply a useful model for how we allocate the profits. there’s nothing wrong or fake about building a company and a product to take on more risk/freedom with the intent of selling it to someone for whom it would be valuable later. it also probably pays a lot better, considering the increased risk of failure and better negotiating position if you invent and produce something truly groundbreaking. this is how silicon valley has worked for decades.
- scarface74 7y agoI’m not saying it’s “wrong”, rather it’s naive to think that they will create a “competitor” to one of the major chip makers/designers or that it is the desire of their investors. Notice I didn’t say whether it was their desire. What they want is inconsequential once you take investor money.
- sneak 7y agoIf it’s not viably competitive against either a potential acquirer’s business or that of their competitors, why pay money for it?
- scarface74 7y agoIt doesn’t have to be viable “against” anyone. Amazon for instance is designing its own custom ARM chips for both servers and their network cards. They could potentially buy them. Exponential Technology for instance was designing PowerPC chips that were faster than Motorola or IBMs. After Apple got rid of the clone market, they closed down the business and started another one. In 2010, Apple acquired them to help design their custom Arm chips.
- myrandomcomment 7y agoBuilding a company to sell is a very bad thing to do. There is no guaranty it will even happen. You should always build a company with the idea that you will go public as doing so forces discipline in how you do things (there are a ton of internal processes, accounting, etc.). Having that work done and clean makes you more attractive to someone that would want to acquire the company and also gives you a better negotiating position. In an ideal world, you build it to go public and are at a point where you are starting the paperwork, and someone makes an offer which you can then shop to their biggest competitor in the space. A bidding war starts and you are sold for IPO price++++, a number that is 12 months down the road from where you think you would be after the IPO. You have just made a ton, and removed a years worth of risk.
- freedomben 7y ago> Building a company to sell is a very bad thing to do. This is considered a very viable exit strategy. Sure you want to have a plan B in case nobody will acquire you, but I've known several companies that plan A was to get acquired. It didn't work out for every one but it does work sometimes. It really depends on your industry and your ability to make yourself attractive to the buyers.
- adventured 7y agoBuild to be acquired has been not uncommon in the semiconductor and network gear spaces in particular over the last two decades. Intel, Cisco, nVidia, AMD, Qualcomm and a dozen other companies are always happy to scoop up new IP for their castles. Just Intel and Cisco together have $37 billion in annual operating income burning a hole in their pockets. Teams that can flip new semi or network IP, are like medtech inventors that routinely do exactly the same thing in that space. It's very difficult, requires particularly specialized industry insider knowledge and the industries are filled with very large, rich corporations happy to overpay to ensure their positions.
- myrandomcomment 7y agoIt is a viable exit strategy as a backup for sure. I would question anyone that I spoke with that came to me with my only plan is for a FANG, et.al. to acquire us, unless they came from of of those companies, left on good relations and was trying to solve a problem that is import but not so important that they would want to do it themself. It also helps if you can be sure that what you are working on is wanted by 2 of the major companies that would be interested in you.
- uoylj 7y agoSeems like a very General Magic style story.. I'm sure apple will acquihire them back if successful.
- asveikau 7y agoIn support of your comment, I don't know much about this space but I would imagine the realities of manufacturing a CPU would make it prohibitively expensive for new entrants and highly amenable to big players buying up anyone with new ideas.
- OnlineGladiator 7y agoAs much as I agree with you, people said the same thing about Tesla. In other words it may be an uphill battle, but every conglomerate was once a startup.
- scarface74 7y agoTesla is turning a profit now every now and then but they also said that they expect to start having losses consistently going forward as they ramp up manufacturing.
- OnlineGladiator 7y agoTesla has really only ever turned a profit through financial engineering, which is why it's never consistent. Tesla still has a long, long way to go before they don't need to keep raising capital to stay alive. > expect to start having losses consistently This is a very rosy view of Tesla. Tesla has always had losses consistently and will continue to do so for years. They are $13 billion in debt with only $4 billion cash, and a not insignificant amount of their cash is from full self-driving preorders they are still obligated to fulfill. My money is still on Tesla going bankrupt.
- fulafel 7y agoPA Semi did it. (And for other kinds of chips besides general purpose CPUs, fabless startups have been common for a long time)
- scarface74 7y agoThey were a fabless semiconductor company and they were bought by Apple in 2008. That kind of proves my point....
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]