11 ms·
Some further background on what happened. I don't see how this can be interpreted as anything other than corruption, plain and simple. https://www.theregister.
by walrus01 7y ago
Some further background on what happened. I don't see how this can be interpreted as anything other than corruption, plain and simple.
https://www.theregister.co.uk/2019/11/20/org_registry_sale_shambles/ https://www.theregister.co.uk/2019/11/20/org_registry_sale_s...
"Former ICANN CEO Fadi Chehade personally registered the domain name currently used by Ethos Capital in May and it was registered as a limited company in the US state of Delaware on May 14. That date is significant because it is one day after ICANN indicated it was planning to approve the lifting of price caps through its public comment summary.
As such it appears that the plan to purchase the .org registry was predicated on the price caps going ahead and that those behind the deal had intricate knowledge of ICANN’s internal processes."
- mehhh 7y agoThe whole deal smells of self dealing, why was Ethos Capital selected to buy the .org registry versus an open bidding process?
- tldmanagement 7y agoPosting from a throwaway account. I worked at one of the main TLDs for years and was on one of the ICANN boards and got to know the industry well. It is well know amongst the domain name community that ICANN is a poorly run organization, whose directors have in recent years have used their position of leadership to lead decisions from which they are afterwards benefiting themselves economically, in many cases by rushing decisions such as in these case. Peter Dengate Thrush was famous for pushing for the new domain extensions (.anything) as chief executive of ICANN and quitting a month later to become the CEO for a company that was the main bidder for a large number of extensions. Fadi Chehade is doing the same with .ORG by lifting the price cap on the prices of an established domain name and then gobbling up the company that sells those domains. Sadly, ICANN has little oversight and since its kind of in the air and doesn’t report to anyone, the directors get away with what would be legally considered corruption in most of the world. The fact that the internet community and most Internet companies have never care about it makes doesn’t help, since a lot or times the “multistakeholder” model that they claim to use in reality doesn’t work. Ultimately, this is why the DNS and domain name industry feels so shady in general and why for most companies getting a name on the internet is a tortuous process that feels very scammy, which is unfair and costs more than it probably should. But so far we don’t have any good alternatives to the current system.
- sytelus 7y agoICANN having little oversights is not an accident. It’s corrupt current and past leaders have ensured that. This organization is supposed to be non-profit international organization. If you ask me “who controls Internet”? it’s these guys. They have managed to convert ICANN into a perpetual personal wealth fund for friends and families.
- nieve 7y agoThe writing was on the wall when the board decided they weren't getting what they wanted from the at-large constituency & direct elections and shut them down, in doing so completely blowing off the Memorandum of Understanding. It's a bit surprising that it's taken so long to hit .org directly, it's a really obvious target if you want to find ways to turn an ICANN position into cash. Full disclosure, I was one of those at-large members and they made it very clear that we weren't being good little peons.
- marvin 7y agoTo me, this seems like a good case for government intervention. Domain names are critical infrastructure at this point.
- nsomaru 7y agoWhich government? Critical to whom?
- cnorthwood 7y agoIt possibly fits within the portfolio of the ITU (although I guess the UN is intergovernmental, rather than a government).
- C14L 7y agoThat has been proposed for as long as I can remember. The result would be that dictatorships and authoritarian governments control the internet, because they make up the majority in the ITU. I don't think we want that.
- unethical_ban 7y agoIf we in the United States had a forceful, competent FTC or FCC, perhaps this would be investigated. I don't think a Sanders or Warren administration would ignore something like this entirely.
- madaxe_again 7y agoThe SEC are both competent and forceful, and this smacks of self-dealing, which is within their remit.
- jeremyjh 7y agoICANN is a "non-profit". They do not issue a publicly traded security, and so they are not subject to the SEC's jurisdiction. The FTC is probably the best hope for intervention in a matter like this.
- yumraj 7y agoI think all this information should be added to Fadi's Wikipedia page [0] so that people can be made aware of it. That is one good way to bring corruption into light. [0] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fadi_Chehad%C3%A9 https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fadi_Chehad%C3%A9
- classified 7y ago> ... corruption, plain and simple. That's right but the right to get rich by corruption is the most important and most appreciated unalienable entitlement of US weenies, even more important than food or shelter or life itself. After all, in a thoroughly corrupt system all of those can be bought. Only corruption itself cannot be bought if the system doesn't already have the necessary level of corruption. It is the US's holiest mission to convince the rest of the world of the fundamental importance and indispensability of our way of corruption.