10 ms·
The violence paradox: Is violence actually declining?
- simonblack 7y agoThe world goes through cycles of peace and violence. We are due for the next cycle of violence to rival WW2, if not even more so. We have forgotten and are unable to imagine when more than a hundred thousand are killed in a single day. But those days will come again and very soon. The next war will be (pretty much) the West against the Rest. The whole of the West has a smaller population and less manufacturing capacity than China alone.
- sideshowb 7y agoUnless both sides find trade more profitable. I think it's more likely the next big war will be fought over fresh water.
- arethuza 7y ago"The world at the beginning of the 20th century seemed for most of its inhabitants stable and relatively benign. Globalizing, booming economies married to technological breakthroughs seemed to promise a better world for most people." From the description of Niall Ferguson's The War of the World.
- gumby 7y ago> The next war will be (pretty much) the West against the Rest Because all the countries of the West think alike and because everyone who isn’t thinks alike? This sounds like those politicians who ask “but what do the minorities want?”
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- throwaway1777 7y agoPredictions with no data or reasoning to back them up are worthless, especially when there’s no skin in the game.
- Scapeghost 7y agoIf you haven't noticed by now, the world is a plutocracy/oligarchy. It hasn't been about nations for a long time, but the rich and powerful people who influence them. Many of them aren't even elected officials. See Trump and Russia, Saudi Arabia and Khashoggi, the American citizens beaten up by Erdogan's bodyguards on American soil, the UAE and Sheikha Latifa, American corporations kowtowing to China, the US ambassador's wife who got away with murdering a UK teen, Jeffrey Epstein and his private island of underage prostitution for the cream of society's crop, and the many other cases where the personal whims of the elite few override sovereign laws. Those people literally have access to everything that human civilization has to offer, and they're not going to ruin their playground.
- Mirioron 7y agoHasn't it always been like this though? At least nowadays they don't claim to just be better humans (nobility).
- Scapeghost 7y agoIndeed, the ruling class never stopped ruling. But this is the first time in human history, when they can go anywhere, do anything, to anyone, at anytime, without having to worry about national borders etc. Money is the universal differentiator now, and anybody of any nation or race can have it. Until you piss off someone else who also has money, then connections come into play, then the might of arms.
- charlesism 7y agoThis comment seems strained. A history book would neither back up the claim about unfettered travel, nor the claim about corruption. The parent comment actually seems reasonable to me. It really wouldn’t take much escalation for a trade war to turn into a shooting war between, at least China and America.
- Scapeghost 7y ago> A history book would neither back up the claim about unfettered travel, nor the claim about corruption. I don't think any ruler would have been able to easily hop to another continent on a whim for an orgy with a wide selection of sex slaves and be back home by next dawn, before the advent of instantaneous communications and jet planes. The point was that the people who command nations have access to a previously unprecedented level of luxury which would be ruined if the world wasn't largely at peace.
- adventured 7y ago> The whole of the West has a smaller population and less manufacturing capacity than China alone. The US + Germany have a larger combined manufacturing capacity than China does, in a population about 30% that of China. With the population gap you can then throw in France, Britain, Italy, Spain, Mexico, Canada and far exceed the manufacturing capacity of China (which has about 20%-22% of global manufacturing output and declining as a share).
- forgetfulusr 7y agoThis sounds like FUD, and the more people believe it the closer it comes to being realized. It has been increasing lately. Some great times to push for new rules/censorship for the internet in the name of safety I assume.
- Melting_Harps 7y agoOr maybe you guys in the Valley could stop offering your labour to FAANG, who then sell that information for profit to Intelligence agencies and go back to the cypherpunk and cryptoanarchist roots of the Valley and help create an alternative? The recent episode of Silicon Valley was so typical of my short stay there of the collective mindset (#Tethics) in the Valley, which was just a summer; my family is actually from San Jose (multi-generational), but they have since divested and left to the South (where I'm from) for good because of the BS politics and police state that emerged from what was once a really awesome culture in the late 60-80s and less so but still decent mid to late 90s. I personally moved to Boulder and rode a decent wave, but to be honest with Google coming here and a lot of its cohort following in masse with the large campus it feels about the same now.
- noirchen 7y agoNylonkong are getting more attention with Trump, Brexit, and the protests. When was the last time you read an in-depth news about some under represented region, say, Nigeria? For a country experiencing population boom and worsening internal conflicts, 200 million people there ARE going to fight for fresh water and other resources if the rest of world just sit there and do nothing.
- nootropicat 7y agoWhat is 'the rest of the world' supposed to do? It's not like they don't have access to internet or condoms (even free), not in 2019. It's a (collective) choice. See [1]. It's about Niger (same largest ethnic group - Hausa[2]), which is also experiencing a population explosion, but the principle appears to be the same: >“I just pray to God to bless those three babies I have,” she says. The local health centre in her village of Darey Maliki offered her free contraception, which they get partly from the NGO Pathfinder, but Hamani declined. “Maybe [my in-laws] would tell my husband to marry another woman to have more babies,” she says. “If they want me to have another pregnancy, I can do it just for them to feel happy.” Perhaps that culture changes in the future generations, but for now Subsaharan Africa is on track for 2B+ in 2050, and nothing short of starvation or violence can change that. [1] https://www.theguardian.com/global-development-professionals-network/2017/mar/15/why-have-four-children-when-you-could-have-seven-contraception-niger https://www.theguardian.com/global-development-professionals... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hausa_people https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hausa_people
- fungicide 7y agoWhere infant mortality is high, humans tend to have more children.
- aaron695 7y ago> Is violence actually declining? We know it is. Not in question at all. But we don't know for sure if war is declining since it's overwhelmed in large spikes. Good doco. I liked the theory good manners is one possible reason. It's cute but actually makes sense, although not a huge fan of the it works part of the brain more. I'd go with a lot of violence is embarrassing and we are taught embarrassing is bad. Sit up straight, use a knife and fork and don't hurt people.
- fithisux 7y agoViolence is changing by getting a more peaceful face in order to be "legalized" and "digested". Violence is always here and it gets stronger.
- ekianjo 7y agoWhat do you mean?
- throw_m239339 7y agoI don't know what the parent means however isn't it true that some cities in the US stopped prosecuting some crimes deemed "petty" such as theft, "hard drugs" dealing, … Which would make crime statistics lower than they really are.
- ekianjo 7y agoI think "under reporting crime" is not something very recent. But something that is usually not under-reported, is violent crimes like murder or assault resulting in severe injuries, because someone ends up at the morgue or in the hospital where they are definitely tracked and recorded. As far as I know this is where we are pretty much sure violence is decreasing over time.
- fithisux 7y agoI mean here in Greece violence is in the workplace (you can be fired just because) in the shops (they change prices just because) in the government (takes anti social measures just because) in the people relations (people play the emotional abuse game because law has not caught up) and the decline of our civilization is a result of the increase in violence. It just takes a peaceful face because the vast majority would like to have an opportunity to exercise their dark side but would like to play safe. So the silently agree what kind of violence is acceptable or not. Violence is not acceptable in any of its forms.
- lazyjones 7y agoViolence as a contagious disease is a concept that isn't going to fare well in certain circles (of proponents of open borders, migration etc.). More research should be done in this area, if possible.
- pjc50 7y agoA border is a structure that requires violence to maintain.
- lazyjones 7y agoIt requires violence on behalf of the authorities sometimes to keep violent intruders out, just like it's required to catch criminals or deflect a hostile army's attack. That doesn't make it bad. In practice, authorities exert no violence at borders e.g. in most European countries, even the threat of violent action is very low nowadays - that's why they are easily overrun.
- pjc50 7y ago"Overrun" is a very extreme word to use here? Are you trying to suggest "invasion"? > violent intruders Very few of the people crossing the border are themselves "violent".
- lazyjones 7y ago> "Overrun" is a very extreme word to use here? Are you trying to suggest "invasion"? It's an appropriate word for what happened at several borders, fences that were erected were torn down violently and hundreds of people ran over them. What word would you rather use? https://www.srf.ch/news/international/fluechtlinge-stuermen-zaun-an-griechisch-mazedonischer-grenze https://www.srf.ch/news/international/fluechtlinge-stuermen-... (this is from a failed attempt)
- michaelt 7y agoSpeaking as a third-party reader, when you assert that borders require violence to maintain, then you disagree with lazyjones saying there are sometimes violent intruders, it leaves me confused about what argument you're trying to make?
- rustybolt 7y agoHere in the Netherlands, crime statistics are declining, but many people suspect that the real reason is that the police often refuses to register declarations (or advises against filing declarations).
- shellac 7y agoDoes the Netherlands not have the equivalent of https://crimesurvey.co.uk/ https://crimesurvey.co.uk/?
- the-dude 7y agoNo. There are only statistics originating from the police force.
- Doxin 7y agoI bet the dutch central office of statistics keeps track of it. But then if you don't trust the one government body why should you trust another? Personally I trust the dutch police force and in fact admire them greatly. They handle dangerous and stressful situations much better than I personally ever could. That said I do see why you'd be mistrustful as average citizen, the most you'll have to do with police is reporting crimes such as broken windows or stolen bikes, in which case you'll probably get a shrug and a "we'll look into it" at most. The police force is currently very well trained and adequately supplied, but as is the story in many places budget cuts are being made all over and I worry for the future. In any case an independent research office looking into the crime stats wouldn't be a bad thing, but I suspect it's a rather tricky thing to gauge in the first place.
- Spoppys 7y agoThe Crime Survey for England & Wales isn't a government body. A third way crime rates are independently checked in the UK, is hospital admissions statistics for shootings and stabbings.
- the-dude 7y agoPolice stations are closed en masse. Police has been in reorganisation since forever. Personnel is over-extended to the point they are contemplating strikes.
- pjc50 7y agoThis is long, and I suspect most of us have neither watched it nor read all the transcript; but from the parts of the transcript I have skimmed it seems to hit absolutely all the areas I would expect it to cover. Everything from evolutionary biology to memetics through colonialism, inequality, the epidemiology model for interventions, sports across cultural divides. I suspect most sentences are themselves summaries of a stack of investigations. Stephen Pinker may get some flak for being a pop-science writer but this seems extremely thorough. It would be nice not to use this article as a platform for exercising our pre-existing prejudices.
- arctangent 7y agoI can't view the video but since Pinker is mentioned in other comments I assume it is a summary of this (not yet read) book on my bookshelf: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Better_Angels_of_Our_Nature https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Better_Angels_of_Our_Natur...
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]