18 ms·
Music is universal and used in strikingly similar ways across the globe: study
- dang 7y agoWe changed the URL from https://science.sciencemag.org/content/366/6468/eaax0868 https://science.sciencemag.org/content/366/6468/eaax0868 to what appears to be the leading popular article on the topic. https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&query=by%3Adang%20%22popular%20article%22&sort=byDate&type=comment https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&que...
- dr_dshiv 7y agoOh, thanks for linking in the original article. It has excellent illustrations and unfortunately the DOI link in the Newsweek article is non-functional. I wish that press coverage of science could at least post a proper academic reference at the end.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- dr_dshiv 7y agoThey found common functions for music around the world: love songs, lullabies, dance music and.... Sound healing? Wow, that's an interesting perspective. Their methods were great, in showing that the functional intent of music could be reliably determined by people around the world.
- username90 7y agoPeople often say things like "This culture doesn't have a word for that color, how strange is that?", but isn't it stranger that basically every culture has so many similarities, like words for the same very abstract things like love, marriage, colors, emotions and so on? Especially if you look at the typical persons of societies instead of the upper classes. I believe many greatly underestimate how much our culture is rooted in our genes, I see no other reason why human societies has so much in common.
- TazeTSchnitzel 7y ago“Mama” and “papa” are interesting words, because some variation on those, with the same meaning, exist in almost every language. Does this mean every language borrowed them from some common ancestor? No, not quite. It's just that newborn children make babbling sounds that resemble speech, with a very limited range of “consonsants”, and humans are such narcissists that they assume those babblings refer to them, the parents :)
- nonsapreiche 7y agothat reminds me the lecture of Bernstein (The unanswered Question) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8fHi36dvTdE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8fHi36dvTdE
- pntnp 7y ago> and humans are such narcissists that they assume those babblings refer to them, the parents :) Or mama, papa, appa, amma, etc are the easiest words for infants/toddlers to pronounce and hence we used these word for children to call attention to the two most important people for their survival? Is it narcissism or the fact that infants/toddlers cannot even pronounce most vowels/consonants other than a, m, b/p?
- TazeTSchnitzel 7y agoYou're assigning meaning onto young infants' babblings that isn't there. They're not words.
- 1996 7y agoPeople like to insist on differences. I prefer to insist on commonalities. We are all human, the same race living on the same planet, with minor variations in customs that add salt to life.
- shrimp_emoji 7y agoPeople like to insist on commonalities. I prefer to insist on differences. If the salt includes prison camps and religious insanity, I'll have low sodium please.
- atoav 7y agoMy theory is that this is due to the natural series of harmonics — sound tells you a ton about any physical object that emits it — so any oranism that lives in a sound transmitting medium profits from interpreting it and dividing it into different emotional responses. This is why a deep bass hit can feel dangerous, or exciting while a scraping metal sound can feel plainly wrong, because there is no harmony at all and this isn’t how anything is meant to sound at all. So depending on what is dangerous or useful to a species it should develop different preferences.
- dr_dshiv 7y agoAlso, more harmonics, more efficient sound production. And human voices are very harmonical. Sexual selection is likely responsible for that. What I find strange, though, is why animals don't appreciate music (or almost never). You can't even train pigeons, nice or apes to tap to the beat.
- cma 7y agohttps://www.newscientist.com/article/dn26694-humans-and-birds-share-the-same-singing-genes/ https://www.newscientist.com/article/dn26694-humans-and-bird...
- Jamwinner 7y agoConsiciousness. I know its in vouge to pretend animals are all reasoning creatures, but alas the world is, thankfully, not disney. Our ability to relate 'Now', with our perception of stimulus moments ago, is how we percieve music. This is mostly absent in animals, or has a vastly different temporal range. Even pure tones are just cycles per second. That said, if you ignore the meter, most animals seem to react to various harmonic and aharmonic sounds. Dogs howling, birds whistling, etc. The timings seem quite specific to the creature, and their adapted envirnment.
- fenwick67 7y agoLots of parrots love music.
- mrob 7y ago
- mrlala 7y agoI took a music class in university in which the entire focus of the class is that music is NOT universal. This was a while back so details I remember are sparse.. but he had tons of examples from around the world where what we might consider "happy" or "sad" was entirely different in many cultures. Granted, it's probably still more true than not to say "for the most part music is universal", I don't think it holds as a simple factual statement.
- Sharlin 7y agoWell, seems to me that music is universal the way language is universal. The idea and basic patterns are pretty much the same, but details vary quite a bit.
- Gene_Parmesan 7y agoI think this study refers more to the ways music is used in societies throughout our species -- e.g., songs for grieving, praying, marriage, love, etc. -- moreso than the specifics of the structure of the music in and of itself. The statement "music is universal" does not mean "all music shares the same mapping between tones and emotions," but instead simply that the use of music has similar functions throughout the globe.
- _red 7y agoNot really. Western music is driven by harmonic progression, which is largely absent in most other cultures. The lack of "chord changes" is why its so easy to discern western vs eastern music.
- ic147 7y agoI think the word "tonality" is used liberally in this article. They didn't seem to be referencing any specific style of harmony, but rather the general act of using distinct tones to create music.
- anigbrowl 7y agoEqual temperament is a relatively recent (hundreds of years) development in Western civilization and arguably originated in China. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Equal_temperament#History https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Equal_temperament#History Harmonic progression is a staple of Western classical and pop styles, but most folk music is diatonic (confined to a single scale), not least because of the limitations of wind instruments. Diatonic music and harmony has seen a major resurgence with the advent of electronic dance music, which subordinates harmonic progression to rhythmic and timbral development so as to stay 'in the groove' by maintaining a particular musical mood.
- dr_dshiv 7y agoMy reading of the Wikipedia is that equal temperament didn't originate in China (though it may have slightly predated the occurrance in the west). Rather, it was a synchronicity -- it occurred at the same time in the west (1584 and 1585), like Leibniz and Newton coinventing calculus independently or Darwin and Wallace inventing survival of the fittest.
- hesk 7y agoMy pet theory is that music is so universal because it hijacks two systems in the human brain that are necessary for survival. First, humans are a social species and use language to communicate. Babies learn language by observing and emulating their parents. So it makes sense that humans evolved a rewards pathway that makes it pleasurable to listen to sounds. Second, the brain is basically a pattern matching and prediction machine. Music is full of patterns, e.g., rhythm and harmonics. That's why music is so popular -- because it allows the brain to do something which it is very good at and which it also finds pleasurable.
- pygy_ 7y agoMy pet theory (which complements yours) is that it was, before the invention of writing, part of the mnemonic techniques used to perpetuate vital information. Other worthy mentions are story-telling/acting, poetry (rhyme and meter) and painting. Being innately predisposed to like these disciplines makes one more likely to practice them, become good at them, and help propagate useful info undamaged, thus rising the group's survival abilities. They were vital for so long (compared to the few millennia since we invented writing) that we still have the taste baked in, even though writing, then the press then computers and photographs took over those roles. Rhymes and meter are the CRC32 check of prehistory.
- jvanderbot 7y agoI was hoping to add an original thought to this thread, but you nailed 80% of my point. The remaining 20% is that music allows "chunking"[1] complex knowledge into a single song that's easy to remember. 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chunking_(psychology) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chunking_(psychology)
- nitwit005 7y agoI wouldn't assume it's a positive trait. People take pleasure out of things like optical illusions, which are arguably defects in human vision. There is a 3-5% rate of people who don't enjoy music, and it at least doesn't obviously handicap them: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Musical_anhedonia https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Musical_anhedonia
- dr_dshiv 7y agoMusic is strikingly tonal, cross culturally. There are different scales, but tonality is universal (across cultures, although cultures can have non tonal songs), likely due to the biological-physical nature of harmony.
- laretluval 7y agoScales are universal, but the distinction between harmony and dissonance is not. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/27409816 https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/27409816
- dr_dshiv 7y agoYeah, I'm skeptical of that paper and it is extremely difficult to disprove, because access to that population is so restricted. The way I'd test it would be presenting a set of 2 tones and giving them control over a third. like 200hz +300hz and then letting them move a slider between 325-425hz. Where do they find the resulting sound most pleasant and where most unpleasant? The sensation of dissonance is so strong and visceral, it is extremely hard to believe it has no universality to it.
- fidla 7y agoAt Hampshire College, I studied ethnomusicology and did a thesis called Universal's in Music, coming to the same conclusion. This was 1983.
- Simon_says 7y agoUniversal’s what?
- Kye 7y agoI think they made a typo and meant Universals as in ubiquitous features of music across cultures.
- justanothersys 7y agoI highly recommend "Noise: The Political Economy of Music" - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Noise:_The_Political_Economy_of_Music https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Noise:_The_Political_Economy_o...
- ken 7y agoI can't tell what exactly they mean by "strikingly similar". The only concrete similarity I see mentioned is that "tonality is used". This sounds like the Joseph Campbell school of finding similarities. If you squint hard enough, everything looks the same.
- lngnmn 7y agoBird songs and natural sounds of nature. There is no accident that classic music and classic Jazz began with "ornithology".