8 ms·
Light pollution is key 'bringer of insect apocalypse'
- maelito 7y agoParis' emblematic Place de la Nation was just rethought, with several car lanes removed, larger green and pedestrian areas, and relevant to this article, no lights. As far as I know, it's now one of the darkest places of Paris, I hope it's on purpose.
- nine_k 7y agoIs it safe at night for humans?
- serpix 7y agoYes. Lack of light is perfectly safe for humans although we tend to get a little depressed with pro longed periods of darkness.
- alexis_fr 7y agoHe may have meant, criminality wise. Public lightening is, and has been, a major factor against criminality. Public sodium-based lightening is too week anyway for depression. One way to ensure security for pedestrians with lowest consumption, is the “light carpet”. Only the feet are enlighted, with low spotlights. Consumes little, lets you see where you walk, but in case of theft, doesn’t allow you to see the criminal’s face. I don’t know whether this is what they chose for Place de la Nation.
- clmul 7y ago> Public lightening is, and has been, a major factor against criminality That's highly debatable (sure, it may feel safer): https://www.darksky.org/light-pollution/lighting-crime-and-safety/ https://www.darksky.org/light-pollution/lighting-crime-and-s... In any case, I don't there is much point in keeping the lights on throughout the entire night, but it might be beneficial to (especially during winter months at higher latitudes) light busy areas in cities for part of the evening.
- newnewpdro 7y agoThere was an article I stumbled across a while back written by someone who was fed up with the amount of crime that occurred just outside his window in an urban neighborhood. His window just happened to be at the darkest part on the street where shady business could be done in the shadows. Drug deals, prostitution, etc. He'd overhear all of it because of the lack of light on the street by his window. I don't remember exactly what the solution was but it involved getting the area lighted somehow. Surely it didn't prevent the crimes from happening, just relocating it elsewhere. But that's the point. As long as the paths people stick to at night are well-lit, they can avoid the dark shadows where crime is more likely occurring. If you leave entire blocks darkened, you make those blocks less safe. Stumbling upon a crime in-progress is a good way to get killed just for being a witness.
- clmul 7y agoWould be interesting to read that article. Crime is a problem indeed, but I still feel like adding more lighting in hopes of solving this is not really the solution, and like you say, just moving the problem around. I think lighting very busy areas (think railway stations, main streets in cities) is a good idea in general, but how many areas are really busy at night? And most people aren't outside in the middle of the night or early morning, so most lights could probably be shutdown after the evening is over?
- newnewpdro 7y agoWish I could find it, I tried briefly but failed miserably. Was kind of hoping someone would recognize it from my comment and be able to provide a link as I wouldn't mind re-reading it myself.
- maelito 7y agoWell there are still cars, that's probably the worst risk for pedestrians and cyclists.
- lucb1e 7y agoBut Paris is within the highest levels of light pollution you can find in Europe (the only other places in Europe being the inner parts of London, Saint Petersburg, and a couple of cities in Spain - no other European country even has places that bright). I don't think that can be called even remotely dark, though it'll be interesting to see if I visit again. Source: http://darksitefinder.com/maps/world.html#6/48.093/6.416 http://darksitefinder.com/maps/world.html#6/48.093/6.416 (Paris/London/etc. has the white level; other cities like Brussels, The Hague or Milan only get to grey).
- js8 7y agoI don't buy it. Sure, I agree it can be a factor, but a key factor? Why I am skeptical: There are many places where there is no light, especially in the countryside or in the forest. Lights have been with us 60+ years, and the insect apocalypse has only been observed in past 20. There is also apocalypse of other species, such as earthworms, also caused by lights?
- maelito 7y ago> “We strongly believe artificial light at night – in combination with habitat loss, chemical pollution, invasive species, and climate change – is driving insect declines,” Well it would be a "key factor" among 5 of them at least, according to the authors.
- herodotus 7y agoLight pollution has been increasing significantly each year. Look at the photographs in this article: https://www.curbed.com/2017/4/26/15442432/photography-dark-sky-light-pollution-skyglow https://www.curbed.com/2017/4/26/15442432/photography-dark-s... There are fewer places than you think with no light. I remember watching many moth's flying around street lights and my porch light. Haven't seen that for years now.
- Zancarius 7y agoI'm not surprised. Rural areas are almost worse than you'd infer from the photographs in that article. 10 years ago, few people would have outside lighting on more than a few hours a night. Now, you can't even drive through most places without seeing high intensity lighting mounted to telephone poles near residential zones. I live about 10-15 miles from the nearest decent-sized town, and I've seen this change. Tons of people moving into these areas, and the first thing they do is install (or pay the electric coop to install) outdoor lighting. As per one of the other posters, it's almost always that obnoxious 6000K+ color lighting that's blue-white enough to hurt your eyes. And I used to whine about the sodium lamps... My state has light pollution laws under the Dark Skies Act. Good luck getting it enforced since most of the astronomers who lived here have either moved or died.
- jmartrican 7y agoHmmmm I'm very skeptical. Insects evolve quickly. We been having artificial light for like a long time. I can't imagine the insects would not have evolved to it by now.
- pergadad 7y agoAs a factor it seems believable, as THE factor it seems more likely that there's a big funder looking for a strawman... Which industry does have an immense and known responsibility for insect deaths? Maybe the industry producing insecticides that are hugely profitable but at risk of global bans? I'd not at all be surprised if this is an elaborate way to sow legal doubt on the anti-insecticide / organic agriculture efforts.
- rob74 7y agoNowhere in the article do they claim that it's THE factor, just a key factor in combination with "habitat loss, chemical pollution, invasive species, and climate change" (3rd paragraph).
- galago 7y agoI think that's exactly how contemporary disinformation campaigns work. Say its almost totally pesticides, the win for them is muddling it into 'numerous causes.' There's so much money involved in some of these issues that stakeholders can spend millions (billions if you own fossil fuel reserves) just to move the needle slightly.
- shrimp_emoji 7y ago>“We strongly believe artificial light at night – in combination with habitat loss, chemical pollution, invasive species, and climate change – is driving insect declines,” the scientists concluded after assessing more than 150 studies. “We posit here that artificial light at night is another important – but often overlooked – bringer of the insect apocalypse.”
- bunkydoo 7y agoWhat? too many mosquitos fly towards the bulb all at once causing it to break?
- briefcomment 7y agoChronic semi-permanent light at night (street lights, signage, lights from businesses like hotels, porch lights, and notably NOT car lights or other transitory light) is generally unpleasant right? I feel like at best it's an annoyance, and at worst, it's something messing with biologicial cycles. Are there any interesting innovations out there addressing this? Like motion strengthened* street lights? I would be tickled pink to have a Navi-esque drone lighting up my way when I need it rather than having everything lit all the time. *edited from "activated"
- khawkins 7y agoMotion activated lights would be far more distracting. It's easy to become accustomed to a constant lighting, but if lights were going on and off every 1-2 hours through the night, it would be unnerving for anyone triggering them or positioned to see the light. The innovation is living in the countryside on your own land or vacationing in those areas. Being away from people and their lights is a privilege, especially when lights improve safety.
- clmul 7y agoI don't think the bright lighting which is rampant in cities improves safety in general, (most) people are perfectly able to see in the dark, and city lights merely make it (because of interfering with the adaptation of the eyes) impossible to see in the spots left without lighting.
- briefcomment 7y agoTrue to your first point, but a compromise like having lights be dim and having them increase to full brightness for approaching traffic may help. Selective darkness is certainly a luxury, but there's no reason we can't innovate away our currently clumsy solutions.
- clumsysmurf 7y agoA hotel nearby replaced all their exterior lighting (several hundred CFLs) with omni-directional LED clusters ~ 6000K. They make the place look like a prison courtyard, and they are painful to walk near after dark (too bright, too harsh). I would think, that as a species we'd all recognize the color temperature of a nice campfire to be comforting and likeable, but I'm honestly surprised some people like these 6000K+ LEDs.
- upofadown 7y ago>LED lights also offer hope as they can be easily tuned to avoid harmful colours ... Can they? Most white LEDs emit blue light into a phosphor. You are always going to end up with a definite blue spike in the spectrum.
- nullc 7y agoThere exist white LEDs that instead use a deep violet emitter which they're able to much more effectively filter out, eliminating the high frequency spike. Good luck finding them in products though.
- tpmx 7y agoContext: Sweden. I spend october-april in a city. I very rarely see any animals at all here, including insects. (Sometimes we get confused rabbits here.) I spend april-october in a house in the countryside. There's so little light-pollution that I've considered buying one of those fancy motorized telescopes. I get lots of insects there, including lots of beautiful butterflies.
- kljhtopur 7y agoI think concrete versus natural landscape is a bigger factor in your case.
- gmiller123456 7y agoI've considered buying one of those fancy motorized telescopes. To completely change the subject: With very dark skies, a non-motorize dobsonian would be a better choice. For the price, you'll get a larger aperture scope which will provide better views. And the dark skies make it easy to star hop to find what you want to see. From my house near Louisville, KY, it's too difficult to see a lot of stars, making a "goto" scope much more useful. I simply can't find the stars to hop to visually even though I have a really good idea where they are.
- tpmx 7y agoThanks for the insight!
- ShorsHammer 7y agoSpent a bit of time in Fiji. A thing that struck me instantly was how well fed the frogs were and how little effort they had to put in to get food. At dusk they just go near little ground lights and eat every bug that would come near them. It's a perverse ecological system.
- ohiovr 7y agoThat isn't the insect apocalyse. The insect apocalyse is in a decade or so when insects overcome what it is we are producing to beat them down.