6 ms·
I would expect more, and more direct language. Doing business with a fascist state or in a fascist state is deplorable. The message should be loud and clear.
by colechristensen 7y ago
I would expect more, and more direct language.
Doing business with a fascist state or in a fascist state is deplorable. The message should be loud and clear. China today shares many parallels with Germany in the 1930s. There needs to be open frank opposition because embarrassing them is the only way to stop them until the US is willing to park an aircraft carrier group in HK waters.
- yumraj 7y agoWhile I completely agree with you, YC is a private organization and not a political one. The above message allows everyone to save face while getting the job done. YC doesn't need to say anything beyond this.
- learc83 7y ago>Doing business with a fascist state or in a fascist state is deplorable >While I completely agree with you, YC is a private organization and not a political If you agree that doing business with a fascist state is deplorable, it doesn't stop being deplorable just because you're a private company.
- colechristensen 7y agoThat is exactly the problem. Saving face. Causing PRC to lose face is the only way to stop them outside a war which nobody wants. If American companies started cutting ties and explicitly calling out their behavior it would make a real difference.
- skybrian 7y ago1. PRC loses face. 2. ??? (Does not include war.) 3. New Chinese government takes control. I don't think anyone knows how to do what you want. Just because a problem is important doesn't mean it has a solution.
- tossAfterUsing 7y agoStep 2: globally orchestrated sanctions on a fascist dictatorship Step 2b: hopefully we avoid WWIII
- AnimalMuppet 7y agoYeah, about step 2b: Note that part of the reasoning behind the Japanese attack on Pearl Harbor was the US's sanctions on Japan for their actions in China.
- skybrian 7y agoThat might work for a smaller country like South Africa, but China too big for that. China could probably make everything it needs itself, or learn in a decade or two. So it sounds to me like a new iron curtain, leaving both sides poorer and the people caught in the middle suffering from the separation. (And good luck fighting global warming.) But though there's a lot of pressure to choose your side, I doubt every country will do so. If forced they might choose China?
- tossAfterUsing 7y ago> China could probably make everything it needs itself, or learn in a decade or two. Even the elites want out... i'm not sure the system wouldn't eat itself before then.
- throwawaybbb 7y ago>That might work for a smaller country like South Africa, but China too big for that. China could probably make everything it needs itself, or learn in a decade or two. So it sounds to me like a new iron curtain, leaving both sides poorer and the people caught in the middle suffering from the separation. (And good luck fighting global warming.) The majority of the US and Soviet population was better off with the iron curtain than without in real terms. The US median hourly wage only surpassed that of 1968 in the last 3 years.
- yumraj 7y agoI don't think that is correct. In fact 1) China is massive with huge labor class, 2) China is heavily export driven, 3) current generation in China has been affluent. So, even moderate global sanctions will have a massive impact with both affluent class and the labor class revolting. However, remember, oil embargo drove Japan to WW-2, I'm sure China will react similarly unless that internal revolt happens first. Too difficult to predict.
- yumraj 7y agoIn my observation, for what it's worth, current China regime does not react well to losing face. They just dig in further. Not sure if it's a cultural artifact. We have seen that time and time again. However, China will react to economic loss. As such pulling out of China, surely and quietly, is the best approach.
- DavidHm 7y agoAnd yet private organizations so often want to sit on the moral perch and pet themselves about all the non-profit oriented actions they take.
- yumraj 7y agoAnd that is their right, and nothing wrong with that IMHO. And, I will support that. However, I was simply noting that it is not a requirement for private organizations.
- fzeroracer 7y agoYou can't say you're an apolitical organization when you work with China given the way running a business in China works. The message is obvious that companies are afraid of angering the Chinese government by speaking ill of it as they commit increasing atrocities because that could potentially eat into their profit margins. Profit over people.
- dangxiaopin 7y agoIn my opinion, one party California is a fascist state. Hey, SF just elected a Chavist as a DA: that person actually went and helped Hugo Chavez administration. By that yardstick, doing business in California is also immortal.
- Gorbzel 7y agoFalse equivalence
- logicreasoning 7y agoI don’t expect anything less from a brainwashed Chinese national (who is most likely living in California and still pledges alliegiance to the dictator xi bao zi) who thinks his whataboutism will work on hacker news
- tossAfterUsing 7y agouser may be Chinese national, but name calling ("brainwashed") probably isn't the best way to encourage the sorts of open dialogue that will be necessary to change their views
- lidHanteyk 7y agoLucky 10000: Go look up the etymology of "brainwashing".
- tossAfterUsing 7y agolol... nice find. brainwashing (n.) "attempt to alter or control the thoughts and beliefs of another person against his will by psychological techniques," 1950, a literal translation of Chinese xi nao. A term from the Korean War. https://www.etymonline.com/word/brainwashing https://www.etymonline.com/word/brainwashing
- seppin 7y agoIgnoring or tolerating a violent ethno-nationalist ideology isn't going to make things better either.
- plntd 7y agoVirtue signaling doesn't work in business. Should yc do any business in the US which is mired in illegal wars and regime change operation all over the world? What about Saudi arabia? Should silicon valley and traditional media give up the billions in Saudi investment? Every major economic player is evil in some form or another. And the parallel with china isn't nazi Germany. It's with 19th century US.
- dangxiaopin 7y agoIt does at Google. They have enough fat to digest it for a while.
- harimau777 7y agoThe US certainly has its problems, but I don't think it's fair to draw a moral equivalence with what's happening in China.
- mirimir 7y agoThe US did invade Iraq, not that long ago. Hundreds of thousands died.
- harimau777 7y agoI generally think that the way in Iraq was a mistake; however, even then: The motivation appears to have been different, fighting terrorism and finding WMDs versus societal control and religious intolerance. The majority, though certainly not all, of the people killed were combatants rather than civilians.
- mirimir 7y agoNo, the majority were ~innocent people. Although, as in any invasion, the distinction was blurry. While the invasion was sold on the basis of terrorism and WMD, that was mostly bullshit. I mean, the US originally supported Saddam Hussein because he opposed communists supported by Russia. And it used Iraq in a proxy war against Iran, is also supported by Russia. Basically, the US invaded Iraq because it had to invade somewhere after the 9/11 attacks. Saudi Arabia was the obvious suspect, given their funding of fundamentalist Islam generally, and Al-Qaeda specifically. Plus the fact that most of the attackers were Saudi. But that was unworkable, for many reasons. Afghanistan was the other obvious target, but everyone knew that it would be a morass. Given Russia's experience, for example. Or Britain's, back in the day. Plus the fact that most of it had already been pounded into sand. So Iraq was the perfect target. With lots of juicy stuff to destroy. And an ineffectual military. Another goal was demonstrating US military hardware. Advertising, to increase sales.
- rl3 7y ago>...until the US is willing to park an aircraft carrier group in HK waters. I'm afraid a single carrier battle group wouldn't be much of a deterrent these days. The US no longer has naval overmatch in that region. Barring any gross incompetence on PLA-N's part, or the US having highly classified tricks up its sleeve, USN would need several fleets to achieve anything but a pyrrhic victory in such a conflict.[0] I otherwise completely agree with your sentiments, and living in a world where what amounts to essentially a fascist state having military supremacy—even if only limited in scope and regional for now—is quite chilling. [0] https://www.reuters.com/investigates/special-report/china-army-navy/ https://www.reuters.com/investigates/special-report/china-ar...
- Aeolun 7y agoNot to mention that the whole fleet would be utterly useless against all the land based missile systems that would target them if it ever came to it. I’m sure they can stop some of it but eventually they’ll just run out of supplies. I think the only way to do something like that is by going all-in.
- RomanBob 7y agoIn the US, as I go through the airport, I am physically violated routinely for my 'security'. All of the data I transmit are recorded, for the agencies to go through them, if not now, then later, when they figured out how. People who don't obey the leftist narrative are cancelled, have their jobs terminated, and so on. China has always been independent. They pride themselves on that. Taking away investment money isn't going to influence them. If you want to influence somebody, first you understand them, then you build a friendship and rapport with them, and then you influence them. Turning off the phone does the opposite.
- csomar 7y agoI think YC has to be reserved because they are linked to all of these companies they have invested in. A bad statement could potentially harm some of their portfolio companies.
- SkyMarshal 7y agoThe US can't take military action in Hong Kong, because its handover to China was completely legal. You can thank the British for their short-sightnedness on this one, but nothing the rest of the world can do, at least overtly. I see this fact repeatedly forgotten or overlooked in the brewhaha over HK.
- stevens32 7y agoAre we just going to ignore why Hong Kong was under British rule in the first place?
- SkyMarshal 7y agoThat's not necessary legally, since the legal handover is already sufficient to justify non-intervention. But of course the way Hong Kong was originally acquired at the point of a gun bolsters the moral/ethical case for both the legal handover and non-intervention.
- master-litty 7y agoNaive perspective: Is it possible that this language prevents YC from being blocked by the Great Firewall? I'm not sure I'd advocate it, but I see the potential argument: It's better to let users see YC's independent decision to not conduct business in China, even with vague reasoning, as there's no realistic narrative that would put China in a great light. The alternative is to be completely censored. If the intent is to spread a message within, I would think an uncensored message is better than no message at all.
- colechristensen 7y agoProbably something more along the lines of censorship via perceived or actual fiduciary duty.
- throwaway423342 7y agoCan the US stay away from this? > park an aircraft carrier group in HK waters. This is called invasion. What is your incentive in supporting an invasion?
- colechristensen 7y ago>What is your incentive in supporting an invasion? Isolationism and appeasement post-WWI leading to the next, disastrous world war which could have been avoided or significantly diminished with early intervention.
- throwaway423342 7y agoBy provoking people, threatening to send aircraft carriers? The fact is this is just a leverage US is holding on to to win the trade war. Human rights have been the excuse the US used to wage war against multiple middle east countries in the past 30 years, eventually for its own benefit, and causing huge sufferings to people in these countries. No one can say no to 'supporting human rights', but you'd be naive to think the US cares about human rights more than it does about benefiting itself and inflicting suffering on other countries. Also, maybe it's turning out that building the wall is not that profitable after all.
- throwaway423342 7y agoSeriously, mind your own stuff. How would you feel if some other country parks an aircraft carrier group in US waters, because the US - has a racial discrimination problem? - invades citizen's privacy through wire tapping? - the presidential election is just a funny show? ... Stay the f* out!