11 ms·
Allbirds CEO on Amazon's copycat strategy
- toasterlovin 7y agoIf you can't succeed because somebody made a low effort, low quality copy of your product, then you don't deserve to make money. Especially in light of the fact that Coke has been around for 150 years and is essentially just sugar water.
- ses1984 7y agoCoke actually has regulatory protections in place. They can use flavor extracted from coca plant through a special arrangement with the dea. Anyway they sell all kinds of varieties of sugar water, and the margins are extremely thin.
- cortesoft 7y agoI mean, the law itself doesn't say only Coca-Cola can use the coca leaves.... they just have an exclusive deal with the only company that is licensed to import it.
- awshepard 7y agoDoes that sort of regulatory capture accomplish the same effect though? If you're a competitor in the space, you'd either a) not have any access to an ingredient you want, or b) would have to go through the trouble of finding a new company to import it AND get them licensed (which I assume is likely a difficult thing to do). To an extent, the barrier to entry could end up so high that it's effectively _as if _ Coca-Cola has a legal stranglehold.
- cortesoft 7y agoYes, it does. Just pointing out that Coca Cola isn't named in the law.
- wolco 7y agoDid I read that correctly. The margin on coke are thin?
- ses1984 7y agoIf you think the margins aren't thin, why don't you swoop in and undercut them?
- likpok 7y agoThe specific flavor/process of coke is protected, but you can get pretty close outside of that. Their other products are often indistinguishable (e.g. sprite/sierra mist). The value there is the brand, not the specific flavor. The special dispensation for Coke works on a branding level: "we have a special process dating back to 1890".
- CamelCaseName 7y agoI'm not sure if this is how you're defining brand, but the real value is in their exclusivity agreements with restaurants and (some) grocers. This is the reason any restaurant that doesn't just resell soft drinks they bought at the grocery store only sells either Pepsi / Coca-Cola. It would be really interesting to see what kind of rates major chains/conglomerates (E.g. McDonalds, Subway, 3G, Recipe Unlimited, etc.) get for their soft drinks as these guys are big enough that they can probably push their own soft drinks and really bite into Coca-Cola/Pepsi's turf.
- toasterlovin 7y agoFWIW, the exclusivity agreements only work because they interact in a virtuous cycle with the incredible amount of effort Coca-Cola has put into building their brand with consumers. Nobody signs exclusivity agreements with PC Cola[0]. [0]: http://www.presidentschoice.ca/en_CA/products/productlisting/pc_cola3933.html http://www.presidentschoice.ca/en_CA/products/productlisting...
- opencl 7y agoWendy's does have their own "Dave's Sodas" brand.
- dobleboble 7y agoMargins are thin? "Coca-Cola's latest twelve months Net Income Margin % is 23.1%." "Coca-Cola's Net Income Margin % for fiscal years ending Dec, 2014 to 2018 averaged 14.3%." https://finbox.com/KO/explorer/ni_margin https://finbox.com/KO/explorer/ni_margin
- supercanuck 7y agoThey split off Coca Cola Enterprises to achieve this. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coca-Cola_Enterprises https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coca-Cola_Enterprises
- gist 7y ago> Coke has been around for 150 years and is essentially just sugar water. Coke is still around (primarily) because of tremendous money spent on marketing and tremendous money spent on owning the channel of distribution of their products (where 'own' means defacto by how they operate).
- toasterlovin 7y agoExactly my point. Figure out how to build a business that can withstand having its products copied.
- raz32dust 7y agoThis is a very simplistic view. (a) Patent litigations can cost a lot of money, and small companies might not be able to fight big ones. (b) Some products are more easily patentable than others. The current situation is definitely not great for innovation or creativity.
- toasterlovin 7y agoMost companies build a moat with something other than patents. Brand, scale, distribution networks, etc.
- rutierut 7y agoI largely agree with your point but I think your example could have been better, companies like CC but a better example would be Red Bull could easily be switched out for a cheap clone and not suffer much in revenue, Red Bull has no superior quality but it's the brand that sells.
- Chris2048 7y agoRed bull tastes better than a lot of others.
- benologist 7y agoAmazon has copied 50,000+ items, some open source, some proprietary SaaS, they surely weren't all garbage undeserving of success. Predatory platforms might be the actual problem.
- toasterlovin 7y agoFWIW, it seems like you're referring to software. I'm commenting solely on their retail business (and that's what the linked article is about).
- benologist 7y agoThe 50,000+ items are physical things across their many brands, they're facing an antitrust action in the EU for the possibility sales data is the deciding factor for what to copy. http://europa.eu/rapid/press-release_IP-19-4291_en.htm http://europa.eu/rapid/press-release_IP-19-4291_en.htm
- toasterlovin 7y agoFWIW, every major retailer can use the exact same data about in-store sales to determine which products to private label.
- ajhurliman 7y agoSource?
- sdan 7y agoAWS
- ApolloFortyNine 7y agoLicenses to stop 'software as a service' from being able to make changes without publishing them back have been around since 2002 [1]. You can hardly develop open source software and then be shocked when someone goes ahead and uses it within their rights. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Affero_General_Public_License https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Affero_General_Public_License
- twblalock 7y agoThis is especially true in the fashion industry, and even more especially true in the shoe industry. Amazon isn't the only company that makes shoes that look like Allbirds. All the shoe companies rip each other off.
- vernie 7y ago...in fact you should probably just hurry up and die!
- jariel 7y agoNo, it's why trademark and copyright exist. Nobody is complaining that Amazon can 'make better shoes'. The issue is about copying design.
- _iyig 7y agoWhat if the person who copies you also controls the marketplace, and prioritizes their copy above your original? That seems much closer to what Amazon is doing.
- Spivak 7y agoNo different than Walmart prioritizing their store brand which explicitly copy the branding of other products ("woah, there's no way that isn't butter"). If you cant get your customers to seek you out directly then you don't have a brand. As a consumer I like when store brands do this. It tells me what they're trying to impersonate more than the "compare to XXX" in teeny tiny print. But they're just a brand like anything else on the shelf -- Kroger pretzels are better than Rolled Gold, but their sandwich cookies are much worse than Oreo.
- giarc 7y agoI did a search on both Amazon.com and Amazon.ca but couldn't find any Amazon Basic shoes that matched Allbirds. I also didn't listen to the podcast, so I must have missed it.
- 40acres 7y agoAbstractly, the question at hand is this: is a retailer that sells its own in house brand anticompetitive due to the information it has on potential competitor sales? Other large retailers: Target, Walmart, etc. have a higher percentage of in house brands for sale than Amazon. So on this argument going after Amazon means you need to decouple retailers from in house brands across the board. Even the concern about search placement has concerns, as shelf space in the store can be viewed as a analogous to search pages.
- admn2 7y agoI think if you look at Warby Parker as a comparison, it's easy to see that Allbirds value is in buying into their brand. There were / are plenty of companies selling cheap glasses, but it took Warby Parker making them cool. I do think Allbirds should get a lot of credit for innovating in such a crowded space, but people buy Allbirds for way more than just the shoe. Walk into any one of their stores on a Saturday or check out their packaging and it seems obvious their customers are not choosing them based on price.
- readams 7y agoI think most people don't know that shelf space is actively sold by the stores. They imagine the stores go out and find the best products to display. That's not what happens.
- barbecue_sauce 7y agoThis really depends on the retail methodology of a company. Space allocation in a category planogram (layout) is often ultimately decided by the category manager (corporate person who is responsible for P/L of that category), but can be affected by the heavy hitters in that category using their internal "retail services" department to help said category manager formulate their planograms. This usually results in somewhat biased product assortments and layouts that give preferential treatment to specific brands, but rarely is space outright purchased within the aisles of a store. End-caps are a different story, but often the "purchase" of an end-cap simply takes the form of wholesale pricing concessions, which allow the store to make more money by promoting those products for a short period of time. Historically, some DSD brands will lease end-caps at stores (speaking specifically about supermarkets in this context), but these are serviced and stocked by external companies. Depending on the marketing strategy of a chain, private label products are often placed on end-caps to drive volume for what are often their highest-margin products (due to heavy control over the whole supply chain) and are not subject to any purchasing. TL;DR: The extent to which retail stores "sell" shelf-space is often exaggerated, a kind of folk wisdom that may have been more truthful in the past but doesn't reflect modern business practices.
- peruvian 7y agoI'm not going to defend Amazon or capitalism as much as others in the comments, but Allbirds are fairly cheaply made shoe sold at a high price to well off tech workers or tech-adjacent workers. It was only a matter of time until someone that can eat the margin (Amazon) stepped in.
- helen___keller 7y agoAllbirds is a luxury brand. Retailers offer cheap versions of luxury brands. There's little surprise here. Should Ray-Bans complain that Walmart offers sunglasses that look nearly identical at a tenth of the price? Amazon has plenty of dodgy business practices, but I don't think this is one of them.
- dfcagency 7y agoThe bigger problem here is that Allbirds ISNT a luxury brand. They've drank the Silicon Valley cool-aid of growth above all else, the "reforge" growth-hack school of tips and tricks to optimize conversion rates and customer retention, without actually building a storied brand - which is what a real luxury brand is (see: LVMH's holdings, Hermes, or more recently Aesop). There's no storied history, hell - their LOGO isn't on their products. They're PERFECTLY ripe for generic disruption. If they had hired real brand marketers, not growth addicts over-analyzing CAC/LTV/AOV formulas all day, they'd have a more defensible position in the marketplace. By the way, your analogy of sunglasses is flawed - those cheap sunglasses look, feel, and function cheaply.
- helen___keller 7y ago> The bigger problem here is that Allbirds ISNT a luxury brand. Sure, perhaps I should have said they price themselves like a luxury brand (or something above commodity pricing but below luxury? I'm not an expert on this stuff) From their marketing on sustainability, and their prices, it seems to follow to me that they probably have a high markup and don't ruthlessly cut corners to survive on a tiny margin at brutally low prices. > By the way, your analogy of sunglasses is flawed - those cheap sunglasses look, feel, and function cheaply. Admittedly I wrote my post under the assumption that Amazon's generic wool runners probably feel cheap in one way or another from having cut some corners to lower production costs. I wouldn't know, though.
- dfcagency 7y agoLuxury isn't necessarily about price (although it's a common component) - it's an ephemeral combination of prestige, exclusivity, quality, and wealth/taste projection.
- jbverschoor 7y agoWell. allbirds has serious supplychain and production problems. This is their own fault
- dinisp89 7y agoAllbirds shoes look very very cheap. I stopped into their NYC store downtown twice. Each time I noticed a ton of glue that had seeped onto the wool when they glued the fabric on. I thought the first time it was a one-off issue. The pattern continues. Allbirds really needs to step up their quality. If you look at the product quality of Merrel, Danner, US Made Red Wing Shoes, it's night and day! I would never buy an Allbird.
- OnlineGladiator 7y agoYou're comparing work boots to what are effectively wool slippers with rubber soles - of course there's a difference in quality because they're not even the same market segment. I agree with you they're overpriced, but not for the reasons you stated.
- magashna 7y agoMaybe they should aim for a different market segment then. Common Projects, a plain but very well made luxury sneaker seems to be doing well. I'd imagine fighting for scraps against Amazon/Walmart isn't going to go well.
- peruvian 7y agoTheir market is well off techies/tech adjacent people that don't care about fashion and just want to be comfy (Allbirds are the butt of jokes in any men's style community). They can't price their shoes too high because their market would scoff at paying more than $~150 for shoes. This market also won't care about where the material is sourced from or who makes it. Allbirds made a cheap product people can easily copy, so they did. Shrug.
- dzhiurgis 7y agoMy biggest problem with them is they wear out in less than a year. Extremely unreliable... That said, if you love merino - check out Icebreaker...
- 7y ago
- bernierocks 7y agoThis is why I stopped selling on Amazon. It's compelling because there's a built-in customer base. But in the long-run, they will use your selling data against you and eventually attempt to put you out of business by finding a cheaper supplier.
- julianozen 7y agoWorth noting that even if you dont sell, they still know how many customers are searching for your product and not finding it
- toasterlovin 7y agoWe have built a good business selling on Amazon in a product category where the competition (including Amazon Basics) is half of our price. If all you bring to Amazon is something that is undifferentiated and can be easily copied, then it'll be a race to the bottom and you'll lose to factories in China selling direct or players like Amazon who can achieve massive economies of scale.
- kevmo 7y agoAmazon needs to be broken up.
- verelo 7y ago> Amazon is known for watching what retail products gain traction on its platform and elsewhere and then creating similar products it can sell for less. Should we really care? Isn't this what consumers want? Value.
- luxuryballs 7y agoBetter, cheaper, faster, thanks Amazon. Plus let’s be realistic any actual good stuff isn’t going to be worth attempting to copy, say an iPhone or some Burton snowboarding boots. Amazon computer mice? HDMI cables? Socks? We are just watching commodities being realized for what they are.
- oh_sigh 7y agoI own a pair of all birds. I think I paid around $100 for them. I wouldn't be surprised if the actual cost of the shoe was around $8. Amazon is a margin-eating business("your margin is my opportunity"). You can't expect margins like that to just go on unmolested from anyone. I'm honestly surprised Amazon hasn't done more of this - e.g. in the makeup industry which has notoriously high margins.
- timothyjames 7y agoThis is pretty ironic given that allbirds are very much a derivative of Nike Roshe Runs which were popular at the same time Allbirds was founded.
- WooShoa 7y agoThis is what happens when the internet is essentially taken over by the walled gardens of "platforms" where the only choices you have are the ones your masters in charge of the platform you have subjugated yourself to allow you to have.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- snarfy 7y agoMy problem is when the oligopolies hurt the market with these practices. I used to buy boxes of nitrile gloves from Home Depot for painting. Then they started carrying 'HDX' brand nitrile gloves. Then they stopped carrying all other brands of nitrile gloves. I'm not sure the practice is the problem, or the oligopoly. I would shop somewhere else, but where am I going to shop? Lowes?