13 ms·
After working in mining for a long while, where this kind of isolation procedure is standard and is taken very seriously (pretty much any breach of procedure is
by taneq 7y ago
After working in mining for a long while, where this kind of isolation procedure is standard and is taken very seriously (pretty much any breach of procedure is an instantly firable offense) it's terrifying coming back home and seeing people working on house wiring etc. with nothing more than a turned-off circuit breaker protecting them from electrocution or other injury. I've seen some trades start to pick up isolation procedures but they're generally still far behind industry best practices.
- ebiester 7y agoHow would you recommend people working on their own house implement anything more than turning off the circuit breaker? (I'm not doing anything electrical in general, but sometimes small fixes are necessary for home owners.)
- devb 7y agoI think OP is referring to a job site where people coming and going have access to the panel. If you're home alone or only have a small handful of people to keep in contact with then it's far less of an issue.
- taneq 7y agoIn those cases you're 'probably fine' but if someone gets home while you're working, sees that the power is out, and goes to check the circuit breaker (as you've probably trained them to do) then you could still get zapped without warning.
- Gibbon1 7y agoThat's why central air conditioners are supposed to have a disconnect within sight of the unit.
- Scoundreller 7y agoI thought it was for easy-money from new/unfamiliar home-owners. https://youtu.be/fUAIBZKeK74 https://youtu.be/fUAIBZKeK74 For the Dateline Special.
- swixmix 7y agoI assume he means no lock was involved. Anyone who ventures in house electricity should have a circuit breaker locking device. Use it, lock it, and verify the circuit is dead each time before you work on it.
- taneq 7y agoIt doesn't have to be anything fancy - you could just fit a hasp to the fuse box (if one's not already attached) to allow you to lock it closed with a padlock. Then you keep the only key for that padlock on your person until you've finished the job. If you want to get fancier or if others are going to need to access the fuse box while you're working, you can get "lock dogs" which let you lock individual circuit breakers. Then you just lock off the one for the circuit you're working on.
- fingerlocks 7y agoIf we’re being honest with ourselves, few (if any) home owner is ever going to go through with locking circuit breakers. Because it’s completely overkill. In the Real World, you’ll just tell your wife/kids/roommates “Hey don’t touch the fuse panel until I’m done doing this thing” and it’s not an issue.
- Gibbon1 7y agoOne of the funniest things I saw like that was my dad on a ladder in a closet trying to sort out a switch and light fixture with a voltmeter and my special needs brother repeatedly going outside and flipping off the circuit breaker. Leaving my dad cursing on a ladder in the dark.
- nullc 7y agoThey make clip on lockouts for residential breakers. https://www.amazon.com/dp/B004J173I8/ref=twister_B007NAGJJG?_encoding=UTF8&psc=1 https://www.amazon.com/dp/B004J173I8/ref=twister_B007NAGJJG?... Personally, I just lock the panel. If your panel can't be locked a big piece of masking tape across the door, holding it shut, with "NOPE. call <you>" written with a sharpie should do the job. :) FWIW, the first photograph in that WP article with the tagged panel is one of mine... from close to 15 years ago.
- zaarn 7y agoWhat I learned when doing electrical work in germany, the procedure for safe electrical working is as follows: - Switch off (at circuit breaker) - Prevent switching on (lock the breaker) - Check voltage free (multimeter cleared for 230V/120V operation with long, isolated test leads) - Ground and short (put a plug into the socket connecting earth, live and neutral, you can DIY that at home safely by cutting open an unused cord and soldering all three wires together) - Cover nearby powered equipment
- matt-attack 7y agoStep three, don’t forget to unplug your short circuitter before flipping back on the breaker.
- zaarn 7y agoUsually you just follow this list in reverse; from bottom up and undoing what you did.
- amluto 7y ago> Ground and short (put a plug into the socket connecting earth, live and neutral Hmm. Given that breakers in the US don’t disconnect the neutral, grounding the neutral can introduce potentially unpleasant stray currents. On the flip side, as far as I can tell, it’s entirely possible for a code-compliant installation to give you a moderate zap if you touch the neutral with the breaker off: if you have a long feeder to the panel, and someone turns on a big, single-phase load on a different breaker, the voltage drop on the feeder neutral could zap you. Imagine a 50A inrush current a across 1 ohm. That’s 50V for a few cycles.
- zaarn 7y agoAtleast in germany the standard breakers don't either but the GFCI does and 3-phase breakers need to interrupt all phases. The neutral is also somewhat regularly grounded in the building's I've seen and atleast one grounding point is required at the distro point. Plus the breakers will trip at 50A inrush anyway. (From experience, 50V AC won't kill you unless you are standing in a bathtub and covered yourself in conductive gel, you'll just get some minor pain in most cases)
- fargle 7y agoSimple answer: close the breaker box lid and put a cheap padlock on it. You don't need a tag or special clip. That ensures that your wife or roommate doesn't try to flip the breaker back on while your arm is in the garbage disposal or you are holding the hot wire with your teeth. You can and should use a test light or DVOM to verify the power is out. You can and should treat the wires as if they were "hot" anyhow. You should keep a wire nut on the hot wire. Don't actually put any of the wires in your teeth. Now. You could do all that, but what I do at home is carry a lot of insurance and work "hot". I don't care about 120V or even 240V. I make sure what I'm touching one arm at a time with no ground path through my heart. Don't stand in water. Simply just don't touch the hot wire. I learned to work hot on a piecework job that payed by units completed and that was about 1000% more if you could work hot. And, you can, if you manage the risk. If you mess up 99% chance you'll say "OW" and NOT do that again. I wouldn't play Russian roulette with 1:6 odds. But 1:100 (die from) x 1:100 (mistake) x 10 hours per year (occasional fixes), fine not worth the bother. Far more chance of dying falling off the ladder than electrocution. DON'T stand on rolly chairs. Now at an uncontrolled job-site, where I'm payed by the hour, 2000 hours/year? NEVER. It's a lot different when you are a company of one vs. many. I know what I'm doing, and while I make mistakes, I can guess how often. If you have more than 0 co-workers, you cannot trust or predict their mistakes.
- vorpalhex 7y agoI uh, have been guilty of similar lack of safety protocols in the distant past. I fortunately learned my lesson by shorting a $900 AC control board and not shocking myself, but needless to say it really is worth taking the time to do it right.
- fargle 7y agoI just zapped myself so hard my hand flew back and got cut on the metal box. Hurt a bit, but it was $900 cheaper than your lesson. :)
- dsfyu404ed 7y ago>How would you recommend people working on their own house implement anything more than turning off the circuit breaker? Tell the other inhabitants what you're doing and tape over the breaker with a note saying to see you before it's turned on. Sure you could stick a padlock clasp on the breaker box but when your job-site has a number of people you can count on one hand a note will have 99.99999% of the same benefit and if they're trying to recklessly kill you all a lock does is buy a little time.
- caseymarquis 7y agoAfter working on high voltage circuits as a lineman for a couple years, and currently writing software for industrial machinery and regularly working in industrial machining cabinets, I think that applying the same level of precaution used for mining to doing minor work on a 100V circuit is being a bit overzealous. To be fair, you're never going to get hurt by being superfluously safe, but at the same time I don't expect my dog is going to flip the circuit breaker on me, so I'm probably not going to resort to LO-TO when doing some minor electrical work when home alone.
- taneq 7y agoHonestly if our mains was 110V rather than "240V" (read 250-260V thanks to all of the rooftop solar in our area) I'd probably be a bit more casual about it. I've been nipped by ~100V from poor earthing and it's not that bad. 240V hurts.
- roenxi 7y agoI've no particular experience working with electricity so maybe you just know what you are doing - but at risk of being a know-it-all on the internet that is not a very safe approach. In an industrial setting any electricity related accident is cause for a trip to the hospital no matter how minor. For starters you don't want to be casual about 110 volts [0] and for seconds the systems that control heart rhythm use electricity. An electric shock can cause a heart to just stop some hours later (happened to a family friend as far as we can tell). It is invisible, can kill and humans don't have the right nerves for pain to be an indicator of how bad the damage is. Electricity is hazardous and work on it should leave no scope for surprises. [0] https://www.asc.ohio-state.edu/physics/p616/safety/fatal_current.html https://www.asc.ohio-state.edu/physics/p616/safety/fatal_cur...
- kozak 7y agoCan someone please point me to details of a biological mechanism that can cause someone to die hours after having seemingly survived an electric zap just fine? I never thought such things are possible.
- ajhurliman 7y agoNuclear also takes this very seriously.
- kom0 7y ago+1 for this one, I work in a nuclear power plant and we use this system even for patch panels.
- dgemm 7y agoI worked in mining as well and it's often terrifying watching the stuff that goes on all day at every urban construction site, even the things you can see from street level. Construction workers that stand directly below suspended crane loads in order to guide them down to the ground is something I see constantly and makes me nervous just to watch. If you tried anything like that at any of the mines I worked at you would be immediately escorted off site and probably blacklisted from working there again.
- taneq 7y agoI've seen some things on mining construction sites that'd curl your toes, too. Once I was troubleshooting a cabinet and the light changed. I looked up and there was an EWP with two guys pulling cables, about 10m directly above me. No warning, no marked drop zone, no communication. On the same site I saw a 20 ton piece of equipment get lifted into position, double lift between a gantry crane and a Franna, again no drop zone or anything, just one guy coordinating with hand signals. It worked out OK, but yikes.
- duckymcduckface 7y agoTieing off if you're above 1.8m, not walking under suspended loads and de-energizing systems are so hard drilled into my brain. Haven't been on site in 4 years and I still get triggered by these.
- habnds 7y agoMy experience has been that the divide in culture tends to coincide with union/non-union workplaces.
- abruzzi 7y agoThe unusual thing though is my first exposure to "lock-out/tag-out" was as a minimum wage employee at WalMart ~30 years ago. Among other things, they had a large cardboard bailer that compress all the empty cardboard boxes into a bale about 4ft x 3ft x 3ft. It would hold it there while you threaded baling wire through and tied it off. Then it would release and dump it onto your waiting pallet jack, so you could cart it off. We had to lo/to whenever it required service.
- anotheryou 7y agoWell if I tell my partner "do not kill me by touching anything in this box today" I trust her. It really depends on the circumstances.
- Simon_says 7y agoThat's great for you. 50% of people are below average, and they have roommates.
- anotheryou 7y agoYea sorry. Totally my privilege speaking here. I just found the claim "everyone should do this" a bit too broad.
- lqet 7y agoWell, I played around enough with electronic equipment as a kid to know that coming in contact with a live 230V house wire is painful and gives you a nice adrenaline rush, but comparing it with the things that could go wrong in a mine (potentially with explosives in place) is exaggerating a bit.
- mcguire 7y agoI worked on Redstone Arsenal, and although the most danger I was in was having an emacs fall on me, the monthly safety bulletins were usually about proper tagout/lockout procedure. Particularly with equipment that people have to crawl into for maintenance.